Experimental Medicine for HIV Vaccine Research and Development.

The development of safe and effective HIV vaccines has been a scientific challenge for more than 40 years. Despite disappointing results from efficacy clinical trials, much has been learnt from years of research and development. In a rapidly evolving HIV prevention landscape, swift evaluation of multiple vaccine approaches eliciting cross-reactive humoral and cellular responses is needed to ensure the development of efficacious vaccine candidates. To contain increasing costs, innovative clinical research methods are required. Experimental medicine has the potential to accelerate vaccine discovery by iterating early stages of clinical testing faster and by selecting the most promising immunogen combinations for further clinical evaluation. As part of its mission to unite diverse stakeholders involved in the response to the HIV epidemic, the Global HIV Vaccine Enterprise at IAS-the International AIDS Society-hosted a series of online events between January and September 2022 to discuss the merits and challenges of experimental medicine studies to accelerate the development of safe and effective HIV vaccines. This report summarizes key questions and discussions across the series of events, which brought together scientists, policy makers, community stakeholders, advocates, bioethicists, and funders.

A phase 2 study to evaluate the safety and immunogenicity of a recombinant HIV type 1 vaccine based on adeno-associated virus.

The recombinant vaccine, tgAAC09, based on an adeno-associated virus serotype 2 (AAV2) vector encoding HIV-1 subtype C Gag, protease, and part of reverse transcriptase, induced robust T cell and antibody responses in nonhuman primates. In a previous phase I study in 80 healthy HIV-seronegative European and Indian adults, the vaccine was generally safe, well tolerated, and modestly immunogenic when administered once at doses up to 3 x 10(11) DRP. This phase II double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial tested two administrations and a higher dosage of tgAAC009. Ninety-one healthy HIV-seronegative adults from three African countries were given one of three dosage levels of tgAAC09 (3 x 10(10), 3 x 10(11), or 3 x 10(12) DRP) intramuscularly, either at a 6- or 12-month interval; follow-up was 18 months. Overall, 65% and 57% of vaccine recipients experienced local and systemic signs and symptoms, respectively, most being mild. Frequency and severity were not dose related and were similar to those in placebo recipients. No vaccine-related serious adverse events were reported. Overall, HIV-specific T cell responses were detected by IFN-gamma ELISPOT in 17/69 (25%) vaccine recipients with 38% (10/26) responders in the highest dosage group. The response rate improved significantly with boosting at 6, but not 12 months, in the 3 x 10(11) and 3 x 10(12) dosage groups only. Neutralizing antibody titers to the AAV2 did not alter the frequency of immune responses to HIV. Two doses of tgAAC09 were well tolerated at the dosage levels given. Fewer than half the recipients of the highest vaccine dosage, 3 x 10(12) DRP, had T cell responses to HIV.

Single-joint outcome measures: preliminary validation of patient-reported outcomes and physical examination.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the validity, responsiveness, and reliability of single-joint outcome measures for determining target joint (TJ) response in patients with inflammatory arthritis. METHODS: Patient-reported outcomes (PRO), consisting of responses to single questions about TJ global status on a 100-mm visual analog scale (VAS; TJ global score), function on a 100-mm VAS (TJ function score), and pain on a 5-point Likert scale (TJ pain score) were piloted in 66 inflammatory arthritis subjects in a phase 1/2 clinical study of an intraarticular gene transfer agent and compared to physical examination measures (TJ swelling, TJ tenderness) and validated function questionnaires (Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand scale, Rheumatoid Arthritis Outcome Score, and the Health Assessment Questionnaire). Construct validity was assessed by evaluating the correlation between the single-joint outcome measures and validated function questionnaires using Spearman's rank correlation. Responsiveness or sensitivity to change was assessed through calculating effect size and standardized response means (SRM). Reliability of physical examination measures was assessed by determining interobserver agreement. RESULTS: The single-joint PRO were highly correlated with each other and correlated well with validated functional measures. The TJ global score exhibited modest effect size and modest SRM that correlated well with the patient's assessment of response on a 100-mm VAS. Physical examination measures exhibited high interrater reliability, but correlated less well with validated functional measures and the patient's assessment of response. CONCLUSION: Single-joint PRO, particularly the TJ global score, are simple to administer and demonstrate construct validity and responsiveness in patients with inflammatory arthritis. (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier NCT00126724).

Safety, tolerability, and clinical outcomes after intraarticular injection of a recombinant adeno-associated vector containing a tumor necrosis factor antagonist gene: results of a phase 1/2 Study.

OBJECTIVE: To assess safety and clinical outcomes in patients with inflammatory arthritis after intraarticular (IA) injection of rAAV2-TNFR:Fc, a recombinant adeno-associated viral vector containing the human tumor necrosis factor (TNF) receptor-immunoglobulin (IgG1) Fc fusion (TNFR:Fc) gene. METHODS: In this phase 1/2 randomized study, adults with persistent moderate or severe inflammation in a target joint, being treated with or without systemic anti-TNF therapy, received a single IA injection of either rAAV2-TNFR:Fc (1 x 10(11), 1 x 10(12), or 1 x 10(13) DNase-resistant particles/ml joint volume) or placebo, followed by open-label rAAV2-TNFR:Fc 12-30 weeks later, depending on when the target joint met predetermined criteria for reinjection. RESULTS: 127 subjects received the first injection of blinded study drug; 95 subjects received open-label rAAV2-TNFR:Fc. Administration site reactions, consisting of transient mild to moderate increases in tenderness and swelling of the injected joint, occurred after 23/191 (12%) rAAV2-TNFR:Fc injections and were dose-dependent. Rates of other adverse events were not dose-dependent. Notable serious adverse events (SAE) included culture-negative septic arthritis in a subject receiving leflunomide and fatal disseminated histoplasmosis considered unrelated to rAAV2-TNFR:Fc in a subject receiving adalimumab. In the phase 2 portion of the study, a 30% decrease in target joint global visual analog scale was observed in 21/50 (42%) rAAV2-TNFR:Fc subjects and 3/16 (19%) placebo subjects 12 weeks after first injection (p = 0.14). CONCLUSION: IA rAAV2-TNFR:Fc resulted in administration site reactions after 12% of injections. A fatal SAE, disseminated histoplasmosis, was considered not related to study agent. Patient-reported outcome measures of clinical response showed greater improvement in treated patients than placebo patients.

Redox modifier genes and pathways in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.

Enhanced redox-stress caused by neuroinflammation, mitochondria, and NADPH oxidases has been hypothesized to play critical roles in disease progression of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). However, distinguishing whether the redox-stress observed in ALS is due to a primary defect in cellular reactive oxygen species metabolism/catabolism, or is a secondary consequence of neuroinflammation, has been difficult and the issue remains a matter of debate. Emerging evidence suggests that defects in genes that regulate NADPH oxidases may account for at least some forms of ALS. NADPH oxidases are key signaling complexes that influence cellular responses to growth factors and cytokines. In this context, NADPH oxidase-derived reactive oxygen species exert spatial control over the redox-dependent activation of certain pro-inflammatory receptors. Understanding the biology of how NADPH oxidases control cell signaling may help to clarify how genetic determinants of ALS lead to dysregulated pro-inflammatory signaling. This review provides a framework for understanding endosomal signaling through NADPH oxidases and potential mechanisms whereby gene defects in various forms of ALS may influence this cellular process and lead to motor neuron degeneration. Lastly, this review discusses past and current efforts to treat ALS using antioxidant therapies, as well as the limitations and advantages of each of these approaches.

A phase 1 study to evaluate the safety and immunogenicity of a recombinant HIV type 1 subtype C adeno-associated virus vaccine.

A novel prophylactic AIDS vaccine candidate, consisting of single-stranded DNA for HIV-1 subtype C gag, protease, and part of reverse transcriptase genes, enclosed within a recombinant adeno-associated virus serotype-2 protein capsid (tgAAC09) induced T cell responses and antibodies in nonhuman primates. In this randomized, dose escalation phase I trial, HIV-uninfected healthy volunteers (50 in Europe, 30 in India) received a single intramuscular injection of tgAAC09 at 3 x 10(9) DNase resistant particles (DRP) (n = 16), 3 x 10(10) DRP (n = 23), 3 x 10(11) DRP (n = 25), or placebo (n = 16). Twenty-one participants in Europe received a second (boost) dose of 3 x 10(11) DRP tgAAC09 or placebo at least 24 weeks after the first injection. The vaccine was safe and well-tolerated after initial and boost vaccination. Local and systemic reactogenicity was experienced by 13-25% of participants and was not dose related. No vaccine-related serious adverse events were reported. Modest HIV-specific T cell responses were detected in 7/64 vaccinees (40-385 SFC/10(6) PBMC), with 16% (4/25) responders in the highest dose group. All responses were to Gag epitopes. tgAAC09 appears to be safe, well-tolerated, and modestly immunogenic. Further evaluation of higher doses of tgAAC09 and boost injections is ongoing in Africa.

Calculating expected lung deposition of aerosolized administration of AAV vector in human clinical studies.

BACKGROUND: Cystic fibrosis is an autosomal recessive disease affecting approximately 1 in 2500 live births. Introducing the cDNA that codes for normal cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) to the small airways of the lung could result in restoring the CFTR function. A number of vectors for lung gene therapy have been tried and adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors offer promise. The vector is delivered to the lung using a breath-actuated jet nebulizer. The purpose of this project was to determine the aerosolized AAV (tgAAVCF) particle size distribution (PSD) in order to calculate target doses for lung delivery. METHODS: A tgAAVCF solution was nebulized using the Pari LC Plus (n = 3), and the PSD was determined by coupling laser diffraction and inertial impaction (NGI) techniques. The NGI allowed for quantification of the tgAAVCF at each stage of impaction, ensuring that rAAV-CFTR vector is present and not empty particles. Applying the results to mathematical algorithms allowed for the calculation of expected pulmonary deposition. RESULTS: The mass median diameter (MMD) for the tgAAVCF was 2.78 +/- 0.43 microm. If the system works ideally and the patient only receives aerosol on inspiration, the patient would receive 47 +/- 0% of the initial dose placed in the nebulizer, with 72 +/- 0.73% of this being deposited beyond the vocal cords. CONCLUSIONS: This technology for categorizing the pulmonary delivery system for lung gene therapy vectors can be adapted for advanced aerosol delivery systems or other vectors.

Safety characterization of HeLa-based cell substrates used in the manufacture of a recombinant adeno-associated virus-HIV vaccine.

The use of transformed cell substrates for prophylactic vaccine manufacturing is widely debated. Extensive characterization is required to address the suitability of neoplastic cell substrates for vaccine manufacture. The HeLa-based cell substrate used in the manufacture of a prophylactic rAAV-HIV vaccine, AAV2-gagPR delta RT (tgAAC09) was tested in vivo for its tumor-forming potential, the oncogenic potential of its high molecular weight DNA and the potential presence of occult oncogenic adventitious agents. This data from these in vivo studies, in conjunction with prion gene and protein characterization, cell and viral clearance studies and quantity of residual host-cell DNA levels in the purified tgAAC09 vaccine, were used to establish what we believe to be an acceptable safety profile for the vaccine manufacturing process. The tumor-producing dose in 50% of the animals was consistent with that in a published report from FDA staff for HeLa cells. High molecular weight cellular DNA was not oncogenic and no occult oncogenic agents were detected by testing in nude mice and newborn rodent models, respectively. Endogenous prion protein was also normal and genomic sequence analysis detected no mutations associated with increased risk of prion disease. In addition, the purification process used to produce this vaccine candidate removed all detectable cells (clearance of greater than 22 log10), viral clearance study showed 6-17 log10 clearance of three model viruses and host-cell DNA in the bulk product was less than 100pg host-cell DNA per dose of 3 x 10(11) DNase resistant particles (DRP) of the vaccine. Taken together, the data from the in vivo and in vitro tests that were performed to characterize the HeLa based producer cell line (T3B12-5B) and HeLa S3 cells support the use of these cells as substrates for the manufacture of a purified rAAV-HIV vaccine candidate. The data also supports the ability of the process, employing the HeLa cell substrate, used to manufacture the rAAV-HIV vaccine to produce a product as free of adventitious agents as current testing procedures can document. Safety of the rAAV-HIV vaccine is currently being assessed in a Phase I clinical trial.

In vivo efficacy of folate-targeted lipid-protamine-DNA (LPD-PEG-Folate) complexes in an immunocompetent syngeneic model for breast adenocarcinoma.

Gene therapy utilizing lipid-based delivery systems holds tremendous promise for the treatment of cancer. However, due to the potential adverse inflammatory and/or immune effects upon systemic administration, treatments thus far have been predominantly limited to intratumoral or regional treatment. Previous studies from our group have demonstrated the antitumor efficacy of systemically administered, folate-targeted, lipid-protamine-DNA complexes (LPD-PEG-Folate) against breast cancer using an immunodeficient xenogenic murine model. In the current study, the antitumor efficacy of LPD-PEG-Folate in a syngeneic, immune competent, murine model of breast cancer was examined. In this model, the potential inflammatory or immune responses and their effects on systemic delivery can be addressed. The 410.4 murine breast adenocarcinoma cell line was initially evaluated in vitro for its interactions with LPD-PEG-Folate and control LPD-PEG formulations. Utilizing fluorescently labeled formulations and fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) analysis, a 1.6-fold enhancement of binding and internalization of LPD-PEG-Folate over LPD-PEG formulations was observed, suggestive of specific receptor interaction. Increased binding was manifested as 5-26-fold increases in luciferase gene expression in 410.4 cell transfection when comparing LPD-PEG-Folate to LPD-PEG. Moreover, in vivo treatment of 410.4 breast tumors in BALB/c mice with i.v. injected LPD-PEG-Folate delivering the HSV-1 thymidine kinase (TK) gene, in combination with gancyclovir treatment, resulted in a significant reduction in mean tumor volume (260.1 mm3) compared to the LPD-PEG-TK (914.1 mm3), as well as the vehicle (749.7 mm3) and untreated (825.3 mm3) control groups (day 25, P<.019). In addition to a reduced tumor volume, LPD-PEG-Folate-TK treatment also increased median survival from 25 days in the nontargeted LPD-PEG-TK groups to 31 days (P=.0011), which correlated with the termination of treatment. Together, these results demonstrate that in the context of a fully functional immune system, LPD-PEG-Folate-TK treatment possesses significant specific antitumor efficacy and the potential for further preclinical development.

Targeting of lipid-protamine-DNA (LPD) lipopolyplexes using RGD motifs.

The incorporation of pegylated lipid into Lipid-Protamine-DNA (LPD-PEG) lipopolyplexes causes a decrease of their in vitro transfection activity. This can be partially attributed to a reduction in particle binding to cells. To restore particle binding and specifically target LPD formulations to tumor cells, the lipid-peptide conjugate DSPE-PEG5K-succinyl-ACDCRGDCFCG-COOH (DSPE-PEG5K-RGD-4C) was generated and incorporated into LPD formulations (LPD-PEG-RGD). LPD-PEG-RGD was characterized with respect to its biophysical and biological properties. The Incorporation of DSPE-PEG5K-RGD-4C ligands into LPD formulations results in a 5 and a 15 fold increase in the LPD-PEG-RGD binding and uptake, respectively, over an LPD-PEG formulation. Enhancement of binding and uptake resulted in a 100 fold enhancement of transfection activity. Moreover, this transfection enhancement was specific to cells expressing appropriate integrin receptors (MDA-MB-231). Huh7 cells, known for their low level of alphavbeta3 and alphavbeta5 integrin expression, failed to show RGD mediated transfection enhancement. This transfection enhancement can be abolished in a competitive manner using free RGD peptide, but not an RGE control peptide. Results demonstrated RGD mediated enhanced LPD-PEG cell binding and transfection in cells expressing the integrin receptor. These formulations provide the basis for effective, targeted, systemic gene delivery.

Systemic gene therapy in human xenograft tumor models by liposomal delivery of the E1A gene.

The adenovirus type 5 E1A protein has been demonstrated to elicit antitumor effects through the induction of apoptosis, inhibition of cell cycle progression, induction of differentiated epithelial phenotypes, repression of oncogene expression and function, and sensitization to chemotherapeutic agents and radiation. These unique properties have led to use of the E1A gene in adenoviral and lipid-based gene therapy systems, and it has demonstrated antitumor effects in tumor xenograft model systems. However, the delivery systems used in those studies are best suited for local or intratumoral delivery rather than systemic delivery. Because the effective treatment of many primary tumors as well as metastatic disease requires systemic delivery systems, a novel gene delivery system composed of liposome/protamine/DNA (LPD) was investigated for systemic delivery of the E1A gene. Athymic nude mice bearing human breast (MDA-MB-361) or head and neck (WSUHN-31) tumor xenografts were treated i.v. with LPD-E1A, and the expression of E1A protein and effects on tumor growth were assessed. In the MDA-MB-361 breast model, expression of E1A protein was detected in the tumors after LPD-E1A treatment, which was associated with down-regulation of HER-2/neu protein expression and the presence of apoptotic cells. Tumor volume was also smaller in mice treated with LPD-E1A than in controls in both of the xenograft models. Lastly, LPD-E1A in combination with paclitaxel was more effective than LPD-E1A or paclitaxel alone in the MDA-MB-361 model. Additional preclinical and clinical development of LPD-E1A is warranted for the treatment of advanced or metastatic cancer.

A multicenter phase II study of tgDCC-E1A for the intratumoral treatment of patients with recurrent head and neck squamous cell carcinoma.

BACKGROUND: The anti-cancer gene, E1A, can be complexed to a lipid carrier, DC-Cholesterol:DOPE, to form tgDCC-E1A, which can be injected directly into tumors. METHODS: Twenty-four patients with recurrent, unresectable, head and neck cancer were treated with intratumoral injections of tgDCC-E1A over 8 weeks. Tumor response was assessed using CT scans. Time to progression and overall survival were calculated. RESULTS: Intratumoral tgDCC-E1A was well tolerated in all patients. No significant toxicities related to tgDCC-E1A were reported. One patient (4.2%) had a complete response, two patients (8.3%) had minor response, and seven patients (29.2%) had stable disease by two-dimensional cross-products on blinded CT scans. The median time to progression was 8.6 weeks (range, 3.3-43.7 weeks), and median survival was 4.6 months (range, 1.3-15.6 months). CONCLUSIONS: Intratumoral injections of tgDCC-E1A were safe and well tolerated. Modest tumor response was observed. Further development of tgDCC-E1A is warranted in combination with other treatment modalities.