Comprehensive molecular and morphological resolution of blubber stratification in a deep-diving, fasting-adapted seal.

Blubber is a modified subcutaneous adipose tissue in marine mammals that provides energy storage, thermoregulation, hydrodynamic locomotion, and buoyancy. Blubber displays vertical stratification by lipid content, fatty acid composition, and vascularization, leading to the assumption that deeper blubber layers are metabolically active, while superficial layers are mainly structural and thermoregulatory. However, few studies have examined functional stratification of marine mammal blubber directly, especially in pinnipeds. We characterized morphological and transcriptional differences across blubber layers in the northern elephant seal, a deep-diving and fasting-adapted phocid. We collected blubber from seals early in their fasting period and divided blubber cores into three similarly sized portions. We hypothesized that the innermost blubber portion would have higher 1) heterogeneity in adipocyte size, 2) microvascular density, and 3) expression of genes associated with metabolism and hormone signaling than outer blubber. We found that adipocyte area and variance increased from outermost (skin-adjacent) to innermost (muscle-adjacent) blubber layers, suggesting that inner blubber has a higher capacity for lipid storage and turnover than outer blubber. Inner blubber had a higher proportion of CD144+ endothelial cells, suggesting higher microvascular density. In contrast, outer blubber had a higher proportion of CD4+ immune cells than inner blubber, suggesting higher capacity for response to tissue injury. Transcriptome analysis identified 61 genes that were differentially expressed between inner and outer blubber layers, many of which have not been studied previously in marine mammals. Based on known functions of these genes in other mammals, we suggest that inner blubber has potentially higher 1) adipogenic capacity, 2) cellular diversity, and 3) metabolic and neuroendocrine signaling activity, while outer blubber may have higher 1) extracellular matrix synthesis activity and 2) responsiveness to pathogens and cell stressors. We further characterized expression of nine genes of interest identified by transcriptomics and two adipokines with higher precision across blubber layers using targeted assays. Our study provides functional insights into stratification of blubber in marine mammals and a molecular key, including CD144, CD4, HMGCS2, GABRG2, HCAR2, and COL1A2, for distinguishing blubber layers for physiological and functional studies in seals.

Snapshots of catalysis: the structure of fructose-1,6-(bis)phosphate aldolase covalently bound to the substrate dihydroxyacetone phosphate.

Fructose-1,6-bis(phosphate) aldolase is an essential glycolytic enzyme found in all vertebrates and higher plants that catalyzes the cleavage of fructose 1,6-bis(phosphate) (Fru-1,6-P(2)) to glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate and dihydroxyacetone phosphate (DHAP). Mutations in the aldolase genes in humans cause hemolytic anemia and hereditary fructose intolerance. The structure of the aldolase-DHAP Schiff base has been determined by X-ray crystallography to 2.6 A resolution (R(cryst) = 0.213, R(free) = 0.249) by trapping the catalytic intermediate with NaBH(4) in the presence of Fru-1,6-P(2). This is the first structure of a trapped covalent intermediate for this essential glycolytic enzyme. The structure allows the elucidation of a comprehensive catalytic mechanism and identification of a conserved chemical motif in Schiff-base aldolases. The position of the bound DHAP relative to Asp33 is consistent with a role for Asp33 in deprotonation of the C4-hydroxyl leading to C-C bond cleavage. The methyl side chain of Ala31 is positioned directly opposite the C3-hydroxyl, sterically favoring the S-configuration of the substrate at this carbon. The "trigger" residue Arg303, which binds the substrate C6-phosphate group, is a ligand to the phosphate group of DHAP. The observed movement of the ligand between substrate and product phosphates may provide a structural link between the substrate cleavage and the conformational change in the C-terminus associated with product release. The position of Glu187 in relation to the DHAP Schiff base is consistent with a role for the residue in protonation of the hydroxyl group of the carbinolamine in the dehydration step, catalyzing Schiff-base formation. The overlay of the aldolase-DHAP structure with that of the covalent enzyme-dihydroxyacetone structure of the mechanistically similar transaldolase and KDPG aldolase allows the identification of a conserved Lys-Glu dyad involved in Schiff-base formation and breakdown. The overlay highlights the fact that Lys146 in aldolase is replaced in transaldolase with Asn35. The substitution in transaldolase stabilizes the enamine intermediate required for the attack of the second aldose substrate, changing the chemistry from aldolase to transaldolase.

The crystal structure of bacillus cereus phosphonoacetaldehyde hydrolase: insight into catalysis of phosphorus bond cleavage and catalytic diversification within the HAD enzyme superfamily.

Phosphonoacetaldehyde hydrolase (phosphonatase) catalyzes the hydrolysis of phosphonoacetaldehyde to acetaldehyde and phosphate using Mg(II) as cofactor. The reaction proceeds via a novel bicovalent catalytic mechanism in which an active-site nucleophile abstracts the phosphoryl group from the Schiff-base intermediate formed from Lys53 and phosphonoacetaldehyde. In this study, the X-ray crystal structure of the Bacillus cereus phosphonatase homodimer complexed with the phosphate (product) analogue tungstate (K(i) = 50 microM) and the Mg(II) cofactor was determined to 3.0 A resolution with an R(cryst) = 0.248 and R(free) = 0.284. Each monomer is made up of an alpha/beta core domain consisting of a centrally located six-stranded parallel beta-sheet surrounded by six alpha-helices. Two flexible, solvated linkers connect to a small cap domain (residues 21-99) that consists of an antiparallel, five-helix bundle. The subunit-subunit interface, formed by the symmetrical packing of the two alpha8 helices from the respective core domains, is stabilized through the hydrophobic effect derived from the desolvation of paired Met171, Trp164, Tyr162, Tyr167, and Tyr176 side chains. The active site is located at the domain-domain interface of each subunit. The Schiff base forming Lys53 is positioned on the cap domain while tungstate and Mg(II) are bound to the core domain. Mg(II) ligands include two oxygens of the tungstate ligand, one oxygen of the carboxylates of Asp12 and Asp186, the backbone carbonyl oxygen of Ala14, and a water that forms a hydrogen bond with the carboxylate of Asp190 and Thr187. The guanidinium group of Arg160 binds tungstate and the proposed nucleophile Asp12, which is suitably positioned for in-line attack at the tungsten atom. The side chains of the core domain residue Tyr128 and the cap domain residues Cys22 and Lys53 are located nearby. The identity of Asp12 as the active-site nucleophile was further evidenced by the observed removal of catalytic activity resulting from Asp12Ala substitution. The similarity of backbone folds observed in phosphonatase and the 2-haloacid dehalogenase of the HAD enzyme superfamily indicated common ancestry. Superposition of the two structures revealed a conserved active-site scaffold having distinct catalytic stations. Analysis of the usage of polar amino acid residues at these stations by the dehalogenases, phosphonatases, phosphatases, and phosphomutases of the HAD superfamily suggests possible ways in which the active site of an ancient enzyme ancestor might have been diversified for catalysis of C-X, P-C, and P-O bond cleavage reactions.

Crystallization and preliminary crystallographic analysis of phosphonoacetaldehyde hydrolase.

Phosphonoacetaldehyde hydrolase, a C-P bond-cleaving enzyme which utilizes an unusual bicovalent catalytic strategy, has been crystallized by the hanging-drop vapor-diffusion method using PEG 4000 as the precipitant. The crystals belong to the monoclinic system and belong to space group C2, with unit-cell parameters a = 210.5, b = 45.5, c = 64.7 A, beta = 105.0 degrees. The asymmetric unit contains a dimer related by a non-crystallographic dyad. In addition to a 2.7 A native data set, the following data sets have been collected: a 2.4 A data set from crystals complexed with the intermediate analog vinyl sulfonate, a 3.0 A three-wavelength MAD data set from crystals complexed with the product analog WO(4)(2-), as well as several heavy-atom data sets to 3.0 A or better, of which only three have proven useful for MIR calculations. Examination of the native Patterson map revealed NCS that made previously uninterpretable derivative data useful. Independent phase sets were first calculated and refined for the MAD and MIR experiments separately and were then combined. The combined phase set was further improved by solvent flattening, histogram matching and NCS averaging. Interpretation of the resulting electron-density map is currently under way.

Structure of a fructose-1,6-bis(phosphate) aldolase liganded to its natural substrate in a cleavage-defective mutant at 2.3 A(,).

Class I fructose-1,6-bis(phosphate) aldolase is a glycolytic enzyme that catalyzes the cleavage of fructose 1,6-bis(phosphate) through a covalent Schiff base intermediate. Although the atomic structure of this enzyme is known, assigning catalytic roles to the various enzymic active-site residues has been hampered by the lack of a structure for the enzyme-substrate complex. A mutant aldolase, K146A, is unable to cleave the C3-C4 bond of the hexose while retaining the ability to form the covalent intermediate, although at a greatly diminished rate. The structure of rabbit muscle K146A-aldolase A, in complex with its native substrate, fructose 1,6-bis(phosphate), is determined to 2.3 A resolution by molecular replacement. The density at the hexose binding site differs between subunits of the tetramer, in that two sites show greater occupancy relative to the other two. The hexose is bound in its linear, open conformation, but not covalently linked to the Schiff base-forming Lys-229. Therefore, this structure most likely represents the bound complex of hexose just after hemiketal hydrolysis and prior to Schiff base formation. The C1-phosphate binding site involves the three backbone nitrogens of Ser-271, Gly-272, and Gly-302, and the epsilon-amino group of Lys-229. This is the same binding site previously found for the analogous phosphate of the product DHAP. The C6-phosphate binding site involves three basic side chains, Arg-303, Arg-42, and Lys-41. The residues closest to Lys-229 were relatively unchanged in position when compared to the unbound wild-type structure. The major differences between the bound and unbound enzyme structures were observed in the positions of Lys-107, Arg-303, and Arg-42, with the greatest difference in the change in conformation of Arg-303. Site-directed mutagenesis was performed on those residues with different conformations in bound versus unbound enzyme. The kinetic constants of these mutant enzymes with the substrates fructose 1, 6-bis(phosphate) and fructose 1-phosphate are consistent with their ligand interactions as revealed by the structure reported here, including differing effects on k(cat) and K(m) between the two substrates depending on whether the mutations affect C6-phosphate binding. In the unbound state, Arg-303 forms a salt bridge with Glu-34, and in the liganded structure it interacts closely with the substrate C6-phosphate. The position of the sugar in the binding site would require a large movement prior to achieving the proper position for covalent catalysis with the Schiff base-forming Lys-229. The movement most likely involves a change in the location of the more loosely bound C6-phosphate. This result suggests that the substrate has one position in the Michaelis complex and another in the covalent complex. Such movement could trigger conformational changes in the carboxyl-terminal region, which has been implicated in substrate specificity.

The 2.1 A structure of a cysteine protease with proline specificity from ginger rhizome, Zingiber officinale.

A cysteine protease from ginger rhizome (GP-II) cleaves peptides and proteins with proline at the P(2) position. The unusual specificity for proline makes GP-II an attractive tool for protein sequencing and identification of stably folded domains in proteins. The enzyme is a 221 amino acid glycoprotein possessing two N-linked oligosaccharide chains (8% glycosylated by weight) at Asn99 and Asn156. The availability of the sequence of these glycosyl chains afforded the opportunity to observe their structure and impact on protein conformation. The three-dimensional structure of GP-II has been determined by X-ray crystallography to a resolution of 2.1 A (overall R-factor = 0.214, free R = 0.248). The overall structure of GP-II is similar to that of the homologous cysteine proteases papain, actinidin, and glycyl endopeptidase, folding into two distinct domains of roughly equal size which are divided by a cleft. The observed N-linked glycosyl chains (half the total carbohydrate sequence) participate in both crystallographic and noncrystallographic contacts, tethering the proteins together via hydrogen bonds to the carbohydrate residues without intervening ordered water molecules. The putative S(2) binding pocket (the proline recognition site) was identified by superposition of the GP-II structure with structures of four previously determined papain-inhibitor complexes. The particular enzymic amino acids forming the S(2) pocket of GP-II (Trp, Met, and Ala) are similar to those found in the proline binding pockets of the unrelated enzymes alpha-lytic protease and cyclophilin. However, there is no conserved three-dimensional arrangement of these residues between the three enzymes (i.e., no proline binding motif). Thus, the particular amino acids found at S(2) are consistent with a binding pocket for a moiety with the steric characteristics and charge distribution of proline. Size exclusion is also a mechanism for selectivity compared to the S(2) binding pocket of papain. The S(2) binding pocket of GP-II greatly restricts the size of the side chain which could be bound because of the occurrence of a tryptophan in place of the corresponding tyrosine in papain. In light of the nature of the binding pocket, the specificity of GP-II for proline over other small nonpolar amino acids may be attributed to a direct effect of proline on the substrate peptide backbone conformation.

Design, synthesis, and characterization of a potent xylose isomerase inhibitor, D-threonohydroxamic acid, and high-resolution X-ray crystallographic structure of the enzyme-inhibitor complex.

The binding of a potent inhibitor to the enzyme D-xylose isomerase from Streptomyces olivochromogenes was examined by kinetics and X-ray crystallography. The inhibitor D-threonohydroxamic acid (THA) was designed to mimic the putative transition state of the isomerization step catalyzed by the enzyme on the substrate xylose. THA was synthesized and found to be a slow-binding competitive inhibitor with the substrate glucose. The Ki < or = 100 nM was at least one million-fold less than the KM for glucose. The X-ray crystallographic structure of xylose isomerase with THA soaked into the crystals (concentration = 1000Ki) was obtained to 1.6-A resolution and refined to an R factor of 21.6%. The free enzyme and the enzyme in the xylose isomerase-THA complex show no significant structural differences. THA binds in an analogous fashion to glucose, in a linear conformation, forming ligands with Mg-1 and Mg-2 and hydrogen bonds with His53 and Lys182. On the basis of these similarities to glucose binding and its potent inhibition, we propose that THA resembles the transition state for the enzyme-catalyzed hydride transfer reaction. The THA C2 hydroxyl forms a bridging ligand between Mg-1 and Mg-2; it must be deprotonated to do so. By analogy, we propose that, during the catalytic reaction, C2 of the substrate glucose is deprotonated, and that this proton can be moved to the C1 hydroxyl concomitant with hydride transfer. We find evidence for metal movement during catalysis upon deprotonation of the C2 hydroxyl, to allow formation of a bridging ligand.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

X-ray crystallographic structures of D-xylose isomerase-substrate complexes position the substrate and provide evidence for metal movement during catalysis.

The X-ray crystallographic structures of the metal-activated enzyme xylose isomerase from Streptomyces olivochromogenes with the substrates D-glucose, 3-O-methyl-D-glucose and in the absence of substrate were determined to 1.96-, 2.19-, and 1.81-A resolution and refined to R-factors of 16.6%, 15.9%, and 16.1%, respectively. Xylose isomerase catalyzes the interconversion between glucose and fructose (xylose and xylulose under physiological conditions) by utilizing two metal cofactors to promote a hydride shift; the metals are bridged by a glutamate residue. This puts xylose isomerase in the small but rapidly growing family of enzymes with a bridged bimetallic active site, in which both metals are involved in the chemical transformation. The substrate 3-O-methylglucose was chosen in order to position the glucose molecule in the observed electron density unambiguously. Of the two essential magnesium ions per active site, Mg-2 was observed to occupy two alternate positions, separated by 1.8 A, in the substrate-soaked structures. The deduced movement was not observed in the structure without substrate present and is attributed to a step following substrate binding but prior to isomerization. The substrates glucose and 3-O-methylglucose are observed in their linear extended forms and make identical interactions with the enzyme by forming ligands to Mg-1 through O2 and O4 and by forming hydrogen bonds with His53 through O5 and Lys182 through O1. Mg-2 has a water ligand that is interpreted in the crystal structure in the absence of substrate as a hydroxide ion and in the presence of substrate as a water molecule. This hydroxide ion may act as a base to deprotonate the glucose O2 and subsequently protonate the product fructose O1 concomitant with hydride transfer. Calculations of the solvent-accessible surface of possible dimers, with and without the alpha-helical C-terminal domain, suggest that the tetramer is the active form of this xylose isomerase.

Role of the divalent metal ion in sugar binding, ring opening, and isomerization by D-xylose isomerase: replacement of a catalytic metal by an amino acid.

The distinct roles of the two magnesium ions essential to the activity of D-xylose isomerase from Streptomyces olivochromogenes were examined. The enzyme-magnesium complex was isolated, and the stoichiometry of cation binding determined by neutron activation analysis to be 2 mol of magnesium per mole of enzyme. A plot of Mg2+ added versus Mg2+ bound to enzyme is consistent with apparent KD values of < or = 0.5-1.0 mM for one Mg2+ and < or = 2-5 mM for the second. A site-directed mutant of D-xylose isomerase was designed to remove the tighter, tetracoordinated magnesium binding site (site 1, Mg-1); Glu180 was replaced with Lys180. The stoichiometry of metal binding to this mutant, E180K, is 1 mol of magnesium per mole of enzyme. Ring-opening assays with 1-thioglucose (H2S released upon ring opening) show E180K catalyzes the opening of the sugar ring at 20% the rate of the wild-type, but E180K does not catalyze isomerization of glucose to fructose. Thus, the magnesium bound to Glu180 is essential for isomerization but not essential for ring opening. The X-ray crystallographic structures of E180K in the absence of magnesium and in the presence and absence of 250 mM glucose were obtained to 1.8-A resolution and refined to R factors of 17.7% and 19.7%, respectively. The wild-type and both E180K structures show no significant structural differences, except the epsilon-amino group of Lys180, which occupies the position usually occupied by the Mg-1.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Isotopic exchange plus substrate and inhibition kinetics of D-xylose isomerase do not support a proton-transfer mechanism.

The D-xylose isomerase of Streptomyces olivochromogenes is a Mg2+- or Mn(2+)-dependent enzyme that catalyzes the aldose-ketose isomerization of xylose to xylulose or of glucose to fructose. Proton exchange into water during enzyme-catalyzed isomerization of C-2 tritiated glucose at 15, 25 and 55 degrees C shows < 0.6% exchange (the loss of one proton in every billion turnovers). High concentrations of guanidine hydrochloride and extremes of pH had no effect on the amount of exchange detected. Such a low percentage of exchange is inconsistent with a proton-transfer mechanism as the main kinetic pathway for isomerization. 19F NMR experiments showed no release of fluoride after incubation of the enzyme for 4 weeks with 800 mM 3-deoxy-3-fluoroglucose or 3-deoxy-3-fluoroallose (both are competitive inhibitors with Ki values of 600 mM). This result is also inconsistent with a proton-transfer mechanism. A hydride-shift mechanism following ring opening has been proposed for the isomerization. Enzyme-catalyzed ring opening was directly measured by demonstrating H2S release upon reaction of xylose isomerase with 1-thioglucose. D-Xylose isomerase-catalyzed interconversion of glucose to fructose exhibited linear Arrhenius behavior with an activation energy of 14 kcal/mol from 0 to 50 degrees C. No change in rate-determining step occurs over this temperature range. 13C NMR experiments with glucose show that enzyme-bound magnesium or manganese does not interact specifically with any one site on the sugar. These results are consistent with nonproductive binding modes for the substrate glucose in addition to productive binding.

On the deletion of inverted repeated DNA in Escherichia coli: effects of length, thermal stability, and cruciform formation in vivo.

We have studied the deletion of inverted repeats cloned into the EcoRI site within the CAT gene of plasmid pBR325. A cloned inverted repeat constitutes a palindrome that includes both EcoRI sites flanking the insert. In addition, the two EcoRI sites represent direct repeats flanking a region of palindromic symmetry. A current model for deletion between direct repeats involves the formation of DNA secondary structure which may stabilize the misalignment between the direct repeats during DNA replication. Our results are consistent with this model. We have analyzed deletion frequencies for several series of inverted repeats, ranging from 42 to 106 bp, that were designed to form cruciforms at low temperatures and at low superhelical densities. We demonstrate that length, thermal stability of base pairing in the hairpin stem, and ease of cruciform formation affect the frequency of deletion. In general, longer palindromes are less stable than shorter ones. The deletion frequency may be dependent on the thermal stability of base pairing involving approximately 16-20 bp from the base of the hairpin stem. The formation of cruciforms in vivo leads to a significant increase in the deletion frequency. A kinetic model is presented to describe the relationship between the physical-chemical properties of DNA structure and the deletion of inverted repeats in living cells.

Inhibition kinetics of acetylcholinesterase with fluoromethyl ketones.

A series of trifluoromethyl ketones that reversibly inhibit acetylcholinesterase and pseudocholinesterase were synthesized. By analogy to chymotrypsin and on the basis of data reported here, we propose that the active-site serine adds to the ketone to form an ionized hemiketal. The compound (5,5,5-trifluoro-4-oxopentyl)trimethylammonium bicarbonate (1) inhibits acetylcholinesterase with Ki = 0.06 X 10(-9)M and pseudocholinesterase with Ki = 70 X 10(-9)M. Replacement of the nitrogen of 1 by carbon (compound 2) increases Ki for 1 200-fold for acetylcholinesterase but does not significantly alter Ki for pseudocholinesterase. The Ki for the methyl ketone corresponding to 2 is 2 X 10(-4)M for both enzymes, as compared with 12 X 10(-9)M for the trifluoromethyl ketone (acetylcholinesterase). For both enzymes, a linear decrease in log Ki with decreasing pK of the inhibitor hydrate was observed with ketones containing from 0 to 3 fluorines. We attribute this effect to the stabilization of the hemiketal oxyanion. The reduction of the pK of the hemiketal by the trifluoromethyl group is an important contributing factor to the low Ki of trifluoromethyl ketones. The inhibition of acetylcholinesterase by tetramethylammonium chloride and trifluoroacetone was compared to the inhibition by 1, which is a composite of the two smaller inhibitors. The entropic advantage of combining the smaller inhibitors into one molecule is 1.1 X 10(3)M. Inhibitors with Ki less than or equal to 70 X 10(-9) M are slow binding (Morrison, 1982; Morrison & Walsh, 1988). The kinetic data do not require formation of a noncovalent complex prior to formation of the ketal, although such a complex(es) cannot be excluded.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Inhibition of pig liver esterase by trifluoromethyl ketones: modulators of the catalytic reaction alter inhibition kinetics.

The kinetics of substrate hydrolysis by pig liver esterase show activation by various substrates as well as activation by organic solvents (both Vmax and Km increase) [Barker, D.L., & Jencks, W.P. (1969) Biochemistry 8, 3890]. The trifluoromethyl ketones 1,1,1-trifluoro-4-phenylbutan-2-one (TPB) and 1,1,1-trifluoro-4-(p-hydroxyphenyl)butan-2-one (OH-TPB) are slow, tight binding inhibitors of pig liver esterase with Ki values of 6.8 X 10(-9) M and 6.0 X 10(-9) M, respectively. Acetonitrile, TPB, and OH-TPB as well as the substrates pNPA and ethyl lactate caused a 15-130-fold increase in the rate of association (kon), and dissociation (koff), of the enzyme--TPB complex. The value of Ki (koff/kon) did not change. The effect cannot be attributed to half-sites reactivity since an increase in koff of OH-TPB is also observed with enzyme monomers. The results are consistent with a model proposed for the catalytic reaction (Barker & Jencks, 1969) which invokes two binding sites on each esterase subunit, a catalytic site and an effector site. Occupation of the effector site can increase koff and kon for the inhibitors TPB and OH-TPB. Not all compounds which bind at the effector site increase koff. Butanol binds at the effector site but does not effect koff of TPB. The results also indicate that an aromatic or a hydrophobic structure and a carbonyl group are required for optimal interaction with the effector site.

Ammonia effects on microinvertebrates and fish in outdoor experimental streams.

Laboratory data on ammonia effects, the US EPA national water quality criteria for ammonia, and ammonia site-specific criteria were evaluated in four outdoor experimental streams (one control and three treatment streams) over a 76-week period. Calculated un-ionised ammonia concentrations varied daily and seasonally according to pH and temperature changes. Populations of four major microinvertebrate taxonomic groups (cladocerans, copepods, rotifers and protozoans) were monitored during a 4-week period early in the study, and six fish species (fathead minnows, bluegills, channel catfish, white suckers, walleyes, and rainbow trout) were tested for various time intervals, from 4 to 26 weeks, throughout the 76-week study period. Copepods and rotifers were unaffected in all three treatment streams, based on comparisons with the control stream. Cladoceran and protozoan populations were reduced in at least two treatment streams, but because of large variability, effects were considered to be inconclusive. However, complete mortality of cladocerans did occur in the high and medium treatments when placed in in situ biomonitor chambers. All six fish species were affected in one or more treatments. Generally, the fish effect values agreed with most laboratory effect values. Of 12 fish groups tested, one channel catfish group and one white sucker group were affected below the recommended protection levels of the national and site-specific criteria. The lowest effect concentrations tested for the other ten groups occurred above the criteria levels.