ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: To assess the impact of multitasking and time pressure on surgeons' brain function during laparoscopic suturing. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Recent neuroimaging evidence suggests that deterioration in surgical performance under time pressure is associated with deactivation of the prefrontal cortex (PFC), an area important for executive functions. However, the effect of multitasking on operator brain function remains unknown. METHODS: Twenty-nine surgical residents performed an intracorporeal suturing task under four conditions: 1) self-paced suturing, 2) time-pressured suturing, 3) self-paced suturing plus decision-making, and 4) time-pressured suturing plus decision-making. Subjective workload was quantified using the Surgical Task Load Index. Technical skill was objectively assessed using task progression scores, error scores, leak volumes, and knot tensile strengths. PFC activation was measured using optical neuroimaging. RESULTS: Compared with self-paced suturing, subjective workload (au) was significantly greater in time-pressured suturing (146.0 vs 196.0, P < 0.001), suturing with decision-making (146.0 vs 182.0, P < 0.001), and time-pressured suturing with decision-making (146.0 vs 227.0, P < 0.001). Technical performance during combined suturing and decision-making tasks was inferior to suturing alone under time pressure or self-paced conditions (P < 0.001). Significant dorsolateral PFC (DLPFC) activations were observed during self-paced suturing, and ventrolateral PFC (VLPFC) deactivations were identified during time-pressured suturing. However, suturing in conjunction with decision-making resulted in significant deactivation across both the VLPFC and DLPFC (P < 0.05). Random effects regression analysis confirmed decision-making predicts VLPFC and DLPFC deactivation (zâ=â-2.62, P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Performance degradation during high workload conditions is associated with deactivation of prefrontal regions important for attentional control, working memory, and cognitive flexibility, particularly during tasks involving simultaneous motor and cognitive engagement.
Subject(s)
General Surgery , Laparoscopy , Multitasking Behavior , Occupational Stress/physiopathology , Prefrontal Cortex/physiopathology , Suture Techniques , Humans , Operating Rooms , Task Performance and Analysis , Time Factors , WorkloadABSTRACT
Robotic surgery may improve technical performance and reduce mental demands compared to laparoscopic surgery. However, no studies have directly compared the impact of robotic and laparoscopic techniques on surgeons' brain function. This study aimed to assess the effect of the operative platform (robotic surgery or conventional laparoscopy) on prefrontal cortical activation during a suturing task performed under temporal demand. Eight surgeons (mean age ± SD = 34.5 ± 2.9 years, male:female ratio = 7:1) performed an intracorporeal suturing task in a self-paced manner and under a 2 min time restriction using conventional laparoscopic and robotic techniques. Prefrontal activation was assessed using near-infrared spectroscopy, subjective workload was captured using SURG-TLX questionnaires, and a continuous heart rate monitor measured systemic stress responses. Task progression scores (au), error scores (au), leak volumes (mL) and knot tensile strengths (N) provided objective assessment of technical performance. Under time pressure, robotic suturing led to improved technical performance (median task progression score: laparoscopic suturing = 4.5 vs. robotic suturing = 5.0; z = - 2.107, p = 0.035; median error score: laparoscopic suturing = 3.0 mm vs. robotic suturing = 2.1 mm; z = - 2.488, p = 0.013). Compared to laparoscopic suturing, greater prefrontal activation was identified in seven channels located primarily in lateral prefrontal regions. These results suggest that robotic surgery improves performance during high workload conditions and is associated with enhanced activation in regions of attention, concentration and task engagement.
Subject(s)
Attention/physiology , Brain Waves , Laparoscopy , Prefrontal Cortex/physiology , Robotic Surgical Procedures , Adult , Female , Humans , MaleABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the impact of time pressure (TP) on prefrontal activation and technical performance in surgical residents during a laparoscopic suturing task. BACKGROUND: Neural mechanisms enabling surgeons to maintain performance and cope with operative stressors are unclear. The prefrontal cortex (PFC) is implicated due to its role in attention, concentration, and performance monitoring. METHODS: A total of 33 residents [Postgraduate Year (PGY)1-2 = 15, PGY3-4 = 8, and PGY5 = 10] performed a laparoscopic suturing task under "self-paced" (SP) and "TP" conditions (TPâ=âmaximum 2 minutes per knot). Subjective workload was quantified using the Surgical Task Load Index. PFC activation was inferred using optical neuroimaging. Technical skill was assessed using progression scores (au), error scores (mm), leak volumes (mL), and knot tensile strengths (N). RESULTS: TP led to greater perceived workload amongst all residents (mean Surgical Task Load Index scoreâ±âSD: PGY1-2: SP = 160.3â±â24.8 vs TP = 202.1â±â45.4, P < 0.001; PGY3-4: SP = 123.0â±â52.0 vs TP = 172.5â±â43.1, P < 0.01; PGY5: SP = 105.8â±â55.3 vs TP = 159.1â±â63.1, P < 0.05). Amongst PGY1-2 and PGY3-4, deterioration in task progression, error scores and knot tensile strength (P < 0.05), and diminished PFC activation was observed under TP. In PGY5, TP resulted in inferior task progression and error scores (P < 0.05), but preservation of knot tensile strength. Furthermore, PGY5 exhibited less attenuation of PFC activation under TP, and greater activation than either PGY1-2 or PGY3-4 under both experimental conditions (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Senior residents cope better with temporal demands and exhibit greater technical performance stability under pressure, possibly due to sustained PFC activation and greater task engagement. Future work should seek to develop training strategies that recruit prefrontal resources, enhance task engagement, and improve performance under pressure.