Observation of Cytotoxicity of Phosphonium Derivatives Is Explained: Metabolism Inhibition and Adhesion Alteration.

The search for new antibiotics, substances that kill prokaryotic cells and do not kill eukaryotic cells, is an urgent need for modern medicine. Among the most promising are derivatives of triphenylphosphonium, which can protect the infected organs of mammals and heal damaged cells as mitochondria-targeted antioxidants. In addition to the antioxidant action, triphenylphosphonium derivatives exhibit antibacterial activity. It has recently been reported that triphenylphosphonium derivatives cause either cytotoxic effects or inhibition of cellular metabolism at submicromolar concentrations. In this work, we analyzed the MTT data using microscopy and compared them with data on changes in the luminescence of bacteria. We have shown that, at submicromolar concentrations, only metabolism is inhibited, while an increase in alkyltriphenylphosphonium (CnTPP) concentration leads to adhesion alteration. Thus, our data on eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells confirm a decrease in the metabolic activity of cells by CnTPPs but do not confirm a cytocidal effect of TPPs at submicromolar concentrations. This allows us to consider CnTPP as a non-toxic antibacterial drug at low concentrations and a relatively safe vector for delivering other antibacterial substances into bacterial cells.

Role of mitochondrial outer membrane in the uncoupling activity of N-terminally glutamate-substituted gramicidin A.

Of a series of gramicidin A (gA) derivatives, we have earlier found the peptide [Glu1]gA exhibiting very low toxicity toward mammalian cells, although dissipating mitochondrial membrane potential with almost the same efficiency as gA. Substitution of glutamate for valine at position 1 of the gA amino acid sequence, which is supposed to interfere with the formation of ion-conducting gA channels via head-to-head dimerization, reduces both channel-forming potency of the peptide in planar lipid bilayer membranes and its photonophoric activity in unilamellar liposomes. Here, we compared [Glu1]gA and gA abilities to cause depolarization of the inner mitochondrial membrane in mitochondria and mitoplasts, the latter lacking the outer mitochondrial membrane. Importantly, much less gA was needed to decrease the membrane potential in mitoplasts than in mitochondria, whereas the depolarizing potency of [Glu1]gA was nearly the same in these systems. Moreover, in multilamellar liposomes, [Glu1]gA exhibited more pronounced protonophoric activity than gA, in contrast to the data for unilamellar liposomes. These results allowed us to conclude that [Glu1]gA has a much higher permeability between adjacent lipid membranes than gA. Therefore, the fraction of peptide molecules, reaching the inner mitochondrial membrane upon the addition to cells, is much higher for [Glu1]gA compared to gА. Under these conditions, the decreased cytotoxicity of [Glu1]gA could be associated with its low efficiency as a channel-former dissipating potassium and sodium ion gradients across plasma membrane. The present study highlighted the role of the ability to permeate among various biological membranes for intracellular efficiency of ionophores.

pH-Dependent properties of ion channels formed by N-terminally glutamate substituted gramicidin A in planar lipid bilayers.

The N-terminally glutamate substituted analogue of the pentadecapeptide gramicidin A [Glu1]gA has been previously described as a low-toxic uncoupler of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation and neuroprotector. Here, we studied ion channel-forming activity of this peptide in planar bilayer lipid membranes (BLMs). [Glu1]gA exhibited an ability to induce both macroscopic current and single channels in a broad pH range, albeit with a lower potency than the parent gramicidin A (gA). Single-channel recordings in 1M KCl at pH about 4 showed channel openings of one type with the conductance (about 26pS), similar to that of gA, and the lifetime (40ms), much shorter than that of gA. By contrast, two populations of channels were found at pH9, one of which had much longer duration (several seconds) and lower conductance (3.5-10pS). Autocorrelation function of the current noise of [Glu1]gA revealed a marked shift towards longer correlation times upon alkalinization. The sensitized photoinactivation technique also revealed substantial differences in [Glu1]gA conducting properties at alkaline and acidic pH, in particular deceleration of the photoinactivation kinetics and a sharp decrease in its amplitude upon alkalinization. A double-logarithmic plot of the concentration dependence of [Glu1]gA-induced BLM conductance had the slope of about 3, which pointed to peptide aggregation in the membrane. The data were discussed in relation to pH-dependent aggregation of [Glu1]gA, resulting from deprotonation of the glutamate side chain at alkaline pH.

Peptide-induced membrane leakage by lysine derivatives of gramicidin A in liposomes, planar bilayers, and erythrocytes.

Introducing a charged group near the N-terminus of gramicidin A (gA) is supposed to suppress its ability to form ion channels by restricting its head-to-head dimerization. The present study dealt with the activity of [Lys1]gA, [Lys3]gA, [Glu1]gA, [Glu3]gA, [Lys2]gA, and [Lys5]gA in model membrane systems (planar lipid bilayers and liposomes) and erythrocytes. In contrast to the Glu-substituted peptides, the lysine derivatives of gA caused non-specific liposomal leakage monitored by fluorescence dequenching of lipid vesicles loaded with carboxyfluorescein or other fluorescent dyes. Measurements of electrical current through a planar lipid membrane revealed formation of giant pores by Lys-substituted analogs, which depended on the presence of solvent in the bilayer lipid membrane. The efficacy of unselective pore formation in liposomes depended on the position of the lysine residue in the amino acid sequence, increasing in the row: [Lys2]gA<[Lys5]gA<[Lys1]gA<[Lys3]gA. The similar series of potency was exhibited by the Lys-substituted gA analogs in facilitating erythrocyte hemolysis, whereas the Glu-substituted analogs showed negligible hemolytic activity. Oligomerization of the Lys-substituted peptides is suggested to be involved in the process of nonselective pore formation.

N-terminally glutamate-substituted analogue of gramicidin A as protonophore and selective mitochondrial uncoupler.

Limited uncoupling of oxidative phosphorylation could be beneficial for cells by preventing excessive generation of reactive oxygen species. Typical uncouplers are weak organic acids capable of permeating across membranes with a narrow gap between efficacy and toxicity. Aimed at designing a nontoxic uncoupler, the protonatable amino acid residue Glu was substituted for Val at the N-terminus of the pentadecapeptide gramicidin A (gA). The modified peptide [Glu1]gA exhibited high uncoupling activity in isolated mitochondria, in particular, abolishing membrane potential at the inner mitochondrial membrane with the same or even larger efficacy as gA. With mitochondria in cell culture, the depolarizing activity of [Glu1]gA was observed at concentrations by an order of magnitude lower than those of gA. On the contrary, [Glu1]gA was much less potent in forming proton channels in planar lipid bilayers than gA. Remarkably, at uncoupling concentrations, [Glu1]gA did not alter cell morphology and was nontoxic in MTT test, in contrast to gA showing high toxicity. The difference in the behavior of [Glu1]gA and gA in natural and artificial membranes could be ascribed to increased capability of [Glu1]gA to permeate through membranes and/or redistribute between different membranes. Based on the protective role of mild uncoupling, [Glu1]gA and some other proton-conducting gA analogues may be considered as prototypes of prospective therapeutic agents.

The pH-dependent induction of lipid membrane ionic permeability by N-terminally lysine-substituted analogs of gramicidin A.

Insertion of charged groups at the N-terminus of the gramicidin A (gA) amino acid sequence is considered to be fatal for peptide channel-forming activity because of hindrance to the head-to-head dimer formation. Here the induction of ionic conductivity in planar bilayer lipid membranes (BLM) was studied with gA analogs having lysine either in the first ([Lys1]gA) or the third ([Lys3]gA) position. If added to the bathing solution at neutral or acidic pH, these analogs, being protonated and thus positively charged, were unable to induce ionic current across BLM. By contrast, at pH 11 the induction of BLM conductivity was observed with both lysine-substituted analogs. Based on the dependence of the macroscopic current on the side of the peptide addition, sensitivity to calcium ions and susceptibility to sensitized photoinactivation, as well as on the single-channel properties of the analogs, we surmise that at alkaline pH [Lys1]gA formed channels with predominantly single-stranded structure of head-to-head helical dimers, whereas [Lys3]gA open channels had the double-stranded helical structure. CD spectra of the lysine-substituted analogs in liposomes were shown to be pH-dependent.