The Challenges of Tuberculosis Management beyond Professional Competence: Insights from Tuberculosis Outbreaks among Ethiopian Immigrants in Israel.

Controlling tuberculosis (TB) among immigrants from high-incidence countries presents a public health concern as well as a medical challenge. In this article, we investigate a TB outbreak in a community of people of Jewish descent who emigrated from Ethiopia to Israel (Israeli Ethiopians) that started in June 2022. The index case was a 20-year-old female who had recently immigrated to Israel with her family. Her pre-immigration tuberculin skin test was positive. After excluding active TB, treatment with daily isoniazid for latent TB (LTB) was started shortly after her arrival. A year later, she was diagnosed with smear-positive, culture-positive, pulmonary TB. Investigation of 83 contacts revealed five additional patients with active TB, and three of whom were members were of her household. In this article, we report the current TB outbreak, review previously published TB outbreaks involving Israeli Ethiopians, analyze the factors that triggered each of these outbreaks, and discuss the challenges that face the Israeli TB control program in an era of declining TB incidence and diminishing resources available for TB control.

Whole-Genome Sequencing and Epidemiological Investigation of Tuberculosis Outbreaks in High Schools in Hunan, China.

Background: Tuberculosis (TB) seriously threatens individual and public health. Recently, TB outbreaks in schools have been reported more frequently in China and have attracted widespread attention. We reported three TB outbreaks in high schools in Hunan Province, China. Methods: When a tuberculosis patient was reported in a school, we carried out field epidemiological investigations, including tuberculin skin testing (TST), chest X-ray (CXR) and laboratory test for all close contacts, and whole-genome sequencing (WGS) analyses to understand the transmission patterns, the causes and the risk factors for the outbreaks, thereby providing a foundation for the control of TB epidemics in schools. Results: A total of 49 students with TB patients were identified in the three schools where TB outbreaks occurred, including nine patients in School A, 14 patients in School B, and 26 patients in School C. In Schools A, B and C, the putative attack rates in the classes of the index case were 13.8% (8/58), 7.6% (5/66), and 40.4% (21/52), while the putative attack rates of expanding screening in the school were 0.3% (1/361), 0.2% (9/3955), and 0.2% (5/2080), respectively. Thirteen patients had patient delay, with a median delay interval of 69 days (IQR 30.5-113 days). Twelve patients had a healthcare diagnostic delay with a median delay interval of 32 days (IQR 24-82 days). Phylogenetic analysis of culture-positive patients revealed that most of them shared a small genetic distance (≤12 SNPs), with three separate genetic clusters (including one MDR-TB genomic cluster), indicating the recent transmission of Mycobacterium tuberculosis strains. Conclusion: This combination of field investigation and WGS analysis revealed the transmission of three TB outbreaks in schools. Reinforced implementation is needed to improve timely case finding and reduce diagnosis delay in routine TB control in the school population.

The MtZ Strain: Molecular Characteristics and Outbreak Investigation of the Most Successful Mycobacterium tuberculosis Strain in Aragon Using Whole-Genome Sequencing.

Since 2004, a tuberculosis surveillance protocol has been carried out in Aragon, thereby managing to detect all tuberculosis outbreaks that take place in the community. The largest outbreak was caused by a strain named Mycobacterium tuberculosis Zaragoza (MtZ), causing 242 cases as of 2020. The main objective of this work was to analyze this outbreak and the molecular characteristics of this successful strain that could be related to its greater transmission. To do this, we first applied whole-genome sequencing to 57 of the isolates. This revealed two principal transmission clusters and six subclusters arising from them. The MtZ strain belongs to L4.8 and had eight specific single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in genes considered to be virulence factors [ptpA, mc3D, mc3F, VapB41, pks15 (two SNPs), virS, and VapC50]. Second, a transcriptomic study was carried out to better understand the multiple IS6110 copies present in its genome. This allowed us to observe three effects of IS6110: the disruption of the gene in which the IS6110 is inserted (desA3), the overexpression of a gene (ppe38), and the absence of transcription of genes (cut1:Rv1765c) due to the recombination of two IS6110 copies. Finally, because of the disruption of ppe38 and ppe71 genes by an IS6110, a study of PE_PGRS secretion was carried out, showing that MtZ secretes these factors in higher amounts than the reference strain, thereby differing from the hypervirulent phenotype described for the Beijing strains. In conclusion, MtZ consists of several SNPs in genes related to virulence, pathogenesis, and survival, as well as other genomic polymorphisms, which may be implicated in its success among our population.

A whole-genome sequencing study of an X-family tuberculosis outbreak focus on transmission chain along 25 years.

Lineage 4/X-family of Mycobacterium tuberculosis is not very notorious, except for the CDC1551 strain. One strain of this family, named Ara50, caused one of the largest tuberculosis outbreaks of the Aragon region, Spain, during the 1990s and remained until 2018. These X-strains are characterised by high transmissibility and by carrying a low copy number of IS6110 in their genomes. Epidemiological data of the 61 patients consisted of inmates, HIV seropositives, intravenous drug users and the homeless. The application of whole-genome sequencing (WGS) to 36 out of 61 isolates, selected by IS6110-RFLP, allowed to confirm 32 as recent transmissions. We found 10 SNPs in genes considered as virulence factors, five of them specific of this strain. WGS identified three sub-clusters (CLSs). The largest one, sub-CLS 1, included 10 cases. Seven of them shared a SNP in the mce3C gene, considered a virulence factor gene. Sub-CLS 2 involved familiar cases, and no link was known for sub-CLS 3. Finally, the strain showed efficacy in latency as a confirmed epidemiological link was established between two cases, with 6 years of distance in their diagnosis. This outbreak study combined epidemiological and molecular analyses in order to elucidate tuberculosis transmission.

Whole-genome sequencing and epidemiological analysis of a tuberculosis outbreak in a high school of southern China.

Tuberculosis (TB) is a serious global public health threat, and school-clustered outbreaks are common. Here, we report a TB outbreak in a high school in southern China, which was confirmed and characterized by traditional epidemiological methods and whole-genome sequencing (WGS) of Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates. All students and faculty (n = 287) were screened by chest X-ray for active TB. TB was diagnosed in 28 patients, according to laboratory confirmation (n = 11) of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, sputum/bronchoalveolar fluid culture, smear, or TB-Xpert. Clinically diagnosed TB cases (n = 17) were further defined by the interferon-γ releasing assay or clinical and radiological findings. Twenty-five of the affected individuals were 12th grade students aged 16 to 19 years; among them, 24 patients were male and 21 had visited the internet café near the school. WGS and phylogenetics analysis confirmed that the outbreak was mainly caused by a super transmission strain of lineage 4.2, which was susceptible to all tested antibiotics. After a treatment regimen of 9 to12 months, all 28 patients were cured. This study highlights the key factors contributing to school-clustered TB outbreaks mainly derived from a single super transmission strain, along with effective interventional measures to prevent a larger scale outbreak.

A tuberculosis school outbreak in China, 2018: reaching an often overlooked adolescent population.

Adolescents have been largely neglected from tuberculosis control efforts. In low- to medium burden settings much of the tuberculosis burden in this age group occurs from school outbreaks. We report on a large tuberculosis outbreak in adolescents from a boarding high school in Jiangsu Province, China. From March to June 2018, a tuberculosis outbreak occurred in a boarding high school. We conducted an outbreak investigation involving clinical diagnostic tests and molecular analysis to determine the outbreak origin. Cases were detected through symptom screening, tuberculin skin testing (TST), chest radiography, sputum smear, solid sputum culture and GeneXpert MTB/RIF. Mycobacterial interspersed repetitive-unit-variable-number tandem-repeat (MIRU-VNTR) genotyping and spoligotyping methods were performed on Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M. tuberculosis) isolates to identify the outbreak origin. A total of 845 students and 131 teachers/staff attended a TST screening for tuberculosis infection. The prevalence of elevated tuberculin reactions at ≥5, ≥10 and ≥15 mm was 12.19% (119/976), 6.35% (62/976) and 3.28% (32/976), respectively. Radiographic abnormalities were present in 5.73% (56 of 976) individuals, 40 students and 16 teachers/staff. Of these, 12 students were diagnosed with confirmed tuberculosis. In total, 14 students (two index cases and 12 confirmed cases) were diagnosed and reported in the tuberculosis outbreak, an attack rate of 1.7% (14/847) among students (two index cases and 845 screened students). Results from MIRU-VNTR typing and spoligotyping analyses demonstrated that three M. tuberculosis strains belong to the Beijing family with corresponding MIRU-VNTR alleles. This school-based tuberculosis outbreak among adolescents demonstrates that transmission among individuals in this age group is common and must be prioritised. It suggests that identifying and timely diagnosis of smear-positive cases, especially in the early phase of outbreaks, is the key to preventing further spread among close contacts.

Tuberculosis outbreak investigation using phylodynamic analysis.

The fast evolution of pathogenic viruses has allowed for the development of phylodynamic approaches that extract information about the epidemiological characteristics of viral genomes. Thanks to advances in whole genome sequencing, they can be applied to slowly evolving bacterial pathogens like Mycobacterium tuberculosis. In this study, we investigate and compare the epidemiological dynamics underlying two M. tuberculosis outbreaks using phylodynamic methods. Specifically, we (i) test if the outbreak data sets contain enough genetic variation to estimate short-term evolutionary rates and (ii) reconstruct epidemiological parameters such as the effective reproduction number. The first outbreak occurred in the Swiss city of Bern (1987-2012) and was caused by a drug-susceptible strain belonging to the phylogenetic M. tuberculosis Lineage 4. The second outbreak was caused by a multidrug-resistant (MDR) strain of Lineage 2, imported from the Wat Tham Krabok (WTK) refugee camp in Thailand into California. There is little temporal signal in the Bern data set and moderate temporal signal in the WTK data set. Thanks to its high sampling proportion (90%) the Bern outbreak allows robust estimation of epidemiological parameters despite the poor temporal signal. Conversely, there is much uncertainty in the epidemiological estimates concerning the sparsely sampled (9%) WTK outbreak. Our results suggest that both outbreaks peaked around 1990, although they were only recognized as outbreaks in 1993 (Bern) and 2004 (WTK). Furthermore, individuals were infected for a significantly longer period (around 9 years) in the WTK outbreak than in the Bern outbreak (4-5 years). Our work highlights both the limitations and opportunities of phylodynamic analysis of outbreaks involving slowly evolving pathogens: (i) estimation of the evolutionary rate is difficult on outbreak time scales and (ii) a high sampling proportion allows quantification of the age of the outbreak based on the sampling times, and thus allows for robust estimation of epidemiological parameters.

Sharecropper's Tuberculosis: Pathologies of Power in a Fatal Outbreak.

Tuberculosis Bacilli (TB) is a global scourge that affects poor people and regions. Drawing on Farmer's (2003) pathologies of power, and a case study approach, we examine the sociostructural landscape of a fatal outbreak of Sharecropper's TB among African Americans in rural Alabama. In a mixed-method qualitative approach involving oral history, surveys, interviews and documentary analysis, we identified three pathologies that contribute to TB susceptibility: corporate power, land wealth, and structural racism. While medicine can cure non-resistant forms of TB, control of future outbreaks will depend upon a social "cure" such as addressing structural inequality and building community trust in the health system.