Revisiting the Cholinergic Hypothesis in Alzheimer's Disease: Emerging Evidence from Translational and Clinical Research.

Scientific evidence collected over the past 4 decades suggests that a loss of cholinergic innervation in the cerebral cortex of patients with Alzheimer's disease is an early pathogenic event correlated with cognitive impairment. This evidence led to the formulation of the "Cholinergic Hypothesis of AD" and the development of cholinesterase inhibitor therapies. Although approved only as symptomatic therapies, recent studies suggest that long-term use of these drugs may also have disease-modifying benefits. A Cholinergic System Workgroup reassessed the role of the cholinergic system on AD pathogenesis in light of recent data, including neuroimaging data charting the progression of neurodegeneration in the cholinergic system and suggesting that cholinergic therapy may slow brain atrophy. Other pathways that contribute to cholinergic synaptic loss and their effect on cognitive impairment in AD were also reviewed. These studies indicate that the cholinergic system as one of several interacting systems failures that contribute to AD pathogenesis.

Clinical trials and late-stage drug development for Alzheimer's disease: an appraisal from 1984 to 2014.

The modern era of drug development for Alzheimer's disease began with the proposal of the cholinergic hypothesis of memory impairment and the 1984 research criteria for Alzheimer's disease. Since then, despite the evaluation of numerous potential treatments in clinical trials, only four cholinesterase inhibitors and memantine have shown sufficient safety and efficacy to allow marketing approval at an international level. Although this is probably because the other drugs tested were ineffective, inadequate clinical development methods have also been blamed for the failures. Here, we review the development of treatments for Alzheimer's disease during the past 30 years, considering the drugs, potential targets, late-stage clinical trials, development methods, emerging use of biomarkers and evolution of regulatory considerations in order to summarize advances and anticipate future developments. We have considered late-stage Alzheimer's disease drug development from 1984 to 2013, including individual clinical trials, systematic and qualitative reviews, meta-analyses, methods, commentaries, position papers and guidelines. We then review the evolution of drugs in late clinical development, methods, biomarkers and regulatory issues. Although a range of small molecules and biological products against many targets have been investigated in clinical trials, the predominant drug targets have been the cholinergic system and the amyloid cascade. Trial methods have evolved incrementally: inclusion criteria have largely remained focused on mild-to-moderate Alzheimer's disease criteria, recently extending to early or prodromal Alzheimer disease or 'mild cognitive impairment due to Alzheimer's disease', for drugs considered to be disease modifying. The duration of trials has remained at 6-12 months for drugs intended to improve symptoms; 18- to 24-month trials have been established for drugs expected to attenuate clinical course. Cognitive performance, activities of daily living, global change and severity ratings have persisted as the primary clinically relevant outcomes. Regulatory guidance and oversight have evolved to allow for enrichment of early-stage Alzheimer's disease trial samples using biomarkers and phase-specific outcomes. In conclusion, validated drug targets for Alzheimer's disease remain to be developed. Only drugs that affect an aspect of cholinergic function have shown consistent, but modest, clinical effects in late-phase trials. There is opportunity for substantial improvements in drug discovery and clinical development methods.

[New spectrum of HIV-associated cognitive disorders in the HAART era]. / Nouveau spectre des troubles cognitifs liés à l'infection par le VIH à l'ère des trithérapies.

Highly active anti-retroviral therapy (HAART) has almost abolished HIV-related mortality and serious opportunistic diseases; among them, AIDS-related dementia. However, minor forms of cognitive dysfunction, have not disappeared, and even increased in frequency. Ageing of HIV+ patients, insufficient penetration of anti-viral drugs into the brain with continuous low-grade viral production and inflammation may play a role. Minor cognitive dysfunction in HIV infection shares some clinical and pathophysiological features with neuro-degenerative diseases, in particular Alzheimers disease. It can thus be postulated that, such in Alzheimer disease, anti-cholinesterase drugs might also be efficacious in AIDS-related minor cognitive dysfunction. This hypothesis has not been tested yet however A clinical trial using ravistigmine is starting this spring in patients with HIV-associated cognitive dysfunction in Geneva and Lausanne.

Mild cognitive impairment--beyond controversies, towards a consensus: report of the International Working Group on Mild Cognitive Impairment.

The First Key Symposium was held in Stockholm, Sweden, 2-5 September 2003. The aim of the symposium was to integrate clinical and epidemiological perspectives on the topic of Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI). A multidisciplinary, international group of experts discussed the current status and future directions of MCI, with regard to clinical presentation, cognitive and functional assessment, and the role of neuroimaging, biomarkers and genetics. Agreement on new perspectives, as well as recommendations for management and future research were discussed by the international working group. The specific recommendations for the general MCI criteria include the following: (i) the person is neither normal nor demented; (ii) there is evidence of cognitive deterioration shown by either objectively measured decline over time and/or subjective report of decline by self and/or informant in conjunction with objective cognitive deficits; and (iii) activities of daily living are preserved and complex instrumental functions are either intact or minimally impaired.

Long-term stabilizing effect of cholinesterase inhibitors in the therapy of Alzheimer' disease.

During the last decade, a systematic effort to develop a pharmacological treatment for Alzheimer disease (AD) resulted into three drugs being registered for the first time in USA and Europe. All three compounds are cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEI). The major therapeutic effect of ChEI on AD patients is to maintain cognitive function at a stable level during a 6 months to one year period of treatment as compared to placebo. Additional drug effects are slowing cognitive deterioration and improving behavioral and daily living activity. Recent studies show that in many patients the cognitive stabilization effect can be prolonged up to 24 months. This long-lasting effect suggests a mechanism of action other than symptomatic and direct cholinergic. In vitro and in vivo studies have consistently demonstrated a link between cholinergic activation and APP metabolism. Lesions of cholinergic nuclei cause a rapid increase in cortical APP and CSF. The effect of such lesions can be reversed by ChEI treatment. Reduction in cholinergic neurotransmission experimental or pathological (AD) leads to amyloidogenic metabolism and contributes to the neuropathology and cognitive dysfunction. In order to explain the long-term effect of ChEI, a mechanism based on beta-amyloid metabolism, is postulated. Evidence for such an effect is available at experimental as well as at clinical level. Does cholinergic stabilization imply slowing down disability or delaying disease progression?

Brain energy metabolism in Alzheimer's disease: 99mTc-HMPAO SPECT imaging during verbal fluency and role of astrocytes in the cellular mechanism of 99mTc-HMPAO retention.

The central hypothesis of the study which has been carried out as part of the NRP38 program, is that perturbations of brain energy metabolism are critically involved in the neurodegeneration occurring in Alzheimer's disease (AD) and that they may correlate with early cognitive dysfunctioning. In the present multidisciplinary study we set out to monitor brain energy metabolism using FDG-PET and HMPAO-SPECT imaging in a cohort of individuals over 65 years of age, drawn from the general population. HMPAO-SPECT imaging, which is a simpler and more widely accessible imaging procedure than FDG-PET, was performed under basal conditions and during the performance of a cognitive task (verbal fluency test). Three groups were studied. Two groups (groups I and II) included individuals age 65 or more, with no cognitive impairment and carrying an APOE4 positive or APOE4 negative phenotype, respectively; a third group (group III) included patients with clinical signs of AD. Each subject entering the study underwent an FDG-PET, an HMPAO-SPECT and an extensive battery of neuropsychological tests which assess various aspects of cognitive functioning, with a strong emphasis on working memory, divided attention and executive functions. A total of 101 participants were submitted to brain imaging and neuropsychological testing. Among these, 60 participants received the same set of imaging and neuropsychological tasks 24-36 months after the first set (phase II). In this article, we present a preliminary analysis performed on ten subjects from groups I and II and nine subjects from group III: activation (verbal fluency task) induced a specific pattern of increase in HMPAO retention (including BA 9/10, BA 18 bilaterally and right BA 17). In contrast to controls, in nine AD subjects no significant differences in HMPAO retention were observed when comparing activation and basal conditions. The cellular and molecular mechanisms that underlie the retention of HMPAO, the tracer used for single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) imaging, has been studied in vitro in purified preparations of neurons and astrocytes with the aim of investigating the contribution of different cell types to hexamethyl-propyleneamineoxime labeled with technetium-99m (99mTc-HMPAO) retention in vitro. Results show that 99mTc-HMPAO retention predominates in astrocytes over neurons by a factor of approximately 2.5. Diethyl maleate, ethacrynic acid and buthionine sulfoximine, three agents which significantly reduce glutathione levels, also decreased 99mTc-HMPAO retention in both astrocytes and in neurons. Decrease did not always correlate with glutathione levels however, thus suggesting that other factors could be involved. The data presented indicate that astrocytes might constitute a prominent site of 99mTc-HMPAO retention and most likely contribute significantly to the SPECT signal. In addition, they also suggest that specific alterations in glial cell metabolism could explain flow-independent changes in 99mTc-HMPAO retention in the brain as observed by SPECT in certain pathologies (including Alzheimer's disease). In particular, these observations suggest a key role of astrocytes in the signal detected with the imaging procedure, which is altered in the Alzheimer's cohort subjected to the verbal fluency activation task.

Is anti-cholinesterase therapy of Alzheimer's disease delaying progression?

During the last decade, a systematic effort to develop a pharmacological treatment for Alzheimer's disease (AD) resulted in three drugs being registered for the first time in the US and Europe. All three compounds are cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEI). The major therapeutic effect of ChEI on AD patients is to maintain cognitive function at a stable level during a 6-month to 1-year period of treatment, as compared to placebo. Additional drug effects are to slow down cognitive deterioration and improve behavioral and daily living activity. Recent studies show that in many patients the cognitive stabilization effect can be prolonged up to 24 months. This long-lasting effect suggests a mechanism of action other than symptomatic, and directly cholinergic. In vitro and in vivo studies have consistently demonstrated a link between cholinergic activation and amyloid precursor protein (APP) metabolism. Lesions of cholinergic nuclei cause a rapid increase in cortical APP and cholinergic synaptic function; the effect of such lesions can be reversed by ChEI treatment. A reduction in cholinergic neurotransmission, experimental or pathological, leads to amyloidogenic metabolism and contributes to the development of neuropathology and cognitive dysfunction. To explain the long-term effect of ChEI, for which evidence is available on an experimental as well as clinical level, a mechanism based on beta-amyloid metabolism is postulated. The question whether cholinergic stabilization implies simply slowing down progression of disability or also involves delay of disease progression is discussed.

Economic considerations of Alzheimer's disease and related disorders.

Economic analyses of geriatric syndromes are seldom performed. However, demographic and epidemiological imperatives have led to significant interest in the evaluation of AD-related costs. Over 300 papers devoted to economic considerations of Alzheimer's disease have been published in peer-reviewed journals, within the last five years. In these papers, the chosen perspective (costs to society or to specific payers) is important. Analytical methods are still evolving and remain complex. Unresolved methodological issues will need to be addressed to further our understanding of long-term economic consequences. At present, it is clear that diagnostic and drug costs are low compared to the major cost of institutionalization. Thus, directing efforts at early diagnosis and delaying nursing home placement are two key cost-containment interventions. In this respect, the need to support informal care should not be underestimated.

Do cholinesterase inhibitors have disease-modifying effects in Alzheimer's disease?

During the last decade, a systematic effort to develop a pharmacological treatment for Alzheimer disease (AD) has resulted in drugs being registered for the first time in the US and Europe for this specific indication. The 3 agents registered are cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEIs). The major therapeutic effect of ChEIs in patients with AD is the maintenance of cognitive function, as compared with placebo, during a 6-month to 1-year period of treatment. Additional drug effects that may occur are the slowing of cognitive deterioration and improvement of behaviour and daily living activities. Comparison of clinical effects of 6 ChEIs demonstrates a rather similar magnitude of improvement in cognitive outcome measures. For some drugs, this level may represent an upper limit, while for others it may be possible to increase the benefit further. In order to maximise and prolong positive drug effects it is important to start treatment early and adjust the dosage during treatment. Recent studies that used this administration strategy have shown that in many patients, the stabilisation effect produced by ChEIs can be prolonged for as long as 36 months. This long-lasting effect suggests mechanisms of action other than symptomatic ones. In this article, the effects of ChEIs on beta-amyloid metabolism are postulated to explain the stabilising (i.e. disease-modifying) effects of the drugs. Evidence for such a mechanism is available at the experimental but not yet at the clinical level.

Selective inhibitors of butyrylcholinesterase: a valid alternative for therapy of Alzheimer's disease?

The brain of mammals contains two major forms of cholinesterases (ChEs): acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE). The two forms differ genetically, structurally and in their kinetics. Butyrylcholine is not a physiological substrate in mammalian brains which makes the function of BuChE difficult to interpret. In human brains, BuChE is found in neurons and glial cells as well as in neuritic plaques and tangles in patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD). While AChE activity decreases progressively in the brain of patients with AD, BuChE activity shows some increase. In order to study the function of BuChE, we perfused intracortically the rat brain with a selective BuChE inhibitor. We found that extracellular acetylcholine levels increased 15-fold from 5 nmol/L to 75 nmol/L concentrations, with little cholinergic adverse effect in the animal. Based on these data, we postulated that two pools of ChEs may be present in the brain: one mainly neuronal and AChE dependent; and one mainly glial and BuChE dependent. The two pools show different kinetic properties with regard to regulation of acetylcholine concentration in the brain and can be separated with selective inhibitors. The recent development of highly selective BuChE inhibitors will allow us to test these new agents in patients with AD in order to find out whether or not they represent an advantage for the treatment of patients with AD as compared with selective (donepezil) or relatively non-selective (rivastigmine, galantamine) ChE inhibitors presently in use. The association between a BuChE-K variant and AD has not been confirmed in several studies. In conclusion, additional experimental and clinical work is necessary in order to elucidate the role of BuChE in normal brain function and in the brains of patients with AD. In the future, it may be possible that selective BuChE inhibitors will have a role in treatment of patients with advanced AD.

Cholinesterase inhibitors stabilize Alzheimer disease.

During the last decade, a systematic effort to develop a pharmacological treatment for Alzheimer disease (AD) has resulted into three drugs being registered for the first time in USA and Europe for this specific indication. All three are cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEI). The major therapeutic effect of ChEI on AD patients is to maintain cognitive function at a constant level during a 6 months to one year period of treatment as compared to placebo. Additional drug effects might be slowing cognitive deterioration and improving behavioral and daily living conditions. Comparison of clinical effects of 6 ChEI demonstrates a rather similar magnitude of improvement in cognitive measures. For some drugs. this may represent an upper limit while for other it may still be possible to increase further the benefit. In order to maximize and prolong positive drug effects it is important to start early and adjust dosage during the treatment. Recent studies show that in many patients the stabilization effect produced by ChEI can be prolonged for as long as a 24 month period. In order to explain the stabilizing effect of ChEI, a mechanism other than AChE inhibition, based on beta-amyloid metabolism, is postulated.

Present and future of Alzheimer therapy.

Three major lines of drugs have been developed or are under development for the treatment of Alzheimer Disease (AD): cholinergic drugs (mainly cholinesterase inhibitors), anti-beta-amyloid drugs, estrogens and anti-inflammatories. Cholinesterase inhibitors are the only drugs presently approved in USA and Europe for the indication of AD. Cholinesterase inhibitors tested in clinical trials in Europe, USA and Japan include less than ten drugs, however most of these compounds have advanced to clinical trials III. Based on results related to a population of over 8,000 patients we conclude that several of these compounds have shown significant clinical efficacy and safety in the treatment of Alzheimer disease. There are, however, differences with regard to side effects. The major clinical effect is stabilization of cognitive function during a six- to 12-months period with a parallel improvement of behavioral symptoms. Long-term effect of cholinesterase inhibitors extending to a two year-period has been reported. Future applications of these drugs are treatment of other types dementias such as Lewy body dementia, vascular dementia and Down Syndrome dementia. Combination of cholinesterase inhibitors with estrogens, anti-oxidants and anti-inflammatories may represent a further improvement of the therapy. From the economical point of view, treatment with cholinesterase inhibitors is not cost neutral.

Cholinesterase inhibitor therapy stabilizes symptoms of Alzheimer disease.

Cholinesterase inhibitors tested in clinical trials in Europe, the United States, and Japan include fewer than 10 drugs; however, most of these compounds have advanced to clinical phase III trials. Based on results related to a population of more than 8,000 patients, we conclude that several of these compounds have shown significant clinical efficacy and safety in the treatment of Alzheimer disease. There are, however, differences with regard to side effects. The major clinical effect is stabilization of cognitive function during a 6- to 12-month period with an improvement of behavioral symptoms. The long-term effect of cholinesterase inhibitors extending to a 2-year period was reported. Future applications of these drugs include treatment of other types of dementias such as Lewy bodies dementia, vascular dementia, and Down syndrome dementia. The combination of cholinesterase inhibitors with estrogens, antioxidants, and anti-inflammatories may represent a further improvement of the therapy. From an economical point of view, treatment with cholinesterase inhibitors is not cost neutral.

Cholinesterase inhibitors stabilize Alzheimer's disease.

During the last decade, a systematic effort to develop a pharmacological treatment for Alzheimer disease (AD) has resulted into three drugs being registered for the first time in the USA and Europe for this specific indication. All three are cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEI). The major therapeutic effect of ChEI on AD patients is to maintain cognitive function at a constant level during a six-month to one-year period of treatment, as compared to placebo. Additional drug effects might slow cognitive deterioration and improve behavioral and daily living conditions. Comparison of clinical effects of six ChEI demonstrates a rather similar magnitude of improvement in cognitive measures. For some drugs, this may represent an upper limit, whereas for other it may still be possible to further increase the benefit. In order to maximize and prolong positive drug effects, it is important to start early and adjust dosage during the treatment. Recent studies show that in many patients the stabilization effect produced by ChEI can be prolonged for as long as a 24-month period. In order to explain the stabilizing effect of ChEI, a mechanism other than AChE inhibition, based on beta-amyloid metabolism, is postulated.

Expression of nicotinic acetylcholine receptor subunits in the cerebral cortex in Alzheimer's disease: histotopographical correlation with amyloid plaques and hyperphosphorylated-tau protein.

Impairment of cholinergic transmission and decreased numbers of nicotinic binding sites are well-known features accompanying the cognitive dysfunction seen in Alzheimer's disease (AD). In order to elucidate the underlying cause of this cholinoceptive dysfunction, the expression of two pharmacologically different nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) subunits (alpha4, alpha7) was studied in the cerebral cortex of Alzheimer patients as compared to controls. Patch-clamp recordings of 14 dissociated neurons of control cortices showed responses suggesting the existence of alpha4- and alpha7-containing functional nAChRs in the human cortex. In cortices of Alzheimer patients and controls, the pattern of distribution and the number of alpha4 and alpha7 mRNA-expressing neurons were similar, whereas at the protein level a decrease in the density of alpha4- and alpha7-expressing neurons of approximately 30% was observed in Alzheimer patients. The histotopographical correlation of nAChR expression with accompanying pathological changes, e.g. accumulation of hyperphosphorylated-tau (HP-tau) protein and beta-amyloid showed that neurons in the vicinity of beta-amyloid plaques bore both nAChR transcripts. Neurons heavily labelled for HP-tau, however, expressed little or no alpha4 and alpha7 mRNA. These results point to an impaired synthesis of nAChRs on the protein level as a possible cause of the cholinoceptive deficit in AD. Further investigations need to elucidate whether interactions of HP-tau with nAChR mRNA, or alterations in the quality of alpha4 and alpha7 transcripts give rise to decreased protein expression at the level of individual neurons.

Cholinergic foundations of Alzheimer's disease therapy.

Cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEI) represent the drug of choice for Alzheimer's disease (AD) treatment. They produce significant improvement on cognitive as well as non-cognitive function for a period up to 1 year during the first 3 years following clinical diagnosis. The magnitude of cognitive improvements is similar for different ChEI, however, differences are seen with regard to incidence and severity of side effects, optimal ChE inhibition, pharmacokinetic properties and mode of administration.

Invited review: Cholinesterase inhibitors for Alzheimer's disease therapy: from tacrine to future applications.

This review starts with an historical background of the pharmacological development of tacrine almost fifty years ago (1949). Tacrine is the first drug to be tested, clinically, on a large scale and to be registered (1993) for treatment of Alzheimer's disease. For the first time, clinical results of four second generation cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEI) (donepezil, ENA 713, eptastigmine and metrifonate) are reviewed and compared with other ChEI such as tacrine, physostigmine and galanthamine. Data based on more than 6000 patients show that second generation drugs are well tolerated and show evidence of clinical efficacy. Differences are mainly due to frequency of side effects, number of drop outs and percentage of improved patients. These results also demonstrate the presence of clinical efficacy for all ChEI tested so far. Clinical mechanism of action, levels of efficacy and differences among various ChEI are discussed. Future potential indications are suggested. The present data indicate that optimization of effects prolongation and maintenance of clinical gains will depend on further knowledge of the compounds pharmacodynamic properties.

Aging, Alzheimer's disease, and estrogen therapy.

Experimental studies in vivo and in vitro, as well-retrospective studies in post-menopausal women suggest that taking estrogens for a number of years may reduce the risk to develop Alzheimer's Disease (AD). Because these conclusions are drawn mainly on the basis of retrospective studies, large, randomized, placebo-controlled trials are necessary before recommending use of estrogens to women for the prevention of AD.

Treatment of Alzheimer's disease. New developments.

Cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEI) represent the drug of choice for Alzheimer's disease treatment. They produce significant improvement on cognitive as well as non-cognitive function for a period up to one year during the first three years period following clinical onset. The magnitude of cognitive improvements is similar for different ChEI; however, differences are seen with regard to incidence and severity of side effects, incidence of drop-outs, optimal ChE inhibition, pharmacokinetics properties and mode of administration.