Cytokine dependency of human B cell cycle progression elicited by ligands which coengage BCR and the CD21/CD19/CD81 costimulatory complex.

Coengagement of BCR and the C3dg binding CD21/CD19/CD81 costimulatory complex can profoundly reduce the BCR binding threshold for eliciting B cell S phase entry, provided cytokine is present. IL-4 is substantially better than IL-2, IL-13, and TNF-alpha at exhibiting synergy with BCR:CD21 coengaging ligand (anti-IgM:anti-CD21:dextran) in promoting B cell DNA synthesis. Synergy between IL-4 and anti-IgM:anti-CD21:dextran (a) is not explained by the viability-promoting function of IL-4, (b) occurs when the anti-CD21 moiety engages either C3dg binding or non-C3dg binding domains, (c) does not reflect reversal of FcgammaRII-mediated negative regulation, and (d) involves differing temporal requirements for BCR and IL-4R signal transduction during the activation process. The IL-4R signaling pathway appears to synergize directly with the BCR:CD21 signaling pathway(s) in promoting the progression of resting B cells past an early G1 checkpoint, as well as to promote independently the progression of activated B cells past a later G1 to S checkpoint.

Evidence for an upper affinity threshold for anti-IgM-induced apoptosis in a human B-cell lymphoma.

The influence of ligand:receptor affinity on B-cell antigen receptor (BCR)-induced apoptosis in the IgM+ Burkitt lymphoma line, Ramos, was evaluated with a group of affinity-diverse murine monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) specific for human B-cell IgM. The studies showed not only a minimal affinity threshold for the induction of apoptosis, but, interestingly, also a maximal affinity threshold above which increases in affinity were associated with diminished apoptosis. The lesser capacity of high-affinity MoAb to induce apoptosis was paralleled by a lesser capacity to induce receptor cross-linking. At high ligand concentration, high MoAb affinity was also associated with a diminished capacity to induce early protein tyrosine phosphorylation. The compromised capacity of two high-affinity MoAbs to trigger apoptosis may be, at least in part, explained by two separate phenomena that can impair the formation of mIgM cross-links: (1) more stable univalent binding and (2) a tendency for monogamous binding of both MoAb Fab to two Fab epitopes on mIgM. These in vitro studies suggest that the use of the highest affinity MoAbs for antireceptor immunotherapies that depend on receptor cross-linking might, on occasion, be contraindicated.

Membrane IgM-stimulated human B lymphocytes succumb to activation-related apoptosis at a G1-->S transition: influence of ligand affinity and valency.

Culture of human B lymphocytes with polyclonally activating surrogates for type II T-cell-independent antigen, i.e., anti-IgM mAb and anti-IgM:dextran, resulted in both membrane IgM (mIgM)-triggered S/G2/M entry and apoptosis. Although high ligand valency could compensate for low affinity, and high affinity could compensate for low valency, in achieving mIgM-triggered apoptosis, the phenomenon was most pronounced when the soluble "antigen" had both high binding site affinity and valency. Most of the mIgM-triggered apoptosis may represent B cells which progress into G1 but fail to receive a sufficient level of continuous mIgM-mediated signaling during G1 for passage through a G1 --> S phase restriction point(s). This was supported by the findings that (a) a lesser proportion of mIg-triggered cells enter S phase than G1; (b) maximal mIgM-triggered apoptosis was noted at 48-72 h of culture and surrounding activated cell clusters; (c) mIgM-triggered apoptosis was not inhibited by pharmacologic blockers of S phase; and (d) a high proportion of viable mIgM-triggered B cell blasts in G1 succumb to apoptosis rather than enter S phase, if high-affinity multivalent ligand is washed from the cultures. In addition to quantitative aspects of initial receptor engagement, the potential for a protracted period of recurrent mIgM signaling events may influence whether apoptosis or cell cycle progression is the functional outcome of B cell encounter with a multivalent antigen.

The affinity threshold for human B cell activation via the antigen receptor complex is reduced upon co-ligation of the antigen receptor with CD21 (CR2).

The present studies have examined whether the potential of an Ag to co-ligate the complement (C3d)-binding CD21 receptor complex with the membrane IgM (mIgM) receptor complex can reduce the mIgM:Ag affinity threshold for triggering human B cell S phase entry. A series of Ab:dextran conjugates consisting of affinity-diverse anti-IgM mAb, with and without anti-CD21 mAb, were synthesized as polyclonally reactive, moderately multivalent ligands that mimic C3d-bearing and non-C3d-bearing Ag. Co-ligation of mIgM and CD21 significantly diminished both the ligand concentration threshold and the IgM:ligand affinity threshold for eliciting S phase entry in the presence of IL-4. Furthermore, such co-engagement ablated the triggering bonus associated with high mlgM:ligand affinity, suggesting that B cells with a high affinity for Ag are not preferentially activated over B cells of intermediate affinity upon encountering a multivalent Ag with bound C3d. The enhancing effects of mIgM:CD21 co-ligation were restricted to low concentrations of ligand; at high concentrations, a decrease in B cell DNA synthesis was often observed. The findings suggest that the ability a moderately multivalent Ag substrate to engage B cells through both mIgM and CD21 is critical for B cell activation at limiting Ag concentrations, and furthermore, that mIgM:CD21 co-engagement may be particularly important in eliciting an immune response to such Ags in unprimed individuals in whom the majority of specific B cells are of low affinity.

Biological function and distribution of human interleukin-12 receptor beta chain.

We previously described the cloning of a cDNA encoding an interleukin-12 receptor (IL-12R) subunit, designated beta, that bound IL-12 with low affinity when expressed in COS cells. We now report that a pair of monoclonal antibodies (mAb), 2B10 and 2.4E6, directed against different epitopes on the IL-12R beta chain, when used in combination, strongly inhibited IL-12-induced proliferation of activated T cells, IL-12-induced secretion of interferon-gamma by resting peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC), and IL-12-mediated lymphokine-activated killer cell activation. The mAb had no effect on lymphoblast proliferation induced by IL-2, -4, or -7. Thus, the IL-12R beta chain appears to be an essential component of the functional IL-12R on both T and natural killer (NK) cells. We previously observed that high affinity IL-12R were expressed on activated T and NK cells, but not B cells. Studies using flow cytometry and reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction analysis showed that IL-12R beta chain was expressed on several human T, NK, and (surprisingly) B cell lines, but not on non-lymphohematopoietic cell lines. The Kit225/K6 (T cell) and SKW6.4 (B cell) lines were found to express the greatest amounts of IL-12R beta chain (800-2500 sites/cell); however, Kit225/K6 but not SKW6.4 cells bound IL-12. Similar to SKW6.4 B cells, activated tonsillar B lymphocytes expressed IL-12R beta chain but, consistent with previous results, did not display detectable IL-12 binding. Likewise, up to 72% of resting PBMC from normal volunteer donors expressed IL-12R beta, but did not bind measurable amounts of IL-12. These results indicate that expression of IL-12R beta is essential, but not sufficient, for expression of functional IL-12R. We speculate that expression of functional, high-affinity IL-12R may require the presence of a second subunit that is more restricted in its expression than IL-12R beta.

Human B cell activation. Effect of T cell cytokines on the physicochemical binding requirements for achieving cell cycle progression via the membrane IgM signaling pathway.

Given the range of mIg-binding affinities expressed by Ag-specific B cells, the ligand:receptor affinity threshold for achieving full B cell activation via the mIgM-mediated signaling pathway is quite high. Several recombinant, or semi-purified, cytokines were found to reduce the very high mIgM:ligand affinity threshold for induction of human B cell S phase entry by bivalent, affinity-diverse anti-IgM mAbs without notably affecting the lower affinity threshold for G1-related RNA synthesis. Two-stage culture experiments suggested that one major means by which IL-4, IL-2, and low m.w. B cell growth factor lower the affinity threshold for S phase entry is an indirect one, i.e., rescue of B cells whose mIg engagements with Ag are of sufficient affinity for achieving G1 entry, but of insufficient affinity for initiating the late-phase mIgM-mediated signals needed for the G1-->S phase transition. IL-4 had additional effects in early G1. In contrast to the above cytokines, IFN-gamma, did not function as an independent cell cycle progression factor, but rather required the concomitant presence of mIgM-cross-linking ligand for enhancement. A greater potential of multivalent anti-IgM-dextran conjugates to trigger S phase entry in the absence of cytokines was found to reflect a greater potential for initiating mIgM signals during the late phase in B cell activation. The results indicate that progression of mIgM receptor-activated B cells past a G1-->S phase restriction point is dependent upon continued signal transduction via either the mIgM receptor and/or a cytokine receptor signaling pathway. When mIgM-engaging ligands are ineffective at initiating late-phase signals, due to limited size and binding site valency and/or affinity, ancillary signal transduction through cytokine receptors becomes most relevant.

A monovalent C mu 4-specific ligand enhances the activation of human B cells by membrane IgM cross-linking ligands.

The ligand-receptor binding requirements for achieving full B cell activation through the membrane immunoglobulin (mIg) signaling pathway are relatively demanding, and mIg-antigen engagements which fall below these critical thresholds cause, at most, only the partial activation of B cells. In an effort to resolve new means of enhancing the efficacy of mIgM-mediated signal transduction, as well as to further understand the process by which mIgM-mediated signals are initiated, we have explored the mechanism for a previously reported synergy between certain mixtures of murine anti-IgM mAbs in eliciting human B cell DNA synthesis. We here report that striking synergy occurs when any of several relatively high affinity mAbs specific for diverse domains of mIgM are combined in culture with the relatively low affinity C mu 4-specific ligand, mAb IG6. Although B cell activation was dependent upon the bivalency, and hence mIgM cross-linking potential, of the high affinity ligand, low affinity mAb IG6 could enhance the activation process when present as a monovalent Fab' fragment. This did not appear due to F(ab')2 contamination or Fab' aggregation, since IG6 Fab' preparations were notably compromised in several other functions requiring ligand bivalency. Pulsing studies revealed that the C mu 4-specific ligand exhibits its functional effects only when stimulatory mIgM receptor cross-links are being formed by bivalent ligands, and that IG6 Fab' enhancement is most notable during the later interval of the prolonged mIgM signaling process that leads to S phase entry. A unique region of the membrane-proximal IgM domain may be important for Fab'-mediated enhancement, since Fab' fragments that bind with higher affinities to distinct sites on C mu 4 were not as effective at mediating this phenomenon. Several possibilities for the adjuvant effects of this C mu 4-specific Fab' on B cell responses triggered by mIgM crosslinking ligands are discussed, including the possibility that IG6 Fab' influences the potential for mIgM dimer formation or interactions of mIgM with other signal-transducing molecules.

Membrane IgM-mediated signaling of human B cells. Effect of increased ligand binding site valency on the affinity and concentration requirements for inducing diverse stages of activation.

The potential for ligand-initiated signal transduction through B cell membrane IgM is assessed in terms of ligand concentration, binding site valency, and binding site affinity for membrane Ig. Estimates of the physicochemical requirements for achieving G0* enhancement of class II MHC expression, G1 entry, and S phase entry in human B cells were made by comparing the stimulatory effects of three affinity-diverse anti-Cmu2 mAb when in bivalent (unconjugated) form, or as mAb-dextran conjugates with low binding site valency (oligovalent ligands) or high binding site valency (multivalent ligands). An increase in binding site number (and concomitant molecular mass) caused a profound reduction in both the minimal concentration and affinity requisites for B cell activation. The enhancing effect of increased binding site valency was most evident for the signaling of those most distal stages in B cell activation, i.e., G1 and S phase, which were difficult to induce with bivalent ligands. The results suggest that highly multimeric TI-2 Ag may be good immunogens because they are able to elicit a full activation response not only from infrequent high affinity B cells, but also from a substantial proportion of the many lower affinity Ag-specific B cells in virgin B cell populations. Interestingly, the activation of B cells by ligands with binding sites of high intrinsic affinity (Ka = 5 x 10(8) M-1) was less influenced by increases in binding site valency than was B cell activation by ligands with intermediate binding site affinity (Ka = 2 x 10(7) M-1). This suggests that the minimal epitope valency requirement for T cell-independent B cell activation by mIg cross-linking Ag may be dependent on the intrinsic affinity with which membrane Ig molecules on a given B cell interact with the redundantly expressed epitopes.

IL-12 receptor. II. Distribution and regulation of receptor expression.

IL-12 is a heterodimeric lymphokine that induces IFN-gamma production by resting PBMC, enhances the lytic activity of NK/lymphokine activated killer cells, and causes the proliferation of activated T cells and NK cells. In this report, we have investigated the expression of IL-12R on mitogen- and IL-2-activated PBMC or tonsillar lymphocytes as well as on a variety of cell lines. The results of radiolabeled IL-12-binding assays indicated that high affinity IL-12R are present on PBMC activated by various T cell mitogens or by IL-2. High affinity IL-12R were also found to be expressed constitutively on a transformed marmoset NK-like cell line HVS.SILVA 40. At the time of peak IL-12R expression, mitogen- or IL-2-activated cells displayed approximately 1000 to 9000 IL-12 binding sites/cell with an apparent Kd of 100 to 900 pM. Kinetic studies revealed that maximum expression of IL-12R occurred earlier on PHA-activated PBMC as compared with PBMC activated by IL-2, and that expression of IL-12R on these cells correlated with their ability to proliferate in response to IL-12. Although IL-2 could up-regulate IL-12R expression on resting PBMC, the ability of mitogen-activated PBMC to up-regulate IL-12R was found to be independent of IL-2. Analysis of IL-12R expression by flow cytometry revealed that receptors for IL-12 are present on activated T cells of both the CD4+ and CD8+ subsets and on activated CD56+ NK cells. In contrast, neither resting PBMC or tonsillar B cells nor tonsillar B cells activated by anti-IgM/Dx, anti-IgM/Dx + IL-2, or SAC + IL-2 displayed IL-12R detectable by flow cytometry or by the radiolabeled IL-12-binding assay. In summary, these results indicate that activation of T cells or NK cells results in up-regulation of IL-12R expression; on the other hand, B cell activation, at least under some circumstances, appears not to be associated with enhanced expression of IL-12R.

Differential effects of cyclosporin A on diverse B cell activation phenomena triggered by crosslinking of membrane IgM.

Cyclosporin A (CsA) was tested for its modulatory effects on the mIgM-mediated signaling of G0*-associated increases in class II MHC expression, G1-related RNA synthesis, and S phase-related DNA synthesis in human B cells. While CsA at concentrations as low as 10-100 ng/ml could completely ablate anti-IgM-induced DNA synthesis, earlier G1-associated RNA synthesis was only partially inhibited, and signaling of increased membrane class II MHC expression was unaffected by up to 1000 ng/ml of CsA. Similar phenomena were observed in a clonal population of leukemic B lymphocytes susceptible to anti-IgM-mediated activation in the absence of T cells and T cell factors indicating (a) that the inhibitory effects are not due to CsA-mediated suppression of cytokine production by contaminating T cells, and (b) that the varying effects of CsA on the diverse activation phenomena do not reflect B cell subpopulation diversity. Pulsing studies revealed that while maximal suppression of anti-IgM-induced G1-associated RNA synthesis required CsA at culture initiation, near maximal suppression of DNA synthesis occurred when CsA, or soluble human IgM, was added up to 30 hr after the initial exposure of resting B cells to the anti-IgM ligand. These latter findings are consistent with the possibility that the CsA-mediated suppression of S phase entry is due to the inhibition of a signaling event proximal to mIgM ligation which must be repeatedly initiated throughout the first 30 hr of activation.

Affinity requirements for induction of sequential phases of human B cell activation by membrane IgM-cross-linking ligands.

The affinity of Ag interaction with a B cell's membrane IgM (mIgM) receptors has long been considered to play a critical role in the in vivo clonal selection of B lymphocytes. This study has examined a possible basis for this affinity selection at the level of Ag induction of sequential B cell activation phenomena, i.e., elevated membrane class II MHC expression (G0* excitation), G1 entry, and S phase entry. Functional experiments with model bivalent Ag, i.e., a group of murine mAb of diverse intrinsic binding affinities for human IgM, revealed that the minimal affinity requisites for inducing the above phenomena vary significantly. At a ligand concentration of 100 micrograms/ml, the induction of increased class II MHC expression, G1 entry, and S phase had minimal affinity thresholds of Ka approximately 0.2 to 2 x 10(6) M-1; approximately 7 x 10(6) M-1; and approximately 1 x 10(8) M-1, respectively. Pulsing studies revealed that whereas high affinity ligand was essential at later periods in the prolonged (greater than 24 h) signaling period that leads to S phase entry, mAb with significantly lower affinity were competent at signaling during the first 24 h. Because all but the lowest affinity ligand (Ka = 2 x 10(5) M-1) could effectively modulate mIgM, and furthermore, because B cells show a substantial increase in surface area during activation, it appears likely that one factor contributing to the higher affinity requirements for induction of late activation phenomena is a progressive decrease in the density of mIgM on the responsive B cells. These studies suggest that whereas only a small proportion of B cells, i.e., those with relatively high affinity for an antigenic epitope, will be triggered to clonally expand on encountering a paucivalent Ag in the absence of T cell help, a much wider spectrum of the B cell repertoire will be triggered to a state of partial activation. How the presence of ancillary T cells and cytokines may facilitate the full clonal expansion of these latter cells is discussed.

Membrane IgD and membrane IgM differ in capacity to transduce inhibitory signals within the same human B cell clonal populations.

The relative capacity of two coexpressed membrane Ig (mIg) isotypes, mIgM and mIgD, to actively transduce tolerogenic signals was evaluated with three human B cell leukemic clonal populations. Although anti-IgM mAb directed to various domains of the mIgM molecule suppressed spontaneous or T cell factor-induced leukemic DNA synthesis at concentrations as low as 0.01 to 0.1 microgram/ml, anti-IgD antibodies of both monoclonal and polyclonal origin failed to inhibit at doses as high as 100 micrograms/ml. Several possibilities for the differential capacity of mIgM and mIgD molecules to signal inhibition in these leukemic clonal populations were evaluated. Differences in the intrinsic membrane expression of the two isotypes before in vitro clonal activation were not responsible because the above distinctions were noted in cells of a chronic lymphocytic leukemia, which expressed slightly more mIgD than mIgM. The ineffective inhibitory signaling capacity of mIgD-specific ligands was also not caused by a selective decrease in the membrane expression of mIgD during cell culture, because the density of each isotype remained relatively constant during the first 44 h of in vitro activation by T cell factors, and following capping, mIgM and mIgD were resynthesized with similar kinetics. Because anti-IgM and anti-IgD mAb with comparable affinities for their respective membrane molecules differed significantly in inhibitory potential, it was considered improbable that the IgD-specific ligands tested bound to mIgD with a suboptimal affinity for inducing tolerance. Inhibition of leukemic DNA synthesis was observed after incubation with either anti-kappa antibody or a mixture of IgM- and IgD-isotype-specific antibodies, indicating that cross-linking of mIgD does not make B cell clones refractory to tolerogenic signal transduction through mIgM. These studies provide strong clonal support for the concept that coexpressed mIgM and mIgD molecules play distinct roles in human B cell immunoregulation.

Anti-IgM-mediated B cell signaling. Molecular analysis of ligand binding requisites for human B cell clonal expansion and tolerance.

The ligand binding requisites for membrane IgM-mediated signaling of human B lymphocyte clonal expansion and B cell tolerance were investigated with a well-characterized set of soluble murine anti-human IgM mAbs. Evaluation of the impact of mu chain domain specificity, affinity, and binding stoichiometry for membrane IgM on antibody-induced regulation of normal and leukemic B cell DNA synthesis revealed that the ligand binding requisites for inducing or, alternatively, suppressing B cell DNA synthesis are significantly different. First, while the induction of S phase entry required micrograms/ml concentrations of ligand, orders of magnitude lower concentrations of ligand sufficed for inhibitory signaling. Second, while an upper affinity threshold for achieving maximal stimulation of B cell DNA synthesis was never detected, inhibitory signaling by bivalent ligands appeared to become relatively affinity independent at Fab binding affinities greater than 7.0 x 10(6) M-1. Third, while a C mu 1-specific mAb with an enhanced incidence of monogamous binding to mIgM was ineffective at inducing B cell DNA synthesis, the antibody was not significantly compromised in ability to initiate inhibitory signals. These differences could be observed in a clonal B cell population which positively or negatively responded to mIgM ligation depending upon its state of activation. The accumulated observations indicate that the ligand binding requisites for inhibitory signal transduction in human B lymphocytes are much less rigorous than those for stimulatory signal transduction and suggest that many physiologically relevant anti-Ig antibodies are more likely to function in the negative feedback regulation of B cell responses than in the direct triggering of human B cell clonal expansion.

Analysis of the domain specificity of various murine anti-human IgM monoclonal antibodies differing in human B lymphocyte signaling activity.

The domain binding specificity of 19 murine anti-human IgM monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) that have shown considerable heterogeneity in the transduction of stimulatory and inhibitory signals to B lymphocytes was evaluated by competition radioimmunoassays. Through the use of: (i) enzymatic fragments of IgM which each encompass more than a single CH domain, i.e. Fc5 mu and F(ab')2 mu, (ii) isolated single domains, C mu 2, C mu 3, and C mu 4, and (iii) mu heavy chain disease proteins, nine anti-IgM MoAbs were found to have C mu 1 domain specificity, five to have C mu 2 specificity, and five others to have C mu 4 specificity. Ineffective binding to isolated mu chain demonstrated that C mu 1-specific MoAbs were directed to epitopes which require light chain for expression. The lack of binding of the C mu 4-specific MoAbs to CNBr cleavage fragments of Fc5 mu suggest that the determinants recognized by these MoAbs may also be conformational in nature. Cross-inhibition analyses were used to determine the number of unique epitopes recognized by the anti-IgM MoAbs. Results from these experiments showed that: (i) eight of the nine MoAbs specific for C mu 1 likely bind to a single epitope, or very proximate epitopes, (ii) the five C mu 2-specific MoAbs recognize at least three distinct epitopes, and (iii) the five C mu 4-specific MoAbs each recognize a separate determinant. A comparison of the known B cell activating properties of these MoAbs with their specificity for the various segments of the IgM molecule indicate that mitogenicity cannot be attributed to selective binding to any one domain.

Human B cell activation. Evidence for diverse signals provided by various monoclonal anti-IgM antibodies.

Seven murine monoclonal antibodies (mAb) with different binding characteristics for human IgM varied markedly in their ability to induce proliferation of T cell-depleted human splenocytes. Two mAb (HB57 and 5D7) that bound to distinct epitopes on IgM were highly effective initiators of B cell proliferation at very low concentrations, in the presence of a T cell factor source. In the absence of T cell supernatant, both HB57 and 5D7 mAbs produced a markedly reduced degree of stimulation at all concentrations. Two additional anti-IgM mAb (VIIIE11 and Mu53) were distinctive in that, even at high concentrations, only limited proliferation was observed compared with the first group of mAb. This proliferation depended on the presence of T cell supernatant. Competitive-binding studies revealed that the epitope recognized by mAb Mu53 may be identical or very proximate to that recognized by HB57. Three other mAb (1G6, XG9, and P24) induced little or no proliferation. 1G6 bound to a unique epitope on the IgM molecule, whereas XG9 shared a determinant with VIIIE11 mAb. Regulatory influences of Fc receptor binding cannot account for all the diversity in proliferation observed with the individual anti-IgM mAb. Markedly augmented proliferation was obtained when B cells were cultured with certain combinations of anti-IgM mAb in the presence of exogenous T cell supernatant. The proliferation induced in the absence of T cell supernatant by high concentrations of mAb mixtures that included 1G6 approached that observed for the same mixtures in the presence of T cell supernatant. The data suggest that certain signals delivered through membrane IgM can bypass the need for T cell supernatant in the activation of human B lymphocytes.

T cell regulation of immunoglobulin class expression in the B cell response to TNP-Ficoll: characterization of the T cell responsible for preferential enhancement of the IgG2a response.

Syngeneic T cells injected into athymic nu/nu mice cause a preferential enhancement in the amount of IgG2a anti-TNP Ab produced by these mice to TNP-Ficoll. This enhancement appears to be caused by T cell effects on the IgG switching pathway. Through the use of F1----parent chimeras, the helper T cells were shown to affect TNP-Ficoll-responsive B cells in an H-2-unrestricted manner. The ability of T cells to mediate this IgG2a enhancement did not appear to be unique to any particular murine genetic background, because it was observed with T cells and nu/nu mice of C57BL/10, BALB/c, CBA/Ca, and B10.D2 strains. Priming of T cell donors with Ficoll or TNP-Ficoll did not increase the ability of splenic T cells, on a per cell basis, to enhance the IgG2a Ab response to TNP-Ficoll. The T cell population responsible for modulating the isotypic response was found to be sensitive to C-mediated cytotoxicity with both anti-Lyt-2 and anti-Lyt-1 hybridoma Ab. Although T cells from both the thymus and the spleen expressed enhancing activity, splenic T cells were more effective, on a per cell basis, than were thymocytes. The observations suggest that T cells that appear to enhance the switch to IgG2a in TNP-Ficoll-responsive B cells are not effectively primed by the antigen and interact with TNP-Ficoll-activated B cells through an H-2-unrestricted mechanism.

Establishment of an inbred line of mice that express a synergistic immune defect precluding in vitro responses to type 1 and type 2 antigens, B cell mitogens, and a number of T cell-derived helper factors.

Introduction of the CBA/N X-linked gene into C3H mice has resulted in the establishment of a new strain of mice that has profound immunologic defects. B cells from these mice show significantly impaired in vitro immune responses to the T cell-independent type 1 antigen trinitrophenyl-Brucella abortus (TNP-BA) as well as markedly reduced proliferative responses to a number of B cell mitogens when compared with the responses of the parental control mice. The in vivo response of such mice to TNP-BA is, however, comparable to that of CBA/N mice. Furthermore, B cells from C3.CBA/N mice are unresponsive to the plaque-forming cell enhancing effects induced by EL4-derived supernatant in the presence of TNP-BA, unlike B cells obtained from CBA/N or C3H/Hen mice whose responsiveness to TNP-BA can be significantly enhanced in the presence of EL4-derived supernatant. The model we have presented to best explain these results suggests that B cells from C3.CBA/N mice can be stimulated only under conditions in which they can interact with carrier-specific T cell help and not under conditions where factor-dependent responses are dominant.