Health technology assessment: A matter of facts and values.

ABSTRACT

The unique task and contribution of health technology assessment (HTA) is to help identify those health technologies and their uses that are most likely to preserve and restore a population's health in a way that is consonant with its values, including, for example, equity and access to high-quality care (1). Such a task is challenging for at least two reasons. First, because of the vast and constantly evolving number and diversity of health technologies and their applications. Second, because of the usual wide variety of competing views within communities and their stakeholders regarding what strategies are likely to be conducive to the goal of preserving and restoring population health. Although perhaps tempting, it would be a grave mistake to hold that the controversies that result from such competing views can be resolved by taking recourse to the facts only. For such controversies are usually fueled by different notions of health and disease and different specifications of values such as equity and individual and collective responsibility for health. For this reason, they cannot be resolved in a satisfactory way without also addressing those normative issues and their interplay with empirical analysis.