Diagnostic discordance among histopathological reviewers of melanocytic lesions.

BACKGROUND: Histopathological examination is adequate for the diagnosis of most cutaneous melanocytic neoplasms. However, there is a subset that is either difficult to definitively diagnose or would have diagnostic disagreement upon review by multiple dermatopathologists if a more exhaustive review was performed. METHODS: Melanocytic lesions underwent an independent, blinded diagnostic histopathological review of hematoxylin and eosin-stained sections. Each lesion was reviewed by three to six dermatopathologists and categorized as benign, malignant, or unknown malignant potential (UMP). Diagnoses were grouped as concordant (all the same designation); opposing (received benign and malignant designations); majority (single designation with the highest number of diagnoses, no benign/malignant opposing designations); and non-definitive (equal number of non-opposing designations [i.e., benign/UMP or malignant/UMP]). Lesions with equivocal designations (concordant or majority UMP, opposing, majority, and non-definitive) were utilized in a patient treatment model of projected surgical treatment discrepancies. RESULTS: In total, 3317 cases were reviewed, and 23.8% of lesions received equivocal diagnoses. Of these, 7.3% were majority benign, 4.8% were majority malignant, 2.7% were majority UMP, 0.5% were concordant UMP, 6.9% were opposing, and 1.6% were non-definitive. Patient treatment models of those with equivocal lesions (n = 788) revealed a potential of overall surgical treatment variations ranging from 18% to 72%, with the highest variation amongst lesions with opposing, non-definitive, or majority UMP (40%-72%) diagnoses. CONCLUSION: Histopathologic review in this large cohort demonstrated substantial diagnostic variation, with 23.8% of cases receiving equivocal diagnoses. We identified diagnostic ambiguity even in lesions where a definitive diagnosis was previously rendered by a single real-world dermatopathologist. The combined clinical impact of diagnostic discordance or a final diagnosis of UMP is highlighted by high diagnosis-dependent treatment variation in the patient treatment model, which could be underreported in a real-world setting, where review by more than one to two dermatopathologists is relatively rare.

Complement Factor H in cSCC: Evidence of a Link Between Sun Exposure and Immunosuppression in Skin Cancer Progression.

Cutaneous squamous cell carcinoma (cSCC) is a common form of skin cancer with an estimated 750,000 cases diagnosed annually in the United States. Most cases are successfully treated with a simple excision procedure, but ~5% of cases metastasize and have a 5-year survival rate of 25-45%. Thus, identification of biomarkers correlated to cSCC progression may be useful in the early identification of high-risk cSCC and in the development of new therapeutic strategies. This work investigates the role of complement factor H (CFH) in the development of cSCC. CFH is a regulatory component of the complement cascade which affects cell mediated immune responses and increases in complement proteins are associated with poor outcomes in multiple cancer types. We provide evidence that sun exposure may increase levels of CFH, suggesting an immunomodulatory role for CFH early in the development of cSCC. We then document increased levels of CFH in cSCC samples, compared to adjacent normal tissue (ANT) routinely excised in a dermatology clinic which, in paired samples, received the same level of sun exposure. We also provide evidence that levels of CFH are even greater in more advanced cases of cSCC. To provide a potential link between CFH and immune modulation, we assessed immune system function by measuring interferon gamma (IFN-γ) and FOXP3 in patient samples. IFN-γ levels were unchanged in cSCC relative to ANT which is consistent with an ineffective cell-mediated immune response. FOXP3 was used to assess prevalence of regulatory T cells within the tissues, indicating either a derailed or inhibitory immune response. Our data suggest that FOXP3 levels are higher in cSCC than in ANT. Our current working model is that increased CFH downstream of sun exposure is an early event in the development of cSCC as it interferes with proper immune surveillance and decreases the effectiveness of the immune response, and creates a more immunosuppressive environment, thus promoting cSCC progression.

Performance of a prognostic 31-gene expression profile in an independent cohort of 523 cutaneous melanoma patients.

BACKGROUND: The heterogeneous behavior of patients with melanoma makes prognostication challenging. To address this, a gene expression profile (GEP) test to predict metastatic risk was previously developed. This study evaluates the GEP's prognostic accuracy in an independent cohort of cutaneous melanoma patients. METHODS: This multi-center study analyzed primary melanoma tumors from 523 patients, using the GEP to classify patients as Class 1 (low risk) and Class 2 (high risk). Molecular classification was correlated to clinical outcome and assessed along with AJCC v7 staging criteria. Primary endpoints were recurrence-free (RFS) and distant metastasis-free (DMFS) survival. RESULTS: The 5-year RFS rates for Class 1 and Class 2 were 88% and 52%, respectively, and DMFS rates were 93% versus 60%, respectively (P < 0.001). The GEP was a significant predictor of RFS and DMFS in univariate analysis (hazard ratio [HR] = 5.4 and 6.6, respectively, P < 0.001 for each), along with Breslow thickness, ulceration, mitotic rate, and sentinel lymph node (SLN) status (P < 0.001 for each). GEP, tumor thickness and SLN status were significant predictors of RFS and DMFS in a multivariate model that also included ulceration and mitotic rate (RFS HR = 2.1, 1.2, and 2.5, respectively, P < 0.001 for each; and DMFS HR = 2.7, 1.3 and 3.0, respectively, P < 0.01 for each). CONCLUSIONS: The GEP test is an objective predictor of metastatic risk and provides additional independent prognostic information to traditional staging to help estimate an individual's risk for recurrence. The assay identified 70% of stage I and II patients who ultimately developed distant metastasis. Its role in consideration of patients for adjuvant therapy should be examined prospectively.

Cytokeratin CK 7 and CK 20 expression in pituitary adenomas.

The pattern of immunohistochemical expression of cytokeratins 7 (CK 7) and 20 (CK 20) is commonly used to assess possible primary sites of metastatic carcinomas. Because pituitary tumors are almost always benign, there has been little interest in their cytokeratin profile. However, we recently reported the use of CK 7/20 expression to document malignant progression and metastasis of a pituitary tumor, indicating the potential diagnostic usefulness of the CK 7/20 profile of pituitary adenomas. We analyzed CK 7/20 expression in 97 pituitary adenomas subclassified by immunohistochemical hormone expression. In about 90% of all subtypes, CK 7 was either negative or reactive in only a few scattered cells. Corticotrophs and sparsely granulated growth hormone-positive adenomas were consistently CK 20 positive (and CK 7 negative) whereas all other subtypes were almost always CK 20 negative. This CK 20-positive, CK 7-negative profile is previously described consistently only in colonic adenocarcinomas. This study documents that subtypes of pituitary adenomas have different CK 7/20 profiles. Whereas this pattern is likely to have diagnostic usefulness in only rare adenomas, the presence of a unique CK signature in corticotrophs and sparsely granulated growth hormone-positive adenomas, subtypes particularly noted for invasive and aggressive behavior, merits further investigation.