Anterior cruciate ligament tear patterns in young patients: An arthroscopic multicenter study.

ABSTRACT

INTRODUCTION: In the last decade, there has been a renewed interest in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) preservation surgeries in the younger patients. Several ACL preservation techniques such as primary repair, augmented repair, and scaffold repair have been described based on the particular tear type and pattern. The purpose of this study was to determine the distribution of tear patterns in young patients presenting with an acute ACL injury. METHODS: A prospective observational study was performed at two tertiary children's hospitals. Patients under 18 years undergoing ACL reconstruction within 8 weeks of initial injury were included from 2017 to 2019. Tear patterns were classified by two orthopedic surgeons from each of the two centers during arthroscopic ACL reconstruction into 4 types I. Avulsion off the femur, II. <10% of total ACL length tear from femoral end, III. Mid-substance tear and IV. Single bundle tear. For reliability, the four surgeons classified ACL injury (2 rounds each) based on de-identified intraoperative videos of 33 randomly selected surgical ACL cases. Inter and intra-rater reliability studies were calculated using Kappa statistics. RESULTS: 224 patients (123 males, 101 females) with mean age of 16 (range 9-18) years were enrolled in this study. Fifty-seven (25%) patients reported contact injury while 167 (75%) reported non-contact. Isolated ACL injury was recorded in 70 (31%) patients, while concomitant injuries were recorded in 154 patients (69%). The most common associated injury was lateral meniscus tear (35%), followed by lateral and medial meniscus tears (20%). According to our classification, 31 (14%) patients were Type I, 30 (13%) were Type II, 139 (62%) were Type III, 18 (8%) were Type IV. The intra-rater reliability was excellent for 2 reviewers, good for 1 and marginal for another. The overall inter-rater reliability for all 4 reviewers was marginal for both readings. There was no statistical difference in the occurrence of type of tear based on the mechanism of injury (contact vs non-contact) or age of the patients. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first multicenter study using an arthroscopic assessment to classify the location of ACL tear in the young population. It gives us further insight on the possible application for surgeries to preserve the ACL in this group. Larger studies incorporating these findings with MRI evaluation and ACL repair techniques are needed to confirm the utility of this information to decide the eligibility for repair in pediatric patients.