Metal Effect on Cationic [Cp2MH]+ (M = Group 4 and 5)-Mediated CO2 Hydrogenation in the Gas Phase.

Effective CO2 hydrogenation has recently attracted quite some attention for producing more valuable chemical oxygenates (such as methanol, formate) in mild conditions. However, the influence of the metal center on the CO2 activation remains unclear. First, electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) was employed to explore the direct CO2 hydrogenation to formic acid mediated by [Cp2MH]+ (M = Zr, Hf) in the gas phase at room temperature. The key formate intermediate [Cp2M(O2CH)]+ (M = Zr, Hf) was confirmed by traveling wave ion mobility spectrometry (TWIMS). Second, to gain insights into the metal effect, the CO2 hydrogenation process involving Group 4 (i.e., Ti, Zr, Hf) transition metals was calculated along with Group 5 (i.e., V, Nb, Ta) by density functional theory (DFT) methods. The CO2 insertion process was found to be the rate-limiting step. For [Cp2TiH]+, [Cp2ZrH]+, [Cp2HfH]+, [Cp2VH]+, [Cp2NbH]+, and [Cp2TaH]+, the barriers are +7.7, +6.5, +5.9, +9.2, +8.0, and +6.3 kcal/mol, respectively. [Cp2HfH]+-mediated CO2 hydrogenation occurs the most rapidly, as revealed by MS. According to the orbital analysis on the CO2 insertion transition state, the electron-deficient metal center resulting in a low-lying lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) could interact more favorably with the π bond of deformed CO2, which was also consistent with the natural bond orbital (NBO) results. Last but not the least, NBO charges on the metal centers were found to correlate linearly well with the CO2 insertion barriers rather than hydride affinity. Thus, the reactivity of different metal hydride complexes with CO2 to produce a formate could be estimated by the NBO charge on metals. Our findings might provide a series of candidates for the catalyst as well as guidance for catalyst design in mild CO2 hydrogenation.

Size Effects in Gas-phase C-H Activation.

The gas-phase clusters reaction permits addressing fundamental aspects of the challenges related to C-H activation. The size effect plays a key role in the activation processes as it may substantially affect both the reactivity and selectivity. In this paper, we reviewed the size effect related to the hydrocarbon oxidation by early transition metal oxides and main group metal oxides, methane activation mediated by late transition metals. Based on mass-spectrometry experiments in conjunction with quantum chemical calculations, mechanistic discussions were reviewed to present how and why the size greatly regulates the reactivity and product distribution.

Striking Size and Doping Effects of Ti-Si-O Clusters on Methane Conversion Reactions.

The size and doping effects in methane activation by Ti-Si-O clusters have been explored by using a combination of gas-phase experiments and quantum chemical calculations. All [Tim Sin O2(m+n) ].+ (m+n=2, 3, 8, 10, 12, 14) clusters can extract a hydrogen from methane. The associated energies and structures have been revealed in detail. Moreover, the doping and size effects have been discussed involving generalized Kohn-Sham energy decomposition analysis, natural population analysis, Wiberg bond indexes (WBI), molecular polarity index (MPI) and ionization potential (IP). It suggested that Ti-Si-O clusters with a low Ti : Si ratio is beneficial to adsorbing methane and inclination to the hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) process, while the clusters with a high Ti : Si ratio favors the generation of a terminal oxygen radical and results in high reactivity and turnover frequency. On the other hand, a cluster size of m+n=12 is recommended considering both the ionization potential and the turnover frequency of the reaction. Hopefully, these finding will be instructive for the design of high-performance Ti-Si-O catalyst toward methane conversion.

Methane Activation by the Heteronuclear Cluster [TiAlO4]+: Direct Hydrogen Abstraction by a Nonradical Oxygen.

The gas-phase reactions of [TiAlO4]+ with methane have been explored by using FT-ICR mass spectrometry complemented by quantum chemical calculations. Interestingly, the [TiAlO4]+ ions can activate two methane molecules continuously. Moreover, in contrast to the previous reports on gas-phase methane activation by metal oxide clusters, in which hydrogen-atom transfer and/or proton-coupled electron transfer prevail, a hydride transfer process dominates the [TiAlO4]+/CH4 system. The associated electronic origins have been discussed, and such a terminal metal-oxo active center as addressed in the [TiAlO4]+ cluster has proven to be promising in the construction of efficient catalysts concerning methane conversion.

Computational Study on Homolytic Bond Energies of the Ag-X (X = C, O, and H) Complexes and Hammett-Type Analysis of Reactivity.

Thirty-seven calculation methods were benchmarked against the available experimental bond lengths and energies data regarding the Ag-X bonds. The theoretical protocol PBE0/VDZ//ωB97x-D/mVTZ was found to be capable of accurately predicting the homolytic bond dissociation energies (BDEs) of Ag-X complexes with a precision of 1.9 kcal/mol. With the available method in hand, a wide range of different Ag-X BDEs were estimated. BDE(Ag-CH2X), BDE(Ag-PhX), BDE(Ag-OPhX), and BDE(Ag-OCOPhX) (X = NH2, OMe, Me, H, Cl, and NO2) were found to be in the ranges of 27-47, 51-54, 19-39, and 64-70 kcal/mol, respectively. Subsequently, Hammett-type analysis was carried out with reactivity parameters. Good positive linear relationships were found for BDE of Ag-O bands and decarboxylation barriers of Ag-OCOPhX with the Hammett constant σ. It suggested that electron-donating substituents could promote either the homolytic cleavage of the Ag-OPhX bond to undergo a radical process or Ag-OCOPhX decarboxylation. Moreover, ligand effects on Ag-H bonds were investigated using BDE(Ag-H) and related NPA charges on Ag. In the case of P-ligands, carbene ligands, and other small molecule ligands (i.e., CO, CO2, and H2O), a good negative linear relationship was found. In contrast, N-ligands could have a reverse effect. Understanding the intrinsic relationships of BDE(Ag-X) with related reactivity parameters might help gain insights into the structure-reactivity relationships in Ag-X-assisted C-H activation/decarboxylation.

Mechanism and Origin of Chemoselectivity of Ru-Catalyzed Cross-Coupling of Secondary Alcohols to ß-Disubstituted Ketones.

Ru-catalyzed cross-coupling of secondary alcohols with only byproducts H2 and H2O provides a green synthetic strategy to prepare ß-disubstituted ketones. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed with the coupling of 1-phenylethanol and cyclohexanol as a model reaction to gain deeper mechanistic insights herein. The mechanistic details of the main reaction and the key steps of possible side reactions were clarified, and the obtained results are consistent with reported selectivity. Hydrogenation of α,ß-unsaturated ketones and dehydrogenation of ruthenium hydride intermediate are direct chemoselectivity-determining stages. The hydrogenation via 1,4-addition generates more stable intermediates, being favored over that via 1,2-addition, and thus avoids the formation of alkene products. The conjugation and π-π stacking effects of phenyl and the weak electronic effect of alkyls explain the dominance of specific ketone products in the hydrogenation stage. Hydrogenation of ketone products is kinetically operative but not exergonic enough to stop the irreversible dihydrogen release in an open reaction system, and thus alcohol products are absent. Furthermore, water evaporation in aldol condensation is found to be a double-edged sword, as it can accelerate the hydrogenation stage to prevent α,ß-unsaturated ketones from being the main products but decrease the selectivity therein from thermodynamics overall.

Ligand-Controlled CO2 Activation Mediated by Cationic Titanium Hydride Complexes, [LTiH](+) (L=Cp2 , O).

CO2 activation mediated by [LTiH](+) (L=Cp2 , O) is observed in the gas phase at room temperature using electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry, and reaction details are derived from traveling wave ion-mobility mass spectrometry. Wheresas oxygen-atom transfer prevails in the reaction of the oxide complex [OTiH](+) with CO2 , generating [OTi(OH)](+) under the elimination of CO, insertion of CO2 into the metal-hydrogen bond of the cyclopentadienyl complex, [Cp2 TiH](+) , gives rise to the formate complex [Cp2 Ti(O2 CH)](+) . DFT-based methods were employed to understand how the ligand controls the observed variation in reactivity toward CO2 . Insertion of CO2 into the Ti-H bond constitutes the initial step for the reaction of both [Cp2 TiH](+) and [OTiH](+) , thus generating formate complexes as intermediates. In contrast to [Cp2 Ti(O2 CH)](+) which is kinetically stable, facile decarbonylation of [OTi(O2 CH)](+) results in the hydroxo complex [OTi(OH)](+) . The longer lifetime of [Cp2 Ti(O2 CH)](+) allows for secondary reactions with background water, as a result of which, [Cp2 Ti(OH)](+) is formed. Further, computational studies reveal a good linear correlation between the hydride affinity of [LTi](2+) and the barrier for CO2 insertion into various [LTiH](+) complexes. Understanding the intrinsic ligand effects may provide insight into the selective activation of CO2 .

Thermal ethane activation by bare [V2O5]⁺ and [Nb2O5]⁺ cluster cations: on the origin of their different reactivities.

The gas-phase reactivity of [V2O5](+) and [Nb2O5](+) towards ethane has been investigated by means of mass spectrometry and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The two metal oxides give rise to the formation of quite different reaction products; for example, the direct room-temperature conversions C2H6→C2H5OH or C2H6→CH3CHO are brought about solely by [V2O5](+). In distinct contrast, for the couple [Nb2O5](+)/C2H6, one observes only single and double hydrogen-atom abstraction from the hydrocarbon. DFT calculations reveal that different modes of attack in the initial phase of C-H bond activation together with quite different bond-dissociation energies of the M-O bonds cause the rather varying reactivities of [V2O5](+) and [Nb2O5](+) towards ethane. The gas-phase generation of acetaldehyde from ethane by bare [V2O5](+) may provide mechanistic insight in the related vanadium-catalyzed large-scale process.

Accurate prediction of rate constants of Diels-Alder reactions and application to design of Diels-Alder ligation.

Bioorthogonal reactions are useful tools to gain insights into the structure, dynamics, and function of biomolecules in the field of chemical biology. Recently, the Diels-Alder reaction has become a promising and attractive procedure for ligation in bioorthogonal chemistry because of its higher rate and selectivity in water. However, a drawback of the previous Diels-Alder ligation is that the widely used maleimide moiety as a typical Michael acceptor can readily undergo Michael addition with nucleophiles in living systems. Thus, it is important to develop a nucleophile-tolerant Diels-Alder system in order to extend the scope of the application of Diels-Alder ligation. To solve this problem, we found that the theoretical protocol M06-2X/6-31+G(d)//B3LYP/6-31G(d) can accurately predict the activation free energies of Diels-Alder reactions with a precision of 1.4 kcal mol(-1) by benchmarking the calculations against the 72 available experimental data. Subsequently, the electronic effect and ring-strain effect on the Diels-Alder reaction were studied to guide the design of the new dienophiles. The criteria of the design is that the designed Diels-Alder reaction should have a lower barrier than the Michael addition, while at the same time it should show a similar (or even higher) reactivity as compared to the maleimide-involving Diels-Alder ligation. Among the designed dienophiles, three substituted cyclopropenes (i.e. 1,2-bis(trifluoromethyl)-, 1,2-bis(hydroxylmethyl)- and 1,2-bis(hydroxylmethyl)-3-carboxylcyclopropenes) meet our requirements. These substituted cyclopropene analogs could be synthesized and they are thermodynamically stable. As a result, we propose that 1,2-bis(trifluoromethyl)-, 1,2-bis(hydroxylmethyl)- and 1,2-bis(hydroxylmethyl)-3-carboxylcyclopropenes may be potential candidates for efficient and selective Diels-Alder ligation in living systems.

Mechanistic origin of ligand-controlled regioselectivity in Pd-catalyzed C-H activation/arylation of thiophenes.

The use of ligands to control regioselectivity in transition-metal-catalyzed C-H activation/functionalization is a highly desirable but challenging task. Recently, Itami et al. reported an important finding relating to Pd-catalyzed ligand-controlled α/ß-selective C-H arylation of thiophenes. Specifically, the use of the 2,2'-bipyridyl ligand resulted in α-arylation, whereas the use of the bulky fluorinated phosphine ligand P[OCH(CF(3))(2)](3) resulted in ß-arylation. Understanding of this surprising ligand-controlled α/ß-selectivity could provide important insights into the development of more efficient catalyst systems for selective C-H arylation, and so we carried out a detailed computational study on the problem with use of density functional theory methods. Three mechanistic possibilities--S(E)Ar and migration, metalation/deprotonation, and Heck-type arylation mechanisms--were examined. The results showed that the S(E)Ar and migration mechanism might not be plausible, because the key Wheland intermediates could not be obtained. On the other hand, our study indicated that the metalation/deprotonation and Heck-type arylation mechanisms were both involved in Itami's reactions. In the metalation/deprotonation pathway the α-selective product (C5-product) was preferred, whereas in the Heck-type arylation mechanism the ß-selective product (C4-product) was favored. The ligands played crucial roles in tuning the relative barriers of the two different pathways. In the 2,2'-bipyridyl-assisted system, the metalation/deprotonation pathway was energetically advantageous, leading to α-selectivity. In the P[OCH(CF(3))(2)](3)-assisted system, on the other hand, the Heck-type arylation mechanism was kinetically favored, leading to ß-selectivity. An interesting finding was that P[OCH(CF(3))(2)](3) could produce a C-H···O hydrogen bond in the catalyst system, which was crucial for stabilization of the Heck-type transition state. In comparison, this C-H···O hydrogen bond was absent with the other phosphine ligands [i.e., P(OMe)(3), PPh(3), PCy(3)] and these phosphine ligands therefore favored the metalation/deprotonation pathway leading to α-selectivity. Furthermore, in this study we have provided theoretical evidence showing that the Heck-type arylation reaction could proceed through an anti-ß-hydride elimination process.