ABSTRACT
Objective:To investigate the reliability and repeatability of 3 classification systems for coronal fractures of distal humerus.Methods:Included were the imaging data (X-ray and CT scan) of the 64 patients with distal humeral coronal fracture who had been admitted to the outpatient and emergency departments of Beijing Jishuitan Hospital from January, 2015 to December, 2021. Four orthopedic surgeons (1 chief surgeon, 1 associate chief surgeon, 1 attending surgeon, and 1 resident surgeon) served as observers who classified the fractures by their imaging data respectively according to the Bryan-Morrey, Ring and Dubberley classifications. Four weeks later when the imaging data of 64 patients were renumbered, the 4 orthopedic surgeons performed the same classifications again. Inter-observer and intra-observer Kappa values were calculated for the 3 classifications. Landis and Koch Kappa's Benchmark Scale was used to interpret the results.Results:Interobserver confidence: The average agreement of the Bryan-Morrey classification was 75.0%, and its Kappa value was 0.546, indicating moderate agreement. The average consistency of Ring classification was 74.7%, and its Kappa value was 0.702, indicating high consistency. The average consistency of Dubberley classification was 84.1%, and its Kappa value was 0.785, indicating high consistency. Intra-observer repeatability: The average consistency of Bryan-Morrey classification was 89.9% and its Kappa value was 0.824 for the same observer. The average consistency of Ring classification was 91.0%, and its Kappa value was 0.884. The average consistency of Dubberley classification was 91.8%, and its Kappa value was 0.888.Conclusions:The 3 classification systems for distal humeral coronal fractures all demonstrate high reproducibility. As the Dubberley classification system is relatively more reliable, it has a certain guiding value for the treatment of coronal fractures of the distal humerus. However, in clinical practice, an optimal surgical strategy should take into account various factors that may affect fracture typing.
ABSTRACT
Objective:To compare the outcomes of isolated Mason type Ⅱ radial head fracture between operative and non-operative treatments.Methods:A retrospective study was conducted to analyze the data of patients who had been treated for isolated Mason type Ⅱ radial head fracture either operatively or nonoperatively at Department of Trauma and Orthopaedics, Beijing Jishuitan Hospital, Capital Medical University from January 2017 to October 2020. The patients were divided into a non-operative group and an operative group according to their treatment method. After 1:1 propensity score matching method was used to match the patients in the 2 groups, a total of 58 pairs of patients were successfully matched. In the operative group, there were 24 males and 34 females with a mean age of (40±14) years and a body mass index of (23.7±3.4) kg/m 2; in the non-operative group, there were 22 males and 36 females with a mean age of (42±13) years and a body mass index of (23.5±3.9) kg/m 2. Elbow flexion-extension, forearm rotation, Mayo elbow performance score (MEPS), Quick-disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand (q-DASH) score and complications were compared between the 2 groups. Results:There was no significant difference in the baseline data between the 2 groups, indicating comparability ( P>0.05). All the patients were followed up for (24±9) months. At the last follow up in the operative and the non-operative groups, respectively, the elbow flexion-extension was 134° (132°, 136°) and 134°(131°, 136°), the forearm rotation 176° (174°, 179°) and 178° (175°, 179°), the MEPS 100 (100, 100) and 100 (100, 100), the q-DASH score 0 (0, 0) and 0 (0, 0), showing no significant differences between the 2 groups in the above items ( P>0.05). Elbow pain was reported respectively in 4 (6.9%) and 6 (10.3%) patients in the operative and non-operative groups, showing no significant difference between the 2 groups ( P>0.05). Conclusion:The outcomes of operative and non-operative treatments of isolated Mason type Ⅱ radial head fracture are comparable.
ABSTRACT
Objective:To explore the characteristics and clinical values of preoperative imaging signs and intraoperative stress test in the surgery of the Weber type B fracture without medial malleolar fracture.Methods:The data of 52 patients were reviewed who had been treated at Orthopaedic Trauma Department, Beijing Jishuitan Hospital for Weber type B ankle fracture without medial malleolar fracture from January 2018 to December 2021.They were assigned into 2 groups depending on their results of intraoperative stress test. In the positive group of 21 cases showing a positive intraoperative stress test, there were 19 males and 2 females with an age of (34.4±10.2) years; in the negative group of 31 cases showing a negative intra operative stress test, there were 22 males and 9 females with an age of (39.5±14.8) years. The 2 groups were compared in terms of the medial clear space, tibiofibular clear space and vertical length of the fibular fracture on the preoperative X-ray film, as well as the relative size of the posterior malleolar fracture fragment on the preoperative CT. The imaging characteristics of intraoperative stress tests were also observed.Results:There was no significant difference between the 2 groups in the preoperative general data, showing comparability between groups ( P>0.05). The medial clear space (7.2±2.5) mm and the vertical length of the fibular fracture [49.2 (33.7, 58.7) mm] in the positive group were significantly larger than those in the negative group [(4.5±1.7) mm and 29.6 (24.7, 36.0) mm] ( P<0.05). There was no significant difference between the 2 groups in the lower tibiofibular space [(6.0±1.9) mm versus (5.2 ± 1.4) mm] or in the relative size of posterior malleolar fracture measured by CT [15.8% (6.9%, 19.1%) versus 12.7% (0%, 18.9%)] ( P>0.05). The intraoperative stress test imaging data of a total of 22 cases were collected from the 2 groups (11 cases from each of the 2 groups). During the stress test, only the medial clear space was widened with no widening of the inferior tibiofibular space was found in 7 cases (5 cases in the positive group and 2 cases in the negative group). Conclusions:A routine stress test is recommended for Weber B ankle fracture without medial malleolus fracture, because instability sometimes exists after fibular fixation. Patients with a wider medial clear space and a longer fibular fracture line on X-ray after injury are more likely to be afflicted by instability after fibular fixation. In the patients with a widened medial clear space but without a widened inferior tibiofibular clear space during an intraoperative stress test, it calls for further study whether it is necessary to fix the inferior tibiofibular joint.