New Horizons of Synthetic Lethality in Cancer: Current Development and Future Perspectives.

In recent years, synthetic lethality has been recognized as a solid paradigm for anticancer therapies. The discovery of a growing number of synthetic lethal targets has led to a significant expansion in the use of synthetic lethality, far beyond poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitors used to treat BRCA1/2-defective tumors. In particular, molecular targets within DNA damage response have provided a source of inhibitors that have rapidly reached clinical trials. This Perspective focuses on the most recent progress in synthetic lethal targets and their inhibitors, within and beyond the DNA damage response, describing their design and associated therapeutic strategies. We will conclude by discussing the current challenges and new opportunities for this promising field of research, to stimulate discussion in the medicinal chemistry community, allowing the investigation of synthetic lethality to reach its full potential.

BRCAness, DNA gaps, and gain and loss of PARP inhibitor-induced synthetic lethality.

Mutations in the tumor-suppressor genes BRCA1 and BRCA2 resulting in BRCA1/2 deficiency are frequently identified in breast, ovarian, prostate, pancreatic, and other cancers. Poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) inhibitors (PARPis) selectively kill BRCA1/2-deficient cancer cells by inducing synthetic lethality, providing an effective biomarker-guided strategy for targeted cancer therapy. However, a substantial fraction of cancer patients carrying BRCA1/2 mutations do not respond to PARPis, and most patients develop resistance to PARPis over time, highlighting a major obstacle to PARPi therapy in the clinic. Recent studies have revealed that changes of specific functional defects of BRCA1/2-deficient cells, particularly their defects in suppressing and protecting single-stranded DNA gaps, contribute to the gain or loss of PARPi-induced synthetic lethality. These findings not only shed light on the mechanism of action of PARPis, but also lead to revised models that explain how PARPis selectively kill BRCA-deficient cancer cells. Furthermore, new mechanistic principles of PARPi sensitivity and resistance have emerged from these studies, generating potentially useful guidelines for predicting the PARPi response and design therapies for overcoming PARPi resistance. In this Review, we will discuss these recent studies and put them in context with the classic views of PARPi-induced synthetic lethality, aiming to stimulate the development of new therapeutic strategies to overcome PARPi resistance and improve PARPi therapy.

Synthetic lethal CRISPR screen identifies a cancer cell-intrinsic role of PD-L1 in regulation of vulnerability to ferroptosis.

Despite the success of programmed cell death 1 (PD-1)/programmed death ligand 1 (PD-L1) inhibition in tumor therapy, many patients do not benefit. This failure may be attributed to the intrinsic functions of PD-L1. We perform a genome-wide CRISPR synthetic lethality screen to systematically explore the intrinsic functions of PD-L1 in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) cells, identifying ferroptosis-related genes as essential for the viability of PD-L1-deficient cells. Genetic and pharmacological induction of ferroptosis accelerates cell death in PD-L1 knockout cells, which are also more susceptible to immunogenic ferroptosis. Mechanistically, nuclear PD-L1 transcriptionally activates SOD2 to maintain redox homeostasis. Lower reactive oxygen species (ROS) and ferroptosis are observed in patients with HNSCC who have higher PD-L1 expression. Our study illustrates that PD-L1 confers ferroptosis resistance in HNSCC cells by activating the SOD2-mediated antioxidant pathway, suggesting that targeting the intrinsic functions of PD-L1 could enhance therapeutic efficacy.

A Kinome-Wide Synthetic Lethal CRISPR/Cas9 Screen Reveals That mTOR Inhibition Prevents Adaptive Resistance to CDK4/CDK6 Blockade in HNSCC.

The comprehensive genomic analysis of the head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) oncogenome revealed the frequent loss of p16INK4A (CDKN2A) and amplification of cyclin D1 genes in most human papillomavirus-negative HNSCC lesions. However, cyclin-dependent kinase 4 and 6 (CDK4/6) inhibitors have shown modest effects in the clinic. The aberrant activation of the PI3K/mTOR pathway is highly prevalent in HNSCC, and recent clinical trials have shown promising clinical efficacy of mTOR inhibitors (mTORi) in the neoadjuvant and adjuvant settings but not in patients with advanced HNSCC. By implementing a kinome-wide CRISPR/Cas9 screen, we identified cell-cycle inhibition as a synthetic lethal target for mTORis. A combination of mTORi and palbociclib, a CDK4/6-specific inhibitor, showed strong synergism in HNSCC-derived cells in vitro and in vivo. Remarkably, we found that an adaptive increase in cyclin E1 (CCNE1) expression upon palbociclib treatment underlies the rapid acquired resistance to this CDK4/6 inhibitor. Mechanistically, mTORi inhibits the formation of eIF4G-CCNE1 mRNA complexes, with the consequent reduction in mRNA translation and CCNE1 protein expression. Our findings suggest that mTORi reverts the adaptive resistance to palbociclib. This provides a multimodal therapeutic option for HNSCC by cotargeting mTOR and CDK4/6, which in turn may halt the emergence of palbociclib resistance. SIGNIFICANCE: A kinome-wide CRISPR/Cas9 screen identified cell-cycle inhibition as a synthetic lethal target of mTORis. A combination of mTORi and palbociclib, a CDK4/6-specific inhibitor, showed strong synergistic effects in HNSCC. Mechanistically, mTORis inhibited palbociclib-induced increase in CCNE1.

Chemical genetic screens reveal defective lysosomal trafficking as synthetic lethal with NF1 loss.

Neurofibromatosis type 1, a genetic disorder caused by pathogenic germline variations in NF1, predisposes individuals to the development of tumors, including cutaneous and plexiform neurofibromas (CNs and PNs), optic gliomas, astrocytomas, juvenile myelomonocytic leukemia, high-grade gliomas and malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors (MPNSTs), which are chemotherapy- and radiation-resistant sarcomas with poor survival. Loss of NF1 also occurs in sporadic tumors, such as glioblastoma (GBM), melanoma, breast, ovarian and lung cancers. We performed a high-throughput screen for compounds that were synthetic lethal with NF1 loss, which identified several leads, including the small molecule Y102. Treatment of cells with Y102 perturbed autophagy, mitophagy and lysosome positioning in NF1-deficient cells. A dual proteomics approach identified BLOC-one-related complex (BORC), which is required for lysosome positioning and trafficking, as a potential target of Y102. Knockdown of a BORC subunit using siRNA recapitulated the phenotypes observed with Y102 treatment. Our findings demonstrate that BORC might be a promising therapeutic target for NF1-deficient tumors.

Methylation synthetic lethality: Exploiting selective drug targets for cancer therapy.

In cancer, synthetic lethality refers to the drug-induced inactivation of one gene and the inhibition of another in cancer cells by a drug, resulting in the death of only cancer cells; however, this effect is not present in normal cells, leading to targeted killing of cancer cells. Recent intensive epigenetic research has revealed that aberrant epigenetic changes are more frequently observed than gene mutations in certain cancers. Recently, numerous studies have reported various methylation synthetic lethal combinations involving DNA damage repair genes, metabolic pathway genes, and paralogs with significant results in cellular models, some of which have already entered clinical trials with promising results. This review systematically introduces the advantages of methylation synthetic lethality and describes the lethal mechanisms of methylation synthetic lethal combinations that have recently demonstrated success in cellular models. Furthermore, we discuss the future opportunities and challenges of methylation synthetic lethality in targeted anticancer therapies.

Synthetic lethality and the minimal genome size problem.

Gene knockout studies suggest that ~300 genes in a bacterial genome and ~1,100 genes in a yeast genome cannot be deleted without loss of viability. These single-gene knockout experiments do not account for negative genetic interactions, when two or more genes can each be deleted without effect, but their joint deletion is lethal. Thus, large-scale single-gene deletion studies underestimate the size of a minimal gene set compatible with cell survival. In yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the viability of all possible deletions of gene pairs (2-tuples), and of some deletions of gene triplets (3-tuples), has been experimentally tested. To estimate the size of a yeast minimal genome from that data, we first established that finding the size of a minimal gene set is equivalent to finding the minimum vertex cover in the lethality (hyper)graph, where the vertices are genes and (hyper)edges connect k-tuples of genes whose joint deletion is lethal. Using the Lovász-Johnson-Chvatal greedy approximation algorithm, we computed the minimum vertex cover of the synthetic-lethal 2-tuples graph to be 1,723 genes. We next simulated the genetic interactions in 3-tuples, extrapolating from the existing triplet sample, and again estimated minimum vertex covers. The size of a minimal gene set in yeast rapidly approaches the size of the entire genome even when considering only synthetic lethalities in k-tuples with small k. In contrast, several studies reported successful experimental reductions of yeast and bacterial genomes by simultaneous deletions of hundreds of genes, without eliciting synthetic lethality. We discuss possible reasons for this apparent contradiction.IMPORTANCEHow can we estimate the smallest number of genes sufficient for a unicellular organism to survive on a rich medium? One approach is to remove genes one at a time and count how many of such deletion strains are unable to grow. However, the single-gene knockout data are insufficient, because joint gene deletions may result in negative genetic interactions, also known as synthetic lethality. We used a technique from graph theory to estimate the size of minimal yeast genome from partial data on synthetic lethality. The number of potential synthetic lethal interactions grows very fast when multiple genes are deleted, revealing a paradoxical contrast with the experimental reductions of yeast genome by ~100 genes, and of bacterial genomes by several hundreds of genes.

Polymerase theta is a synthetic lethal target for killing Epstein-Barr virus lymphomas.

Treatment options for Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-cancers are limited, underscoring the need for new therapeutic approaches. We have previously shown that EBV-transformed cells and cancers lack homologous recombination (HR) repair, a prominent error-free pathway that repairs double-stranded DNA breaks; instead, EBV-transformed cells demonstrate genome-wide scars of the error-prone microhomology-mediated end joining (MMEJ) repair pathway. This suggests that EBV-cancers are vulnerable to synthetic lethal therapeutic approaches that target MMEJ repair. Indeed, we have previously found that targeting PARP, an enzyme that contributes to MMEJ, results in the death of EBV-lymphoma cells. With the emergence of clinical resistance to PARP inhibitors and the recent discovery of inhibitors of Polymerase theta (POLθ), the polymerase essential for MMEJ, we investigated the role of POLθ in EBV-lymphoma cells. We report that EBV-transformed cell lines, EBV-lymphoma cell lines, and EBV-lymphomas in AIDS patients demonstrate greater abundance of POLθ, driven by the EBV protein EBNA1, compared to EBV-uninfected primary lymphocytes and EBV-negative lymphomas from AIDS patients (a group that also abundantly expresses POLθ). We also find POLθ enriched at cellular DNA replication forks and exposure to the POLθ inhibitor Novobiocin impedes replication fork progress, impairs MMEJ-mediated repair of DNA double-stranded breaks, and kills EBV-lymphoma cells. Notably, cell killing is not due to Novobiocin-induced activation of the lytic/replicative phase of EBV. These findings support a role for POLθ not just in DNA repair but also DNA replication and as a therapeutic target in EBV-lymphomas and potentially other EBV-cancers as EBNA1 is expressed in all EBV-cancers.IMPORTANCEEpstein-Barr virus (EBV) contributes to ~2% of the global cancer burden. With a recent estimate of >200,000 deaths a year, identifying molecular vulnerabilities will be key to the management of these frequently aggressive and treatment-resistant cancers. Building on our earlier work demonstrating reliance of EBV-cancers on microhomology-mediated end-joining repair, we now report that EBV lymphomas and transformed B cell lines abundantly express the MMEJ enzyme POLθ that likely protects cellular replication forks and repairs replication-related cellular DNA breaks. Importantly also, we show that a newly identified POLθ inhibitor kills EBV-cancer cells, revealing a novel strategy to block DNA replication and repair of these aggressive cancers.

Mitoferrin2 is a synthetic lethal target for chromosome 8p deleted cancers.

BACKGROUND: Somatic copy number alterations are a hallmark of cancer that offer unique opportunities for therapeutic exploitation. Here, we focused on the identification of specific vulnerabilities for tumors harboring chromosome 8p deletions. METHODS: We developed and applied an integrative analysis of The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA), the Cancer Dependency Map (DepMap), and the Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia to identify chromosome 8p-specific vulnerabilities. We employ orthogonal gene targeting strategies, both in vitro and in vivo, including short hairpin RNA-mediated gene knockdown and CRISPR/Cas9-mediated gene knockout to validate vulnerabilities. RESULTS: We identified SLC25A28 (also known as MFRN2), as a specific vulnerability for tumors harboring chromosome 8p deletions. We demonstrate that vulnerability towards MFRN2 loss is dictated by the expression of its paralog, SLC25A37 (also known as MFRN1), which resides on chromosome 8p. In line with their function as mitochondrial iron transporters, MFRN1/2 paralog protein deficiency profoundly impaired mitochondrial respiration, induced global depletion of iron-sulfur cluster proteins, and resulted in DNA-damage and cell death. MFRN2 depletion in MFRN1-deficient tumors led to impaired growth and even tumor eradication in preclinical mouse xenograft experiments, highlighting its therapeutic potential. CONCLUSIONS: Our data reveal MFRN2 as a therapeutic target of chromosome 8p deleted cancers and nominate MFNR1 as the complimentary biomarker for MFRN2-directed therapies.

G6PD and ACSL3 are synthetic lethal partners of NF2 in Schwann cells.

Neurofibromatosis Type II (NFII) is a genetic condition caused by loss of the NF2 gene, resulting in activation of the YAP/TAZ pathway and recurrent Schwann cell tumors, as well as meningiomas and ependymomas. Unfortunately, few pharmacological options are available for NFII. Here, we undertake a genome-wide CRISPR/Cas9 screen to search for synthetic-lethal genes that, when inhibited, cause death of NF2 mutant Schwann cells but not NF2 wildtype cells. We identify ACSL3 and G6PD as two synthetic-lethal partners for NF2, both involved in lipid biogenesis and cellular redox. We find that NF2 mutant Schwann cells are more oxidized than control cells, in part due to reduced expression of genes involved in NADPH generation such as ME1. Since G6PD and ME1 redundantly generate cytosolic NADPH, lack of either one is compatible with cell viability, but not down-regulation of both. Since genetic deficiency for G6PD is tolerated in the human population, G6PD could be a good pharmacological target for NFII.

SOD1 is a synthetic-lethal target in PPM1D-mutant leukemia cells.

The DNA damage response is critical for maintaining genome integrity and is commonly disrupted in the development of cancer. PPM1D (protein phosphatase Mg2+/Mn2+-dependent 1D) is a master negative regulator of the response; gain-of-function mutations and amplifications of PPM1D are found across several human cancers making it a relevant pharmacological target. Here, we used CRISPR/Cas9 screening to identify synthetic-lethal dependencies of PPM1D, uncovering superoxide dismutase-1 (SOD1) as a potential target for PPM1D-mutant cells. We revealed a dysregulated redox landscape characterized by elevated levels of reactive oxygen species and a compromised response to oxidative stress in PPM1D-mutant cells. Altogether, our results demonstrate a role for SOD1 in the survival of PPM1D-mutant leukemia cells and highlight a new potential therapeutic strategy against PPM1D-mutant cancers.

Targeting AURKA to induce synthetic lethality in CREBBP-deficient B-cell malignancies via attenuation of MYC expression.

Loss-of-function mutations in CREBBP, which encodes for a histone acetyltransferase, occur frequently in B-cell malignancies, highlighting CREBBP deficiency as an attractive therapeutic target. Using established isogenic cell models, we demonstrated that CREBBP-deficient cells are selectively vulnerable to AURKA inhibition. Mechanistically, we found that co-targeting CREBBP and AURKA suppressed MYC transcriptionally and post-translationally to induce replication stress and apoptosis. Inhibition of AURKA dramatically decreased MYC protein level in CREBBP-deficient cells, implying a dependency on AURKA to sustain MYC stability. Furthermore, in vivo studies showed that pharmacological inhibition of AURKA was efficacious in delaying tumor progression in CREBBP-deficient cells and was synergistic with CREBBP inhibitors in CREBBP-proficient cells. Our study sheds light on a novel synthetic lethal interaction between CREBBP and AURKA, indicating that targeting AURKA represents a potential therapeutic strategy for high-risk B-cell malignancies harboring CREBBP inactivating mutations.

A synthetic lethal dependency on casein kinase 2 in response to replication-perturbing therapeutics in RB1-deficient cancer cells.

Resistance to therapy commonly develops in patients with high-grade serous ovarian carcinoma (HGSC) and triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC), urging the search for improved therapeutic combinations and their predictive biomarkers. Starting from a CRISPR knockout screen, we identified that loss of RB1 in TNBC or HGSC cells generates a synthetic lethal dependency on casein kinase 2 (CK2) for surviving the treatment with replication-perturbing therapeutics such as carboplatin, gemcitabine, or PARP inhibitors. CK2 inhibition in RB1-deficient cells resulted in the degradation of another RB family cell cycle regulator, p130, which led to S phase accumulation, micronuclei formation, and accelerated PARP inhibition-induced aneuploidy and mitotic cell death. CK2 inhibition was also effective in primary patient-derived cells. It selectively prevented the regrowth of RB1-deficient patient HGSC organoids after treatment with carboplatin or niraparib. As about 25% of HGSCs and 40% of TNBCs have lost RB1 expression, CK2 inhibition is a promising approach to overcome resistance to standard therapeutics in large strata of patients.

Synthetic lethality: targeting the SMARCA2 bromodomain for degradation in SMARCA4-deficient tumors - a review of patent literature from 2019-June 2023.

INTRODUCTION: SMARCA2 and SMARCA4 are subunits of the SWI/SNF complex which is a chromatin remodeling complex and a key epigenetic regulator that facilitates gene expression. Tumors with loss of function mutations in SMARCA4 rely on SMARCA2 for cell survival and this synthetic lethality is a potential therapeutic strategy to treat cancer. AREAS COVERED: The current review focuses on patent applications that claim proteolysis-targeting chimeras (PROTAC) degraders that bind the bromodomain site of SMARCA2 and are published between January 2019-June 2023. A total of 29 applications from 9 different applicants were evaluated. EXPERT OPINION: SMARCA2/4 bromodomain inhibitors do not lead to desired effects on cancer proliferation; however, companies have converted bromodomain binders into PROTACs to degrade the protein, with a preference for SMARCA2 over SMARCA4. Selective degradation of SMARCA2 is most likely required to be efficacious in the SMARCA4-deficient setting, while allowing for sufficient safety margin in normal tissues. With several patent applications disclosed recently, interest in targeting SMARCA2 should continue, especially with a selective SMARCA2 PROTAC now in the clinic from Prelude Therapeutics. The outcome of the clinical trials will influence the evolution of selective SMARCA2 PROTACs development.

PARP inhibition leads to synthetic lethality with key splicing-factor mutations in myelodysplastic syndromes.

BACKGROUND: Splicing factors are frequently mutated in patients with myelodysplastic syndromes and acute myeloid leukaemia. Recent studies have revealed convergent molecular defects caused by splicing factor mutations, among which R-loop dysregulation and resultant genome instability are suggested as contributing factors to disease progression. On the other hand, understanding how mutant cells survive upon aberrant R-loop formation and genome instability is essential for developing novel therapeutics. METHODS: The immunoprecipitation was performed to identify R-loops in association with PARP1/poly-ADP-ribosylation. The western blot, immunofluorescence, and flow cytometry assays were used to test the cell viability, cell cycle arrest, apoptosis, and ATM activation in mutant cells following the treatment of the PARP inhibitor. The Srsf2(P95H) knock-in murine hematopoietic cells and MLL-AF9 transformed leukaemia model were generated to investigate the potential of the PARP inhibitor as a therapy for haematological malignancies. RESULTS: The disease-causing mutations in SRSF2 activate PARP and elevate the overall poly-ADP-ribosylation levels of proteins in response to R-loop dysregulation. In accordance, mutant cells are more vulnerable to the PARP inhibitors in comparison to the wild-type counterpart. Notably, the synthetic lethality was further validated in the Srsf2(P95H) knock-in murine hematopoietic cell and MLL-AF9 leukaemia model. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that mutant cells antagonise the genome threat caused by R-loop disruption by PARP activation, thus making PARP targeting a promising therapeutic strategy for myeloid cancers with mutations in SRSF2.

Discovery of a Meisoindigo-Derived PROTAC as the ATM Degrader: Revolutionizing Colorectal Cancer Therapy via Synthetic Lethality with ATR Inhibitors.

Meisoindigo (Mei) has long been recognized in chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) treatment. To elucidate its molecular target and mechanisms, we embarked on designing and synthesizing a series of Mei-derived PROTACs. Through this endeavor, VHL-type PROTAC 9b was identified to be highly cytotoxic against SW620, SW480, and K562 cells. Employing DiaPASEF-based quantitative proteomic analysis, in combination with extensive validation assays, we unveiled that 9b potently and selectively degraded ATM across SW620 and SW480 cells in a ubiquitin-proteasome-dependent manner. 9b-induced selective ATM degradation prompted DNA damage response cascades, thereby leading to the cell cycle arrest and cell apoptosis. This pioneering discovery renders the advent of ATM degradation for anti-cancer therapy. Notably, 9b-induced ATM degradation synergistically enhanced the efficacy of ATR inhibitor AZD6738 both in vitro and in vivo. This work establishes the synthetic lethality-inducing properties of ATR inhibitors in the ATM-deficient context, thereby providing new avenues to innovative therapies for colorectal cancer.

Synthetic Lethality between Cohesin and WNT Signaling Pathways in Diverse Cancer Contexts.

Cohesin is a highly conserved ring-shaped complex involved in topologically embracing chromatids, gene expression regulation, genome compartmentalization, and genome stability maintenance. Genomic analyses have detected mutations in the cohesin complex in a wide array of human tumors. These findings have led to increased interest in cohesin as a potential target in cancer therapy. Synthetic lethality has been suggested as an approach to exploit genetic differences in cancer cells to influence their selective killing. In this study, we show that mutations in ESCO1, NIPBL, PDS5B, RAD21, SMC1A, SMC3, STAG2, and WAPL genes are synthetically lethal with stimulation of WNT signaling obtained following LY2090314 treatment, a GSK3 inhibitor, in several cancer cell lines. Moreover, treatment led to the stabilization of ß-catenin and affected the expression of c-MYC, probably due to the occupancy decrease in cohesin at the c-MYC promoter. Finally, LY2090314 caused gene expression dysregulation mainly involving pathways related to transcription regulation, cell proliferation, and chromatin remodeling. For the first time, our work provides the underlying molecular basis for synthetic lethality due to cohesin mutations and suggests that targeting the WNT may be a promising therapeutic approach for tumors carrying mutated cohesin.