Retreatment of tuberculosis patients in the city of Porto Alegre, Brazil: outcomes.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the outcomes of retreatment in tuberculosis patients receiving the regimen known, in Brazil, as regimen 3 (streptomycin, ethambutol, ethionamide, and pyrazinamide for 3 months + ethambutol and ethionamide for 9 months) after treatment failure with the basic regimen (rifampin, isoniazid, and pyrazinamide for 2 months + rifampin and isoniazid for 4 months). METHODS: A descriptive, uncontrolled, historical cohort study involving adult tuberculosis patients treated with regimen 3. We evaluated adverse drug effects, recurrence, treatment outcomes, and associated factors. RESULTS: The study included 229 patients. The overall cure rate was 62%. For the patients who used the medications regularly and those who did not, the cure rate was 88% and 31%, respectively. Adverse events occurred in 95 patients (41.5%), and most of those events were related to the gastrointestinal tract. In the five-year follow-up period, relapse occurred in 17 cases (12.0%). CONCLUSIONS: Overall, the outcomes of treatment with regimen 3 were unsatisfactory, in part because this regimen was administered to a selected population of patients at high risk for noncompliance with treatment, as well as because it presents high rates of adverse effects, especially those related to the gastrointestinal tract, which might be caused by ethionamide. However, for those who took the medications regularly, the cure rate was satisfactory. The recurrence rate was higher than that recommended in international consensus guidelines, which might be attributable to the short (12-month) treatment period. We believe that regimen 3, extended to 18 months, represents an option for patients with proven treatment compliance.

Resultado do tratamento da tuberculose com estreptomicina, isoniazida e etambutol (esquema SHM) / Results of tuberculosis treatment with streptomycin, isoniazid, and ethambutol (scheme SHM)

Objetivo: Avaliar o desempenho do esquema SHM (estreptomicina, isoniazida e etambutol), na rotina de trabalho de uma unidade ambulatorial de tratamento da tuberculose. Método: Setenta e oito pacientes tuberculosos, cujo tratamento prévio com o esquema RHZ (seis meses de rifampicina, isoniazida e pirazinamida) teve de ser interrompido devido a efeitos adversos, ou que não puderam receber o esquema RHZ por serem de alto risco para hepatotoxicidade a esse esquema, foram tratados ambulatorialmente com o esquema de 12 meses de SHM, de 1986 a 1994, em Porto Alegre, Rio Grande do Sul, Brasil. Resultados: Em três pacientes houve necessidade de troca de esquema por toxicidade (3,8 por cento). Nos 75 restantes observaram-se 58 curas (77,3 por cento), oito abandonos (10,7 por cento), cinco falências (6,7 por cento) e quatro óbitos (5,3 por cento). A taxa teórica de cura, que é o percentual de cura entre os bacilíferos que fizeram tratamento regular, foi de 95,3 por cento. Reações adversas ocorreram em 32 pacientes (41 por cento), sendo as mais freqüentes as manifestações de dano vestibular, em 18 (23,1 por cento). Esses resultados foram comparados com os obtidos no mesmo ambulatório com o esquema de 12 meses de RHM (rifampicina, isoniazida e etambutol) e de seis meses de RHZ. Conclusão: O esquema SHM pode ser recomendado como alternativa para o tratamento da tuberculose quando o esquema RHZ não pode ser indicado