Biaxial testing of human annulus fibrosus and its implications for a constitutive formulation.

Internal pressure in the healthy human annulus fibrosus leads to multiaxial stress in vivo, yet uniaxial tests have been used exclusively to characterize its in vitro mechanical response and to determine its elastic strain energy function (W). We expected that biaxial tension tests would provide unique and necessary data for characterizing the annular material response, and thereby, for determining W. We performed uniaxial and biaxial tests on specimens of annulus, then developed an objective methodology for defining an appropriate form for W that considers data from multiple experiments simultaneously and allows the data to dictate more directly the form and the number of parameters needed. We found that the stresses attained in the biaxial tests were higher, while the strains were considerably lower, than those observed in the uniaxial tests. A comparison of strain energy functions determined from the different data sets demonstrated that constitutive models derived from uniaxial data could not predict annulus behavior in biaxial tension and vice versa. Since the annulus is in a state of multaxial stress in vivo, we conclude that uniaxial tests alone are insufficient to prescribe a physiologically relevant W for this tissue.

Effect of frozen storage on the creep behavior of human intervertebral discs.

STUDY DESIGN: A biomechanical study of the compressive creep behavior of the human intervertebral disc before and after frozen storage. OBJECTIVES: To determine whether frozen storage alters the time-dependent response of the intact human intervertebral disc. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The biomechanical properties of the intervertebral disc are generally determined using specimens that have been previously frozen. Although it is well established that freezing does not alter the elastic response of the disc, recent data demonstrate that freezing permanently alters the time-dependent mechanical behavior of porcine discs. METHODS: Twenty lumbar motion segments from 10 human spines were harvested between 12 and 36 hours postmortem. The specimens were randomly assigned to one of two groups: Group 1 was tested promptly, stored frozen for 3 weeks, then thawed, and tested a second time; Group 2 was stored frozen for 3 weeks, thawed, and then tested. Each specimen was subjected to 5 cycles of compressive creep under 1 MPa for 20 minutes, followed by a 40-minute recovery under no load. After testing each specimen was graded on a degeneration scale. A fluid transport model was used to parameterize the creep data. RESULTS: There was no statistically significant effect of freezing on the elastic or creep response of the discs. The degree of pre-existing degeneration had a significant effect on the creep response, with the more degenerated discs appearing more permeable. CONCLUSIONS: Frozen storage for a reasonable time with a typical method does not significantly alter the creep response of human lumbar discs. Freezing may produce subtle effects, but these potential artifacts do not appear to alter the discs' time-dependent behavior in any consequential way. These results may not apply to tissue kept frozen for long durations and with poor packaging.

Frozen storage affects the compressive creep behavior of the porcine intervertebral disc.

STUDY DESIGN: A biomechanical study of the compressive creep behavior of the porcine intervertebral disc before and after frozen storage. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether frozen storage alters the creep response, hydration, and nuclear swelling pressure of the intact intervertebral disc. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The mechanical response of the disc is dominated by swelling and fluid flow, whose effects are time-dependent. Because fluid content, which may change during storage, plays a significant role in the disc's time-dependent behavior, changes in mechanical response due to freezing may have been missed in previous studies that focused on time-independent behavior only. METHODS: Porcine intervertebral discs were tested in repeated cycles of compressive creep either immediately postmortem or after 3 weeks of frozen storage. Swelling pressure and nuclear hydration were also measured in fresh and frozen discs. A fluid transport model was used to analyze the creep data. RESULTS: The creep behavior of the intact porcine intervertebral disc is dramatically affected by frozen storage. The apparent permeability of the frozen discs was 82% higher than that of the fresh discs, and the swelling pressure of frozen discs was 25% lower in frozen discs (P < 0.01). The behavior of fresh and frozen discs became more dissimilar with repeated cycles of creep. CONCLUSIONS: In vitro tests of frozen porcine intervertebral discs do not represent fresh behavior. Frozen storage appears to permanently alter disc behavior. The precise nature of any freezing-induced damage, and whether frozen storage similarly affects human discs, remains to be seen.