Thyroid homeostasis in B6C3F1 mice upon sub-chronic exposure to trifluoroiodomethane (CF3I).

Trifluoroiodomethane (CF3I) is a fire suppressant gas with potential for use in low global-warming refrigerant blends. Data from studies in rats suggest that the most sensitive health effect of CF3I is thyroid hormone perturbation, but the rat is a particularly sensitive species for disruption of thyroid homeostasis. Mice appear to be less sensitive than rats but still a conservative model with respect to humans. The purpose of this study was to test tolerance and thyroid response to CF3I in B6C3F1 male mice. Male mice were exposed to CF3I for 6 h per day, for 28 days, via whole body exposure at concentrations of 2500, 5000 and 10,000 ppm. A 16-day recovery period was included to evaluate reversibility. No adverse clinical signs were observed throughout the study, and body weights were unaffected by exposure. CF3I exposure had no effect on thyroid histology. An increase in relative thyroid weight was observed at 10,000 ppm on day 28 but not in a separate group of animals evaluated on day 29, and thyroid weight was not different from controls at 44 days. Slight and sporadic changes in serum triiodothyronine, thyroxine, and thyroid-stimulating hormone were observed but did not follow a consistent pattern with respect to timing, dose, or direction. Overall, exposure at up to 10,000 ppm (1.0%) of CF3I gas for 28 days produced no overt general toxicity and only transient, recoverable effects on thyroid weight and hormones at certain concentrations. On the basis of the effect of CF3I exposure on the thyroid, including evaluation of thyroid histopathology, the no observed adverse effect level for this study is 10,000 ppm. Considering the apparently greater toxicity reported in prior studies in male rats, our data suggest a species difference between rats and mice in terms of susceptibility to CF3I-induced thyroid hormone perturbation.

Evaluating the Application of Decision Analysis Methods in Simulated Alternatives Assessment Case Studies: Potential Benefits and Challenges of Using MCDA.

We compare how several forms of multicriteria decision analysis (MCDA) can enhance the practice of alternatives assessment (AA). We report on a workshop in which 12 practitioners from US corporations, government agencies, NGOs, and consulting organizations applied different MCDA techniques to 3 AA case studies to understand how they improved the decision process. Participants were asked to select a preferred alternative in each case using a different decision analysis approach: their unaided decision-making method, individual or lightly facilitated group multiattribute value theory (MAVT), and more extensively facilitated group structured decision making (SDM). Surveys conducted after each exercise revealed that participants were positive toward the use of formal decision-making methods for AA, reporting meaningful increases in their understanding of the trade-offs involved and their own values. Participants also reported challenges with each approach. While the MCDA techniques were reported to enhance transparency and communication, they did not consistently lead to higher satisfaction with a decision and/or outcome, and they were not more likely to be adopted within their organizations than unaided approaches. More formal decision-making methods have promise in the context of AA, but practitioners will need more guidance to use such tools successfully. Practitioners will also need to define what "success" constitutes; different approaches may be called for depending on whether the objective is increased understanding, satisfaction with the outcome, satisfaction with the process, or something else. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2021;17:27-41. © 2020 SETAC.

Derivation of the critical effect size/benchmark response for the dose-response analysis of the uptake of radioactive iodine in the human thyroid.

Potential adverse effects of chemical substances on thyroid function are usually examined by measuring serum levels of thyroid-related hormones. Instead, recent risk assessments for thyroid-active chemicals have focussed on iodine uptake inhibition, an upstream event that by itself is not necessarily adverse. Establishing the extent of uptake inhibition that can be considered de minimis, the chosen benchmark response (BMR), is therefore critical. The BMR values selected by two international advisory bodies were 5% and 50%, a difference that had correspondingly large impacts on the estimated risks and health-based guidance values that were established. Potential treatment-related inhibition of thyroidal iodine uptake is usually determined by comparing thyroidal uptake of radioactive iodine (RAIU) during treatment with a single pre-treatment RAIU value. In the present study it is demonstrated that the physiological intra-individual variation in iodine uptake is much larger than 5%. Consequently, in-treatment RAIU values, expressed as a percentage of the pre-treatment value, have an inherent variation, that needs to be considered when conducting dose-response analyses. Based on statistical and biological considerations, a BMR of 20% is proposed for benchmark dose analysis of human thyroidal iodine uptake data, to take the inherent variation in relative RAIU data into account. Implications for the tolerated daily intakes for perchlorate and chlorate, recently established by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), are discussed.

Iodine supplementation and drinking-water perchlorate mitigation.

Ensuring adequate iodine intake is important, particularly among women of reproductive age, because iodine is necessary for early life development. Biologically based dose-response modeling of the relationships among iodide status, perchlorate dose, and thyroid hormone production in pregnant women has indicated that iodide intake has a profound effect on the likelihood that exposure to goitrogens will produce hypothyroxinemia. We evaluated the possibility of increasing iodine intake to offset potential risks from perchlorate exposure. We also explored the effect of dietary exposures to nitrate and thiocyanate on iodine uptake and thyroid hormone production. Our modeling indicates that the level of thyroid hormone perturbation associated with perchlorate exposures in the range of current regulatory limits is extremely small and would be overwhelmed by other goitrogen exposures. Our analysis also shows that microgram levels of iodine supplementation would be sufficient to prevent the goitrogenic effects of perchlorate exposure at current regulatory limits among at risk individuals. The human health risks from supplementing drinking water with iodine are negligible; therefore, this approach is worthy of regulatory consideration.

Emissions and risks associated with oxyfuel combustion: state of the science and critical data gaps.

UNLABELLED: Oxyfuel combustion is a promising technology that may greatly facilitate carbon capture and sequestration by increasing the relative CO2 content of the combustion emission stream. However, the potential effect of enhanced oxygen combustion conditions on emissions of criteria and hazardous air pollutants (e.g., acid gases, particulates, metals and organics) is not well studied. It is possible that combustion under oxyfuel conditions could produce emissions posing different risks than those currently being managed by the power industry (e.g., by changing the valence state of metals). The data available for addressing these concerns are quite limited and are typically derived from laboratory-scale or pilot-scale tests. A review of the available data does suggest that oxyfuel combustion may decrease the air emissions of some pollutants (e.g., SO2, NO(x), particulates) whereas data for other pollutants are too limited to draw any conclusions. The oxy-combustion systems that have been proposed to date do not have a conventional "stack" and combustion flue gas is treated in such a way that solid or liquid waste streams are the major outputs. Use of this technology will therefore shift emissions from air to solid or liquid waste streams, but the risk management implications of this potential change have yet to be assessed. Truly useful studies of the potential effects of oxyfuel combustion on power plant emissions will require construction of integrated systems containing a combustion system coupled to a CO2 processing unit. Sampling and analysis to assess potential emission effects should be an essential part of integrated system tests. IMPLICATIONS: Oxyfuel combustion may facilitate carbon capture and sequestration by increasing the relative CO2 content of the combustion emission stream. However, the potential effect of enhanced oxygen combustion conditions on emissions of criteria and hazardous air pollutants has not been well studied. Combustion under oxyfuel conditions could produce emissions posing different risks than those currently being managed by the power industry. Therefore, before moving further with oxyfuel combustion as a new technology, it is appropriate to summarize the current understanding of potential emissions risk and to identify data gaps as priorities for future research.

Administrative censoring in ecological analyses of autism and a Bayesian solution.

Widely cited ecological analyses of autism have reported associations with mercury emissions, with precipitation, and race at the level of counties or school districts. However, state educational agencies often suppress any low numerical autism counts before releasing data--a phenomenon known as "administrative censoring." Previous analyses did not describe appropriate methods for censored data analysis; common substitution or exclusion methods are known to introduce bias and produce artificially narrow confidence intervals. We apply a Bayesian censored random effects Poisson model to reanalyze associations between 2001 Toxic Release Inventory reported mercury emissions and 2000-2001 autism counts in Texas. Relative risk estimates for autism decreased from 4.44 (95% CI: 4.16, 4.74) per thousand lbs. of air mercury emissions using a naive zero-substitution approach to 1.42 (95% CI: 1.09, 1.78) using the Bayesian approach. Inadequate attention to censoring poses a serious threat to the validity of ecological analyses of autism and other health outcomes.

Questions regarding environmental mercury release, special education rates, and autism disorder: an ecological study of Texas by Palmer et al.

Palmer et al. present an analysis in which they look for an association between Toxic Release Inventory (TRI) reporting data for mercury and rates of autism and special education enrollment in Texas. In their analysis, the link between TRI release data and actual mercury exposure is not clear at all, and thus the conclusions drawn from the analysis are questionable.

Modeling developmental processes in animals: applications in neurodevelopmental toxicology.

Biologically based dose-response models can provide a framework for incorporating mechanistic information into our assessments of neurotoxicity considering both kinetic and dynamic processes. We have constructed models for normal midbrain and neocortex development and we have extended these models to evaluate the neurodevelopmental toxicity of ethanol and methyl mercury. Using such modeling approaches, we have been able to test hypothesized modes of action for these neurodevelopmental toxicants. Specifically, we have compared ethanol's effects on neocortical neurogenesis and exacerbation of apoptosis during the synaptogenesis period. We have used methylmercury as an example of how one can link toxicokinetic and toxicodynamic models and also as an example of how mechanistic data on gene expression can support model development. In summary, using examples from our research group, this paper illustrates the need for models that evaluate both qualitative and quantitative kinetic and dynamic factors in order to understand the potential impacts of neurodevelopmental toxicants.

Changes in cell cycle parameters and cell number in the rat midbrain during organogenesis.

We employed 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU) labeling to identify in vivo changes in the cell cycle patterns of the rat midbrain during the major period of midbrain organogenesis, gestational days (gd) 11 to 16. We also used quantitative stereology to determine changes in absolute cell numbers during these gestational time points. Between gd 12 and 16, the length of S-phase did not change significantly while the fraction of cycling cells decreased from 73 to 11%. The average cell cycle length was determined to be 15 h on gd 12 and 17 h on gd 16, the difference not being statistically significant. The cell number in the midbrain increased from 1.3E5 cells on gd 11 to 1.7E7 cells on gd 16. On gd 12 and gd 13, there was a significant negative correlation between litter position and midbrain cell number, the effect diminishing on later days of gestation. The combined use of quantitative stereology and flow cytometry to study brain development represents a novel application that allows for simultaneous evaluation of changes in cell proliferation kinetics and the resulting effect of those kinetic changes on embryonic midbrain development.