RESUMEN
PURPOSE: Energy changes in pencil beam scanning proton therapy can be a limiting factor in delivery time, hence, limiting patient throughput and the effectiveness of motion mitigation techniques requiring fast irradiation. In this study, we investigate the feasibility of performing fast and continuous energy modulation within the momentum acceptance of a clinical beamline for proton therapy. METHODS: The alternative use of a local beam degrader at the gantry coupling point has been compared with a more common upstream regulation. Focusing on clinically relevant parameters, a complete beam properties characterization has been carried out. In particular, the acquired empirical data allowed to model and parametrize the errors in range and beam current to deliver clinical treatment plans. RESULTS: For both options, the local and upstream degrader, depth-dose curves measured in water for off-momentum beams were only marginally distorted (γ(1%, 1 mm) > 90%) and the errors in the spot position were within the clinical tolerance, even though increasing at the boundaries of the investigated scan range. The impact on the beam size was limited for the upstream degrader, while dedicated strategies could be required to tackle the beam broadening through the local degrader. Range correction models were investigated for the upstream regulation. The impaired beam transport required a dedicated strategy for fine range control and compensation of beam intensity losses. Our current parameterization based on empirical data allowed energy modulation within acceptance with range errors (median 0.05 mm) and transmission (median -14%) compatible with clinical operation and remarkably low average 27 ms dead time for small energy changes. The technique, tested for the delivery of a skull glioma treatment, resulted in high gamma pass rates at 1%, 1 mm compared to conventional deliveries in experimental measurements with about 45% reduction of the energy switching time when regulation could be performed within acceptance. CONCLUSIONS: Fast energy modulation within beamline acceptance has potential for clinical applications and, when realized with an upstream degrader, does not require modification in the beamline hardware, therefore, being potentially applicable in any running facility. Centers with slow energy switching time can particularly profit from such a technique for reducing dead time during treatment delivery.
Asunto(s)
Terapia de Protones , Humanos , Terapia de Protones/métodos , Dosificación Radioterapéutica , Planificación de la Radioterapia Asistida por Computador , Sincrotrones , AguaRESUMEN
We present the commissioning and quality assurance of our clinical protocol for respiratory gating in pencil beam scanning proton therapy for cancer patients with moving targets. In a novel approach, optical tracking has been integrated in the therapy workflow and used to monitor respiratory motion from multiple surrogates, applied on the patients' chest. The gating system was tested under a variety of experimental conditions, specific to proton therapy, to evaluate reaction time and reproducibility of dose delivery control. The system proved to be precise in the application of beam gating and allowed the mitigation of dose distortions even for large (1.4cm) motion amplitudes, provided that adequate treatment windows were selected. The total delivered dose was not affected by the use of gating, with measured integral error within 0.15cGy. Analysing high-resolution images of proton transmission, we observed negligible discrepancies in the geometric location of the dose as a function of the treatment window, with gamma pass rate greater than 95% (2%/2mm) compared to stationary conditions. Similarly, pass rate for the latter metric at the 3%/3mm level was observed above 97% for clinical treatment fields, limiting residual movement to 3mm at end-exhale. These results were confirmed in realistic clinical conditions using an anthropomorphic breathing phantom, reporting a similarly high 3%/3mm pass rate, above 98% and 94%, for regular and irregular breathing, respectively. Finally, early results from periodic QA tests of the optical tracker have shown a reliable system, with small variance observed in static and dynamic measurements.
Asunto(s)
Terapia de Protones , Humanos , Fantasmas de Imagen , Terapia de Protones/métodos , Protones , Planificación de la Radioterapia Asistida por Computador , Reproducibilidad de los Resultados , RespiraciónRESUMEN
PURPOSE: Fast energy switching is of fundamental importance to implement motion mitigation techniques in pencil beam scanning proton therapy, allowing efficient irradiation and high patient throughput. However, depending on magnet design, when switching between different energy layers, eddy currents arise in the bending magnets' yoke, damping the speed of the magnetic field change and lengthening the settling time of the magnetic field. In a proton therapy gantry, this can cause a temporary displacement of the beam trajectory and consequently an incorrect beam position in the bending direction, resulting in an unacceptable loss of position precision at isocenter. The precision can be recovered by either increasing the beam off time after an energy change (waiting until the magnetic field is fully settled) or by actively correcting for the misplacement. We studied the transient magnetic field effects at PSI Gantry 2 in order to develop a correction strategy for this beam position misplacement. METHODS: We used position and proton range sensitive detectors (segmented strip chamber and multilayer ionization chambers respectively) to measure the difference between expected and actual proton beam position and range as a function of time. The detectors are automatically triggered, read out, and analyzed by the treatment control system. We studied the effects due to the magnets on the gantry and those upstream of the gantry separately, in order to identify which elements contribute the most to the beam position instability. We then designed a spot position algorithm to be applied with the gantry scanning magnets, to correct for the displacement observed as a function of time and achieve the PSI Gantry 2 clinical target of 1 mm precision at isocenter at all times, even after an energy change. RESULTS: When switching energy layers in a field, we observed an exponentially decaying spot position displacement at isocenter. The effect increases with increasing energy difference between energy layers (ΔE). The initial residuals between expected and measured position are higher than 1 mm for most of the clinical cases at Gantry 2 and fall below 1 mm within about 1 s or more (depending on ΔE). We found no time dependence for the proton range, thus confirming that the displacement is purely due to a beam trajectory displacement resulting from the longer settling time of the magnetic field. A double exponential model, with two time constants and amplitudes depending on ΔE, fits the data and provides an easy model for the correction function. We implemented this correction as a spot position correction, applied by the scanning magnets during field application. After correction, the residuals were below 0.5 mm right after the energy change. CONCLUSIONS: We developed a spot position correction for PSI Gantry 2 which reduces the beam off time needed in current state-of-the-art gantries to settle the magnetic fields in the bending magnets. Thanks to this correction, the spot position is stable within 100 ms of an energy change at Gantry 2. This is low enough to make possible efficient use of motion mitigation techniques.
Asunto(s)
Algoritmos , Terapia de Protones/métodosRESUMEN
PURPOSE: In this experimental study, the authors explored the possibility to deliver the dose for proton therapy with fast uniform scanning on a gantry primarily designed for the delivery of conformal beam scanning and IMPT. The uniform scanning submode has been realized without equipment modifications by using the same small pencil beam used for conformal scanning, resulting in reduced realization costs. Uniform scanning has recently been adopted in a few proton therapy centers, as a basic beam delivery solution, and as an alternative to the use of scattering foils. The option to use such a mode to mimic scattering on a full-fledged scanning gantry could be of interest for treating some specific indications and as a possible solution for treating moving targets. METHODS: Uniform iso-energy dose layers were painted by fast magnetic scanning alternated with fast energy changes with the gantry beam line. The layers were stacked and repainted appropriately to produce homogeneous three-dimensional dose distributions. A collimator∕compensator was used to adjust the dose to coincide laterally∕distally with the target volume. In addition, they applied volumetric repainting, since they are confident that this will further mitigate the effects of organ motion as compared with the presently used clinical scanning solutions. With the approach presented in this paper, they can profit from the higher flexibility of the scanning system to obtain additional advantages. For instance the shape of the energy layers can be adjusted to the projected target shape in order to reduce treatment time and neutrons produced in the collimator. The shape of the proximal layers can be shrunk, according to the cross section of the target at the corresponding range. This provides variable range modulation (proximal conformity) while standard scattering only provides fixed range modulation with unnecessary 100% dose proximal to the target. The field-specific hardware for a spherical target volume was mounted on the Gantry 2 nozzle. One field with proximal field size shrinking and one without, each of 1 Gy, were delivered. The dose distributions at different depths were recorded as CCD images of a scintillating screen. RESULTS: The time to scan the volume once was about 4 s and the total delivery time was approximately 30 s. For the field with proximal conformity, dose sparing of up to 25% was measured in the region proximal to the target. A repainting capability of 48 times was achieved on the most distal layer. The proximal layers were repainted more due to the contribution of the plateau dose from the deeper layers. CONCLUSIONS: The flexibility of a fast scanning gantry with very fast energy changes can easily provide beam delivery by uniform layer stacking with a significant degree of volumetric repainting and with the benefit of a dose reduction proximal to the target volume.