The effect of MAR elements on variation in spatial and temporal regulation of transgene expression.

The level of transgene expression often differs among independent transformants. This is generally ascribed to different integration sites of the transgene into the plant genome in each independently obtained transformant (position effect). It has been shown that in tobacco transformants expressing, for example, a cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter-driven beta-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter gene, these position-induced quantitative differences among individual transformants were reduced by the introduction of matrix-associated regions (MAR elements) on the T-DNA. We have previously shown by imaging of in planta firefly luciferase (luc) reporter gene activity that quantitative differences in transgene activity can be the result of either a variation in (1) level, (2) spatial distribution and/or (3) temporal regulation of transgene expression between independent transformants. It is not known which of these three different aspects of transgene expression is affected when the transgene is flanked by MAR elements. Here we have used the firefly luciferase reporter system to analyse the influence of MAR elements on the activity of a CaMV 35S-luc transgene in a population of independently transformed tobacco plants. Imaging of in planta LUC activity in these tobacco plant populations showed that the presence of MAR elements does not result in less variation in the average level of transgene expression between individual transformants. This result is different from that obtained previously with a 35S-GUS reporter gene flanked by MAR elements and reflects the differences in the stability of the LUC and GUS reporter proteins. Also the variation in spatial patterns of in vivo LUC activity is not reduced between independent transformants when the transgene is flanked by MAR elements. However, MAR elements do seem to affect the variation in temporal regulation of transgene expression between individual transformants. The potential effects of MAR elements on the variability of transgene expression and the relation to the stability of the (trans)gene product are discussed.

Detailed characterization of the posttranscriptional gene-silencing-related small RNA in a GUS gene-silenced tobacco.

Posttranscriptional gene-silencing phenomena such as cosuppression and RNA interference are associated with the occurrence of small, about 21-23 nt short RNA species homologous to the silenced gene. We here show that the small RNA present in silenced transgenic plants can easily be detected in total RNA isolated according to standard procedures. This will allow for the development of routine and early screenings for the presence of small RNA species and, therefore, gene silencing in transgenic plants. We further demonstrate that the small RNA fraction can be visualized with the SYBR Green II RNA stain, isolated from a gel, labeled and used as a specific probe. Using these approaches, we have fine-mapped the sequences of the GUS gene that are represented in the small RNA fraction of a GUS-silenced tobacco line containing an inverted repeat of the GUS gene. In this tobacco line, the silencing-associated small RNA is a mixture of fragments that cover the 3' two-thirds of the GUS coding region. The 5' coding and the 3' noncoding ends of the GUS mRNA are not represented in the small RNA fraction. The RNA fragments are not likely to be a primary synthesis product of an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, but rather degradation products from nuclease activity. Surprisingly, RNA isolated from wild-type, untransformed plants showed the presence of a similar-sized small RNA pool. This might indicate the existence of small RNA species from putative endogenous genes that are down regulated by a similar posttranscriptional gene-silencing mechanism. The possibility of isolating and labeling the small RNA pool from wild-type plants will provide a way to identify and study such putative genes.

Flank matrix attachment regions (MARs) from chicken, bean, yeast or tobacco do not prevent homology-dependent trans-silencing in transgenic tobacco plants.

The effect of flanking matrix attachment regions (MARs) on homology-dependent trans-silencing was tested using two strong trans-silencing loci. The transgenic tobacco line 271 carries at a single locus a p35S-RiN-tNos transgene which is able to silence, in trans and at the transcriptional level, the expression of any p35S-driven transgene irrespective of its position. The transgenic tobacco line 6b8 carries at a single locus a p35S-uidA-tRbcS transgene which is able to silence in trans, at the post-transcriptional level, the expression of any uidA-expressing transgene irrespective of its position. Various transgenic tobacco lines carrying a target p35S-uidA-tNos transgene, flanked on each side by MARs from chicken, bean, yeast or tobacco, were crossed with lines carrying the 271 and 6b8 loci. Expression of the target transgene was silenced in all hybrids, irrespective of the presence or absence of MAR sequences. These results therefore demonstrate that MARs are not able to protect transgene expression from strong silencing loci that act in trans.

Dissection of a synthesized quantitative trait to characterize transgene interactions.

Six transgenic tobacco lines, each homozygous for the beta-glucuronidase (GUS) gene at a different locus, and wild type were selfed and intercrossed to evaluate GUS activity in all possible hemizygous, homozygous and dihybrid combinations of GUS alleles. The transgenic lines are characterized by their GUS activity (two low, three intermediate, one high), T-DNA complexity (four single-copy, two more complex single-locus) and the presence of the chicken lysozyme matrix-associated region (MAR) around the full T-DNA (two lines). Gene action and interaction was analyzed by weighted linear regression with parameters for additivity, dominance and epistasis. The analysis showed that each of the four single-copy lines acted fully additively. In contrast, the two complex single-locus lines showed classical single-locus overdominance and were epistatic dominant over all other GUS alleles. The latter is manifested in severe suppression of GUS activity in dihybrid lines, irrespective of the presence of MAR elements around the GUS gene. Such elements apparently do not protect against epistatic dominance. The quantitative data suggested that the epistatic dominance and overdominance are based on the same molecular mechanism. Our approach of a genetic analysis of quantitative variation in well-characterized transgenic lines provides a powerful tool to gain insight into complex plant traits.

Approaching the Lower Limits of Transgene Variability.

The inclusion of chicken lysozyme matrix-associated regions (MARs) in T-DNA has been demonstrated to reduce the variation in [beta]-glucuronidase (GUS) gene expression among first-generation transformed plants. The residual variation observed between transgenic plant lines with MARs at the T-DNA borders was investigated. By definition, any phenotypic variance between or within genetically identical plants is caused by random or environmental variation. This variation therefore sets a lower limit to the variation in GUS activities. The variance of GUS activity in offspring plant populations of genetically identical individuals was used as an estimate of environmental variation. For transgenic plants with MARs at the T-DNA borders, the variation between independent transformants could not be distinguished from the environmental variation. The variation could be attributed mainly to the variation in the GUS activity measurement. Therefore, the MAR element approached the maximal possible reduction of transgene variability given current technology and sample sizes. The role of MARs in offspring plants was evaluated by comparing such populations of transgenic plants for the magnitude of and variation in GUS activity. Pairwise comparisons showed that the presence of MARs reduced variation in offspring generations in the same manner as demonstrated for primary transformants. The populations carrying a doubled cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter-GUS gene tended to be more variable than the Lhca3.St.1 promoter-GUS gene-carrying populations. This tendency indicated an intrinsic susceptibility of the doubled cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter to variation. Homozygous plants were approximately twice as active as the corresponding hemizygous plants and tended to be more variable than the hemizygous plants. We hypothesized that the magnitude of environmental variations is related to a higher susceptibility to transgene silencing.

The MAR-Mediated Reduction in Position Effect Can Be Uncoupled from Copy Number-Dependent Expression in Transgenic Plants.

To study the role of matrix-associated regions (MARs) in establishing independent chromatin domains in plants, two transgenes were cloned between chicken lysozyme A elements. These transgenes were the neomycin phosphotransferase (NPTII) gene under control of the nopaline synthase (nos) promoter and the [beta]-glucuronidase (GUS) gene controlled by the double cauliflower mosaic virus (dCaMV) 35S promoter. The A elements are supposed to establish an artificial chromatin domain upon integration into the plant DNA, resulting in an independent unit of transcriptional regulation. Such a domain is thought to be characterized by a correlated and position-independent, hence copy number-dependent, expression of the genes within the domain. The presence of MARs resulted in a higher relative transformation efficiency, demonstrating MAR influence on NPTII gene expression. However, variation in NPTII gene expression was not significantly reduced. The selection bias for NPTII gene expression during transformation could not fully account for the lack of reduction in variation of NPTII gene expression. Topological interactions between the promoter and A element may interfere with the A element as a domain boundary. In contrast, the GUS gene on the same putative chromatin domain showed a highly significant reduction in variation of gene expression, as expected from previous results. Surprisingly, no copy number-dependent GUS gene expression was observed: all plants showed approximately the same GUS activity. We concluded, therefore, that dCaMV 35S-GUS gene expression in mature tobacco plants is regulated by some form of dosage compensation.

Reduced Position Effect in Mature Transgenic Plants Conferred by the Chicken Lysozyme Matrix-Associated Region.

Matrix-associated regions may be useful for studying the role of chromatin architecture in transgene activity of transformed plants. The chicken lysozyme A element was shown to have specific affinity for tobacco nuclear matrices, and its influence on the variability of transgene expression in tobacco plants was studied. T-DNA constructs in which this element flanked either the [beta]-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter gene or both reporter and selection gene were introduced in tobacco. The variation in GUS gene activity was reduced significantly among mature first-generation transgenic plants carrying the A element. Average GUS activity became somewhat higher, but the maximum attainable level of gene expression was similar for all three constructs. Transient gene expression assays showed that the A element did not contain general enhancer functions; therefore, its presence seemed to prevent the lower levels of transgene expression. The strongest reduction in variability was found in plants transformed with the construct carrying the A elements at the borders of the T-DNA. In this population, expression levels became copy number dependent. The presence of two A elements in the T-DNA did not interfere with meiosis.

High efficiency Agrobacterium-mediated gene transfer to flax.

Using an Agrobacterium tumefaciens binary vector (pAL4404, pBI131), we have demonstrated the transfer of the ß-glucuronidase gene into the flax (Linum usitatissimum L.) cultivar Glenelg after selection for kanamycin resistance. The transformed lines were obtained by inoculation and subsequent regeneration of hypocotyl segments. The callus that formed on the cut surfaces of the hypocotyl segments was isolated three weeks after infection and was subsequently subcultured to yield shoots. This procedure generated a large number of transgenic shoots over a relatively short period of time. The transformation efficiencies obtained were the highest reported so far for this plant species.

Activity of the promoter of the Lhca3.St.1 gene, encoding the potato apoprotein 2 of the light-harvesting complex of Photosystem I, in transgenic potato and tobacco plants.

We have isolated cDNA and genomic clones for the potato (Solanum tuberosum) apoprotein 2 of the light harvesting complex of Photosystem I, designated Lhca3.St.1. The protein shows all characteristics of the family of chlorophyll a/b-binding proteins. Potato Lhca3.1 gene expression occurs predominantly in leaves, and is transcriptionally regulated by light. One gene copy is present per haploid genome. The sequence of the 5' upstream region was determined. Most boxes identified in the promoter sequences of genes whose expression is light-regulated recur in the Lhca3.St.1 sequence. Functional analyses of the Lhca3.St.1 promoter and two deletion derivatives in transgenic potato transformed with a promoter-GUS fusion show high promoter activity in leaves and other green parts of the plant, which depends on light. Activity is absent in roots and potato tubers. The 500 bp promoter fragment is as active as the full 2.0 kb sequence, showing that all regulatory elements are present on the smallest deletion derivative. In transgenic tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) plants carrying the largest promoter derivative a similar distribution of activity is found. Promoter activity is not restricted to the phloem, but also prominent in the xylem of the young stem, which contrasts with promoters of other photosynthesis-associated genes.