To mesh or not mesh "apical prolapse," that is the question!

Surgical approaches for pelvic organ prolapse have evolved over the last 30 years and is a popular topic for debate, particularly when discussing apical prolapse. Transvaginal native tissue repairs remain the mainstay of POP surgeries, however, transabdominal approaches continue to evolve. Use of interposition material, such as synthetic polypropylene mesh, is the standard when performing an abdominal sacrocolpopexy, however, use of autologous fascia can be considered. This debate article provides an overview of this subject and highlights the value of different approaches to apical prolapse. The authors were asked to support their approach in various scenarios including:extremes of age, prior hysterectomy and intact uterus, desire to avoid mesh, sexual activity, and presence of comorbidities. In discussing common patient scenarios, ultimate decision making on specific POP surgeries is determined by patient preference and goals.

A Primer for Primary Care Physicians Managing Neurogenic Bladder Patients.

Primary care plays an important role in caring for neurogenic bladder patients. Clinicians should assess neurogenic bladder patients for common urologic symptoms/signs and refer to urology if refractory or safety issues are identified.

Practice Readiness? Trends in Chief Resident Year Training Experience Across 13 Residency Programs.

INTRODUCTION: Urology residency prepares trainees for independent practice. The optimal operative chief resident year experience to prepare for practice is undefined. We analyzed the temporal arc of cases residents complete during their residency compared to their chief year in a multi-institutional cohort. METHODS: Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education case logs of graduating residents from 2010 to 2022 from participating urology residency programs were aggregated. Resident data for 5 categorized index procedures were recorded: (1) general urology, (2) endourology, (3) reconstructive urology, (4) urologic oncology, and (5) pediatric urology. Interactions were tested between the trends for total case exposure in residency training relative to the chief resident year. RESULTS: From a sample of 479 resident graduates, a total of 1,287,433 total cases were logged, including 375,703 during the chief year (29%). Urologic oncology cases had the highest median percentage completed during chief year (56%) followed by reconstructive urology (27%), general urology (24%), endourology (17%), and pediatric urology (2%). Across the study period, all categories of cases had a downward trend in median percentage completed during chief year except for urologic oncology. However, only trends in general urology (slope of -0.68, P = .013) and endourology (slope of -1.71, P ≤ .001) were significant. CONCLUSIONS: Over 50% of cases completed by chief residents are urologic oncology procedures. Current declining trends indicate that residents are being exposed to proportionally fewer general urology and endourology cases during their chief year prior to entering independent practice.

Diversity in Urology, Are We Moving in the Right Direction?: Analysis of American Urologic Association Urology Residency Match Statistics 2019-2023.

Analysis of the urology match statistics provides a window into the future of the urology workforce. Match statistics from 2019 to 2023 were analyzed to determine whether the efforts to promote diversity in 2020 have been impactful. The popularity in the field of urology among all racial/ethnic groups peaked interest in application in 2022. However despite an increase in URIM applicants over the last 5 years, 2023 URM applicants have 1/3 the odds of matching into urology as white applicants.

Genital Sparing Robot-Assisted Radical Cystectomy with Intracorporeal Neobladder & Paravaginal Repair.

OBJECTIVE: Vaginal prolapse is a known complication after radical cystectomy, requiring additional procedures in 10% of the patients.1 This results from loss of level I and II vaginal support due to the removal of pelvic structures. In addition, a neobladder urinary diversion, with Valsalva voiding, predisposes to vaginal prolapse. A genital-sparing approach with paravaginal repair can help prevent such complications. METHODS: The genital sparing technique preserves the uterus, fallopian tubes, ovaries, and vagina, while paravaginal repair involves suturing of the lateral vaginal wall to the arcuate fascia located on the medial aspect of the obturator internus muscle. The procedure begins by placing the patient in a lithotomy position, with a steep Trendelenburg. Standard 6 port cystectomy configuration is utilized with an additional 15 mm port for bowel anastomosis. Initially, the ureters and lateral bladder space are mobilized. Posteriorly a dissection plane is developed separating the bladder from the anterior vaginal wall. Distal dissection is carefully performed in that plane to avoid disrupting the urethral-external sphincter complex. Then the bladder is dropped from anterior attachments, the Dorsal venous complex (DVC) and bladder neck are exposed. Urethra is transected distal to the bladder neck, after circumferential mobilization, to complete the cystectomy, again avoiding disruption of the continence mechanism, and opening the endo-pelvic fascia. Cystectomy and pelvic lymph node dissection are completed in a standard fashion. The arcuate fascia is identified bilaterally for level I paravaginal repair. The lateral aspect of the paravaginal tissue is secured to this ligament, using 3 interrupted Polydioxanone (PDS) sutures, bilaterally. An ileal "Hautman's W pouch" neobladder is constructed using 50 cm of the small intestine, similar to the previously reported technique.2 Bricker-type uretero-ileal anastomosis is performed over a double J stent. Bowel continuity is restored by a side-to-side anastomosis using endo-GIA (gastrointestinal anastamosis EndoGIATM ) staplers. RESULTS: No intra or postoperative complications were noted. Robot dock time was 8 hours and 23 minutes with an EBL of 100 mL. The patient was discharged on post operative day (POD) 6 and Foley catheter with ureteral stents was removed on POD 27 after a cystogram confirmed no leaks. At 6-month follow-up, the patient reported good continence using a single pad, voiding every 3-4 hours. Fluoro-urodynamics demonstrated 651 mL capacity, low-pressure voiding, minimal residual urine, and no reflux. No prolapse was noted on fluoroscopy and pelvic examination with the Valsalva maneuver. The patient reported a good satisfaction level, regarding her urinary symptoms. CONCLUSION: We report satisfactory short-term outcomes of a feasible technique to prevent postcystectomy prolapse; however, long-term follow-up of a larger cohort can help establish its efficacy.

Who Is Shaping the Future of Academic Urology? A Descriptive Analysis of Residency Program Directors.

OBJECTIVE: To characterize the demographics, educational background, and scholarly characteristics of current urology residency program directors (PDs). METHODS: Urology programs were identified by the listing on the "Accredited US Urology Programs" section of American Urological Association website as of October 2021. Demographics and academic data were collected via publicly available department website and Google search engine. Metrics obtained included years of service as PD from time of appointment, sex, medical school/residency/fellowship, all-time H-index, dual degrees obtained, and professorial ranking. RESULTS: One hundred and forty-seven accredited urological residencies were reviewed; every PD was included. The majority were male (78%) and fellowship trained (68%). Women represented only 22% of PDs. The median active time served as PD, as of 11/2021, was 4years (IQR: 2-7). Forty (28%) were faculty at the same program they completed their residency. The median all-time H-index was 12 (IQR: 7-19; range 1-61). Twelve PDs also served as chair of their department. CONCLUSION: The vast majority of PDs are male, fellowship trained, and have served for less than 5years. Future studies are necessary to follow the trends of representation in leaders of urology residency programs.

Comparison of Urinary Tract Infection Incidence Following Intradetrusor OnabotulinumtoxinA in Office Versus Operating Room Settings.

IMPORTANCE: Urinary tract infection (UTI) is a known complication of intradetrusor onabotulinumtoxinA (BTX) injection. However, whether administering intradetrusor BTX in different clinical settings affects the risk of postprocedural UTI has not been investigated. OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to assess differences in the incidence of postprocedural UTI in women who received intradetrusor BTX in an outpatient office versus an operating room (OR). STUDY DESIGN: We performed a retrospective chart review of intradetrusor BTX procedures at a single institution between 2013 and 2020. Demographic data, comorbidities, and perioperative data were abstracted. The primary outcome was UTI defined as initiation of antibiotics within 30 days following BTX administration based on clinician assessment of symptoms and/or urine culture results. Univariate analysis of patients with and without UTI was performed. RESULTS: A total of 446 intradetrusor BTX procedures performed on female patients either in an outpatient office (n = 160 [35.9%]) or in an OR (n = 286 [64.1%]) were included in the analysis. Within 30 days of BTX administration, UTI was diagnosed after 14 BTX procedures (8.8%) in the office group and 29 BTX procedures (10.1%) in the OR group ( P = 0.633). De novo postprocedural urinary retention occurred in more women who were treated in the office than in the OR (13 [9.6%] vs 3 [1.3%], P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Selecting the appropriate setting for BTX administration is dependent on multiple factors. However, the clinical setting in which intradetrusor BTX is administered may not be an important factor in the development of postprocedural UTI, and further research is warranted.

Workforce Diversity in Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery: An Analysis of the American Urological Association Census Data.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the current state of workforce diversity in Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery (FPMRS) using the 2014-2019 American Urological Association (AUA) census data. MATERIALS: We evaluated FPMRS workforce diversity using the AUA census data from 2014 to 2019. Underrepresented in medicine (URiM) groups were categorized as individuals who self-identified as non-Hispanic Black/African American, Hispanic, Multiracial, and Other. The FPMRS workforce was then compared to the overall urologic workforce and the other urologic subspecialties (oncology, pediatric urology, and endourology) and assessed by AUA section. RESULTS: In 2019, 602 urologists self-identified as FPMRS providers. Of these 12.4% (n = 74) were categorized as URiM urologists compared to 8% of the overall urologic workforce. Women who represent 9.9% of all urologists were overrepresented in FPMRS workforce (46.5%). FPMRS had the largest proportion of URiM and women urologists when compared to the other subspecialty areas. CONCLUSION: The FPMRS urologic subspecialty has the highest percentage of women and URiM urologists compared to all other urologic subspecialty areas. Engagement initiatives and targeted programs may offer insights into this trend. Further research is required to determine the impact of such programs in attracting URiM and women to FPMRS.

Vaginal Free Graft Dorsal Onlay Urethroplasty.

OBJECTIVE: Female urethral stricture is a rare, but often underrecognized, cause of voiding dysfunction in females.1 Vaginal free graft urethroplasty has been shown to have good efficacy and durability in treating urethral stricture, though accessible descriptions of technique are not widely available.1,2 Accordingly, we set out to describe and demonstrate our technique for vaginal mucosal free graft dorsal onlay urethroplasty. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A fifty-one year old female with long-standing history of voiding dysfunction and incomplete emptying presented to our urology clinic, and was diagnosed with urethral stricture. Following evaluation to ensure adequate vaginal mucosal tissue, treatment with vaginal graft urethroplasty was offered. Tenets for success in performing vaginal free graft urethroplasty include adequate dorsal urethral dissection and mobilization, incision of entire length of stricture, removal of underlying fibromuscular tissue from graft, and tension-free anastomosis of graft to urethra. Appropriate selection of vaginal graft harvest site is key to avoid excessive narrowing of the vagina. RESULTS: In this patient, vaginal free graft urethroplasty provided a successful and durable treatment of her urethral stricture. Vaginal free graft urethroplasty is an approachable and reproducible technique for treating urethral stricture in a female, while avoiding the morbidity associated with buccal graft harvest. CONCLUSION: This video provides a step-by-step description of technique for performing vaginal free graft dorsal onlay urethroplasty to treat urethral stricture in a female.

High uterosacral ligament hysteropexy for the management of pelvic organ prolapse

ABSTRACT Objective: To demonstrate our transvaginal high uterosacral ligament (HUL) hysteropexy technique as an alternative mesh-free uterine-preserving pelvic organ prolapse (POP) repair approach and present our institutional outcomes. Concurrent hysterectomy with POP repair is controversial as uterine-preserving techniques may beneficially allow fertility, body image and sexual function preservation (1, 2). Materials and Methods: This video illustrates a step-by-step sequence of our HUL hysteropexy technique in a symptomatic Stage III POP patient. Retrospective single-institution, single-surgeon analysis of patients treated by either HUL hysteropexy or hysterectomy with HUL suspension for symptomatic prolapse was performed with minimum 2 years of follow-up. Patient demographics, operative characteristics, pre and post-operative POP-Q evaluation, American Urological Association Symptom scores (AUASS) and post-operative Pelvic Floor Distress Inventory (PFDI-20) were compared. Results: Surgery time was 3 hours 24 minutes. No immediate/early complications were noted, with successful repair on follow-up. Outcomes of 18 patients (10 HUL hysteropexy, 8 hysterectomy and HUL suspension) were assessed (Supplemental Table). The only baseline difference was a lower body mass index in the HUL hysteropexy cohort (25.8 vs. 35.8kg/m2, p=0.008). In the HUL hysteropexy cohort, blood loss (mean: 58 vs. 205ml, p=0.00086) and operative time (190.4 vs. 279.1minutes, p=0.0021) were significantly reduced. There was no difference in post-operative AUASS, POP-Q or PFDI-20 at 2 years. Conclusion: We present our HUL hysteropexy technique. Although limited by sample size and retrospective design, resulted in significantly reduced blood loss and operative time with comparable post-operative 2 year outcomes to non-uterine-preserving techniques. In our opinion, HUL hysteropexy is a safe, durable POP management option for women without significant endometrial pathology risk factors.

Best Approaches to Evaluation and Feedback in Post-Graduate Medical Education.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The objectives of this literature review are to appraise current approaches and assess new technologies that have been utilized for evaluation and feedback of residents, with focus on surgical trainees. RECENT FINDINGS: In 1999, the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education introduced the Milestone system as a tool for summative evaluation. The organization allows individual program autonomy on how evaluation and feedback are performed. In the past, questionnaire evaluations and informal verbal feedback were employed. However, with the advent of technology, they have taken a different shape in the form of crowdsourcing, mobile platforms, and simulation. Limited data is available on new methods but studies show promise citing low cost and positive impact on resident education. No one "best approach" exists for evaluation and feedback. However, it is apparent that a multimodal approach that is based on the ACGME Milestones can be effective and aid in guiding programs.

Contemporary multicenter outcomes of continent cutaneous ileocecocystoplasty in the adult population over a 10-year period: A Neurogenic Bladder Research Group study.

AIMS: Evidence is sparse on the long-term outcomes of continent cutaneous ileocecocystoplasty (CCIC). We hypothesized that obesity, laparoscopic/robotic approach, and concomitant surgeries would affect morbidity after CCIC and aimed to evaluate the outcomes of CCIC in adults in a multicenter contemporary study. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed the charts of adult patients from sites in the Neurogenic Bladder Research Group undergoing CCIC (2007-2017) who had at least 6 months of follow-up. We evaluated patient demographics, surgical details, 90-day complications, and follow-up surgeries. the Mann-Whitney U test was used to compare continuous variables and χ² and Fisher's Exact tests were used to compare categorical variables. RESULTS: We included 114 patients with a median age of 41 years. The median postoperative length of stay was 8 days. At 3 months postoperatively, major complications occurred in 18 (15.8%), and 24 patients (21.1%) were readmitted. During a median follow-up of 40 months, 48 patients (42.1%) underwent 80 additional related surgeries. Twenty-three patients (20.2%) underwent at least one channel revision, most often due to obstruction (15, 13.2%) or incontinence (4, 3.5%). Of the channel revisions, 10 (8.8%) were major and 14 (12.3%) were minor. Eleven patients (9.6%) abandoned the catheterizable channel during the follow-up period. Obesity and laparoscopic/robotic surgical approach did not affect outcomes, though concomitant surgery was associated with a higher rate of follow-up surgeries. CONCLUSIONS: In this contemporary multicenter series evaluating CCIC, we found that the short-term major complication rate was low, but many patients require follow-up surgeries, mostly related to the catheterizable channel.

Managing Urology Consultations During COVID-19 Pandemic: Application of a Structured Care Pathway.

OBJECTIVE: To describe and evaluate a risk-stratified triage pathway for inpatient urology consultations during the SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) pandemic. This pathway seeks to outline a urology patient care strategy that reduces the transmission risk to both healthcare providers and patients, reduces the healthcare burden, and maintains appropriate patient care. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Consultations to the urology service during a 3-week period (March 16 to April 2, 2020) were triaged and managed via one of 3 pathways: Standard, Telemedicine, or High-Risk. Standard consults were in-person consults with non COVID-19 patients, High-Risk consults were in-person consults with COVID-19 positive/suspected patients, and Telemedicine consults were telephonic consults for low-acuity urologic issues in either group of patients. Patient demographics, consultation parameters and consultation outcomes were compared to consultations from the month of March 2019. Categorical variables were compared using Chi-square test and continuous variables using Mann-Whitney U test. A P value <.05 was considered significant. RESULTS: Between March 16 and April 2, 2020, 53 inpatient consultations were performed. By following our triage pathway, a total of 19/53 consultations (35.8%) were performed via Telemedicine with no in-person exposure, 10/53 consultations (18.9%) were High-Risk, in which we strictly controlled the urology team member in-person contact, and the remainder, 24/53 consultations (45.2%), were performed as Standard in-person encounters. COVID-19 associated consultations represented 18/53 (34.0%) of all consultations during this period, and of these, 8/18 (44.4%) were managed successfully via Telemedicine alone. No team member developed COVID-19 infection. CONCLUSION: During the COVID-19 pandemic, most urology consultations can be managed in a patient and physician safety-conscious manner, by implementing a novel triage pathway.

Business and Practice Readiness of Early Career Urologists: an Unmet Need.

INTRODUCTION: Business education in surgical residency, defined as contract negotiation, investing, financial planning and information on practice types, is currently lacking, and it is unknown if early career urologists possess this business education. Thus, we investigated how young urologists perceive their business knowledge and which vehicles of education they most prefer. METHODS: A 12-question survey was distributed to all urology residents, fellows and recent graduates to assess their self-reported business preparedness. Questions were administered concerning financial planning, familiarity with business models, ancillary income opportunities, coding and billing, contract negotiation, and awareness/use of AUA (American Urological Association) resources. Data were stratified by training year and practice type. The respondents were also asked their most preferred format for business education. RESULTS: A response rate of 10% was obtained with 230 total responses, including 89 (38.7%) from practicing urologists and 141 (61.3%) from trainees. The majority (88.3%) of respondents were not comfortable planning the business side of their practice and 71% were not aware of the AUA resources. Only 8% of practicing urologists and trainees were extremely comfortable with contract negotiation and 70% were not comfortable with assessing their own financial value. A majority was interested in podcasts, websites and online education. CONCLUSIONS: The survey results demonstrate a significant unmet need among early career urologists regarding business education. This self-reported lack of business literacy presents a blind spot in urological training. The development of an accessible business curriculum along with practical resources may have a vital role in the promotion of wellness and financial success among early career urologists.

Outcomes of Intradetrusor Onabotulinum Toxin A Therapy in Overactive Bladder Refractory to Sacral Neuromodulation.

PURPOSE: Intradetrusor onabotulinum toxin A (BTXA) and sacral neuromodulation (SNM) are effective third-line therapies for overactive bladder (OAB). We aimed to measure the outcomes of BTXA for treatment of OAB refractory to initial SNM and identify patient characteristics associated with these outcomes. METHODS: This retrospective cohort study included patients who failed to respond to initial SNM treatment for OAB and subsequently received BTXA at a single provider's clinic between January 2013 and December 2016. Treatment successes were defined as patients willing to continue BTXA or who found symptom relief whereas treatment failures discontinued BTXA due to adverse effects or lack of symptom relief. Symptoms and patient-reported outcomes on validated questionnaires were compared before the initial BTXA trial to 2 months after the last BTXA treatment. The SNM failure BTXA groups were also compared to BTXA SNM naïve groups. RESULTS: Of 18 patients who received BTXA after failed SNM treatment, 7 (39%) achieved treatment success. Successfully treated patients demonstrated decreased urinary frequency from a median 11 voids/day pre-BTXA to 8 voids/day with BTXA (P=0.042). Patients whose treatment failed reported increased complaints of a weak urinary stream (P=0.03) and higher frequency of straining to urinate (P=0.016) than the successful treatment group pre-BTXA. Compared to BTXA patients without prior SNM, the odds of failing BTXA after initial SNM were 3.6 times higher (P=0.016). CONCLUSION: BTXA appears effective for OAB refractory to SNM, although the success rate is lower compared to BTXA patients without SNM exposure.

Bladder Augmentation (Enterocystoplasty): the Current State of a Historic Operation.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The goal of this paper was to evaluate the current use of enterocystoplasty, a historical operation for bladder dysfunction but with continued and increasing modern relevance. RECENT FINDINGS: Since the advent of third line neuromodulation techniques for neurogenic and idiopathic overactive bladder (OAB), the usage of enterocystoplasty has decreased. However, this procedure continues to be utilized in pediatric urology patients and the most refractory OAB patients. Adult urologist should be familiar with this operative technique in an effort to manage pediatric patients transitioning to adulthood. Minimally invasive techniques for this surgical procedure have been described with very limited outcome data. It is important for all urologists to be familiar with enterocystoplasty, both technically and with the unique needs of these patients postoperatively. Further studies evaluating the outcomes of this procedure in idiopathic overactive bladder patients and efforts to standardize recommendations for neurogenic bladder patients will help guide care in the future.