Improved sensitivity for solid-support invasive cleavage reactions with flow cytometry analysis.

A new configuration of the solid-support invasive cleavage reaction provides a small reaction-volume format for high-sensitivity discrimination of nucleic acid targets with single nucleotide differences. With target concentrations as low as 2 amol/assay, the solid-support invasive cleavage reaction clearly distinguishes single base mutations. Two oligonucleotides tethered to the solid support hybridize to the target nucleic acid, forming a tripartite substrate that can be recognized and cleaved by Cleavase, a structure-specific 5'-nuclease. Each cleavage event yields fluorescence signal on the surface. When microspheres serve as the solid-support surface, analysis by fluorometer imparts real-time information about change in the reaction signal over time. Flow cytometry provides an alternative detection technology that collects endpoint information about the reaction signal on individual microspheres. A reaction volume of 10 microL with as few as 3000 microspheres is sufficient to distinguish single nucleotide differences at target concentrations less than 200 fM. This sensitivity level is within the range required for analysis of SNPs in genomic DNA. In addition, the flow cytometry format has multiplexing potential, making the microsphere-based invasive cleavage assay attractive for high-throughput genomic applications.

Analysis of single nucleotide polymorphisms with solid phase invasive cleavage reactions.

Using microparticles as the capture surface and fluorescence resonance energy transfer as the detection technology, we have demonstrated the feasibility of performing the invasive cleavage reaction on a solid phase. An effective tool for many genomic applications, the solution phase invasive cleavage assay is a signal amplification method capable of distinguishing nucleic acids that differ by only a single base mutation. The method positions two overlapping oligonucleotides, the probe and upstream oligonucleotides, on the target nucleic acid to create a complex recognized and cleaved by a structure-specific 5'-nuclease. For microarray and other multiplex applications, however, the method must be adapted to a solid phase platform. Effective cleavage of the probe oligonucleotide occurred when either of the two required overlapping oligonucleotides was configured as the particle-bound reagent and also when both oligonucleotides were attached to the solid phase. Positioning probe oligonucleotides away from the particle surface via long tethers improved both the signal and the reaction rates. The particle-based invasive cleavage reaction was capable of distinguishing the ApoE Cys158 and Arg158 alleles at target concentrations as low as 100 amol/assay (0.5 pM).

An invasive cleavage assay for direct quantitation of specific RNAs.

RNA quantitation is becoming increasingly important in basic, pharmaceutical, and clinical research. For example, quantitation of viral RNAs can predict disease progression and therapeutic efficacy. Likewise, gene expression analysis of diseased versus normal, or untreated versus treated, tissue can identify relevant biological responses or assess the effects of pharmacological agents. As the focus of the Human Genome Project moves toward gene expression analysis, the field will require a flexible RNA analysis technology that can quantitatively monitor multiple forms of alternatively transcribed and/or processed RNAs (refs 3,4). We have applied the principles of invasive cleavage and engineered an improved 5'-nuclease to develop an isothermal, fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based signal amplification method for detecting RNA in both total RNA and cell lysate samples. This detection format, termed the RNA invasive cleavage assay, obviates the need for target amplification or additional enzymatic signal enhancement. In this report, we describe the assay and present data demonstrating its capabilities for sensitive (<100 copies per reaction), specific (discrimination of 95% homologous sequences, 1 in > or =20,000), and quantitative (1.2-fold changes in RNA levels) detection of unamplified RNA in both single- and biplex-reaction formats.

Secondary structure prediction and structure-specific sequence analysis of single-stranded DNA.

DNA sequence analysis by oligonucleotide binding is often affected by interference with the secondary structure of the target DNA. Here we describe an approach that improves DNA secondary structure prediction by combining enzymatic probing of DNA by structure-specific 5'-nucleases with an energy minimization algorithm that utilizes the 5'-nuclease cleavage sites as constraints. The method can identify structural differences between two DNA molecules caused by minor sequence variations such as a single nucleotide mutation. It also demonstrates the existence of long-range interactions between DNA regions separated by >300 nt and the formation of multiple alternative structures by a 244 nt DNA molecule. The differences in the secondary structure of DNA molecules revealed by 5'-nuclease probing were used to design structure-specific probes for mutation discrimination that target the regions of structural, rather than sequence, differences. We also demonstrate the performance of structure-specific 'bridge' probes complementary to non-contiguous regions of the target molecule. The structure-specific probes do not require the high stringency binding conditions necessary for methods based on mismatch formation and permit mutation detection at temperatures from 4 to 37 degrees C. Structure-specific sequence analysis is applied for mutation detection in the Mycobacterium tuberculosis katG gene and for genotyping of the hepatitis C virus.

Mapping of RNA accessible sites by extension of random oligonucleotide libraries with reverse transcriptase.

A rapid and simple method for determining accessible sites in RNA that is independent of the length of target RNA and does not require RNA labeling is described. In this method, target RNA is allowed to hybridize with sequence-randomized libraries of DNA oligonucleotides linked to a common tag sequence at their 5'-end. Annealed oligonucleotides are extended with reverse transcriptase and the extended products are then amplified by using PCR with a primer corresponding to the tag sequence and a second primer specific to the target RNA sequence. We used the combination of both the lengths of the RT-PCR products and the location of the binding site of the RNA-specific primer to determine which regions of the RNA molecules were RNA extendible sites, that is, sites available for oligonucleotide binding and extension. We then employed this reverse transcription with the random oligonucleotide libraries (RT-ROL) method to determine the accessible sites on four mRNA targets, human activated ras (ha-ras), human intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1), rabbit beta-globin, and human interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma). Our results were concordant with those of other researchers who had used RNase H cleavage or hybridization with arrays of oligonucleotides to identify accessible sites on some of these targets. Further, we found good correlation between sites when we compared the location of extendible sites identified by RT-ROL with hybridization sites of effective antisense oligonucleotides on ICAM-1 mRNA in antisense inhibition studies. Finally, we discuss the relationship between RNA extendible sites and RNA accessibility.

Experimental and theoretical analysis of the invasive signal amplification reaction.

The invasive signal amplification reaction is a sensitive method for single nucleotide polymorphism detection and quantitative determination of viral load and gene expression. The method requires the adjacent binding of upstream and downstream oligonucleotides to a target nucleic acid (either DNA or RNA) to form a specific substrate for the structure-specific 5' nucleases that cleave the downstream oligonucleotide to generate signal. By running the reaction at an elevated temperature, the downstream oligonucleotide cycles on and off the target leading to multiple cleavage events per target molecule without temperature cycling. We have examined the performance of the FEN1 enzymes from Archaeoglobus fulgidus and Methanococcus jannaschii and the DNA polymerase I homologues from Thermus aquaticus and Thermus thermophilus in the invasive signal amplification reaction. We find that the reaction has a distinct temperature optimum which increases with increasing length of the downstream oligonucleotide. Raising the concentration of either the downstream oligonucleotide or the enzyme increases the reaction rate. When the reaction is configured to cycle the upstream instead of the downstream oligonucleotide, only the FEN1 enzymes can support a high level of cleavage. To investigate the origin of the background signal generated during the invasive reaction, the cleavage rates for several nonspecific substrates that arise during the course of a reaction were measured and compared with the rate of the specific reaction. We find that the different 5' nuclease enzymes display a much greater variability in cleavage rates on the nonspecific substrates than on the specific substrate. The experimental data are compared with a theoretical model of the invasive signal amplification reaction.

Sensitive detection of DNA polymorphisms by the serial invasive signal amplification reaction.

The invasive signal amplification reaction has been previously developed for quantitative detection of nucleic acids and discrimination of single-nucleotide polymorphisms. Here we describe a method that couples two invasive reactions into a serial isothermal homogeneous assay using fluorescence resonance energy transfer detection. The serial version of the assay generates more than 10(7) reporter molecules for each molecule of target DNA in a 4-h reaction; this sensitivity, coupled with the exquisite specificity of the reaction, is sufficient for direct detection of less than 1,000 target molecules with no prior target amplification. Here we present a kinetic analysis of the parameters affecting signal and background generation in the serial invasive signal amplification reaction and describe a simple kinetic model of the assay. We demonstrate the ability of the assay to detect as few as 600 copies of the methylene tetrahydrofolate reductase gene in samples of human genomic DNA. We also demonstrate the ability of the assay to discriminate single base differences in this gene by using 20 ng of human genomic DNA.

RNA template-dependent 5' nuclease activity of Thermus aquaticus and Thermus thermophilus DNA polymerases.

DNA replication and repair require a specific mechanism to join the 3'- and 5'-ends of two strands to maintain DNA continuity. In order to understand the details of this process, we studied the activity of the 5' nucleases with substrates containing an RNA template strand. By comparing the eubacterial and archaeal 5' nucleases, we show that the polymerase domain of the eubacterial enzymes is critical for the activity of the 5' nuclease domain on RNA containing substrates. Analysis of the activity of chimeric enzymes between the DNA polymerases from Thermus aquaticus (TaqPol) and Thermus thermophilus (TthPol) reveals two regions, in the "thumb" and in the "palm" subdomains, critical for RNA-dependent 5' nuclease activity. There are two critical amino acids in those regions that are responsible for the high activity of TthPol on RNA containing substrates. Mutating glycine 418 and glutamic acid 507 of TaqPol to lysine and glutamine, respectively, increases its RNA-dependent 5' nuclease activity 4-10-fold. Furthermore, the RNA-dependent DNA polymerase activity is controlled by a completely different region of TaqPol and TthPol, and mutations in this region do not affect the 5' nuclease activity. The results presented here suggest a novel substrate binding mode of the eubacterial DNA polymerase enzymes, called a 5' nuclease mode, that is distinct from the polymerizing and editing modes described previously. The application of the enzymes with improved RNA-dependent 5' nuclease activity for RNA detection using the invasive signal amplification assay is discussed.

The kinetics of oligonucleotide replacements.

The formation of a duplex between two nucleic acid strands is restricted if one of the strands forms an intra- or intermolecular secondary structure. The formation of the new duplex requires the dissociation and replacement of the initial structure. To understand the mechanism of this type of kinetics we studied the replacement of a labeled DNA oligonucleotide probe bound to a complementary DNA target with an unlabeled probe of the same sequence. The replacement kinetics were measured using a gel-shift assay for 12, 14 and 16-nucleotide probes as a function of temperature and concentration of the unlabeled probe. The results demonstrate that the overall replacement rate is a combination of two kinetic pathways: dissociative and sequential displacement. The dissociative pathway occurs by the spontaneous dissociation of the initial duplex followed by association of the target and unlabeled probe. The sequential displacement pathway requires only the partial melting of the initial duplex to allow for the formation of a branched nucleation complex with the unlabeled probe, followed by the complete displacement of the labeled probe by migration of the branch point. The contribution from the dissociative pathway is predominant at temperatures close to the melting point of the labeled probe, whereas the contribution from the displacement pathway prevails at lower temperatures and when the concentration of the replacing unlabeled probe is high. The results show that at physiological conditions, duplex formation between a single-stranded oligonucleotide probe and a structured region of a target molecule occurs mainly by the sequential-displacement mechanism.

A comparison of eubacterial and archaeal structure-specific 5'-exonucleases.

The 5'-exonuclease domains of the DNA polymerase I proteins of Eubacteria and the FEN1 proteins of Eukarya and Archaea are members of a family of structure-specific 5'-exonucleases with similar function but limited sequence similarity. Their physiological role is to remove the displaced 5' strands created by DNA polymerase during displacement synthesis, thereby creating a substrate for DNA ligase. In this paper, we define the substrate requirements for the 5'-exonuclease enzymes from Thermus aquaticus, Thermus thermophilus, Archaeoglobus fulgidus, Pyrococcus furiosus, Methanococcus jannaschii, and Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum. The optimal substrate of these enzymes resembles DNA undergoing strand displacement synthesis and consists of a bifurcated downstream duplex with a directly abutted upstream duplex that overlaps the downstream duplex by one base pair. That single base of overlap causes the enzymes to leave a nick after cleavage and to cleave several orders of magnitude faster than a substrate that lacks overlap. The downstream duplex needs to be 10 base pairs long or greater for most of the enzymes to cut efficiently. The upstream duplex needs to be only 2 or 3 base pairs long for most enzymes, and there appears to be interaction with the last base of the primer strand. Overall, the enzymes display very similar substrate specificities, despite their limited level of sequence similarity.

Comparison of the 5' nuclease activities of taq DNA polymerase and its isolated nuclease domain.

Many eubacterial DNA polymerases are bifunctional molecules having both polymerization (P) and 5' nuclease (N) activities, which are contained in separable domains. We previously showed that the DNA polymerase I of Thermus aquaticus (TaqNP) endonucleolytically cleaves DNA substrates, releasing unpaired 5' arms of bifurcated duplexes. Here, we compare the substrate specificities of TaqNP and the isolated 5' nuclease domain of this enzyme, TaqN. Both enzymes are significantly activated by primer oligonucleotides that are hybridized to the 3' arm of the bifurcation; optimal stimulation requires overlap of the 3' terminal nucleotide of the primer with the terminal base pair of the duplex, but the terminal nucleotide need not hybridize to the complementary strand in the substrate. In the presence of Mn2+ ions, TaqN can cleave both RNA and circular DNA at structural bifurcations. Certain anti-TaqNP mAbs block cleavage by one or both enzymes, whereas others can stimulate cleavage of nonoptimal substrates.

Polymorphism identification and quantitative detection of genomic DNA by invasive cleavage of oligonucleotide probes.

Flap endonucleases (FENs) isolated from archaea are shown to recognize and cleave a structure formed when two overlapping oligonucleotides hybridize to a target DNA strand. The downstream oligonucleotide probe is cleaved, and the precise site of cleavage is dependent on the amount of overlap with the upstream oligonucleotide. We have demonstrated that use of thermostable archaeal FENs allows the reaction to be performed at temperatures that promote probe turnover without the need for temperature cycling. The resulting amplification of the cleavage signal enables the detection of specific DNA targets at sub-attomole levels within complex mixtures. Moreover, we provide evidence that this cleavage is sufficiently specific to enable discrimination of single-base differences and can differentiate homozygotes from heterozygotes in single-copy genes in genomic DNA.

Clinical, genetic, and pharmacogenetic applications of the Invader assay.

The Invader technology has been developed for the detection of nucleic acids. It is a signal amplification system able to accurately quantify DNA and RNA targets with high sensitivity. Exquisite specificity is achieved by combining hybridization with enzyme recognition, which provides the ability to discriminate mutant from wild-type at ratios greater than 1/1000 (mutant/wt). The technology is isothermal and flexible and incorporates a homogeneous fluorescence readout. It is therefore readily adaptable for use in clinical reference laboratories, as well as high-throughput applications using 96-, 384-, and 1,536-well microtiter plate formats. The molecular mechanism of the system and specific applications for use in clinical and research laboratories are described. These include direct analysis of unamplified human genomic DNA to detect mutations and single-nucleotide polymorphisms associated with factor V Leiden, factor II, cystic fibrosis, and apolipoprotein E, and gene expression assays that quantify messenger RNA levels in cells using direct lysates.

Determination of hepatitis C virus genotypes in the United States by cleavase fragment length polymorphism analysis.

We describe the application of a new DNA-scanning method, which has been termed Cleavase Fragment Length Polymorphism (CFLP; Third Wave Technologies, Inc., Madison, Wis.), for the determination of the genotype of hepatitis C virus (HCV). CFLP analysis results in the generation of structural fingerprints that allow discrimination of different DNA sequences. We analyzed 251-bp cDNA products generated by reverse transcription-PCR of the well-conserved 5'-noncoding region of HCV. We determined the genotypes of 87 samples by DNA sequencing and found isolates representing 98% of the types typically encountered in the United States, i.e., types 1a, 1b, 2a/c, 2b, 3a, and 4. Blinded CFLP analysis of these samples was 100% concordant with DNA sequencing results, such that closely related genotypes yielded patterns with strong familial resemblance whereas more divergent sequences yielded patterns with pronounced dissimilarities. In each case, the aggregate pattern was indicative of genotypic grouping, while finer changes suggested subgenotypic differences. We also assessed the reproducibility of CFLP analysis in HCV genotyping by analyzing three distinct isolates belonging to a single subtype. These three isolates yielded indistinguishable CFLP patterns, as did replicate analysis of a single isolate. This study demonstrates the suitability of this technology for HCV genotyping and suggests that it may provide a low-cost, high-throughput alternative to DNA sequencing or other, more costly or cumbersome genotyping approaches.

Differentiation of bacterial 16S rRNA genes and intergenic regions and Mycobacterium tuberculosis katG genes by structure-specific endonuclease cleavage.

We describe here a new approach for analyzing nucleic acid sequences using a structure-specific endonuclease, Cleavase I. We have applied this technique to the detection and localization of mutations associated with isoniazid resistance in Mycobacterium tuberculosis and for differentiating bacterial genera, species and strains. The technique described here is based on the observation that single strands of DNAs can assume defined conformations, which can be detected and cleaved by structure-specific endonucleases such as Cleavase I. The patterns of fragments produced are characteristic of the sequences responsible for the structure, so that each DNA has its own structural fingerprint. Amplicons, containing either a single 5'-fluorescein or 5'-tetramethyl rhodamine label were generated from a 620-bp segment of the katG gene of isoniazid-resistant and -sensitive M. tuberculosis, the 5' 350 bp of the 16S rRNA genes of Escherichia coli O157:H7, Salmonella typhimurium, Salmonella enteritidis, Salmonella arizonae, Shigella sonnei, Shigella dysenteriae, Campylobacter jejuni, staphylococcus, hominis, Staphylococcus warneri, and Staphylococcus aureus and an approximately 550-bp DNA segment comprising the intergenic region between the 16S and 23S rRNA genes of Salmonella typhimurium, Salmonella enteritidis, Salmonella arizonae, Shigella sonnei, and Shigella dysenteriae serotypes 1, 2, and 8. Changes in the structural fingerprints of DNA fragments derived from the katG genes of isoniazid-resistant M. tuberculosis isolates were clearly identified and could be mapped to the site of the actual mutation relative to the labeled end. Bland patterns which clearly differentiated bacteria to the level of genus and, in some cases, species were generated from the 16S genes. Cleavase I analysis of the intergenic regions of Salmonella and Shigella species differentiated genus, species, and serotypes. Structural fingerprinting by digestion with Cleavase I is a rapid, simple, and sensitive method for analyzing nucleic acid sequences and may find wide utility in microbial analysis.

Electron microscopic studies of sequence-specific recognition of duplex DNA by different ligands.

The following ligands were used to study sequence specific recognition of duplex DNA by electron microscopic techniques: methyltransferases BspR1 and EcoR124 (recognition sequences GGCC and GAAN7RTCG, respectively), a biotinylated deoxyoligonucleotide 5'-CTCTCTCTCTCTCT-3' capable of forming triplex DNA, and PNA oligomer H-T10-LysNH2. For each ligand the best conditions for electron microscopic (EM) detection of stable specific complex formation were determined. It was demonstrated that EM allowed us to determine the position of the individual target site with an error of 15-20 bp, the relative affinities for individual target sites and kinetic parameters of the binding. These results open new possibilities for EM investigations of sequence-specific interactions with a wide range of other ligands of a similar nature. They also imply that a wide range of different sequences can be unambiguously and precisely mapped by EM and greatly extend the scope of EM applications for physical mapping of genomic DNA.

Structure-specific endonucleolytic cleavage of nucleic acids by eubacterial DNA polymerases.

Previously known 5' exonucleases of several eubacterial DNA polymerases have now been shown to be structure-specific endonucleases that cleave single-stranded DNA or RNA at the bifurcated end of a base-paired duplex. Cleavage was not coupled to synthesis, although primers accelerated the rate of cleavage considerably. The enzyme appeared to gain access to the cleavage site by moving from the free end of a 5' extension to the bifurcation of the duplex, where cleavage took place. Single-stranded 5' arms up to 200 nucleotides long were cleaved from such a duplex. Essentially any linear single-stranded nucleic acid can be targeted for specific cleavage by the 5' nuclease of DNA polymerase through hybridization with an oligonucleotide that converts the desired cleavage site into a substrate.

Unusual conformation of (dA)n.(dT)n-tracts as revealed by cyclobutane thymine-thymine dimer formation.

Cyclobutane dimer formation has been used to probe conformation of (dA)n.(dT)n-tracts cloned in plasmid DNA. The observed dimer probability patterns for (dA)n.(dT)n-tracts with n greater than or equal to 4 exhibit maximum intensity at the 3'-terminal TT site of Tn-tract, whereas photoreactivity at all the other TT sites is inhibited. Both the temperature and dimethyl sulfoxide increase dimer formation within Tn-tracts and result in an even dimer pattern. The data obtained have been interpreted in terms of an unusual structure adopted by (dA)n.(dT)n-tracts. An influence of flanking base pairs, ethidium bromide binding and ionic strength has also been studied.

Photofootprinting of DNA triplexes.

We have used a photofootprinting assay to study intermolecular and intramolecular DNA triplexes. The assay is based on the fact that the DNA duplex is protected against photodamage (specifically, against the formation of the (6-4) pyrimidine photoproducts) within a triplex structure. We have shown that this is the case for PyPuPu (YRR) as well as PyPuPy (YRY) triplexes. Using the photofootprinting assay, we have studied the triplex formation under a variety of experimentally defined conditions. At acid pH, d(C)n.d(G)n.d(C)n and d(CT)n.d(GA)n.d(CT)n triplexes are detected by this method. The d(CT)n.d(GA)n.d(CT)n triplexes are additionally stabilized by divalent cations and spermidine. PyPuPu triplexes are pH-independent and are stabilized by divalent cations, such as Mg++ and Zn++. The effect depends on the type of cation and on the DNA sequence. The d(CT)n.d(GA)n.d(GA)n triplex is stabilized by Zn++, but not by Mg++, whereas the d(C)n.d(G)n.d(G)n triplex is stabilized by Mg++. In H-DNA, virtually the entire pyrimidine chain is protected against photodimerization, whereas only half of the pyrimidine chain participating in a triplex is protected in the CGG intramolecular triplex.

Formation of (dA-dT)n cruciforms in Escherichia coli cells under different environmental conditions.

We have detected cruciform formation of (dA-dT)n inserts in Escherichia coli cells by analyzing the superhelical density of isolated plasmid DNA samples and by probing intracellular DNA with chloroacetaldehyde. The plasmids we used were pUC19 containing inserts of (dA-dT)n. The cruciforms appeared after cells underwent different stresses: inhibition of protein synthesis, anaerbiosis, and osmotic shock. At the same time, all these stimuli led to an increase in superhelical density of the control pUC19 plasmid DNA. Therefore, we suggest that the increase in plasmid superhelicity in response to different environmental stimuli entails the appearance of cruciform structures. The use of the (dA-dT)n units of various lengths made it possible to estimate the superhelical density of the plasmid DNA in vivo.