GRAPPA 2023 Debate: Is Psoriatic Disease Really a Primary Enthesitis That Drives Joint Synovitis? The Enthesitis Hypothesis 25 Years On.

The enthesitis hypothesis posits that enthesitis is a primary lesion and that inflammation at the enthesis initiates the musculoskeletal symptoms of psoriatic arthritis (PsA) and spondyloarthropathies (SpA). The hypothesis suggested that inflamed entheseal tissue near the synovium could trigger cytokine-mediated synovitis, that enthesis bone anchorage could explain osteitis, and that the location of entheses at the soft tissue interface could explain dactylitis. Advances in imaging techniques that allow better visualization of enthesitis lesions and the development of animal models have allowed evolution of the concept of enthesitis as a central mechanistic driver of musculoskeletal symptoms in PsA and SpA. A debate between Drs. Dennis McGonagle and Bruce Kirkham at the Group for Research on Psoriasis and Psoriatic Arthritis (GRAPPA) 2023 annual meeting discussed the data supporting and refuting this hypothesis in PsA and SpA, respectively. The major points of this debate are summarized in this article.

Subclinical Enthesopathy in Psoriasis-An Ultrasonographic Study.

The present study is aimed at assessing the presence and prevalence of subclinical entheseal changes in Psoriasis (PsO) patients using musculoskeletal ultrasonography (US), conjoined with the analysis of possible differences in terms of demographic, clinical, or biological features. We carried out an observational study on 54 patients with PsO and 40 controls. Subclinical enthesopathy, according to OMERACT definitions, was identified in 20 of the psoriasis patients (37.03%), a significantly difference compared to the controls (5 patients; 10.20%). A comparison between US examinations for psoriasis patients and controls indicates that all the examined areas manifested changes in a significantly higher percentage of patients than the controls. The most common structural changes were represented by thickened tendon (85%), calcification (65%), erosions (35%), power Doppler (PD) signal (20%), and bursitis (5%). The difference in mean MASEI (Madrid Sonographic Enthesitis Index) score between the psoriasis and control groups was statistically significant (10.56 + 2.96 vs. 2.9 + 2.20; p < 0.0001). In conclusion, ultrasound is an easily accessible and vital follow-up method for psoriasis patients to enable an early, subclinical detection of entheseal involvement, i.e., the first red-flag sign for a future transition to psoriatic arthritis (PsA).

Enthesopathies - Mechanical, inflammatory or both?

Entheses have the challenging task of transferring biomechanical forces between tendon and bone, two tissues that differ greatly in composition and mechanical properties. Consequently, entheses are adapted to withstand these forces through continuous repair mechanisms. Locally specialized cells (mechanosensitive tenocytes) are crucial in the repair, physiologically triggering biochemical processes to maintain hemostasis. When repetitive forces cause "material fatigue," or trauma exceeds the entheses' repair capacity, structural changes occur, and patients become symptomatic. Clinical assessment of enthesopathies mainly depends on subjective reports by the patient and lacks specificity, especially in patients with central sensitization syndromes. Ultrasonography has been increasingly used to improve the diagnosis of enthesopathies. In this article, the literature on how biomechanical forces lead to entheseal inflammation, including factors contributing to differentiation into a "clinical enthesitis" state and the value of ultrasound to diagnose enthesopathies will be reviewed, as well as providing clues to overcome the pitfalls of imaging.

Using Ultrasound to Improve Diagnostic Confidence and Management of Psoriatic Disease: Highlights From the GRAPPA 2023 Ultrasound Workshop.

The sensitivity of ultrasound (US) to detect, characterize, and monitor the relevant pathologies of psoriatic arthritis (PsA), including synovitis, enthesitis, tenosynovitis, and dactylitis, has made it an attractive tool for informing clinical decisions. The Group for Research and Assessment of Psoriasis and Psoriatic Arthritis (GRAPPA) US working group ran 2 sessions during the annual GRAPPA meeting held in July 2023 in Dublin, Ireland. During the first workshop, the group presented 2 topics, followed by a live demonstration and a group discussion. The 2 topics were (1) an overview of the Diagnostic Ultrasound Enthesitis Tool (DUET) enthesitis scoring methodology, and (2) small hand-held probes-will the promise deliver? The live demonstration that followed compared the performance of 2 hand-held US (HHUS) devices vs a console US machine in patients with PsA, and the interactive group discussion considered gaps in the literature and future research suggestions relating to HHUS and its application in psoriatic disease. During the second session, the US working group provided further updates regarding the GRAPPA US studies currently underway or recently completed.

Advances in Psoriatic Disease Research: Insights From GRAPPA Pilot Research Awardees.

Research progress from the Group for Research and Assessment of Psoriasis and Psoriatic Arthritis (GRAPPA) pilot award program was presented and discussed at the GRAPPA 2023 annual meeting. Topics included identification of protein biomarkers associated with enthesitis in psoriatic arthritis (PsA), the role of HLA-B27 on gut microbial dysbiosis in PsA, single-cell profiling of synovial fluid vs psoriatic skin lesions in PsA, and the role of mechanotransduction in hyperactivation of transforming growth factor-ß via αVß6 integrin in psoriatic epidermis.

The role of GDF5 in regulating enthesopathy development in the Hyp mouse model of XLH.

X-linked hypophosphatemia (XLH) is caused by mutations in PHEX, leading to rickets and osteomalacia. Adults affected with XLH develop a mineralization of the bone-tendon attachment site (enthesis), called enthesopathy, which causes significant pain and impaired movement. Entheses in mice with XLH (Hyp) have enhanced bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) and Indian hedgehog (IHH) signaling. Treatment of Hyp mice with the BMP signaling blocker palovarotene attenuated BMP/IHH signaling in Hyp entheses, thus indicating that BMP signaling plays a pathogenic role in enthesopathy development and that IHH signaling is activated by BMP signaling in entheses. It was previously shown that mRNA expression of growth/differentiation factor 5 (Gdf5) is enhanced in Hyp entheses at P14. Thus, to determine a role for GDF5 in enthesopathy development, Gdf5 was deleted globally in Hyp mice and conditionally in Scx + cells of Hyp mice. In both murine models, BMP/IHH signaling was similarly decreased in Hyp entheses, leading to decreased enthesopathy. BMP/IHH signaling remained unaffected in WT entheses with decreased Gdf5 expression. Moreover, deletion of Gdf5 in Hyp entheses starting at P30, after enthesopathy has developed, partially reversed enthesopathy. Taken together, these results demonstrate that while GDF5 is not essential for modulating BMP/IHH signaling in WT entheses, inappropriate GDF5 activity in Scx + cells contributes to XLH enthesopathy development. As such, inhibition of GDF5 signaling may be beneficial for the treatment of XLH enthesopathy.

X-linked hypophosphatemia (XLH) is a rare bone disorder that leads to short stature and poorly mineralized bones. As adults, patients with XLH often develop a mineralization of the bone-tendon attachment site, called enthesopathy, which results in significant pain. We previously showed that Achilles bone-tendon attachment sites (entheses) in mice with XLH (Hyp) have an enthesopathy characterized by increased bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signaling. In the current studies, we show that treating Hyp mice with the BMP signaling inhibitor palovarotene prevents enthesopathy, demonstrating that the increased BMP signaling in Hyp entheses leads to enthesopathy development. We also reported that gene expression of Gdf5, which activates BMP signaling, is enhanced in Hyp entheses. Therefore, to determine if the enhanced Gdf5 expression leads to the increased BMP signaling seen Hyp entheses, Gdf5 was deleted from Hyp mice and also deleted specifically in the entheses of Hyp mice. In both mouse models, enthesopathy development was attenuated, demonstrating that the increased Gdf5 expression in Hyp entheses plays a role in enthesopathy development. These data indicate that blocking GDF5 and BMP signaling may prevent enthesopathy in patients with XLH.

Enthesitis as an initial presentation of vascular Behçet's syndrome: a case-based review.

Enthesitis is a characteristic manifestation of spondyloarthropathy (SpA). Historically, Behçet's syndrome (BS) was classified within SpA. Although they are now classified separately, the association between BS and SpA remains controversial. The concept of MHC-I (major histocompatibility complex class I)-opathy has been proposed based on the overlap in immunopathological mechanisms among diseases associated with human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I. Enthesitis is a frequent complication in patients with BS who also have acne and arthritis. However, information regarding enthesitis in patients with BS without arthritis (BS-WA) is limited. Herein, we report a case of vascular BS complicated by enthesitis. In this case, heel pain was the dominant symptom at presentation. Laboratory tests revealed chlamydia antibody positivity, leading to a tentative diagnosis of reactive arthritis. Despite treatment, C-reactive protein (CRP) levels remained elevated. Imaging revealed numerous aneurysmal lesions in the large vessels. Based on these findings and other symptoms, patient was diagnosed with vascular BS. He tested positive for HLA-B15 and HLA-B46, which are associated with peripheral SpA. Subsequent remission induction therapy for BS was effective and the patient was discharged without complications. Our case and a literature review suggest that there exists a subgroup of BS-WA with a complication of enthesitis, possibly belonging to the spectrum of MHC-I-opathies. It is important to consider BS as a differential diagnosis in patients presenting with enthesitis and to conduct a precise medical history review regarding the symptoms of BS.