A role for initiation codon context in chloroplast translation.

To study the role of initiation codon context in chloroplast protein synthesis, we mutated the three nucleotides immediately upstream of the initiation codon (the -1 triplet) of two chloroplast genes in the alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. In prokaryotes, the -1 triplet has been proposed to base pair with either the 530 loop of 16S rRNA or the extended anticodon of fMet-tRNA. We found that in vivo, none of the chloroplast mutations affected mRNA stability. However, certain mutations did cause a temperature-sensitive decrease in translation and a more dramatic decrease at room temperature when combined with an AUU initiation codon. These mutations disrupt the proposed extended base pairing interaction with the fMet-tRNA anticodon loop, suggesting that this interaction may be important in vivo. Mutations that would still permit base pairing with the 530 loop of the 16S rRNA also had a negative effect on translation, suggesting that this interaction does not occur in vivo. Extended base pairing surrounding the initiation codon may be part of a mechanism to compensate for the lack of a classic Shine-Dalgarno rRNA interaction in the translation of some chloroplast mRNAs.

The chloroplast gene ycf9 encodes a photosystem II (PSII) core subunit, PsbZ, that participates in PSII supramolecular architecture.

We have characterized the biochemical nature and the function of PsbZ, the protein product of a ubiquitous open reading frame, which is known as ycf9 in Chlamydomonas and ORF 62 in tobacco, that is present in chloroplast and cyanobacterial genomes. After raising specific antibodies to PsbZ from Chlamydomonas and tobacco, we demonstrated that it is a bona fide photosystem II (PSII) subunit. PsbZ copurifies with PSII cores in Chlamydomonas as well as in tobacco. Accordingly, PSII mutants from Chlamydomonas and tobacco are deficient in PsbZ. Using psbZ-targeted gene inactivation in tobacco and Chlamydomonas, we show that this protein controls the interaction of PSII cores with the light-harvesting antenna; in particular, PSII-LHCII supercomplexes no longer could be isolated from PsbZ-deficient tobacco plants. The content of the minor chlorophyll binding protein CP26, and to a lesser extent that of CP29, also was altered substantially under most growth conditions in the tobacco mutant and in Chlamydomonas mutant cells grown under photoautotrophic conditions. These PsbZ-dependent changes in the supramolecular organization of the PSII cores with their peripheral antennas cause two distinct phenotypes in tobacco and are accompanied by considerable modifications in (1) the pattern of protein phosphorylation within PSII units, (2) the deepoxidation of xanthophylls, and (3) the kinetics and amplitude of nonphotochemical quenching. The role of PsbZ in excitation energy dissipation within PSII is discussed in light of its proximity to CP43, in agreement with the most recent structural data on PSII.

A nucleus-encoded suppressor defines a new factor which can promote petD mRNA stability in the chloroplast of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii.

Mutations in the Chlamydomonas reinhardtii nuclear gene MCD1 specifically destabilize the chloroplast petD mRNA, which encodes subunit IV of the cytochrome b6/f complex. The MCD1 gene product is thought to interact with the mRNA 5' end to protect it from degradation by a 5' --> 3' exoribonuclease and may also have a role in translation initiation. Here we report the isolation and characterization of a semidominant, allele-specific, nucleus-encoded suppressor of the mcd1-2 mutation. The suppressor mutation, which defines a new locus MCD2, allows accumulation of 10% of the wild-type level of petD mRNA and as much as 50% of the wild-type subunit IV level. Taken together, these results suggest the suppressor mutation restores photosynthetic growth by stabilizing petD mRNA. In addition, it may promote increased translational efficiency, an inference supported by direct measurements of the subunit IV synthesis rate. Thus, both MCD1 and MCD2 may participate in both chloroplast RNA stability and translation initiation.

Processing and degradation of chloroplast mRNA.

The conversion of genetic information stored in DNA into a protein product proceeds through the obligatory intermediate of messenger RNA. The steady-state level of an mRNA is determined by its relative synthesis and degradation rates, i.e., an interplay between transcriptional regulation and control of RNA stability. When the biological status of an organism requires that a gene product's abundance varies as a function of developmental stage, environmental factors or intracellular signals, increased or decreased RNA stability can be the determining factor. RNA stability and processing have long been known as important regulatory points in chloroplast gene expression. Here we summarize current knowledge and prospects relevant to these processes, emphasizing biochemical data. The extensive literature on nuclear mutations affecting chloroplast RNA metabolism is reviewed in another article in this volume (Barkan and Goldschmidt-Clermont, this issue).

Disruption of the petB-petD intergenic region in tobacco chloroplasts affects petD RNA accumulation and translation.

Translation initiation in chloroplasts is a complex process involving a variety of cis-elements and trans-acting factors. Many chloroplast mRNAs are processed products of polycistronic primary transcripts, but the functional requirement for processing is mostly enigmatic. In tobacco, the petB and petD genes, which encode subunits of the cytochrome b6/f complex, are transcribed from the psbB operon, whose primary transcript is processed into products including di- or tricistronic, but not monocistronic, petB and petD mRNAs. To begin to identify elements important for petB and/or petD translation, we generated tobacco chloroplast transformants by inserting selectable aadA marker cassette in the petB-petD intergenic region. The resulting plants required sucrose for growth, and their phenotypes depended on the orientation of the aadA cassette. When aadA was inserted in the same transcriptional orientation as the psbB operon, petB and petD mRNAs were abundantly produced but aberrant in size, and only 25% of the wild-type amount of the cytochrome b6/f complex accumulated. With the aadA cassette in the opposing orientation, however, very little petD mRNA accumulated, and the cytochrome b6/f complex was undetectable. Polysome analysis suggested that petD mRNAs in both transformants were poorly translated, indicating that the intergenic region contains essential translational elements.

Polyadenylation of three classes of chloroplast RNA in Chlamydomonas reinhadtii.

Three classes of RNA, represented by atpB and petD mRNAs, Arg and Glu tRNAs, and 5S rRNA, were found to exist in polyadenylated form in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii chloroplasts. Sequence analysis of cDNA clones derived from reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction protocols used to select polyadenylated RNAs revealed that, at least for the mRNAs and tRNAs, there are three apparent types of polyadenylation. In the first case, the poly(A) tail is added at or near the mature 3' end, even when this follows a strong secondary structure. In the second case, the tail is added to pre-mRNA or pre-tRNA, suggesting a possible competition between polyadenylation and RNA-processing pathways. Finally, in all cases, the poly(A) tail can be added internally, possibly as a part of an RNA-decay pathway. The tails found in Chlamydomonas chloroplasts differ from those of spinach chloroplasts in adenine content, being nearly homopolymeric (>98% adenine) versus 70% in spinach, and are similar in length to those of Escherichia coli, being mostly between 20 and 50 nt. In vitro assays using a Chlamydomonas chloroplast protein extract showed that a 3' end A25 tail was sufficient to stimulate rapid degradation of atpB RNA in vitro, with a lesser effect for petD, and only minor effects on trnE. We therefore propose that polyadenylation contributes to mRNA degradation in Chlamydomonas chloroplasts, but that its effect may vary.

Post-transcriptional defects in tobacco chloroplast mutants lacking the cytochrome b6/f complex.

A variety of post-transcriptional mechanisms govern the synthesis and assembly of photosynthetic protein complexes in chloroplasts. To test whether such mechanisms are conserved between photosynthetic algae and vascular plants, we have interrupted the chloroplast petA, petB and petD genes of tobacco, which encode three subunits of the cytochrome b6/f complex, and compared our results to those previously obtained with Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. As expected, the mutants exhibited high chlorophyll fluorescence, consistent with the loss of a functional cytochrome b6/f complex. Unlike the corresponding mutants of Chlamydomonas, however, cytochrome f was barely detectable in the DeltapetB or DeltapetD mutants. The amounts of petB- and petD-containing mRNAs were reduced in the mutants compared to wild-type plants, but the remaining mRNA was normally associated with polysomes. In contrast, there was a decrease in polysome association of the polycistronic petA mRNA in the DeltapetB and DeltapetD mutants, suggesting that the synthesis of cytochrome f may be decreased in the absence of cytochrome b6 or SUIV. These results are discussed in light of the translational autoregulation model that has been proposed for cytochrome b6/f complex assembly in Chlamydomonas.

The sequence and secondary structure of the 3'-UTR affect 3'-end maturation, RNA accumulation, and translation in tobacco chloroplasts.

RNA maturation and modulation of RNA stability play important roles in chloroplast gene expression. In vitro and in vivo studies have shown that both the 5'- and 3'-untranslated regions (UTRs) contain sequence and structural elements that guide these processes, and interact with specific proteins. We have previously characterized the spinach chloroplast petD 3'-UTR in detail by in vitro approaches. This stem-loop forming sequence is a weak terminator but is required for RNA maturation and also exhibits sequence-specific protein binding. To test petD 3'-UTR function in vivo, tobacco chloroplast transformants were generated containing uidA reporter genes flanked by variants of the petD 3'-UTR, including one which does not form an RNA-protein complex in vitro, and one which lacks a stem-loop structure. Analysis of uidA mRNA indicated that a stable secondary structure is required to accumulate a discrete mRNA, and that changes in the 3'-UTR sequence which affect protein binding in vitro can also affect RNA metabolism in vivo. The 3'-UTR also influenced beta-glucuronidase protein accumulation, but not in proportion to RNA levels. These results raise the possibility that in tobacco chloroplasts, the 3'-UTR may influence translational yield.

Target and specificity of a nuclear gene product that participates in mRNA 3'-end formation in Chlamydomonas chloroplasts.

Chloroplast mRNA maturation is catalyzed by nucleus-encoded processing enzymes. We previously described a recessive nuclear mutation (crp3) that affects 3'-end formation of several chloroplast mRNAs in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (Levy, H., Kindle, K. L., and Stern, D. B. (1997) Plant Cell 9, 825-836). In the crp3 background, atpB mRNA lacking a 3'-inverted repeat normally required for stability accumulates as a discrete transcript. The mutation also affects the atpA gene cluster; polycistronic mRNAs with psbI or cemA 3'-ends accumulate to a lower level in the crp3 background. Here, we demonstrate that the crp3 mutation also alters 3'-end formation of psbI mRNA and cemA-containing mRNAs. A novel 3'-end is formed in monocistronic psbI transcripts, and this is the only terminus observed when the psbI 3'-untranslated region is fused to an aadA reporter gene. Accumulation of mRNAs with 3'-ends between cemA and atpH, which is immediately downstream, was reduced. However, this sequence was not recognized as a 3'-end formation element in chimeric genes. The crp3 mutation was able to confer stability to three different atpB 3'-stem-loop-disrupting mutations that lack sequence similarity, but are located at a similar distance from the translation termination codon. We propose that the wild-type CRP3 gene product is part of the general 3' --> 5' processing machinery.

Small cis-acting sequences that specify secondary structures in a chloroplast mRNA are essential for RNA stability and translation.

Nucleus-encoded proteins interact with cis-acting elements in chloroplast transcripts to promote RNA stability and translation. We have analyzed the structure and function of three such elements within the Chlamydomonas petD 5' untranslated region; petD encodes subunit IV of the cytochrome b(6)/f complex. These elements were delineated by linker-scanning mutagenesis, and RNA secondary structures were investigated by mapping nuclease-sensitive sites in vitro and by in vivo dimethyl sulfate RNA modification. Element I spans a maximum of 8 nucleotides (nt) at the 5' end of the mRNA; it is essential for RNA stability and plays a role in translation. This element appears to form a small stem-loop that may interact with a previously described nucleus-encoded factor to block 5'-->3' exoribonucleolytic degradation. Elements II and III, located in the center and near the 3' end of the 5' untranslated region, respectively, are essential for translation, but mutations in these elements do not affect mRNA stability. Element II is a maximum of 16 nt in length, does not form an obvious secondary structure, and appears to bind proteins that protect it from dimethyl sulfate modification. Element III spans a maximum of 14 nt and appears to form a stem-loop in vivo, based on dimethyl sulfate modification and the sequences of intragenic suppressors of element III mutations. Furthermore, mutations in element II result in changes in the RNA structure near element III, consistent with a long-range interaction that may promote translation.

5' to 3' exoribonucleolytic activity is a normal component of chloroplast mRNA decay pathways.

Molecular genetic studies have shown that determinants of chloroplast mRNA stability lie in both the 5' and 3' untranslated regions. While it is well-known that chloroplast mRNAs are unstable in the absence of certain nucleus-encoded factors, little is known of the decay mechanisms for chloroplast mRNA in wild-type cells. Here we used a poly(G)18 sequence, which impedes both 5'-->3' and 3'-->5' exoribonucleolytic RNA decay in vivo, to study the degradation pathway of petD mRNA in wild-type and mcd1 mutant chloroplasts of Chlamydomonas; the mcd1 mutant lacks a nucleus-encoded factor required for petD mRNA accumulation. Upon inserting poly(G) at positions -20, +25, +165 or +25/+165 relative to the mature petD 5' end, mRNAs accumulate with 5' ends corresponding to the poly(G) sequence, in addition to the normal RNA with its 5' end at +1. We interpret these results as evidence for continuous degradation of petD mRNA in wild-type cells by a 5'-->3' exoribonucleolytic activity. In the case of the -20 insertion, the accumulating RNA can be interpreted as a processing intermediate, suggesting that 5' end maturation may also involve this activity. When examined in the mcd1 mutant background, petD mRNAs with the poly(G) 5' ends, but not normal +1 ends, accumulated. However, no expression of SUIV, the petD gene product, was detected. Insertion of poly(G) at +165 in wild-type cells did not demonstrably affect SUIV accumulation, suggesting that ribosomal scanning does not occur upstream of this position. However, since neither poly(G) -20 nor +165 RNA could be translated in mcd1 cells, this raises the possibility that the MCD1 product is essential for translation.

Genomic context influences the activity of maize mitochondrial cox2 promoters.

Plant mitochondrial genomes are highly recombinogenic, with a variety of species-specific direct and inverted repeats leading to in vivo accumulation of multiple DNA forms. In maize, the cox2 gene, which encodes subunit II of cytochrome c oxidase, lies immediately downstream of a 0.7-kilobase direct repeat, which is present in two copies in the 570-kilobase master chromosome. Promoters for cox2 exist upstream of both of these copies, in regions we have termed A and B. Three region B promoters are active for cox2 transcription in the master chromosome, whereas two region A promoters are active for cox2 transcription after recombination across the direct repeats. We have measured the proportion of genomes carrying region A or B upstream of cox2 in maize seedlings and found a ratio of approximately 1:6. Promoter strength, based on run-on transcription assays, shows a ratio of 1:4 for region A to region B promoters. These data allowed us to predict the relative contributions of region A and B to mitochondrial transcript accumulation, based on a simple product of genome-form abundance and promoter strength. When promoter use was determined by using quantitative reverse transcriptase-PCR, however, we found that region A promoters were used at an unexpectedly high rate when upstream of cox2 and used less than expected when not upstream of cox2. Thus, the use of this set of promoters seems to respond to genomic context. These results suggest a role for intragenomic and intergenomic recombination in regulating plant mitochondrial gene expression.

Altering the 3 UTR endonucleolytic cleavage site of a Chlamydomonas chloroplast mRNA affects 3-end maturation in vitro but not in vivo.

The 3' ends of chloroplast mRNAs are produced by the processing of longer precursors. The 3' ends of most plastid mRNAs are located at, or several nucleotides downstream of, stem-loop structures, which act as 3'-end-processing signals and RNA stability elements. In chloroplasts of the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, 3'-end maturation of atpB mRNA involves endonucleolytic cleavage of the pre-mRNA at an AU-rich site located about 10 nucleotides downstream of the stem-loop structure. This cleavage is followed by exonucleolytic resection to generate the mature 3' end. In order to define critical nucleotides of the endonucleolytic cleavage site, we mutated its sequence. Incubation of synthetic atpB pre-RNAs containing these mutations in a chloroplast protein extract resulted in the accumulation of 3'-end-processed products. However, in two cases where the AU-rich sequence of this site was replaced with a GC-rich one, the 3' end of the stable processing product differed from that of the wild-type product. To examine whether these mutations affected atpB mRNA processing or accumulation in vivo, the endogenous 3' UTR was replaced with mutated sequences by biolistic transformation of Chlamydomonas chloroplasts. Analysis of the resulting strains revealed that the accumulation of atpB mRNA was approximately equal to that of wild-type cells, and that a wild-type atpB 3' end was generated. These results imply that Chlamydomonas atpB 3' processing parallels the situation with other endonucleases such as Escherichia coli RNAse E, where specific sequences are required for correct in vitro processing, but in vivo these mutations can be overcome.

Polyadenylation occurs at multiple sites in maize mitochondrial cox2 mRNA and is independent of editing status.

Polyadenylation of nucleus-encoded transcripts has a well-defined role in gene expression. The extent and function of polyadenylation in organelles and prokaryotic systems, however, are less well documented. Recent reports of polyadenylation-mediated RNA destabilization in Escherichia coli and in vascular plant chloroplasts prompted us to look for polyadenylation in plant mitochondria. Here, we report the use of reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction to map multiple polyadenylate addition sites in maize mitochondrial cox2 transcripts. The lack of sequence conservation surrounding these sites suggests that polyadenylation may occur at many 3' termini created by endoribonucleolytic and/or exoribonucleolytic activities, including those activities involved in 3' end maturation. Endogenous transcripts could be efficiently polyadenylated in vitro by using maize mitochondrial lysates with an activity that added AMP more efficiently than GMP. Polyadenylated substrates were tested for stability in maize mitochondrial S100 extracts, and we found that, compared with nonpolyadenylated RNAs, the polyadenylated substrates were less stable. Taken together with the low abundance of polyadenylated RNAs in maize mitochondria, our results are consistent with a degradation-related process. The fact that polyadenylation does not dramatically destabilize plant mitochondrial transcripts, at least in vitro, is in agreement with results obtained for animal mitochondria but differs from those obtained for chloroplasts and E. coli. Because fully edited, partially edited, and unedited transcripts were found among the cloned polyadenylated cox2 cDNAs, we conclude that RNA editing and polyadenylation are independent processes in maize mitochondria.

DNA-binding factors assemble in a sequence-specific manner on the maize mitochondrial atpA promoter.

The maize mitochondrial atpA promoter has been well-characterized using in vitro transcription. The functional elements of this promoter comprise a central domain extending from -7 to +5 relative to the transcription start site, and an upstream domain of 1-3 bp that is purine-rich and centered around positions -11 to -12. As a first step in characterizing the transcriptional machinery, exonuclease-III mapping (toeprinting) was used to map the borders of DNA-protein interactions using either a 107-bp wild-type template or transcriptionally-inactive templates containing linker-scanning mutations. These experiments revealed that, with a wild-type promoter, protein factors occupy as much as 36 bp, from positions -20 to +16 relative to the transcription initiation site. Protein-binding patterns were altered when the linker-scanning mutants were used, suggesting that either the number or conformation of DNA-binding proteins could account for their inability to promote transcription initiation.

Functional analysis of two maize cDNAs encoding T7-like RNA polymerases.

We have characterized two maize cDNAs, rpoTm and rpoTp, that encode putative T7-like RNA polymerases. In vivo cellular localization experiments using transient expression of the green fluorescent protein suggest that their encoded proteins are targeted exclusively to mitochondria and plastids, respectively. An antibody raised against the C terminus of the rpoTp gene product identified mitochondrial polypeptides of approximately 100 kD. Their presence was correlated with RNA polymerase activity, and the antibody inhibited mitochondrial in vitro transcription activity. Together, these results strongly suggest that the product of rpoTm is involved in maize mitochondrial transcription. By contrast, immunoblot analysis and an antibody-linked polymerase assay indicated that rpoTp specifies a plastid RNA polymerase component. A quantitative reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction assay was used to study the transcription of rpoTp and rpoTm in different tissues and under different environmental conditions. Although both genes were constitutively expressed, rpoTm transcripts were generally more prevalent in nonphotosynthetic tissues, whereas an increase in rpoTp transcripts paralleled chloroplast development. We suggest that these two genes encode constitutive components of the organelle transcription machinery but that their expression is nonetheless subject to modulation during plant development.

The maize mitochondrial cox2 gene has five promoters in two genomic regions, including a complex promoter consisting of seven overlapping units.

Plant mitochondrial genes are often transcribed into complex sets of RNAs, resulting from multiple initiation sites and processing steps. To elucidate the role of initiation in generating the more than 10 cox2 transcripts found in maize mitochondria, we surveyed sequences upstream of cox2 for active promoters. Because the cox2 coding region is immediately downstream of a 0.7-kb recombination repeat, cox2 is under the control of two different sets of potential expression signals. Using an in vitro transcription assay, we localized four promoters upstream of the coding region in the so-called master chromosome, and two promoters upstream of the coding region in the recombinant subgenome. Ribonuclease protection analysis of labeled primary transcripts confirmed that all but one of these promoters is active in vivo. Primer extension was used to identify the promoter sequences and initiation sites, which agree with the consensus established earlier for maize mitochondria. This study identified two unusual promoters, the core sequences of which were composed entirely of adenines and thymines, and one of which was a complex promoter consisting of seven overlapping units. Deletion mutagenesis of the complex promoter suggested that each of its units was recognized independently by RNA polymerase. While each active promoter fit the maize core consensus sequence YRTAT, not all such sequences surveyed supported initiation. We conclude that in vitro transcription is a powerful tool for locating mitochondrial promoters and that, in the case of cox2, promoter multiplicity contributes strongly to transcript complexity.

3'-Processed mRNA is preferentially translated in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii chloroplasts.

3'-end processing of nucleus-encoded mRNAs includes the addition of a poly(A) tail that is important for translation initiation. Since the vast majority of chloroplast mRNAs acquire their 3' termini by processing yet are not polyadenylated, we asked whether 3' end maturation plays a role in chloroplast translation. A general characteristic of the 3' untranslated regions of chloroplast mRNAs is an inverted repeat (IR) sequence that can fold into a stem-loop structure. These stem-loops and their flanking sequences serve as RNA 3'-end formation signals. Deletion of the Chlamydomonas chloroplast atpB 3' IR in strain Delta26 results in reduced accumulation of atpB transcripts and the chloroplast ATPase beta-subunit, leading to weakly photosynthetic growth. Of the residual atpB mRNA in Delta26, approximately 1% accumulates as a discrete RNA of wild-type size, while the remainder is heterogeneous in length due to the lack of normal 3' end maturation. In this work, we have analyzed whether these unprocessed atpB transcripts are actively translated in vivo. We found that only the minority population of discrete transcripts of wild-type size is associated with polysomes and thus accounts for the ATPase beta-subunit which accumulates in Delta26. Analysis of chloroplast rbcL mRNA revealed that transcripts extending beyond the mature 3' end were not polysome associated. These results suggest that 3'-end processing of chloroplast mRNA is required for or strongly stimulates its translation.

In vivo evidence for 5'-->3' exoribonuclease degradation of an unstable chloroplast mRNA.

The acetate-requiring Chlamydomonas reinhardtii nuclear mutant F16 harbors the mutation mcd1-1 and fails to accumulate the cytochrome b6/f complex. The primary defect of mcd1-1 was determined to be the instability of petD mRNA, which encodes subunit IV of the complex. Chimeric reporter genes introduced by chloroplast transformation demonstrated that the determinant of petD mRNA instability in the mcd1-1 background is located in the 5' untranslated region (UTR). However, when this 5' UTR was present downstream of other sequences in dicistronic or chimeric transcripts, the RNAs were no longer destabilized in the mcd1-1 background. Together, these results suggest that the 5' end of the petD 5' UTR interacts with the MCD1 product. The insertion of a polyguanosine sequence into the petD 5' UTR fused to a reporter gene allowed accumulation of the reporter gene transcript in the mutant background. Since polyguanosine forms a structure that is known to impede exonucleases, these data provide in vivo evidence that petD mRNA can be degraded by 5'-->3' exoribonuclease activity. Furthermore, the data support a model in which protein binding to the petD 5' UTR protects the mRNA from 5'-->3' degradation in wild-type cells.