Objective and subjective consequences of pandemic-related study program changes for the perception of the practical year - a comparison of medical students in Germany with and without a second national board examination.

Background: Due to SARS-CoV-2, the Bavarian Ministry of Health decided in April 2020 to postpone the second national board examination in human medicine and to bring forward the start of the practical year (in German: Praktisches Jahr, further abbreviated with PJ) from May to April 2020. The different tertial times made it necessary for affected students to reorganise the PJ and rendered the preparation for the national board examination that had already taken place obsolete. As a result, students had to prepare for it again after the PJ and take it together with the third national board examination. Research question: How do students affected by the early PJ differ in their perception of the practical year and in their psychological well-being from the comparison groups with a regular PJ schedule? Methodology: The study is based on quantitative data from the Dean of Studies Office of the Medical Faculty of Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München (LMU) and an online survey. The sample consists of LMU students who started the early PJ in April 2020 (n=86) and two comparison groups: The cohort of LMU students who started their PJ regularly in May 2019 (n=50), and students from other German universities who started their PJ regularly in May 2020 (n=98) and took the second national board examination in human medicine in spring 2020. Results: For students affected by the early PJ, there were measurable negative effects on the choice of training institutions, the quality of the PJ content, preparation for the national board examinations, and career planning. Compared to regular students from other federal states, affected students reported higher psychological stress, with comparable resilience. Conclusion: It can be assumed that the insights gained apply to the entirety of medical students in the affected federal states of Bavaria and Baden-Württemberg. As a conclusion, we make the recommendation to include the position of the students in decisions of great consequence.

Predictors of College Academic Achievement for Medical Students: The Case of Gondar University, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, Ethiopia.

Background: In Ethiopia, the University Entrance Exam (UEE) score is the only criteria for selecting prospective medical students entering the university system, disregarding their career choice motivation. Methods: A cross-sectional study design was conducted to identify medical students career choice motivation and predictors of college academic achievement at Gondar university, Ethiopia. The study was conducted on 222 medical students enrolled at Gondar University in 2016. A self-administered questionnaire was used to collect data on study participants demographic characteristics, career choice motivation, and informed career choice. Data on the UEE score and student's college academic achievement were collected from the university registrar. Descriptive statistics and regression analysis were used to analyze the data. Results: Desire to help others as a medical doctor and prevent and cure diseases were mentioned as the first important career choice reasons by 147 (68.2%) and 135 (64.0%) study participants, respectively. The results of regression analysis showed that the UEE score was significantly associated with pre-clinical cumulative GPA (R2=.327, p<.05) and 5th year cumulative GPA (R2=.244, p<.05) respectively. The stepwise multiple regression revealed that UEE score, having prior knowledge about medical profession, positive experience in the medical school, and intrinsic career choice motivation significantly predicted 5th year cumulative GPA (p<.05). The high beta weight of 0.254 and 0.202 confirmed the strongest prediction to come from prior knowledge about the medical profession and positive experience in medical school, respectively. Conclusion and Recommendation: The UEE score is a significant predictor for medical students' academic achievement, but it should not be the sole admission criterion. We suggest that comprehensive admissions criteria covering both cognitive and non-cognitive factors, as well as informed career choice, be developed to select the best applicants in the future.

Differences in perceptions of capability, autonomy, and expectations between residents and surgical team members in executing EPAs in Ethiopian medical education.

Background: Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) are units of professional practice that are defined as tasks or responsibilities that are entrusted to an unsupervised execution by a trainee. In 2021, a framework of 29 EPAs was developed for surgical residency training programs in Ethiopia, with the goal of residents being able to perform independently by the time they graduate. However, studies show that surgical residents lack confidence and are unable to execute EPAs autonomously upon graduation, and concerns have been raised about graduate competencies in EPA execution. The goal of this research is to assess how surgical team members judge/perceive residents' performance in executing these EPAs autonomously at the time of graduation and how residents rate their own capability and autonomy in executing EPAs in order to systematically introduce and implement EPAs in Ethiopian medical education. Methods: A survey was conducted in the Departments of Surgery at four residency training institutions in Ethiopia. All eligible surgical team members and final-year general surgery residents were invited to participate. Surgical team members were asked to rate the observed performance of a group of graduating surgical residents in each of the 29 EPAs, and residents were asked to rate their own capability in executing EPAs. The analysis focused on variations in performance ratings between surgical team members and residents, as well as across surgical team members. Results: A total of 125 surgical team members and 49 residents participated in this study. Residents rate their competence in performing these EPAs higher than surgical team members, mean 4.2 (SD = 0.63) vs. 3.7 (SD = 0.9). A statistically significant difference in perceptions of capability, autonomy, and expectations in executing EPAs was observed between the two groups of study (p = 0.03, CI: 0.51-0.95), as well as within surgical team members (p < 0.001). Conclusions: Differences in perceptions of capability, autonomy, and expectations between residents and surgical team members, as well as within faculty members, were seen in executing EPAs. There were concerns about graduate surgical residents' competence to execute EPAs autonomously at the time of graduation. Surgical team members perceived that a set of graduating surgical residents are not yet safe to perform these EPAs independently (without supervision) and still requires distant supervision.

Effects of tablet-based drawing and paper-based methods on medical students' learning of gross anatomy.

The way medical students learn anatomy is constantly evolving. Nowadays, technologies such as tablets support established learning methods like drawing. In this study, the effect of drawing on a tablet on medical students' anatomy learning was investigated compared to drawing or summarizing on paper. The quality of drawings or summaries was assessed as a measure of the quality of strategy implementation. Learning outcome was measured with an anatomy test, both immediately afterward and after 4-6 weeks to assess its sustainability. There were no significant group differences in learning outcome at both measurement points. For all groups, there was a significant medium strength correlation between the quality of the drawings or summaries and the learning outcome (p < 0.05). Further analysis revealed that the quality of strategy implementation moderated outcomes in the delayed test: When poorly implemented, drawing on a tablet (M = 48.81) was associated with lower learning outcome than drawing on paper (M = 58.95); The latter (M = 58.89) was related to higher learning outcome than writing summaries (M = 45.59). In case of high-quality strategy implementation, drawing on a tablet (M = 60.98) outperformed drawing on paper (M = 52.67), which in turn was outperformed by writing summaries (M = 62.62). To conclude, drawing on a tablet serves as a viable alternative to paper-based methods for learning anatomy if students can make adequate use of this strategy. Future research needs to identify how to support student drawing, for instance, by offering scaffolds with adaptive feedback to enhance learning.

[Project report on fostering scientific competencies in pain medicine in the context of student education]. / Projektbericht zur Förderung wissenschaftlicher Kompetenzen im Fach Schmerzmedizin im Rahmen der curricularen Lehre.

AIM: The training of scientific skills and competencies is an essential part of academic medical studies. As part of the MaReCuM model study program at Heidelberg University's Mannheim Medical School, a fifth-year rotation on scientific skills in the field of pain medicine was implemented. This paper describes this competence-oriented rotation as well as the investigation of the educational effect. METHOD: A total of 114 fifth-year medical students participated in the survey (response rate: 83%). The control group completed the fifth year prior to the implementation of the rotation. The experimental group was required to participate in the rotation and the real healthcare research study "Case management program: low back pain". A survey of both groups was conducted on the first day of the rotation and at the end of the module. RESULTS: The innovative and competency-based learning unit was successfully implemented as part of the MaReCuM model study program and carried out with partners in general practice as well as the Mannheim Institute of Public Health. The participating students accepted the rotation well. There was no measurable effect on the subjective learning success of the rotation in the evaluation. DISCUSSION: To the authors' knowledge, this educational approach has never been tested before in a German study program. The presented rotation offers an additional option for the training of scientific competencies as part of medical studies. The missing of a measurable effect could be due to the extensive experience of the medical students as well as the limitations on participation in a real healthcare study. An additional learning opportunity could be created by connecting the preexisting lectures to a longitudinal module on scholarly competencies. The implementation of the program also offers a unique opportunity for educational research on the acquisition of scientific competencies in medical students.

Development of an Entrustable Professional Activities (EPA) Framework to Inform Surgical Residency Training Programs in Ethiopia: A Three-round National Delphi Method Study.

BACKGROUND: Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) have been proposed as a means to translate competencies into clinical practice. Although EPAs for residency training have become available, 1 set of core EPAs cannot automatically be transferred from one context to another due to cultural variability. Further, there is a lack of African- and Asian-based EPA development and implementation studies. We developed an end-of-training EPAs framework to inform surgical residency training programs in the local context of Ethiopian medical education. METHODS: A three-round Delphi method was used to establish consensus about important surgical EPAs among experts. A total of 136 experts representing all surgical residency training institutions in Ethiopia were invited to participate. Round 1 & 2 consisted of senior expert panelists (n = 8) to identify potential EPAs and determine the content validity. Round 3 consisted of a survey (n = 128) to further validate the identified EPAs by attending surgeons who work with them. Each EPA had to achieve at least 80% or higher agreement among experts to be considered having acceptable content validity. RESULTS: In round 1, a total of 272 EPAs were proposed, reduced, and grouped to 39 consented EPAs. In round 2, the same experts rated each EPA's relevance, resulting in 32 EPAs with a satisfactory item-level content validity index (I-CVI > 0.83). Overall, in the survey in round 3, 29 EPAs met the standard criterion for acceptability (S-CVI/Ave = 0.90) and achieved a high degree of final consensus (ICC = 0.998, 95% CI [0.996, 0.999]; (F = 439.2, p < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: The framework of 29 validated and accepted EPAs can guide future surgical residency training programs in the Ethiopian medical education context. The framework allows programs to move from a time-dependent to an outcome-based model and transforms traditional assessment into entrustment decisions. Thus, the use of the framework can improve the quality of training and patient care in Ehtiopia.

Childhood Stroke: Long-Term Outcomes and Health-Related Quality of Life with a Special Focus on the Development of Epilepsy.

BACKGROUND: Childhood stroke is rare and can predispose to post-stroke epilepsy. The purpose of this study was to evaluate long-term quality of life (QoL) in patients with childhood stroke, focusing on epileptic aspects. METHOD: This involves a retrospective study of 98 patients with childhood stroke (pre- and neonatal strokes excluded), who had been inpatients between 1986 and 2003 for early rehabilitation. Data were obtained via interviews using a standardized questionnaire: QoL evaluation with KINDL, functional outcome with Barthel Index, and motor handicaps-assessment with modified Rankin Score. RESULTS: Forty-nine of 98 patients (31 males, mean follow-up 16 years, range 8-25 years) were included. Six patients passed away (three of sudden unexpected death in epilepsy). At least one epileptic seizure occurred in 27/49 patients (occurrence: 2 days-13 years.; mean 3.3 years.). Epilepsy manifested in 19/49 patients. No correlation was found between the development of epilepsy and the location or etiology of the stroke. The presence of functional independence was significantly higher in seizure-free patients and in patients without epilepsy. For the external assessment (filled in for the patient by the parent/caregiver), there was no significant difference in QoL in patients with and without epilepsy; however, in the in-person KINDL questionnaire a significantly lower QoL was noted in epilepsy patients compared with patients without epilepsy. CONCLUSION: One important finding in our study is that in the long-term course 39% of patients developed epilepsy after a childhood stroke. It occurred as late as 13 years after the acute episode and affected the QoL especially in cognitively less handicapped patients.

Statistical literacy and scientific reasoning & argumentation in physicians.

Objective: Statistical literacy (SL) of physicians, i.e. the ability to use and interpret statistical numbers in the context of science, is an essential prerequisite for risk estimation and communication. Together with scientific reasoning and argumentation (SRA) skills, SL provides the basis for evidence-based practice. Several studies suggest that in medical students both skills are underdeveloped. The aim of the present study was to investigate these skills in practicing physicians and how these skills were acquired. Methods: Data collection in N=71 physicians was conducted online and as paper pencil. SL was assessed with multiple-choice items. SRA skills evidence evaluation and drawing conclusions were measured with a decision scenario. Results: Study results indicated that physicians have medium levels of SL (M=17.58, SD=6.92, max 30 pts.) and SRA (evidence evaluation: M=7.75, SD=1.85, max 10 pts.; drawing conclusions: M=37.20, SD=5.35, max 60 pts.). Skills development via autodidactic learning activities (M=4.78, SD=1.13, range 1-6) was reported significantly more often than development during formal medical education (M=2.31, SD=1.46), t(71)=-9.915, p<.001, or in extracurricular activities (M=3.34, SD=1.87), t(71)=4.673, p<.001. The active involvement in research seemed decisive: The number of publications and time spent in research significantly correlated with SL, r(71)=.355, p=.002; respectively r(71)=.280, p=.018. SRA skills were predicted by the type of MD-thesis, ß=-.380, p=.016, and working in research, ß=3.355, p=.008. Conclusion: Active involvement in research activities seems to be a very important factor for the development of both SL and SRA skills. The implementation of systematic fostering of these skills during formal medical education seems warranted.

The influence of prompts on final year medical students' learning process and achievement in ECG interpretation.

Objective: ECG interpretation is prone to errors that can lead to relevant misdiagnoses and incorrect treatment. Prompts are one way in lectures to encourage learning from one's own mistakes and to reduce error rates. Prompts are measures such as questions, hints, and suggestions of content-related or metacognitive nature, which can lead to self-explanation in the learner and thus to a deeper understanding of an issue. The aim of the study was therefore to investigate whether the use of prompts can reduce the error rate in ECG interpretation among students. Method: In a 2x2 experimental test and control group design, N=100 final year medical students carried out ECG interpretation tasks in the form of online case vignettes in CASUS®. In these tasks, justification prompts (B) and error analysis prompts (F) were systematically varied in four groups and the learning success was measured using a knowledge test. In addition, prior knowledge in ECG interpretation, motivation, interest in the topic, subjective confidence in ECG interpretation, and cognitive load was collected. Results: Neither error analysis prompts nor justification prompts had a significant effect on the correct ECG interpretation by students, F(1,96)=1.03, p=.31. Justification prompts seemed to have a positive effect on the confidence of answering the questions, F(1,96)=10.15, p=.002, partial η2 =.10; and a negative effect on student motivation, F(1,96)=8.13 , p=.005, partial η2 =.08; but both with comparable diagnostic accuracy. Conclusion: The present study could not confirm the positive effects of prompts on the error rate in ECG interpretation reported in the literature but showed significant effects on subjective confidence and motivation which should be investigated in further studies.

[Quality of findings, interpretation, and self-assessment of readers of chest x-rays acquired in one plane depending on the use of an anatomical viewing scheme and reader expertise]. / Qualität von Befunderstellung, Beurteilung und Selbsteinschätzung bei der Auswertung von Radiographien des Thorax in einer Ebene in Abhängigkeit von der Verwendung eines anatomischen Betrachtungsschemas und der Auswerterexpertise.

PURPOSE: To objectify effects of an anatomical viewing scheme on the respective correctness of (a) findings, (b) interpretations, and (c) self-assessments of readers in chest radiographs acquired in one plane and the assessment of other influencing factors. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In all, 20 radiologists with 3-60 months of full-time radiography experience evaluated 12 chest radiographs of varying difficulty: once with and once without using an anatomical viewing scheme with at least 1 month in between (n = 480). In consensus of 3 radiological experts (a) and (b) were determined by means of a current computed tomography. The self-assessment (c) of readers was queried. RESULTS: (a) Findings were either missed or not described in 21%. Another 20% were recognized, but incorrectly described, (b) 62% of interpretations and 31% of derived clinical consequences were wrong and (c) in 39% of items the readers overestimated themselves. Experts were faster and better than novices, but for the scheme usage no further significant differences were detected (p > 0.5, respectively). The most pronounced effect was found in comparison with the routine report produced by the joint evaluation of novices and experts being clearly superior even to the expert study results (a), (b) and (c) alone (p < 0.001, respectively). CONCLUSION: Reporting of chest X­rays acquired in one plane was often incomplete or even wrong, and the evaluators overestimated themselves, which was not influenced by the use of the anatomical viewing scheme. Since errors between the evaluators sometimes differed greatly, duplicate evaluation of the radiographs by two different radiologists, which is already the case in many training facilities, may possibly be advisable in general.

The role of electronic health records in clinical reasoning.

Electronic health records (eHRs) play an increasingly important role in documentation and exchange of information in multi-and interdisciplinary patient care. Although eHRs are associated with mixed evidence in terms of effectiveness, they are undeniably the health record form of the future. This poses several learning opportunities and challenges for medical education. This review aims to connect the concept of eHRs to key competencies of physicians and elaborates current learning science perspectives on diagnostic and clinical reasoning based on a theoretical framework of scientific reasoning and argumentation. It concludes with an integrative vision of the use of eHRs, and the special role of the patient, for teaching and learning in medicine.