Response-surface analysis of exposure-duration relationships: the effects of hyperthermia on embryonic development of the rat in vitro.

In developing exposure standards, an assumption is often made in the case of less-than-lifetime exposures that the probability of response depends on the cumulative exposure, i.e., the product of exposure concentration and duration. Over the last two decades, the general applicability of this assumption, referred to as Haber's Law, has begun to be questioned. This study examined the interaction of exposure concentration and duration on embryonic development during a portion of organogenesis. Embryos were exposed in whole embryo culture to various temperature-duration combinations and evaluated for alterations in development 24 h later. The specific purpose of the study was to assess whether the developmental responses followed Haber's Law, or whether an additional component of exposure was needed to model the relationship. The current study demonstrated that the response of the developing embryo to hyperthermia, with rare exception, was dependent on an additional component of exposure beyond the cumulative exposure. For the vast majority of the parameters measured in this study, the probability of an effect was greater at higher temperatures for short durations than at lower temperatures for long durations, given the same cumulative exposure. Thus, Haber's Law did not adequately describe the results of our study.

Harmonization of cancer and noncancer risk assessment: proceedings of a consensus-building workshop.

Significant advancements have been made toward the use of all relevant scientific information in health risk assessments. This principle has been set forth in risk-assessment guidance documents of international agencies including those of the World Health Organization's International Programme on Chemical Safety, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, and Health Canada. Improving the scientific basis of risk assessment is a leading strategic goal of the Society of Toxicology. In recent years, there has been a plethora of mechanistic research on modes of chemical toxicity that establishes mechanistic links between noncancer responses to toxic agents and subsequent overt manifestations of toxicity such as cancer. The research suggests that differences in approaches to assessing risk of cancer and noncancer toxicity need to be resolved and a common broad paradigm for dose-response assessments developed for all toxicity endpoints. In November 1999, a workshop entitled "Harmonization of Cancer and Noncancer Risk Assessment" was held to discuss the most critical issues involved in developing a more consistent and unified approach to risk assessment for all endpoints. Invited participants from government, industry, and academia discussed focus questions in the areas of mode of action as the basis for harmonization, common levels of adverse effect across toxicities for use in dose-response assessments, and scaling and uncertainty factors. This report summarizes the results of those discussions. There was broad agreement, albeit not unanimous, that current science supports the development of a harmonized set of principles that guide risk assessments for all toxic endpoints. There was an acceptance among the participants that understanding the mode of action of a chemical is ultimately critical for nondefault risk assessments, that common modes of action for different toxicities can be defined, and that our approach to assessing toxicity should be biologically consistent.

Workshop to identify critical windows of exposure for children's health: reproductive health in children and adolescents work group summary.

This work group report addresses the central question: What are the critical windows during development (preconception through puberty) when exposure to xenobiotics may have the greatest adverse impact on subsequent reproductive health? The reproductive system develops in stages, with sex-specific organogenesis occurring prenatally and further maturational events occurring in the perinatal period and at puberty. Complex endocrine signals as well as other regulatory factors (genetics, growth factors) are involved at all stages. Evidence from animal models and human studies indicates that many specific events can be perturbed by a variety of toxicants, with endocrine-mediated mechanisms being the more widely studied. Prioritized research needs include basic studies on the cellular-molecular and endocrine regulation of sexual differentiation and development; increased efforts regarding potential adverse effects on development in females, including breast development; expanded animal studies on different classes of chemicals, comparing responses during development (prenatal and postnatal) with responses in adults; and, more extensive explorations regarding the reproductive biology and toxicology of puberty in humans.

Heat shock during rat embryo development in vitro results in decreased mitosis and abundant cell death.

Epidemiologic studies strongly suggest that in utero exposure to hyperthermia results in developmental defects in humans. Rats, mice, guinea pigs, and other species exposed to hyperthermia also exhibit a variety of developmental defects. Studies in our laboratory have focused on exposure to hyperthermia on Gestation Day (GD) 10 of rats in vivo or in vitro. Within 24 h after in vivo or in vitro exposure, delayed or abnormal CNS, optic cup, somite, and limb development can be observed. At birth, only rib and vertebral malformations are seen after hyperthermia on GD 10, and these have been shown to be due to alterations in somite segmentation. Unsegmented somites have been thought to result from a cell-cycle block in the presomitic mesoderm, from which somites emerge individually during normal development. In the present study, DNA fragmentation (terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT) catalyzed fluorescein-12-dUTP DNA end-labelling), indicative of apoptotic cell death, and changes in cell proliferation were examined in vitro in 37 degrees C control and heat treated (42 degrees C for 15 min) GD 10 CD rat embryos. Embryos were returned to 37 degrees C culture following exposure and evaluated 5, 8, or 18 h later. A temperature-related increase in TdT labelled cells was observed in the CNS, optic vesicle, neural tube, and somites. Increased cell death in the presomitic mesoderm also was evident. Changes in cell proliferation were examined using the cell-specific abundance of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and the quantification of mitotic figures. In neuroectodermal cells in the region of the optic cup, a change in the abundance of PCNA was not apparent, but a marked decrease in mitotic figures was observed. A significant change in cell proliferation in somites was not detected by either method. These results suggest that acute hyperthermia disrupts embryonic development through a combination of inappropriate cell death and/or altered cell proliferation in discrete regions of the developing rat embryo. Furthermore, postnatal vertebral and rib defects following disrupted somite development may be due, in part, to abundant cell death occurring in the presomitic mesoderm.

Exposure to ethylene oxide during the early zygotic period induces skeletal anomalies in mouse fetuses.

Exposure of mouse zygotes to ethylene oxide (EtO) has been shown to increase the incidence of external malformations among late fetuses [Generoso et al. (1987) Mutat. Res., 176:267-274; Rutledge and Generoso, (1989) Teratology, 39:563-572]. The present study was designed to determine whether EtO also affects the skeletal system. We report here the effects of varying times of exposure during the zygotic period on skeletal development. Female hybrid mice were injected intraperitoneally (IP) with 125 mg/kg EtO at 1, 3, 5, or 7 hr postmating. A positive control group consisted of female mice that were injected IP with 150 mg/kg EtO once daily between the 6th to 8th days of gestation. Day 17 fetuses were double-stained for "blind" examination of skeletal deviations and degree of ossification. Zygotic exposure to EtO significantly increased loss of conceptuses as well as the incidence of external defects, skeletal anomalies, and retarded ossification in live day 17 fetuses. An increase in the number of exposed fetuses with cleft sternum was observed with the highest rate (58.5%) occurring in fetuses whose mothers were exposed to EtO 3 hours postmating. Cleft sternum was seen in only 5% of fetuses exposed during the period of organogenesis and less than 1% of control fetuses. It is concluded that zygotic exposure to EtO produces a pattern of skeletal defects that differs from those observed following treatment with EtO during organogenesis.

Relationship between abnormal somite development and axial skeletal defects in rats following heat exposure.

The effects of in vivo heat exposure on gestation day (GD) 10 rat embryos were evaluated on GD 11 to determine the relationships between morphological sequelae following in vivo and in vitro exposures and between effects detected on GD 11 and those observed in postnatal day (PND) 3 pups. Anesthetized rats were exposed to 42 degrees C in a warm air incubator until their rectal temperatures reached 41 degrees C or until a rectal temperature of 42-42.5 degrees C had been maintained for 5 minutes. Heat-exposed embryos exhibited a significant decrease in growth parameters including head length, somite number, and protein content/embryo versus controls. These changes correlated well with in vitro effects from an earlier study (G.L. Kimmel et al., '93). Among the morphological endpoints which were slightly delayed in development were the caudal neural tube, branchial bars, forelimb and hindlimb. The only effect on the embryos that could not be explained as a transient delay in development induced by heat was the induction of unsegmented somites. Additional embryos were exposed to 42 degrees C for 15-20 min in vitro and examined specifically for unsegmented somites, which were observed in 47% of embryos exposed to 42 degrees C in vivo or in vitro. This phenomenon was observed in somites 9-20, i.e., those that give rise to cervical and thoracic vertebrae and ribs. These results correlated well with the axial skeletal malformations observed in PND 3 pups exposed to the same heat treatment (C.A. Kimmel et al., '93).

Perinatal toxicity associated with nickel chloride exposure.

Several reports have suggested that soluble nickel salts may affect development. In this study female Long-Evans rats drank nickel chloride solutions (0, 10, 50, or 250 ppm Ni) for 11 weeks prior to mating and then during two successive gestation (G1, G2) and lactation (L1, L2) periods. Pups were observed until weaning; breeder males were unexposed. Dams drinking 250 ppm consumed less liquid and more food per kilogram body weight than did controls (liquid: prebreeding, G1, and G2; food: prebreeding, G2 and L2). Maternal weight gain was reduced during G1 in the high- and middle-dose groups; indices of reproductive performance were comparable across groups. Pup birth weight was unaltered by treatment and weight gain was reduced only in male pups exposed to 50 ppm Ni during L1. The frequency of perinatal death is the most significant toxicologic finding of the study. The proportion of dead pups per litter was significantly elevated at the high dose in L1 and at 10 and 250 ppm in L2 (50 ppm, P = 0.076), with a dose-related response in both experimental segments. The number of dead pups per litter was significantly increased at each dose in L2. Prolactin levels in pups were unchanged by treatment and were reduced in dams at the high dose. We conclude that 10 ppm Ni represents the lowest observed adverse effect level (LOAEL) in this study.

Statistical model for fetal death, fetal weight, and malformation in developmental toxicity studies.

The purpose of this paper is to present a statistical model for analyzing the joint effects of exposure on fetal death, fetal weight, and malformation in a developmental toxicity study. In addition to allowing for the usual litter effect, the model allows for correlations between different outcomes measured on the same fetus. Fitting the model requires first focusing on non-live outcomes by modeling the probability of fetal death or resorption as a function of dose. Then outcomes among live fetuses are modeled using a two-stage regression approach. The first stage models fetal weight as a function of dose and the second stage models fetal malformation as a function of dose, as well as residuals from the weight model. The regression coefficients from the malformation model have intuitive interpretations in terms of correlations between littermates and between different outcomes measured within the same fetus. Not only does the approach provide a useful way to investigate the relationship between adverse fetal outcomes, it also yields a natural framework for conducting quantitative risk assessment. A procedure is proposed for quantifying overall risk by incorporating the three outcomes in order to estimate safe dose levels and corresponding lower confidence limits. The method is illustrated using data from an experiment in mice conducted through the National Toxicology Program.

Skeletal development following heat exposure in the rat.

The effects of gestation day (GD) 10 heat exposure in the rat were studied to determine the temperature-response relationship for the induction of skeletal and other defects. Conscious pregnant rats (Experiment 1) were exposed to various temperatures in a warm air chamber. Body temperature was measured using a rectal probe, and these measurements were confirmed as representing core body temperature in separate animals using telemetric procedures. Those animals whose core body temperature was raised to 41-41.9 degrees C had over 90% malformed pups (examined at postnatal day (PND) 3), and a 25% reduction in the percent of live pups per litter. Animals whose temperature was raised to 39.2-40.9 degrees C had a low incidence of pups with similar types of malformations. The primary types of malformations were of the axial skeleton, consisting of fusions and other abnormalities of the ribs and vertebral elements, and a decrease in the total number of ribs and centra. The acute maternal effects of these temperature increases were signs of heat exhaustion during and 1-2 hr after exposure, but there were no permanent changes in weight gain or other signs. When temperatures were raised to > or = 42 degrees C, all maternal animals died. In a second study (Experiment 2), pregnant rats (from a different supplier) were anesthetized to determine the effect of reducing maternal stress and were exposed to heat as in Experiment 1. Those animals whose core body temperature was raised to 42-42.5 degrees C for 5 min had pups with similar responses to those in Experiment 1 at 41-41.9 degrees C, although the reduction in litter size was not as great. Animals whose temperature was raised to 41 degrees C had a much lower incidence of pups with similar defects, and animals whose temperature was raised to 43 degrees C did not survive. A more detailed analysis of the skeletal defects in Experiment 2 showed rib and vertebral malformations that appear to be related to the stage of somite development at the time of exposure.

Embryonic development in vitro following short-duration exposure to heat.

Gestation day (GD) 10 rat embryos (10-12 somites) were exposed in vitro for 10 to 25 minutes at 42 or 43 degrees C and evaluated 24 hrs later for alterations in growth and specific morphological parameters, using a modified Brown-Fabro (Brown and Fabro: Teratology, 24:65-78, '81) scoring system that allowed evaluation of development relative to gestational age. At 42 degrees C, crown-rump length appeared to be particularly sensitive, responding to only 10 mins exposure. A 15-min exposure resulted in decreased total protein, somite number and morphological score. No system was uniquely sensitive, since all parameters demonstrated some degree of response. Rather, systems affected were those that would be developing most rapidly at this time in gestation. At 43 degrees C, all of the parameters measured were affected by a 10-min exposure. These results demonstrate alterations in vitro after much shorter exposure periods than previously reported on GD10, which may be due, in part, to the use of a modified scoring system that permitted the evaluation of graded individual end point changes relative to gestational age. The response patterns demonstrated a clear temperature- and exposure duration-dependency, with a shift from a more shallow duration-response curve to a more dramatic inhibition of development as temperature increased from 42 degrees C to 43 degrees C.

Developmental and reproductive toxicity of dioxins and related compounds: cross-species comparisons.

Developmental toxicity to TCDD-like congeners in fish, birds, and mammals, and reproductive toxicity in mammals are reviewed. In fish and bird species, the developmental lesions observed are species dependent, but any given species responds similarly to different TCDD-like congeners. Developmental toxicity in fish resembles "blue sac disease," whereas structural malformations can occur in at least one bird species. In mammals, developmental toxicity includes decreased growth, structural malformations, functional alterations, and prenatal mortality. At relatively low exposure levels, structural malformations are not common in mammalian species. In contrast, functional alterations are the most sensitive signs of developmental toxicity. These include effects on the male reproductive system and male reproductive behavior in rats, and neurobehavioral effects in monkeys. Human infants exposed during the Yusho and Yu-Cheng episodes, and monkeys and mice exposed perinatally to TCDD developed an ectodermal dysplasia syndrome that includes toxicity to the skin and teeth. Toxicity to the central nervous system in monkey and human infants is a potential part of the ectodermal dysplasia syndrome. Decreases in spermatogenesis and the ability to conceive and carry a pregnancy to term are the most sensitive signs of reproductive toxicity in male and female mammals, respectively.

Relationship between fetal weight and malformation in developmental toxicity studies.

Exposure to developmental toxicants may cause fetal malformations, increase prenatal death rates and reduce fetal weight at term. However, there has been little formal study of the relationship among these effects. Certainly, no statistical methods are currently available to jointly analyze these effects of exposure. As a preliminary step in developing such methods, simple exploratory analyses were conducted using a series of ten studies conducted for the National Toxicology Program. Because fetal weight and malformation status were both reported for all live fetuses, the data permitted an exploration of the correlation between these two outcomes. The data show a clear pattern wherein malformed fetuses tended to be lighter at term than nonmalformed fetuses. While these patterns cannot be used to draw inferences regarding the biological relationship between fetal weight and malformation, they do suggest the potential value in developing statistical models for the joint effect of exposure on fetal weight and malformations.

Activity profiles of developmental toxicity: design considerations and pilot implementation.

The available literature was searched for quantitative test results from both in vitro and in vivo assays for developmental toxicity for five model compounds: cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, hydroxyurea, caffeine, and ethylenethiourea. These compounds were chosen on the basis of their extensive utilization in a variety of assay systems for developmental toxicity as evidenced by their representation in the ETIC database (each generally has 100-500 citations encompassing multiple test systems). Nine cellular-based assays, six assays using whole embryos in culture, as well as Segment II and abbreviated exposure tests for mammalian test species are included in the database. For each assay, the critical endpoints were identified, each of which was then provided a three-letter code, and the criteria for extraction of quantitative information were established. The extracted information was placed into a computerized reference file and subsequently plotted such that the qualitative (positive/negative) and quantitative (e.g., IC50, highest ineffective dose (HID), lowest effective dose (LED] results across all test systems could be displayed. The information contained in these profiles can be used to compare qualitative and quantitative results across multiple assay systems, to identify data gaps in the literature, to evaluate the concordance of the assays, to calculate relative potencies, and to examine structure-activity relationships.

Influence of symmetrical polychlorinated biphenyl isomers on embryo and fetal development in mice. II. Comparison of 4,4'-dichlorobiphenyl, 3,3',4,4'-tetrachlorobiphenyl, 3,3',5,5'-tetrachlorobiphenyl, and 3,3',4,4'-tetramethylbiphenyl.

Outbred albino (CD-1) mice were given the following biphenyl isomers by gavage in cottonseed oil on Days 6-15 of gestation: 4,4'-dichlorobiphenyl (DCB) at 16, 32, and 64 mg/kg/day; 3,3',4,4'-tetrachlorobiphenyl (3,4-TCB) at 1,2,4,8,16,32, and 64 mg/kg/day; 3,3',5,5'-tetrachlorobiphenyl (3,5-TCB) at 64 mg/kg/day; and 3,3',4,4'-tetramethylbiphenyl (TMB) at 64 mg/kg/day. The mice were killed on Day 18 of gestation, necropsies were performed on the dams, and the fetuses were examined for external, visceral, and skeletal malformations. Although DCB was toxic to the dams at 64 mg/kg/day, developmental toxicity was not detected. 3,4-TCB administration was followed by a significant (p less than 0.01) increase in the average percentage of malformed fetuses per litter at 4 (7.2%), 8 (9.8%), 16 (25.4%), 32 (50.0%), and 64 (75.0%) mg/kg/day versus the vehicle control group (1.1%). None of the dosages tested was lethal to any of the dams. Significant decreases in maternal weight gain were observed at 16 mg/kg/day and above; however, the differences from the control value most likely were due to significant decreases in the mean number of live fetuses per dam, as the result of reductions in the number of implants per dam, and significant increases in the incidence of resorptions. Vaginal bleeding and other evidence of abortifacient effects also were present in several dams in groups receiving 3,4-TCB at 16 mg/kg/day and above. Cleft palate and hydronephrosis (significantly increased at dosages of 4 mg/kg/day and above) were the predominant malformations detected. Thus, 3,4-TCB was found to be toxic to the conceptus at dosages of 4 mg/kg/day and above. Neither 3,5-TCB nor TMB showed indications of maternal or developmental toxicity at 64 mg/kg/day.

Prenatal reserpine exposure alters cardiovascular parameters in rat offspring.

Electrocardiograms (ECGs) and blood pressures (BPs) were recorded and evaluated in postnatal rats that had been exposed in utero to 0.375 or 0.75 mg reserpine/kg/day sc on Gestational Days (GD) 12-15. These doses caused reduced maternal weight gain during pregnancy and decreased pup body weight at birth, as well as reduced heart weight during the preweaning period. There were no changes in other maternal parameters or in litter size. During the postweaning period, pup body weight was reduced only at the highest dose at Postnatal Days (PND) 30 and 60. By PND 342, the weight reduction was no longer significant when compared to controls. Lead II ECGs were recorded in conscious animals on PND 30, 60, and 342; BPs were recorded in anesthetized animals on PND 346. Several ECG parameters were attenuated by prenatal reserpine exposure: R wave and S wave amplitudes and the QRS interval in males, and the PR interval in females. The BP recordings showed that low-dose males had significantly higher pulse pressures than did high-dose males, but neither group was significantly different from controls. Following an intraarterial norepinephrine challenge, resultant peak pulse pressure was greater in high-dose females than in controls. These results indicate that subtle, long-term, sex-specific alterations in cardiovascular parameters were produced by prenatal reserpine treatment at doses that altered body weight in young animals at PNDs 30 and 60, but this change was no longer apparent at PND 342.

Postnatal function following prenatal reserpine exposure in rats: neurobehavioral toxicity.

Behavioral and neurochemical analyses were conducted on preweanling CD rats prenatally exposed to either 0, 0.375 or 0.750 mg/kg/day reserpine SC on gestation days 12-15. Offspring body weights were taken on test days, and pups were tested for negative geotaxis responding on postnatal day 8, developmental activity on days 12, 16 and 20, and auditory startle habituation on day 19 or 20. In addition, brains were removed from culled pups on day 1, 1 male and 1 female/litter on day 8, and animals tested for activity on day 21. Neurochemical assays were performed on whole brains from 1- and 8-day-old pups, and on caudate nucleus, frontal cortex and hippocampus of day 21 rats. Treatment resulted in dose-related decreases in maternal weight gain over gestation and mean pup weight at birth. Changes in the normal developmental activity pattern were both sex and dose dependent in treated rats. In auditory startle habituation experiments, rats exhibited a dose-related decrease in response amplitude and rate of habituation. In the day 21 females, caudate nucleus dopamine (DA) and serotonin (5-HT) concentrations and DA-receptor binding were decreased in a dose-dependent manner. Males showed less dramatic, but similar trends in caudate changes. However, hippocampal 5-HT and 5-HT receptor binding were significantly reduced only in females. Thus, sex-related behavioral alterations were accompanied by sex-related neurochemical changes, and females generally were more affected than males by prenatal reserpine treatment. The significant decrease in activity and auditory startle amplitude in the females is consistent with the suggested down regulation of the DA system in regional brain areas.

Effect of prenatal reserpine exposure on development of the postnatal rat heart.

Previous studies have suggested that reserpine treatment may result in altered heart development. In order to more fully investigate this possibility, reserpine was administered s.c. at 0, 0.375, or 0.75 mg/kg/day to pregnant rats on gestation days 12-15. Maternal weight gain, as well as pup weight on postnatal day (PND) 1, was significantly reduced in a dose-dependent manner. Litter size was unaffected, but reserpine-treated dams had more dead pups than did control dams. On PND 1, litters were randomly standardized at ten pups each for analysis on PNDs 5, 8, 15, and 22. Pup body weight and heart weight were reduced in a dose-related manner at all ages measured. The decreased heart weights were probably due to decreases in cell number. Beta-adrenergic receptor concentration was significantly reduced only on PND 5, at the low reserpine dose, and was not considered to be a treatment effect. Prenatal reserpine exposure had no effect on levels of basal cardiac ornithine decarboxylase (ODC), an enzyme associated with growth and development. Cardiac ODC stimulation by insulin and isoproterenol also showed no effects of maternal reserpine treatment. The results suggest that maternal reserpine treatment may lead to adverse effects in the developing offspring.