Personnel radiation dose considerations in the use of an integrated PET-CT scanner for radiotherapy treatment planning.

The acquisition of radiotherapy planning scans on positron emission tomography (PET)-CT scanners requires the involvement of radiotherapy radiographers. This study assessed the radiation dose received by these radiographers during this process. Radiotherapy planning (18)F-fluorodeoxyglucose ((18)F-FDG) PET-CT scans were acquired for 28 non-small cell lung cancer patients. In order to minimise the radiation dose received, a two-stage process was used in which the most time-consuming part of the set-up was performed before the patient received their (18)F-FDG injection. Throughout this process, the radiographers wore electronic personal dosemeters and recorded the doses received at different stages of the process. The mean total radiation dose received by a radiotherapy radiographer was 5.1+/-2.6 microSv per patient. The use of the two-stage process reduced the time spent in close proximity to the patient by approximately a factor of four. The two-stage process was effective in keeping radiation dose to a minimum. The use of a pre-injection set-up session reduces the radiation dose to the radiotherapy radiographers because of their involvement in PET-CT radiotherapy treatment planning scans by approximately a factor of three.

A method for synchronizing an external respiratory signal with a list-mode PET acquisition.

A method is proposed to synchronize positron emission tomography (PET) list-mode data with an externally recorded respiratory signal in the absence of a master clock. When the respiratory signal reaches a user-defined threshold, a trigger mark is stored in the list-mode file. After the acquisition, synchronization is achieved when the stored trigger marks are superimposed on the respiratory curve to form a horizontal line over time at the user-defined threshold. Synchronization was possible and unequivocal for ten out of ten clinical studies. The list-mode acquisition actually started approximately 40 and 4 s after acquisition initiation at the user interface of the Philips Gemini and the GE DLS PET-CT systems, respectively.

Fuzzy hidden Markov chains segmentation for volume determination and quantitation in PET.

Accurate volume of interest (VOI) estimation in PET is crucial in different oncology applications such as response to therapy evaluation and radiotherapy treatment planning. The objective of our study was to evaluate the performance of the proposed algorithm for automatic lesion volume delineation; namely the fuzzy hidden Markov chains (FHMC), with that of current state of the art in clinical practice threshold based techniques. As the classical hidden Markov chain (HMC) algorithm, FHMC takes into account noise, voxel intensity and spatial correlation, in order to classify a voxel as background or functional VOI. However the novelty of the fuzzy model consists of the inclusion of an estimation of imprecision, which should subsequently lead to a better modelling of the 'fuzzy' nature of the object of interest boundaries in emission tomography data. The performance of the algorithms has been assessed on both simulated and acquired datasets of the IEC phantom, covering a large range of spherical lesion sizes (from 10 to 37 mm), contrast ratios (4:1 and 8:1) and image noise levels. Both lesion activity recovery and VOI determination tasks were assessed in reconstructed images using two different voxel sizes (8 mm3 and 64 mm3). In order to account for both the functional volume location and its size, the concept of % classification errors was introduced in the evaluation of volume segmentation using the simulated datasets. Results reveal that FHMC performs substantially better than the threshold based methodology for functional volume determination or activity concentration recovery considering a contrast ratio of 4:1 and lesion sizes of <28 mm. Furthermore differences between classification and volume estimation errors evaluated were smaller for the segmented volumes provided by the FHMC algorithm. Finally, the performance of the automatic algorithms was less susceptible to image noise levels in comparison to the threshold based techniques. The analysis of both simulated and acquired datasets led to similar results and conclusions as far as the performance of segmentation algorithms under evaluation is concerned.

The role of PET/CT scanning in radiotherapy planning.

The introduction of functional data into the radiotherapy treatment planning process is currently the focus of significant commercial, technical, scientific and clinical development. The potential of such data from positron emission tomography (PET) was recognized at an early stage and was integrated into the radiotherapy treatment planning process through the use of image fusion software. The combination of PET and CT in a single system (PET/CT) to form an inherently fused anatomical and functional dataset has provided an imaging modality which could be used as the prime tool in the delineation of tumour volumes and the preparation of patient treatment plans, especially when integrated with virtual simulation. PET imaging typically using 18F-Fluorodeoxyglucose (18F-FDG) can provide data on metabolically active tumour volumes. These functional data have the potential to modify treatment volumes and to guide treatment delivery to cells with particular metabolic characteristics. This paper reviews the current status of the integration of PET and PET/CT data into the radiotherapy treatment process. Consideration is given to the requirements of PET/CT data acquisition with reference to patient positioning aids and the limitations imposed by the PET/CT system. It also reviews the approaches being taken to the definition of functional/tumour volumes and the mechanisms available to measure and include physiological motion into the imaging process. The use of PET data must be based upon a clear understanding of the interpretation and limitations of the functional signal. Protocols for the implementation of this development remain to be defined, and outcomes data based upon clinical trials are still awaited.

UK audit of single photon emission computed tomography reconstruction software using software generated phantoms.

The purpose of this study was to undertake an audit of the quantitative characteristics of single photon emission computed tomography software using projection data from an analytically generated software phantom and a measured line source. The phantom consisted of three structures. A uniformly filled cylinder, a series of cylindrical rods of various diameters in a background activity with a rod to background ratio of 2:1 and lastly, a set of three concentric rings of activity in the ratio 1:0:1. The phantom contained no added statistical noise. No attenuation was imposed on the data. The phantom was generated analytically and projections were distributed at six different count densities. A single set of projections from a thin line source was also distributed. These data were distributed to centres throughout the UK. Centres were asked to reconstruct the data using a 'ramp only' reconstruction with no additional smoothing function applied. Data were requested for mean and standard deviation in the uniform cylinder, the maximum counts for each cylindrical rod and the mean counts in regions placed within the concentric rings. For the measured line source, centres were asked to measure the full width at half maximum and peak pixel counts for a profile through the reconstructed line. Results from 115 systems were obtained from 100 centres throughout the UK. These provided data from 12 software providers, 11 of these being commercial companies. Data were compared with the known input values and histograms of the distribution of results obtained. Significant differences in quantitative parameters were noted for the different input count densities as well as between suppliers and revisions of software from single suppliers.

UK audit and analysis of quantitative parameters obtained from gamma camera renography.

The purpose of this study was to perform an audit of quantitative values obtained from gamma camera renography in the UK. Ten patient image sequences representing normal and pathological renal function were obtained from archived studies and distributed to hospitals in the UK. Hospitals were asked to measure five parameters: relative function, renogram time-to-peak (left and right), and whole kidney mean transit time (left and right). Details of methodology, software used and operator experience were requested. This allowed the influence of operational factors on variations in reported values to be examined. A total of 180 responses from 81 hospitals were received. Values reported for the parameters, together with other details supplied, were entered into Excel and SPSS for statistical analysis. Histograms representing the distribution of values were produced for each parameter. The largest variations were found for mean transit time and occasionally for time-to-peak. The effect of factors was assessed using nonparametric statistical tests applied independently to each renogram. For all the parameters, the hospital, UK region, supplier, computer and software version influenced variations in the reported values. Algorithm and site of background region were influencing factors for relative function, the background subtraction method influenced time-to-peak, and curve smoothing influenced mean transit time.

Influence of arm positioning on tomographic thallium-201 myocardial perfusion imaging and the effect of attenuation correction.

Lateral attenuation in single-photon emission tomography (SPET) myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) has been attributed to the left arm if it is held by the patient's side during data acquisition. As a result MPI data are conventionally acquired with the arms held above the head. The aims of this study were to determine the effect of imaging arms down on reconstructed tomographic images depicting regional myocardial thallium-201 distribution and to assess whether attenuation-corrected (AC) myocardial perfusion images acquired arms down could replace uncorrected (NC) images acquired arms up for routine clinical service. Twenty-eight patients referred for routine MPI underwent sequential 180 degrees emission/transmission imaging for attenuation correction using an L-shaped dual-headed gamma camera (GE Optima) fitted with two gadolinium-153 scanning line sources. Delay data were acquired twice: once supine with the arms up and then supine with the arms down. Detector radius of rotation (ROR) for arms up and arms-down studies was recorded. For each data set, count density was measured in 17 segments of a polar plot and segmental uptake expressed relative to study maximum. Oblique images were assessed qualitatively by two observers blinded to study type for tracer distribution and overall quality. Transmission maps were assessed for truncation. Mean detector ROR was 190 mm for arms-up studies and 232 mm for arms-down studies (P<0.05). Population mean segmental relative uptake values for NC arms-up studies were higher than for NC arms-down studies, with the greatest difference seen anterolaterally. Nevertheless, the majority (24/28) of oblique NC arms-up and NC arms-down images appeared similar and only four (14%) NC arms-down studies showed additional areas of reduced count density (one anterior and three lateral). Corresponding AC arms-down studies showed that count density within the anterior defect improved to normal but the lateral reductions persisted, and in two of these three studies the arms-down transmission map was distorted. Population mean segmental relative uptake values for NC arms-down studies were lower than for AC arms-down studies apart from three anterolateral segments where NC arms-down values were higher. Of 28 AC arms-down studies, 11 (39%) were of reduced quality compared with NC arms-up studies because of poorer spatial resolution and because AC enhances liver activity compared with NC. It is concluded that arm positioning influences reconstructed tomographic images depicting regional 201T1 distribution, particularly anterolaterally. There is lateral undercorrection in approximately 10% of AC arms-down studies, possibly because of attenuation map truncation. Image quality is reduced in about one-third of AC armsdown studies compared with NC arms-up studies. These data suggest that this attenuation correction method is not sufficiently robust to allow routine acquisition of MPI data with the arms down.

Quality assurance in myocardial perfusion tomography: a collaborative BNCS/BNMS audit programme. British Nuclear Cardiology Society/British nuclear Medicine Society.

The aim of this study was to assess the status of acquisition and reporting of myocardial perfusion tomography in the UK. Centres were asked to provide an expert panel with clinical and technical information, digital and hard copy of raw data and reconstructed tomograms, as well as their report (optional) for five randomly selected studies. Ninety studies were received from 18 centres; report text was provided for 66 studies. Six parameters (stress technique, radiopharmaceutical usage, image acquisition and processing, report images and text) were scored as good (2), adequate (1) or poor (0) by consensus. Centres received the quality scores for each study and a consensus clinical report from the panel. Stress technique was scored as inadequate in 10 (11%) studies, radiopharmaceutical usage and image acquisition as inadequate in 5 (6%) studies, image processing as inadequate in 8 (10%) studies and report images as inadequate in 2 (3%) studies. Report text was felt to be inadequate in 21 of 66 (32%) studies; in 11 of these (52%), the report text was judged to be incorrect and in 10 (48%) it was essentially correct but misleading because of poor phraseology. The mean quality score per study was 1.3 (range 0.5-2.0). Seventeen of 88 (19%) studies scored less than 1.0 and were considered to be of poor quality. In conclusion, a large variation in standards of myocardial perfusion tomography was seen. Data acquisition was generally satisfactory, but 32% of reports were inadequate.

UK audit of relative renal function measurement using DMSA scintigraphy.

A variety of software is used to determine quantitative parameters from radionuclide imaging procedures. Knowledge of the variability of parameter values found in different hospitals is an important aspect of clinical audit of these techniques. This study investigated the variation in relative renal function measurement from static DMSA scintigraphy in the UK. Ten studies representing a range of ages and relative function values were distributed in digital form to 100 hospitals with the assistance of the gamma camera computer suppliers and regional audit coordinators. The studies were analysed at each participating hospital and details of the different techniques and computer systems used were documented. The median value of relative percentage function was assessed for each of the studies. Methods varied in terms of the view used for analysis (54% geometric mean, 46% posterior), the type of background subtraction (single region 32%, separate regions 60%, none 8%) and the definition of the renal regions of interest (73% manual, 27% semi-automatic). Eighty-eight percent of results were within two percentage points of the study median and 98% within five percentage points. There were statistically significant differences observed in the results arising from the view used for the analysis and the background subtraction protocol. The results indicate that relative renal function assessment from static DMSA scintigraphy in the UK is essentially a reliable procedure, although improvements could be made by standardizing the technique used.

Effect of attenuation correction on myocardial thallium-201 distribution in patients with a low likelihood of coronary artery disease.

Regional variation of tracer distribution is seen in uncorrected thallium-201 images of normal hearts. This study evaluates the effect of attenuation correction on myocardial 201T1 distribution in patients with low risk of coronary artery disease. An L-shaped dual-detector single-photon emission tomographic system equipped with a pair gadolinium-153 scanning line sources was used for sequential emission/transmission imaging in 36 patients (14 men and 22 women) with less than 5% risk for coronary artery disease. Uncorrected emission images were reconstructed using filtered back-projection (FBP) whereas the attenuation corrected (AC) images were iteratively reconstructed using the attenuation map computed from the transmission data. Both sets of images were reorientated into short axis, vertical long axis and horizontal long axis images. For quantification data were reconstructed into polar plots and count density estimated in 17 myocardial segments. The population % standard deviation for each segment of AC data was significantly smaller than that for FBP data, indicating improved homogeneity of tracer distribution. In men the anterior-basal inferior activity ratio improved from 1.20 for FBP to 0.96 for AC (stress) and from 1.23 for FBP to 0.98 for AC (delay) (P < 0.0001). In women the anterior-basal inferior activity ratio changed from 1.08 for FBP to 0.94 for AC (stress) and from 1.08 for FBP to 0.93 for AC (delay) (P < 0.001). These ratios reflect appropriate compensation for basal attenuation but a lack of scatter correction. The lateral-septal activity ratio in men changed from 1.05 for FBP to 0.99 for AC (stress) and from 1.02 for FBP to 0.96 for AC (delay), while in women it changed from 1.05 for FBP to 0.98 for AC (stress) and from 1.04 for FBP to 0.98 for AC (delay) (P < 0.005 in all cases). The apex of AC images showed a decrease in activity consistent with wall thining at this site. It is concluded that the use of attenuation correction yields improved homogeneity of myocardial tracer distribution in patients with low risk of coronary artery disease. The diagnostic benefits of attenuation correction are yet to be fully assessed.

Transmission scanning for attenuation correction of myocardial 201Tl images in obese patients.

For attenuation correction (AC) of 201Tl myocardial perfusion images, an accurate attenuation map is required. This study assessed whether prolonged transmission scanning is required in obese compared to normal-sized patients. Twenty-nine obese patients (mean body mass index 33 kg m-2) underwent sequential emission/transmission imaging for AC using an L-shaped, dual-headed gamma camera fitted with two 153Gd scanning line sources. Transmission data were acquired for 5 s per view (scan time for normal-sized patients) and for 10 s per view and used to reconstruct individual attenuation maps. Emission data were reconstructed using each attenuation map in turn to produce attenuation-corrected images (AC5 and AC10). Tracer distribution in the AC5 and AC10 images was compared by two observers blinded to study type. For each data set, count density was measured in 17 segments of a polar plot and segmental uptake expressed relative to study maximum. Although myocardial count density was low on the 5 s per view transmission images (0.5-13.0 and 3.0-14.0 counts per pixel in the anteroposterior and lateral projections respectively), no significant differences in tracer distribution were seen between the AC5 and AC10 images and these were reported identically. In addition, the mean segmental relative uptake values were similar (P > 0.05) for corresponding segments of the AC5 and AC10 images. We conclude that prolonged transmission scanning is not required in obese compared to normal-sized patients. The transmission scanning protocol used in normal-sized patients is applicable across a wide patient weight range.

PET imaging using gamma camera systems: a review.

Optimized positron emission tomographs have begun to demonstrate an ever widening range of clinical applications for positron labelled pharmaceuticals. This potential has led to a renewed interest in the use of the more widely available Anger gamma camera detectors for imaging the 511 keV photons from the positron decay process. Two forms of detection can be considered: either the detection of the 511 keV photons as single events or the detection of coincidence events from the opposed pair annihilation photons. The widespread availability of dual, opposed-pair, large field-of-view detectors has promoted the development of coincidence detection without collimation. With detector rotation, positron emission tomography (PET) can be performed. An alternative and lower cost option has been the universal development of ultra high-energy collimators to perform single photon emission tomography (SPET) with 511 keV photons. This review outlines the currently available performance characteristics of these two approaches and compares them with those from two- and three-dimensional PET optimized systems. The limitations on the development of these systems is discussed through the analysis of the principles underlying both single photon and coincidence detection. Preliminary clinical experience indicates that limitations in the performance characteristics of these systems has implications for their potential role, although applications in cardiology and oncology are being pursued.

Combined rest thallium-201/stress technetium-99m-tetrofosmin SPECT: feasibility and diagnostic accuracy of a 90-minute protocol.

UNLABELLED: Technetium-99m tetrofosmin is a recently developed compound that clears from background organs rapidly. Tetrofosmin has a good correlation with 201Tl. This study assesses the feasibility and diagnostic accuracy of a combined protocol involving rest 201Tl SPECT and stress imaging with 99mTc-tetrofosmin. METHODS: Twenty-five patients (23 men, 2 women; aged 36-73 yr) with known coronary artery disease underwent the combined protocol. Twenty minutes after the resting injection of 201Tl, resting SPECT data were acquired using low-energy, high-resolution collimators. A stress test using adenosine infusion combined with low-level dynamic exercise was performed. The stress data were collected 20 min later. The reconstructed vertical long-axis, horizontal long-axis and short-axis slices were analyzed qualitatively. Analysis was carried out using nine segments of the left ventricle. The segments were reported either as fixed or reversible. The results were compared to coronary angiography results. RESULTS: The sensitivity and specificity for the detection of diseased coronary vessels were 85% and 70% for the left anterior descending territory, respectively, 78% and 71% for the right coronary artery, and 69% and 70% for the left circumflex. Overall, the sensitivity was 80% and the specificity 70%. CONCLUSION: Combined rest 201Tl/stress 99mTc-tetrofosmin SPECT provides a protocol of short duration which displays similar diagnostic accuracy to a protocol using tetrofosmin as a single agent.

High-resolution renal SPECT in eight minutes using a multi-detector gamma camera.

Planar renal scintigraphy with Tc-99m DMSA has become established as a standard diagnostic test to determine if a kidney has been scarred by infection. It has been suggested that high resolution SPECT may improve the sensitivity of detection of renal scars. To determine if it is possible to produce good quality renal SPECT with a short acquisition time, 10 adults were examined with a new multi-detector gamma camera using 8 minute, 16 minute, and 32 minute acquisitions. The number of defects seen (N = 16) with an 8 minute acquisition was not significantly different from the defects (N = 15) seen using a 16 minute and a 32 minute acquisition. In adults when imaging with a multi-detector gamma camera there was no clinical advantage in using an acquisition of longer than 8 minutes.

201Tl myocardial perfusion SPET: adenosine alone or combined with dynamic exercise.

201Tl myocardial perfusion single photon emission tomography (SPET) with pharmacological coronary vasodilatation using adenosine is now often used in the investigation of a patient with ischaemic heart disease (IHD). In this study, we present data from two groups of patients. Group A (n = 40) experienced 201Tl SPET with adenosine only as the pharmacological stress test, using an infusion rate of 140 micrograms kg-1 min-1. Group B patients (n = 50) had the same test combined with low-level dynamic exercise. The side effects were noted for both groups and 201Tl SPET studies were acquired for stress and redistribution images. There was a lesser degree of non-cardiac side effects in patients of group B. There was a significant difference in the haemodynamic parameters between the two groups. There was no significant difference in overall sensitivity (87% versus 90%) and specificity (84% versus 88%) in the detection of IHD between the two groups. In conclusion, addition of low-level dynamic exercise with adenosine is to be preferred to adenosine infusion alone, as this protocol is better tolerated and may enhance the detection of right coronary artery disease (sensitivity = 82% versus 90%, n.s.).

Clinical experience with a multidetector SPET system (Toshiba GCA-9300A).

The clinical experience with the Toshiba GCA-9300A single photon emission tomography (SPET) system is discussed along with typical acquisition protocols for various SPET studies. The system was used to perform SPET studies in normals and in a variety of brain and body disorders. Its three Anger-type gamma cameras forming a triangular aperture offer a substantial increase in sensitivity compared to a single rotating gamma camera. This has allowed the routine use of lead fanbeam super high-resolution collimators (SHR FB) for 99Tcm-hexamethylpropyleneamine oxime (HMPAO) brain SPET studies and high-resolution parallel-hole collimators (HR PH) for cardiac and other body studies. The resulting improvement in spatial resolution coupled with the ease of patient positioning and the greater patient throughput compared to a conventional tomographic gamma camera, will enhance the role of brain and body SPET for both routine and research purposes.