Practical guide to the Idea, Development and Exploration stages of the IDEAL Framework and Recommendations.

BACKGROUND: Evaluation of new surgical procedures is a complex process challenged by evolution of technique, operator learning curves, the possibility of variable procedural quality, and strong treatment preferences among patients and clinicians. Preliminary studies that address these issues are needed to prepare for a successful randomized trial. The IDEAL (Idea, Development, Exploration, Assessment and Long-term follow-up) Framework and Recommendations provide an integrated step-by-step evaluation pathway that can help investigators achieve this. METHODS: A practical guide was developed for investigators evaluating new surgical interventions in the earlier phases before a randomized trial (corresponding to stages 1, 2a and 2b of the IDEAL Framework). The examples and practical tips included were chosen and agreed upon by consensus among authors with experience either in designing and conducting IDEAL format studies, or in helping others to design such studies. They address the most common challenges encountered by authors attempting to follow the IDEAL Recommendations. RESULTS: A decision aid has been created to help identify the IDEAL stage of an innovation from literature reports, with advice on how to design and report the IDEAL study formats discussed, along with the ethical and scientific rationale for specific recommendations. CONCLUSION: The guide helps readers and researchers to understand and implement the IDEAL Framework and Recommendations to improve the quality of evidence supporting surgical innovation.

Establishing a clinic-based pancreatic cancer and periampullary tumour research registry in Quebec.

BACKGROUND: Enrolling patients in studies of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (pdac) is challenging because of the high fatality of the disease. We hypothesized that a prospective clinic-based study with rapid ascertainment would result in high participation rates. Using that strategy, we established the Quebec Pancreas Cancer Study (qpcs) to investigate the genetics and causes of pdac and other periampullary tumours (pats) that are also rare and underrepresented in research studies. METHODS: Patients diagnosed with pdac or pat were introduced to the study at their initial clinical encounter, with a strategy to enrol participants within 2 weeks of diagnosis. Patient self-referrals and referrals of unaffected individuals with an increased risk of pdac were also accepted. Family histories, epidemiologic and clinical data, and biospecimens were collected. Additional relatives were enrolled in families at increased genetic risk. RESULTS: The first 346 completed referrals led to 306 probands being enrolled, including 190 probands affected with pdac, who represent the population focus of the qpcs. Participation rates were 88.4% for all referrals and 89.2% for pdac referrals. Family history, epidemiologic and clinical data, and biospecimens were ascertained from 91.9%, 54.6%, and 97.5% respectively of patients with pdac. Although demographics and trends in risk factors in our patients were consistent with published statistics for patients with pdac, the qpcs is enriched for families with French-Canadian ancestry (37.4%), a population with recurrent germ-line mutations in hereditary diseases. CONCLUSIONS: Using rapid ascertainment, a pdac and pat research registry with high participation rates can be established. The qpcs is a valuable research resource and its enrichment with patients of French-Canadian ancestry provides a unique opportunity for studies of heredity in these diseases.

Magnitude of change in alpha-fetoprotein in response to transarterial chemoembolization predicts survival in patients undergoing liver transplantation for hepatocellular carcinoma.

BACKGROUND: Downsizing strategies are often attempted for patients with hepatocellular carcinoma (hcc) before liver transplantation (lt). The objective of the present study was to determine clinical predictors of favourable survival outcomes after transarterial chemoembolization (tace) before lt for hcc outside the Milan criteria, so as to better select candidates for this strategy. METHODS: In this retrospective study, patients with hcc tumours either beyond Milan criteria (single lesion > 5 cm, 3 lesions with 1 or more > 3 cm) or at the upper limit of Milan criteria (single lesions between 4.1 cm and 5.0 cm), with a predicted waiting time of more than 3 months, received carboplatin-based tace treatments. Exclusion criteria for tace included Child-Pugh C cirrhosis or the presence of portal vein invasion or extrahepatic disease on imaging. Only patients without tumour progression after tace underwent lt. RESULTS: Of 160 hcc patients who received liver grafts between 1997 and 2010, 35 were treated with tace preoperatively. The median of the sum of tumour diameters was 6.7 cm (range: 4.8-8.5 cm), which decreased with tace to 5.0 cm (range: 3.3-7.0 cm) at transplantation (p < 0.0004). The percentage drop in alpha-fetoprotein (αfp) was a positive predictor (p = 0.0051) and the time from last tace treatment to transplantation was a negative predictor (p < 0.0001) for overall survival. CONCLUSIONS: The percentage drop in αfp and a shorter time from the final tace treatment to transplantation significantly predicted improved overall survival after lt for hcc downsized with tace. As a serum marker, αfp should be followed when tace is used as a strategy to stabilize or downsize hcc lesions before lt.

Randomised clinical trial: MRCP-first vs. ERCP-first approach in patients with suspected biliary obstruction due to bile duct stones.

BACKGROUND: The preferred initial investigation with either magnetic resonance (MRCP) or endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) in patients with suspected biliary obstruction remains controversial in many clinical settings. AIM: To assess the effectiveness of an initial MRCP vs. ERCP in the work-up of patients at moderate likelihood of a suspected biliary obstruction. METHODS: Patients with an unconfirmed benign biliary obstruction, based on laboratory and ultrasound findings, were randomised to an ERCP-first or MRCP-first strategy, stratified by level of obstruction. The primary outcome was the occurrence of a disease or procedure-related bilio-pancreatic adverse events within the next 12 months. Secondary outcomes were the number of subsequent bilio-pancreatic procedures, duration of hospitalisation, days away from activities of daily living (ADL), quality of life (SF-36) and mortality. RESULTS: We randomised 126 patients to ERCP-first and 131 to MRCP-first (age 54 ± 18 years, 62% female, 39% post-cholecystectomy). In follow-up, 18/126 (14.3%) ERCP-first and 25/131 (19.1%) MRCP-first patients experienced a procedure- or disease-related complication (P = 0.30) (disease-related in 13 and 18 patients, and procedure-related in 5 and 7 patients respectively). A cause of biliary obstruction was found in 39.7% vs. 49.6% of patients (P = 0.11). Sixty-six (50%) patients in the MRCP-first group ended up avoiding an ERCP in follow-up. ERCP-first and MRCP-first patients were away from usual activities for 3.4 ± 7.7 days and 2.0 ± 4.8 days respectively (P < 0.001). CONCLUSION: A strategy of MRCP-first decreased the need for subsequent MRCPs, but not complications. Further study is required to define factors influencing the eventual use of MRCP vs. ERCP in appropriately selected patients (ClinicalTrial.gov: NCT01424657).

Prolonged lymphopenia following anti-thymocyte globulin induction is associated with decreased long-term graft survival in liver transplant recipients.

BACKGROUND AND AIM: Induction with anti-thymocyte globulin (ATG) during solid organ transplantation is associated with an improved clinical course and leads to prolonged lymphopenia. This study aims to investigate whether prolonged lymphopenia, caused by ATG induction, has an impact on patient and graft survival following liver and kidney transplantation. PATIENTS AND METHODS: This was a single-center, retrospective study. A total of 292 liver and 417 kidney transplants were performed with ATG induction (6 mg/kgr, divided into four doses), and the transplant recipients were followed for at least three months. The average lymphocyte count for the first 30 days after the operation was calculated, and the cut-off value for defining lymphopenia was arbitrarily set to ≤ 500 cells/mm(3). RESULTS: There were 210 liver transplant recipients (71.9%) who achieved prolonged lymphopenia, whereas the remaining 82 recipients (28.1%) did not. The mean survival time of these patient groups was 10.27 and 12.71 years, respectively (p = 0.1217), and the mean graft survival time was 8.98 and 12.25 years, respectively (p = 0.0147). Of the kidney transplant patients, 330 (79.1%) recipients achieved prolonged lymphopenia, whereas the remaining 87 (20.9%) did not. The mean survival time of these patient groups was 13.94 and 14.59 years, respectively, (p = 0.4490), and the mean graft survival time was 11.84 and 11.54 years, respectively (p = 0.7410). CONCLUSION: The efficacy and safety of ATG induction partially depend on decreased total lymphocyte counts. Following ATG induction in liver transplant recipients, a reasonable average lymphocyte count during the first postoperative month would be above 500 cells/mm(3).

Re-vascularization may not increase graft survival after hepatic artery thrombosis in liver transplant recipients.

BACKGROUND AND AIM: Hepatic artery thrombosis (HAT) occurs in 3% to 11% of all liver transplantations. Some authors have reported good outcomes with early thrombectomy. To investgate the impact of re-vascularization on graft survival. METHODS: A total of 566 primary, cadaveric, single organ, adult liver transplants were performed. Hepatic arterial Doppler was performed routinely and patients with abnormal findings during the first two post-operative weeks were reexplored. Abnormal findings after this time-point were verified by non-invasive angiogram. The 47 patients that were diagnosed with arterial thrombosis, either intra-operatively or by angiogram, were divided into three groups. No further action was taken for group A, thrombectomy alone was performed for group B1, thrombectomy and anastomotic revision was employed for group B2. RESULTS: Arterial thrombosis was diagnosed in 47 (8.3%) patients. Mean patient survival was 42, 62 and 98 months for groups A, B1 and B2 respectively (p: 0.0629). Mean graft survival was 24, 29 and 60 months for groups A, B1 and B2 respectively (p: 0.3386). Re-transplant incidence was 8.7%, 40% and 28.6% for groups A, B1, and B2 respectively (p: 0.035). CONCLUSIONS: Early diagnosis of HAT by surveillance Doppler may lead to improved recipient survival secondary to earlier re-transplantation and not because of successful graft re-vascularization.

Replacing an inpatient electronic medical record. Lessons learned from user satisfaction with the former system.

OBJECTIVE: Since it is important to develop strategies for the successful implementation of electronic clinical information systems, the aim of this study is to explore where, and to what extent, users' attitudes toward the former system that is being replaced may vary. METHODS: A cross-sectional survey of 346 nurses and physicians practicing in two Canadian teaching hospitals resulted in a total response rate of 63%. User attitudes were measured in three dimensions: a) user satisfaction with the system's quality attributes, b) perceived system usefulness, and c) perceived impact on quality of care and patient safety. The current system (the one being replaced) was analyzed as a dual system composed of both paper-based and electronic records. RESULTS: The results on user satisfaction demonstrate a wide variation in opinions, with satisfaction ranging from 4.2 to 7.7 on a 10-point disagree-agree, Likert scale. The quality attributes varied by record type, with differences that were systematically in favor of the electronic record component, which received higher scores. The results also highlighted large differences by user group. Physicians and nurses systematically rated the two record formats differently. The nurses were more satisfied with the attributes of the paper-based record. Multivariate regression analyses results also revealed strong interdependencies among the three dimensions of user attitudes, to the extent that perceived system usefulness was strongly correlated with system quality attributes and the system outcomes were also correlated, although less strongly, with the two former system dimensions. CONCLUSION: Understanding users' attitudes toward a clinical information system in use, both in its paper and electronic aspects, is crucial for developing more successful implementation strategies for electronic record systems.

Liver transplantation for metastases from a bile duct carcinoid.

BACKGROUND: A 29-year-old woman who presented with fatigue and jaundice was found to have an obstructing mass at the bifurcation of the bile duct. The patient underwent a successful left hepatectomy with resection of the bile duct bifurcation and a reconstruction with a right hepaticojejunostomy. Pathology revealed an atypical carcinoid tumour of the left extrahepatic bile duct, with perineural and lymphatic invasion. The patient subsequently developed multiple metastases in the remaining liver. METHODS: In the absence of extrahepatic disease, the patient underwent a successful liver transplant. RESULTS: Two years later she remains disease-free. DISCUSSION: To our knowledge this is the first report of a biliary carcinoid treated with hepatectomy and finally with liver transplantation, with excellent results. The biological behaviour of these rare tumours mandates aggressive surgical management.

The impact of thymoglobulin on renal function and calcineurin inhibitor initiation in recipients of orthotopic liver transplant: a retrospective analysis of 298 consecutive patients.

BACKGROUND: Renal dysfunction remains the Achilles' heel of calcineurin inhibitor (CI)use. The purpose of this study was to assess our institutional, renal-sparing strategy using thymoglobulin (TMG) in recipients of orthotopic liver transplants. METHODS: We performed a retrospective analysis of data from 298 adult recipients who were transplanted between 1991 and 2002. The patients were divided into two groups: those induced with TMG (group 1) and those that were not treated with this agent (group 2). A subgroup analysis was performed of patients with baseline serum creatinine values above 1.5 mg/dL (group 1A received TMG; group 2A did not). All patients received tacrolimus or cyclosporine (CyA) maintenance immunosuppression. RESULTS: Indications and demographics were similar between the two groups. Although there was no difference in patient and graft survivals, there was a statistically significant benefit in the rejection-free graft survival at 1 year for group 1 (51% vs 39%; P =.02). Furthermore, serum creatinine at 6 months was lower for group 1, despite a similar baseline creatinine. Subgroup analysis for patients with baseline abnormal serum creatinines showed that group 1A displayed an improved rejection-free graft survival at 1 month but not at 1 year. CONCLUSIONS: Thymoglobulin induction therapy may allow a delay in the initiation of CI therapy without compromising patient and graft survival, while preventing early rejection, even among patients with baseline renal dysfunction.

Leukoreduction and acute rejection in liver transplantation: an interim analysis.

BACKGROUND: Little is known about the effect of blood transfusions and leukoreduction on acute rejection in liver transplantation. The purpose of this study was to assess the impact of leukoreduction on the occurrence of early rejection episodes in liver transplantation. METHODS: In 1999, mandatory leukoreduction was implemented in our program. Data from 339 consecutive liver transplant recipients were analyzed with attention to the time period as a proxy for leukoreduction, the number of transfusions, the wait list status, the hepatitis B or C status, the recipient age, and the type of immunosuppression. RESULTS: Using an early (6-month) rejection-free graft survival model, we observed that introduction of leukoreduction was independently associated with fewer rejection episodes (P =.001). Despite the lower rejection rate, due to a regimen of tacrolimus and antithymocyte globulin, the effect of implementation of leukoreduction remained significant (P =.021). CONCLUSION: The use of leukoreduction is associated with fewer early rejections, irrespective of the type of immunosuppression. These data support an exploration of the immunomodulatory effect of leukoreduction.

History of C2 monitoring in heart and liver transplant patients treated with cyclosporine microemulsion.

Therapeutic drug monitoring of CsA has evolved since the introduction of CsA microemulsion. The purpose of the present review is to summarize the history of CsA concentration 2 hours postdose (C2) monitoring in heart and liver transplantation. C2 has been shown to be the best single time point that correlates with the area-under-the-curve, with a correlation coefficient (r2) ranging between .83 and.93. C2 monitoring (300 to 600 ng/mL) has resulted in a significant clinical benefit in long-term heart and liver transplant patients compared to trough level (C0) monitoring. Moreover, a C2 range of 300 to 600 ng/mL resulted in a similar calcineurin inhibition compared to a C2 range of 700 to 1000 ng/mL or a C0 range of 100 to 200 ng/mL while being less injurious to renal function. In de novo liver transplant patients not receiving induction therapy, the achievement of a target C2 of 850 to 1400 ng/mL by postoperative day 3 has resulted in a low acute rejection rate. Furthermore, C2 monitoring has been associated with a lower rejection rate in hepatitis C virus (HCV)-negative patients and with an overall lesser severity of acute rejection compared to C0 monitoring. In de novo heart transplant patients who receive antithymocyte globulin induction, a lower C2 range may be sufficient to prevent rejection and renal dysfunction. Future studies should help to fine-tune the optimal C2 range in heart or liver transplant patients receiving induction therapy and different maintenance immunosuppressive combinations.

Do biliary endoprostheses decrease biliary complications after liver transplantation?

AIM: Most technical complications after orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) are related to the biliary tree. This report reviews the role of routine intraoperative placement of stents to reduce biliary complications. METHODS: We retrospectively analyzed 396 consecutive OLTs. We reviewed rates of biliary complications after hepaticojejunostomy (HJA) as well as following choledochocholedochostomy (CCA) groups: "experimental" group (routine intraoperative biliary stenting, last 10 months), "recent" control group (nonstented, previous 10 months), "historical" control group (prior to that period of time). RESULTS: All groups were matched for donor/recipient characteristics and for graft cold/warm ischemia time. The overall prevalence of biliary complications was 30.7% after CCA versus 35% after HJA. In the experimental group 21 patients had a 4.8% biliary complication rate compared to the recent control and historical groups, where biliary complication rates were 30% and 32.6%, respectively (P <.05). CONCLUSIONS: The intraoperative use of biliary stents is feasible and appears to decrease the rate of biliary complications. These results support the need for a prospective randomized trial.

Efficacy of mycophenolate mofetil combined with very low-dose cyclosporine microemulsion in long-term liver-transplant patients with renal dysfunction.

BACKGROUND: Cyclosporine (CsA)-induced renal dysfunction is common after liver transplantation. We evaluated the efficacy of tapering CsA to a very low dose and introducing mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) in long-term liver-transplant recipients with renal dysfunction. In addition, we assessed the impact of this strategy on calcineurin inhibition and on transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta levels. METHODS: We prospectively enrolled 19 adult, long-term (>1 year) liver-transplant recipients with a decreased creatinine clearance greater than 25% compared with the first month posttransplant. MMF was introduced, and CsA was tapered to 25 mg twice daily. Calcineurin inhibition and TGF-beta were measured at baseline and 3 months thereafter. RESULTS: The CsA dose was tapered over 13+/-3 weeks. At 1-year follow-up, serum creatinine decreased from 141+/-24 to 105+/-22 micromol/L (P=0.002), creatinine clearance increased from 53+/-9 to 71+/-19 ml/min (P=0.02), and glomerular filtration rate increased from 40+/-13 to 64+/-18 mL/min (P=0.002). The incidence of acute rejection was 29%. Antihypertensive medications were discontinued in 71% of the patients. Although CsA levels decreased significantly, serum TGF-beta did not differ from normal controls, and calcineurin inhibition remained stable. The incidence of gastrointestinal side-effects and leukopenia was 18% and 24%, respectively. CONCLUSION: In long-term liver-transplant recipients with renal dysfunction, the introduction of MMF followed by tapering of CsA to a very low dose resulted in a significant improvement in renal function. However, this strategy maybe associated with a risk of acute rejection. The clinical pertinence of measuring serum TGF-beta levels and calcineurin inhibition remains to be determined.

Elevation of CA-125 level is due to abdominal distension in liver transplantation candidates.

BACKGROUND: CA (cancer antigen) 125 is a serologic marker used in the monitoring of ovarian cancer. Elevated levels are also reported in cirrhosis. We evaluated the range of serum CA 125 levels seen before and after liver transplantation, and examined possible factors associated with CA 125 elevation. METHODS: We examined prospectively 57 consecutive patients with cirrhosis who underwent liver transplantation. CA 125 levels were also measured in two patients with polycystic liver disease. RESULTS: The mean serum CA 125 level before transplantation was 352+/-549 u/ml, compared with 46+/-49 u/ml after transplantation (P<0.001). Multivariate analysis identified the degree of ascites as the only significant predictive variable of preoperative CA 125 level. In five patients who underwent abdominal paracentesis, the mean ascites CA 125 level (951+/-322 u/ml) was higher than that of the serum (619+/-290 u/ml) (P<0.003). In 16 hepatectomy specimens, the grade of staining for CA 125 was 0.8+/-1.4 for the mesothelium of patients with a normal serum CA 125 level, compared with 1.5+/-1.1 in patients with elevated serum levels (P=0.37). Two patients with severe abdominal distension due to polycystic liver disease but without ascites had elevated serum CA 125 levels. DISCUSSION: CA 125 concentration is elevated in the majority of patients with cirrhosis and normalizes after liver transplantation. It is a reflection of the abdominal distention seen in these patients. Therefore, an elevation in CA 125 should not be considered a contraindication to liver transplantation in the absence of evidence of malignancy.

Laparoscopic fundoplication: a model for assessing new technology in surgical procedures.

BACKGROUND: Surgical success has traditionally been judged from the surgeon's perspective. A more complete evaluation of outcome incorporates the patient's, surgeon's, and payor's perspectives. Because gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) is primarily a quality-of-life (QOL) problem, the evaluation of laparoscopic fundoplication (LF) is a useful model for evaluating outcomes from these 3 perspectives. METHODS: Between 1995 and 2000, 74 patients underwent primary LF for GERD. In addition to undergoing physiologic testing, 63 patients (85%) were evaluated with use of a disease-specific health-related QOL scale (GERD-HRQL), scored from 0 (no symptoms) to 45 (incapacitating symptoms). Thirty-three patients also completed a generic QOL questionnaire (SF-12), in which patient satisfaction was scored from 1 (very satisfied) to 5 (very dissatisfied). Preoperative and postoperative data were compared with use of the Wilcoxon signed rank test or the paired t test. RESULTS: The median GERD-HRQL score improved from 18 to 0 at 2 years postoperation (P <.01). The median satisfaction score improved from 5 to 1 (P <.01). The SF-12 summary scores also improved after 6 weeks postoperatively (P <.05). The mean +/- SD lower esophageal sphincter pressure rose from 7.3 +/- 4 mm Hg preoperatively to 17.5 +/- 6 postoperatively (P <.01), and the mean percentage of time that the esophagus was exposed to a pH of less than 4 declined from 14.7% +/- 12% to 1.1% +/- 2% (P <.01). The median operative time was 110 minutes, which declined with experience with the procedure (P <.01). Median postoperative stay was 2 days. CONCLUSIONS: In evaluating the outcomes of a new procedure, 3 overlapping points of view were addressed: the patient's (QOL, satisfaction), the surgeon's (physiologic changes), and the payor's (operating room time, hospital stay). With use of this framework, we found that LF for GERD improves QOL, corrects the physiologic abnormalities, and is associated with short hospitalization and operating time that declines with experience with the procedure.

Successful outcome after transplantation of a donor liver with focal nodular hyperplasia.

Because of the increasing gap in the number of patients awaiting organ transplantation and the supply of organ donors, reevaluation of donor criteria is an important issue in clinical transplantation. It has become necessary to make maximal use of the currently available donor pool. We describe a case of successful orthotopic liver transplantation in a 57-year-old man with Laënnec's cirrhosis using a liver containing an 8-cm focal nodular hyperplasia (FNH) lesion involving segments II and III and the caudate lobe. The donor liver was procured from a 46-year-old woman declared brain dead after a subarachnoid hemorrhage. Definitive pathological diagnosis was made at laparotomy by obtaining a Tru-cut (Allegiance Health Care Inc, Toronto, Ontario, Canada) core biopsy specimen. The recipient operation was performed uneventfully except for bleeding from the biopsy site. The patient did well postoperatively and was discharged on tacrolimus, mofetil mycophenolate, and prednisone therapy. He continues to thrive 2(1/2) years posttransplantation with no change in the size of the lesion. In well-selected donors, FNH should not be a contraindication for use in transplantation. However, FNH must be differentiated from hepatocellular adenoma. Although FNH has a benign course with little propensity for bleeding and almost no malignant potential, hepatic adenoma is reported to have a 15% to 33% chance of bleeding and rupture with a well-documented potential for neoplastic degeneration, making the liver unsuitable for donation.

Rejection of pig liver xenografts in patients with liver failure: implications for xenotransplantation.

The pathophysiological state of rejection in liver xenotransplantation is poorly understood. Data from clinical pig liver perfusion suggest that pig livers might be rejected less vigorously than pig hearts or kidneys. Pig livers used in clinical xenoperfusions were exposed to blood from patients with liver failure. We have shown in an animal model that transplant recipients with liver failure are less capable of initiating hyperacute rejection of a xenografted liver than a healthy transplant recipient. The goal of this report is to examine the pathological characteristics of pig livers used in 2 clinical pig liver perfusions and combine this information with in vitro studies of pig-to-human liver xenotransplantation to determine whether the findings in the perfused pig livers could be explained in part by the diminished capacity of the patient with liver failure to respond to xenogeneic tissue. Pathological analysis of the perfused pig livers showed immunoglobulin M deposition in the sinusoids with little evidence of complement activation. Our in vitro studies showed that serum from patients with liver failure caused less injury to pig liver endothelium than serum from healthy subjects. Serum from patients with liver failure had similar levels of xenoreactive antibodies as serum from healthy humans. Incubation of serum from patients with liver failure with pig hepatic endothelial cells generated less iC3b, Bb fragment, and C5b-9 than serum from healthy subjects. We conclude that the altered injury in the perfused pig livers can be attributed to the relative complement deficiency that accompanies liver failure.