Altered-specificity mutants of the HIV Rev arginine-rich motif-RRE IIB interaction.

Arginine-rich motifs (ARMs) bind RNA structures with high affinity and specificity, and the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) exploits ARM-RNA interactions to regulate its lifecycle. The expression of HIV structural genes relies on recognition between the ARM of its Rev protein and its primary binding site, an internal loop in the viral RNA, the Rev-response element region IIB (IIB). Many functional variants of the Rev ARM-IIB interaction have been discovered, yet how easily it can evolve new specificities is poorly explored. A double mutant of Rev ARM, R35G-N40 V, uses an unknown strategy to recognize IIB. Here, isothermal titration calorimetry and gel shift assays show that the R35G-N40V-IIB interaction has high affinity and specificity in vitro and a larger unfavorable entropy change upon binding than that of wild-type Rev ARM-IIB. In stark contrast with the critical dependence of wild-type Rev on Arg35, Arg39, Asn40, and Arg44, mutational profiling shows R35G-N40V is highly mutable at positions 40 and 44 and dependent on Gly35, Arg38, Arg39, Arg42, and Arg43. Affinity measurements in vitro and reporter assay measurements in vivo are consistent with the wild-type Rev ARM and R35G-N40V maintaining their recognition strategies when binding IIB mutants specific to wild-type Rev ARM and R35G-N40V, respectively. Some single amino acid mutants of wild-type Rev ARM and R35G-N40V have enhanced specificity, recognizing mutant IIBs yet not wild-type IIB. These results provide another example of viral ARM-RNA interactions evolving new specificities with few mutations, consistent with neutral theories of evolution.

HK022 Nun Requires Arginine-Rich Motif Residues Distinct from λ N.

UNLABELLED: Bacteriophage λ N protein binds boxB RNA hairpins in the nut (N utilization) sites of immediate early λ transcripts and interacts with host factors to suppress transcriptional termination at downstream terminators. In opposition to λ N, the Nun protein of HK022 binds the boxBs of coinfecting λ transcripts, interacts with a similar or identical set of host factors, and terminates transcription to suppress λ replication. Comparison of N-boxB and Nun-boxB nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) structural models suggests similar interactions, though limited mutagenesis of Nun is available. Here, libraries of Nun's arginine-rich motif (ARM) were screened for the ability to exclude λ coinfection, and mutants were assayed for Nun termination with a boxB plasmid reporter system. Several Nun ARM residues appear to be immutable: Asp26, Arg28, Arg29, Arg32, Trp33, and Arg36. Asp26 and Trp33 appear to be unable to contact boxB and are not found at equivalent positions in λ N ARM. To understand if the requirement of Asp26, Trp33, and Arg36 indicated differences between HK022 Nun termination and λ N antitermination complexes, the same Nun libraries were fused to the activation domain of λ N and screened for clones able to complement N-deficient λ. Mutants were assayed for N antitermination. Surprisingly, Asp26 and Trp33 were still essential when Nun ARM was fused to N. Docking suggests that Nun ARM contacts a hydrophobic surface of the NusG carboxy-terminal domain containing residues necessary for Nun function. These findings indicate that Nun ARM relies on distinct contacts in its ternary complex and illustrate how protein-RNA recognition can evolve new regulatory functions. IMPORTANCE: λ N protein interacts with host factors to allow λ nut-containing transcripts to elongate past termination signals. A competing bacteriophage, HK022, expresses Nun protein, which causes termination of λ nut transcripts. λ N and HK022 Nun use similar arginine-rich motifs (ARMs) to bind the same boxB RNAs in nut transcripts. Screening libraries of Nun ARM mutants, both in HK022 Nun and in a λ N fusion, revealed amino acids essential to Nun that could bind one or more host factors. Docking suggests that NusG, which is present in both Nun termination and N antitermination, is a plausible partner. These findings could help understand how transcription elongation is regulated and illustrate how subtle differences allow ARMs to evolve new regulatory functions.

Randomized codon mutagenesis reveals that the HIV Rev arginine-rich motif is robust to substitutions and that double substitution of two critical residues alters specificity.

The binding of the arginine-rich motif (ARM) of HIV Rev protein to its high-affinity site in stem IIB in the Rev response element (RRE) initiates assembly of a ribonucleoprotein complex that mediates the export of essential, incompletely spliced viral transcripts. Many biochemical, genetic, and structural studies of Rev-RRE IIB have been published, yet the roles of many peptide residues in Rev ARM are unconfirmed by mutagenesis. Rev aptamer I (RAI) is an optimized RRE IIB that binds Rev with higher affinity and for which mutational data are sparse. Randomized-codon libraries of Rev ARM were assayed for their ability to bind RRE IIB and RAI using a bacterial reporter system based on bacteriophage λ N-nut antitermination. Most Rev ARM residues tolerated substitutions without strong loss of binding to RRE IIB, and all except arginine 39 tolerated substitution without strong loss of binding to RAI. The pattern of critical Rev residues is not the same for RRE IIB and RAI, suggesting important differences between the interactions. The results support and aid the interpretation of existing structural models. Observed clinical variation is consistent with additional constraints on Rev mutation. By chance, we found double mutants of two highly critical residues, arginine 35 (to glycine) and asparagine 40 (to valine or lysine), that bind RRE IIB well, but not RAI. That an apparently distinct binding mode occurs with only two mutations highlights the ability of ARMs to evolve new recognition strategies and supports the application of neutral theories of evolution to protein-RNA recognition.

The RNA-binding domain of bacteriophage P22 N protein is highly mutable, and a single mutation relaxes specificity toward lambda.

Antitermination in bacteriophage P22, a lambdoid phage, uses the arginine-rich domain of the N protein to recognize boxB RNAs in the nut site of two regulated transcripts. Using an antitermination reporter system, we screened libraries in which each nonconserved residue in the RNA-binding domain of P22 N was randomized. Mutants were assayed for the ability to complement N-deficient virus and for antitermination with P22 boxB(left) and boxB(right) reporters. Single amino acid substitutions complementing P22 N(-) virus were found at 12 of the 13 positions examined. We found evidence for defined structural roles for seven nonconserved residues, which was generally compatible with the nuclear magnetic resonance model. Interestingly, a histidine can be replaced by any other aromatic residue, although no planar partner is obvious. Few single substitutions showed bias between boxB(left) and boxB(right), suggesting that the two RNAs impose similar constraints on genetic drift. A separate library comprising only hybrids of the RNA-binding domains of P22, lambda, and phi21 N proteins produced mutants that displayed bias. P22 N(-) plaque size plotted against boxB(left) and boxB(right) reporter activities suggests that lytic viral fitness depends on balanced antitermination. A few N proteins were able to complement both lambda N- and P22 N-deficient viruses, but no proteins were found to complement both P22 N- and phi21 N-deficient viruses. A single tryptophan substitution allowed P22 N to complement both P22 and lambda N(-). The existence of relaxed-specificity mutants suggests that conformational plasticity provides evolutionary transitions between distinct modes of RNA-protein recognition.

Bacteriophage P22 antitermination boxB sequence requirements are complex and overlap with those of lambda.

Transcription antitermination in phages lambda and P22 uses N proteins that bind to similar boxB RNA hairpins in regulated transcripts. In contrast to the lambda N-boxB interaction, the P22 N-boxB interaction has not been extensively studied. A nuclear magnetic resonance structure of the P22 N peptide boxB(left) complex and limited mutagenesis have been reported but do not reveal a consensus sequence for boxB. We have used a plasmid-based antitermination system to screen boxBs with random loops and to test boxB mutants. We find that P22 N requires boxB to have a GNRA-like loop with no simple requirements on the remaining sequences in the loop or stem. U:A or A:U base pairs are strongly preferred adjacent to the loop and appear to modulate N binding in cooperation with the loop and distal stem. A few GNRA-like hexaloops have moderate activity. Some boxB mutants bind P22 and lambda N, indicating that the requirements imposed on boxB by P22 N overlap those imposed by lambda N. Point mutations can dramatically alter boxB specificity between P22 and lambda N. A boxB specific for P22 N can be mutated to lambda N specificity by a series of single mutations via a bifunctional intermediate, as predicted by neutral theories of evolution.