Differences in gene regulation in a tephritid model of prezygotic reproductive isolation.

The two tephritid fruit fly pests, Bactrocera tryoni and Bactrocera neohumeralis, are unusually well suited to the study of the genetics of reproductive isolating mechanisms. Sequence difference between the species is no greater than between a pair of conspecific Drosophila melanogaster populations. The two species exist in close sympatry, yet do not hybridize in the field, apparently kept separate by a strong premating isolation mechanism involving the time of day at which mating occurs. This spurred us to search for key genes for which time of day expression is regulated differently between the species. Using replicated, quantitative transcriptomes from head tissues of males of the two species, sampled in the day and night, we identified 141 transcripts whose abundance showed a significant interaction between species and time of day, indicating a difference in gene regulation. The brain transcripts showing this interaction were enriched for genes with a neurone function and 90% of these were more abundant at night than day in B. tryoni. Features of the expression patterns suggest that there may be a difference in the regulation of sleep-wake cycles between the species. In particular several genes, which in D. melanogaster are expressed in circadian pacemaker cells, are promising candidates to further explore the genetic differentiation involved in this prezygotic reproductive isolation mechanism.

Genetic consequences of domestication and mass rearing of pest fruit fly Bactrocera tryoni (Diptera: Tephritidae).

Tephritid fruit flies, an important pest of horticulture worldwide, are increasingly targeted for control or eradication by large-scale releases of sterile flies of the same species. For each species treated, strains must be domesticated for mass rearing to provide sufficiently large numbers of individuals for releases. Increases in productivity of domesticated tephritid strains are well documented, but there have been few systematic studies of the genetic consequences of domestication in tephritids. Here, we used nine DNA microsatellite markers to monitor changes in genetic diversity during the early generations of domestication in replicated lines of the fruit fly Bactrocera tryoni (Froggatt) (Diptera: Tephritidae). The observed changes in heterozygosity and allelic richness were compared with the expected changes in heterozygosity generated by a stochastic simulation including genetic drift but not selection. The results showed that repeatable genetic bottlenecks occur in the early generations and that selection occurs in the later generations. Furthermore, using the same simulation, we show that there is inadvertent selection for increased productivity for the entire life on a mass-rearing colony, in addition to intentional selection for increased productivity. That additional selection results from the common practice of establishing the next generation of the breeding colony from a small proportion of one day's pupae collection (the pupal raffle). That selection occurs during all generations and acts only on fecundity variation. Practical methods to counter that unavoidable loss of genetic diversity during the domestication process in B. tryoni are discussed.

Pest fruit fly (Diptera: Tephritidae) in northwestern Australia: one species or two?

Since 1985, a new and serious fruit fly pest has been reported in northwestern Australia. It has been unclear whether this pest was the supposedly benign endemic species, Bactrocera aquilonis, or a recent introduction of the morphologically near-identical Queensland fruit fly, B. tryoni. B. tryoni is a major pest throughout eastern Australia but is isolated from the northwest region by an arid zone. In the present study, we sought to clarify the species status of these new pests using an extensive DNA microsatellite survey across the entire northwest region of Australia. Population differentiation tests and clustering analyses revealed a high degree of homogeneity within the northwest samples, suggesting that just one species is present in the region. That northwestern population showed minimal genetic differentiation from B. tryoni from Queensland (FST=0.015). Since 2000, new outbreaks of this pest fruit fly have occurred to the west of the region, and clustering analysis suggested recurrent migration from the northwest region rather than Queensland. Mitochondrial DNA sequencing also showed no evidence for the existence of a distinct species in the northwest region. We conclude that the new pest fruit fly in the northwest is the endemic population of B. aquilonis but that there is no genetic evidence supporting the separation of B. aquilonis and B. tryoni as distinct species.

Correlation measures for linkage disequilibrium within and between populations.

Correlation statistics can be used to measure the amount of linkage disequilibrium (LD) between two loci in subdivided populations. Within populations, the square of the correlation of gene frequencies, r2, is a convenient measure of LD. Between populations, the statistic rirj, for populations i and j, measures the relatedness of LD. Recurrence relationships for these two parameters are derived for the island model of population subdivision, under the assumptions of the linked identity-by-descent (LIBD) model in which correlation measures are equated to probability measures. The recurrence relationships closely predict the build-up of r2 and rirj following population subdivision in computer simulations. The LIBD model predicts that a steady state will be reached with r2 equal to 1/[1+4Nec(1+(k-1)rho)], where k is the number of island populations, Ne is the effective local population (island) size, and rho measures the ratio of migration (m) to recombination (c) and is equal to m/[c(k-1)+m]. For low values of m/c, rho=0, and E(r2) is equal to 1/(1+4Nec). For high values of m/c, rho=1, and E(r2) is equal to 1/(1+4kNec). The value of rirj following separation eventually settles down to a steady state whose expectation, E(rirj), is equal to E(r2) multiplied by rho. Equations predicting the change in rirj values are applied to the separation of African (Yoruba - YRI) and non-African (European - CEU) populations, using data from Hapmap. The primary data lead to an estimate of separation time of less than 1000 generations if there has been no migration, which is around one-third of minimum current estimates. Ancient rather than recent migration can explain the form of the data.

Properties of re-arranged P elements in Drosophila melanogaster.

P elements, both complete and incomplete, contain a left and right end, normally depicted as pointing away from each other. Here, we examine the properties of P elements that may be described as 're-arranged elements' or 'inside-out elements', containing inverted ends. Two such structures exist, having either ends pointing towards each other, 'head-to-head or H-H', or ends pointing in the same direction 'head-to-tail or H-T'. We show that both structures are unstable in the presence of P element transposase. For the H-H element there is a high frequency of deletion of the intervening material and almost exact rejoining of element ends with the 4 bp CATG palindromic end sequence shared by the two element ends. This result is predicted by the Beall and Rio model of P element excision. For the H-T element there is a high frequency of exact excision of the entire inverted right-end, a result again predicted by the Beall and Rio model. Both structures lead to recombination in the way expected from a normal element. The rates of recombination are, however, much lower than might be expected from the organization of ends, a result that can be explained in terms of the low likelihood of insertion into a chromosomal region lacking another P element end. We also investigate the properties of combinations of re-arranged and normal elements, and show that there is a directionality property when left and right ends are combined in trans that can be explained in terms of strand repair.

Repair of P element ends following hybrid element excision leads to recombination in Drosophila melanogaster.

P elements are thought to replicate themselves starting with the association of the left and right ends, followed by a cut-copy-paste process. An abnormal form of this process has been shown to occur when the associated left and right ends come from sister elements rather than from the same element, leading to formation of a 'hybrid element.' These ends can insert nearby in the genome to produce recombination, with associated structural changes. We have previously increased the frequency of such 'hybrid element insertion' by combining end-deleted elements in trans in a genotype with a left-end on one chromosome and a right-end on the homologous chromosome. Although many recombinants produced by this genotype have structural changes expected with insertion, nearly 50% of the predicted insertional recombinants contain no structural change. We present evidence using RFLP markers closely linked to the end-deleted elements that in these cases the P element ends dissociate before insertion, and are subsequently ligated together following a process analogous to synthesis-dependent strand annealing. The results suggest that broken ends containing P elements are resolved by the same repair process as ends not containing P elements, and that such repair from hybrid element events may occur in the majority of cases.

A two-sex polygenic model for the evolution of premating isolation. I. Deterministic theory for natural populations.

It is proposed that mating behavior is normally determined by independent genetic systems in the male and female. A specific model is put forward in which mating behavior is determined by additive gene contributions in both sexes, and the strength of mating attraction is maximized when mating "scores" in the two sexes are equalized. This type of model, which may be described as a "facilitation" model, is related to models proposed by a number of authors. It is pointed out that a second class of models exists, "avoidance" models, and that these, although less tractable analytically, could be more realistic.-An organism is assumed to be divided into two strains, and selection is introduced through lethality or sterility of the hybrid (postmating isolation). The selective tendency for divergence of mating behavior in one sex is then shown to be proportional to the amount of divergence that already exists in the opposite sex, multiplied by a quantity that can be described as the heritability of mating attraction. The situation in which no initial divergence exists in either sex constitutes an equilibrium that is unstable, but one that requires substantial deviations before any selective progress can be made. Thus, the evolution of premating isolation to reinforce postmating isolation may be an inefficient process. The process would occur much more efficiently if some initial chance divergence in mating behavior occurred during the period in which postmating isolation evolved.

A Two-Sex Polygenic Model for the Evolution of Premating Isolation. II. Computer Simulation of Experimental Selection Procedures.

A Monte-Carlo simulation program is described for a polygenic mating model introduced in the first paper in this series (Sved 1981). The program is used to simulate the situation in laboratory experiments in which two strains are allowed to mass-mate, hybrids are artificially eliminated and the establishment of mating isolation is studied. It is shown that, if mating choice is sufficiently precise, a combination of chance fluctuation and selection can lead to divergence in mating behavior. However, for small population sizes, the variability would usually be considerably reduced by the time some divergence is established, leading to low eventual levels of isolation. For larger population sizes, on the other hand, it may take many generations for any divergence to be established.-A dissection of the selective forces involved in the divergence shows that the major force potentially responsible for initial selective response is the tendency for divergent females and males to reject mates from the wrong strain. However, this is nullified in mixed-strain matings by the tendency of such individuals equally to reject mates from the correct strain. To overcome this problem, it is suggested that the usual mixed-strain mating procedure be replaced by procedures specifically designed to select for rejection of interstrain matings. Two procedures are suggested for this, and computer simulation shows that one or other of the procedures will work under the assumptions of the mating model. Other possible outcomes of selection, including asymmetrical divergence, are discussed for cases in which the assumptions of the mating model are invalid.

Hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster: evidence from sterility and southern hybridization tests that P cytotype is not maintained in the absence of chromosomal P factors.

A two-generation crossing program was used to replace the entire chromosome complement of P strains by M strain chromosomes, the maternal contribution being from the P strain. The cytotype of chromosomally substituted females was indistinguishable from M strain cytotype, judged by the sterility of offspring from the cross of such females to P strain males. In addition, following replacement of the chromosomes, the level of DNA homologous to the P factor was sufficiently low to be explicable by low levels of P factor transposition. These results are consistent with immediate chromosomal control for the switching from P to M cytotype. However, the reverse chromosome substitution, replacing all chromosomes of an M strain with P chromosomes, did not usually lead to immediate change of cytotype properties, showing that there is a true maternal effect in the M to P direction. The absence of true maternal inheritance for P cytotype argues against models of P factor repression which depend on autonomous replication of a nonchromosomal element. The repression could still be explained by nonchromosomal copies of the P factor, provided that these are replenished from chromosomal P factors. A model is put forward in which P cytotype is due to the presence of circular P factors carrying a P factor target sequence, leading to preferential transposition of chromosomal P factors to nonchromosomal target sites.

A reevaluation of data from competitive tests shows high levels of heterosis in Drosophila melanogaster.

We have analyzed the results from a range of procedures designed to measure the fitness under competitive conditions of inbred strains of Drosophila melanogaster, specifically strains which are homozygous for chromosome 2. All methods show a substantial reduction in fitness, ranging from an estimated 70-80% for single generation competition tests to 80-90% for a multiple generation population cage procedure. Furthermore, inbreeding through brother-sister mating reduces fitness by a comparable amount when allowance is made for the expected degree of homozygosity.

Germ-line and somatic recombination induced by in vitro modified P elements in Drosophila melanogaster.

The P element insertion delta 2-3(99B) has previously been shown to activate incomplete P elements elsewhere in the genome. We show that this element, in conjunction with a second incomplete P element, P[CaSpeR], also induces recombination in the male germ line. The recombination is induced preferentially in the region of the P[CaSpeR] element. Recombinant chromosomes contain the P[CaSpeR] element in more than 50% of cases, and alternative models of transposon replication and preferential chromosome breakage are put forward to explain this finding. As is the case with male recombination induced by P-M dysgenic crosses, recombination appears to be premeiotic in a high proportion of cases. The delta 2-3(99B) element is known to act in somatic cells. Correspondingly, we show that the delta 2-3(99B)-P[CaSpeR] combination elevates the incidence of somatic recombination.

Inferring modes of colonization for pest species using heterozygosity comparisons and a shared-allele test.

Long-range dispersal of a species may involve either a single long-distance movement from a core population or spreading via unobserved intermediate populations. Where the new populations originate as small propagules, genetic drift may be extreme and gene frequency or assignment methods may not prove useful in determining the relation between the core population and outbreak samples. We describe computationally simple resampling methods for use in this situation to distinguish between the different modes of dispersal. First, estimates of heterozygosity can be used to test for direct sampling from the core population and to estimate the effective size of intermediate populations. Second, a test of sharing of alleles, particularly rare alleles, can show whether outbreaks are related to each other rather than arriving as independent samples from the core population. The shared-allele statistic also serves as a genetic distance measure that is appropriate for small samples. These methods were applied to data on a fruit fly pest species, Bactrocera tryoni, which is quarantined from some horticultural areas in Australia. We concluded that the outbreaks in the quarantine zone came from a heterogeneous set of genetically differentiated populations, possibly ones that overwinter in the vicinity of the quarantine zone.

P-element-induced recombination in Drosophila melanogaster: hybrid element insertion.

It has previously been shown that the combination of two deleted P elements in trans, one containing the left functional end and the second element the right functional end, can lead to high levels of male recombination. This finding strongly suggests that P-element ends from different chromosomes can become associated, followed by "pseudo-excision". We show that two different processes are involved in resolving the pseudo-excision event: (1) the excised P-element ends continue to function as a single unit (Hybrid Element) and insert at a nearby site in the chromosome or into the element itself [Hybrid Element Insertion (HEI)] and (2) free ends that do not contain P elements repair and rejoin [(Hybrid Excision and Repair (HER)]. Both types of resolution can lead to recombination, and this paper concentrates on the HEI class. One type of HEI event predicts the exact reverse complementary duplication of an 8-bp target site, and we have confirmed the existence of such a structure in six independently derived recombinant chromosomes. There is also a high tendency for insertion events to occur within a few bases of the original 8-bp target site, including six apparent cases of insertion into the exact site.

Flanking duplications and deletions associated with P-induced male recombination in Drosophila.

We studied P element-induced recombination in germline mitotic cells by examining the structure of the recombinant chromosomes. We found that most recombinants retain a mobile P element at the site of the recombination, usually with either a deletion or a duplication immediately adjacent to the P end at which the crossover occurred. The sizes of these deletions and duplications ranged from a few base pairs to well over 100 kb. These structures fit the "hybrid element insertion" (HEI) model of male recombination in which the two P-element copies on sister chromatids combine to form a "hybrid element" whose termini insert into a nearby position on the homologue. The data suggest that P-induced recombination can be used as an efficient means of generating flanking deletions in the vicinity of existing P elements. These deletions are easily screened using distant flanking markers, and they can be chosen to extend in a given direction depending on which reciprocal recombinant type is selected. Furthermore, the retention of a mobile P element allows one to extend the deletion or generate additional variability at the site by subsequent rounds of recombination.

Hybrid Dysgenesis in DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER: A Syndrome of Aberrant Traits Including Mutation, Sterility and Male Recombination.

A syndrome of associated aberrant traits is described in Drosophila melanogaster. Six of these traits, mutation, sterility, male recombination, transmission ratio distortion, chromosomal aberrations and local increases in female recombination, have previously been reported. A seventh trait, nondisjunction, is described for the first time. All of the traits we have examined are found nonreciprocally in F(1) hybrids. We present evidence that at least four of the traits are not found in nonhybrids. Therefore we have proposed the name hybrid dysgenesis to describe this syndrome.-A partition of tested strains into two types, designated P and M, was made according to the paternal or maternal contribution required to produce hybrid dysgenesis. This classification seems to hold for crosses of strains from within the United States and Australia, as well as for crosses between strains from the two countries. Strains collected recently from natural populations are typically of the P type and those having a long laboratory history are generally of the M type. However, a group of six strains collected from the wild in the 1960's are unambiguously divided equally between the P and M types. The dichotomy of this latter group raises interesting questions concerning possible implications for speciation.-Temperature often has a critical effect on the manifestation of hybrid dysgenesis. High F(1 ) developmental temperatures tend to increase the expression of sterility, sometimes to extreme levels. Conversely, low developmental temperatures tend to inhibit the expression of some dysgenic traits.-There are potentially important practical implications of hybrid dysgenesis for laboratory experimentation. The results suggest that care should be exercised in planning experiments involving strain crosses.

P-element-induced male recombination can be produced in Drosophila melanogaster by combining end-deficient elements in trans.

Male recombination, not normally present in Drosophila melanogaster, can be produced at high rates when target P elements at homologous sites are combined in the presence of transposase protein. We have produced a set of elements by in situ deletion of a particular insertion and have found elements that have deletions stretching into either end. Elements were tested in pairs to see whether they complement each other in their ability to induce recombination. The combination of elements that are deficient for the same end produces very little recombination, but the combination of a right-end and a left-end element can generate recombination values higher than given by two complete P[CaSpeR] elements at homologous sites. This strongly suggests that "hybrid" P elements, containing ends from two different elements, can be recognized by transposase protein. We have also examined genotypes containing a normal and an end-deficient element and found that they yield reasonably high levels of recombination. We interpret the resultant gametes from such genotypes as showing that the majority of events in this genotype derive from the association of complementary ends from the same element, whereas the complementary ends from elements in trans associate in only a minority of cases.

The accumulation of P-element-induced recombinants in the germline of male Drosophila melanogaster.

P-element-induced recombination in Drosophila melanogaster occurs premeiotically. Recombinants are therefore expected to accumulate in the stem cells of the germline of P-element-carrying males. We show that both the recombination frequency and the incidence of "clustering" increase with the age of males carrying various P-element derivatives. The combination of end-deleted elements can lead to average recombination frequencies >50% with individual instances of 100% recombination. These elements also lowered the fertility of the carriers. We investigated these features by constructing an analytical and a computer simulation model of the course of events in the germline, incorporating the recently proposed hybrid element insertion (HEI) model of P-element activity. The model is able to predict extreme recombination levels, segregation ratio biases and lowered fertility through cell death in a single analysis.