Temporal recruitment of base excision DNA repair factors in living cells in response to different micro-irradiation DNA damage protocols.

Laser micro-irradiation across the nucleus rapidly generates localized chromatin-associated DNA lesions permitting analysis of repair protein recruitment in living cells. Recruitment of three fluorescently-tagged base excision repair factors [DNA polymerase ß (pol ß), XRCC1 and PARP1], known to interact with one another, was compared in gene-deleted mouse embryonic fibroblasts and in those expressing the endogenous factor. A low energy micro-irradiation (LEMI) forming direct single-strand breaks and a moderate energy (MEMI) protocol that additionally creates oxidized bases were compared. Quantitative characterization of repair factor recruitment and sensitivity to clinical PARP inhibitors (PARPi) was dependent on the micro-irradiation protocol. PARP1 recruitment was biphasic and generally occurred prior to pol ß and XRCC1. After LEMI, but not after MEMI, pol ß and XRCC1 recruitment was abolished by the PARPi veliparib. Consistent with this, pol ß and XRCC1 recruitment following LEMI was considerably slower in PARP1-deficient cells. Surprisingly, the recruitment half-times and amplitudes for pol ß were less affected by PARPi than were XRCC1 after MEMI suggesting there is a XRCC1-independent component for pol ß recruitment. After LEMI, but not MEMI, pol ß dissociation was more rapid than that of XRCC1. Unexpectedly, PARP1 dissociation was slowed in the absence of XRCC1 as well with a PARPi after LEMI but not MEMI, suggesting that XRCC1 facilitates PARP1 dissociation from specific DNA lesions. XRCC1-deficient cells showed pronounced hypersensitivity to the PARPi talazoparib correlating with its known cytotoxic PARP1 trapping activity. In contrast to DNA methylating agents, PARPi only minimally sensitized pol ß and XRCC1-deficient cells to oxidative DNA damage suggesting differential binding of PARP1 to alternate repair intermediates. In summary, pol ß, XRCC1, and PARP1 display recruitment kinetics that exhibit correlated and unique properties that depend on the DNA lesion and PARP activity revealing that there are multiple avenues utilized in the repair of chromatin-associated DNA.

Structural basis for proficient oxidized ribonucleotide insertion in double strand break repair.

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) oxidize cellular nucleotide pools and cause double strand breaks (DSBs). Non-homologous end-joining (NHEJ) attaches broken chromosomal ends together in mammalian cells. Ribonucleotide insertion by DNA polymerase (pol) µ prepares breaks for end-joining and this is required for successful NHEJ in vivo. We previously showed that pol µ lacks discrimination against oxidized dGTP (8-oxo-dGTP), that can lead to mutagenesis, cancer, aging and human disease. Here we reveal the structural basis for proficient oxidized ribonucleotide (8-oxo-rGTP) incorporation during DSB repair by pol µ. Time-lapse crystallography snapshots of structural intermediates during nucleotide insertion along with computational simulations reveal substrate, metal and side chain dynamics, that allow oxidized ribonucleotides to escape polymerase discrimination checkpoints. Abundant nucleotide pools, combined with inefficient sanitization and repair, implicate pol µ mediated oxidized ribonucleotide insertion as an emerging source of widespread persistent mutagenesis and genomic instability.

Watching a double strand break repair polymerase insert a pro-mutagenic oxidized nucleotide.

Oxidized dGTP (8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2´-deoxyguanosine triphosphate, 8-oxodGTP) insertion by DNA polymerases strongly promotes cancer and human disease. How DNA polymerases discriminate against oxidized and undamaged nucleotides, especially in error-prone double strand break (DSB) repair, is poorly understood. High-resolution time-lapse X-ray crystallography snapshots of DSB repair polymerase µ undergoing DNA synthesis reveal that a third active site metal promotes insertion of oxidized and undamaged dGTP in the canonical anti-conformation opposite template cytosine. The product metal bridged O8 with product oxygens, and was not observed in the syn-conformation opposite template adenine (At). Rotation of At into the syn-conformation enabled undamaged dGTP misinsertion. Exploiting metal and substrate dynamics in a rigid active site allows 8-oxodGTP to circumvent polymerase fidelity safeguards to promote pro-mutagenic double strand break repair.

DNA polymerase ß: Closing the gap between structure and function.

DNA polymerase (dpol) ß has served as a model for structural, kinetic, and computational characterization of the DNA synthesis reaction. The laboratory directed by Samuel H. Wilson has utilized a multifunctional approach to analyze the function of this enzyme at the biological, chemical, and molecular levels for nearly 50 years. Over this time, it has become evident that correlating static crystallographic structures of dpol ß with solution kinetic measurements is a daunting task. However, aided by computational and spectroscopic approaches, novel and unexpected insights have emerged. While dpols generally insert wrong nucleotides with similar poor efficiencies, their capacity to insert the right nucleotide depends on the identity of the dpol. Accordingly, the ability to choose right from wrong depends on the efficiency of right, rather than wrong, nucleotide insertion. Structures of dpol ß in various liganded forms published by the Wilson laboratory, and others, have provided molecular insights into the molecular attributes that hasten correct nucleotide insertion and deter incorrect nucleotide insertion. Computational approaches have bridged the gap between structures of intermediate complexes and provided insights into this basic and essential chemical reaction.

Preferential DNA Polymerase ß Reverse Reaction with Imidodiphosphate.

DNA replication and repair reactions involve the addition of a deoxynucleoside monophosphate onto a growing DNA strand with the loss of pyrophosphate. This chemical reaction is also reversible; the addition of pyrophosphate generates a deoxynucleoside triphosphate, thereby shortening the DNA by one nucleotide. The forward DNA synthesis and reverse pyrophosphorolysis reactions strictly require the presence of divalent metals, usually magnesium, at the reactive center as cofactors. The overall equilibrium enzymatic reaction strongly favors DNA synthesis over pyrophosphorolysis with natural substrates. The DNA polymerase ß chemical reaction has been structurally and kinetically characterized, employing natural and chemically modified substrates. Substituting an imido-moiety (NH) for the bridging oxygen between Pß and Pγ of dGTP dramatically decreased the overall enzymatic activity and resulted in a chemical equilibrium that strongly favors the reverse reaction (i.e., K ≪ 1). Using QM/MM calculations in conjunction with the utilization of parameters such as quantum mechanically derived atomic charges, we have examined the chemical foundation for the altered equilibrium with this central biological reaction. The calculations indicate that the rapid reverse reaction is likely due, in part, to the increased nucleophilicity of the reactive oxygen on the tautomeric form of imidodiphosphate.

DNA polymerase ß nucleotide-stabilized template misalignment fidelity depends on local sequence context.

DNA polymerase ß has two DNA-binding domains that interact with the opposite sides of short DNA gaps. These domains contribute two activities that modify the 5' and 3' margins of gapped DNA during base excision repair. DNA gaps greater than 1 nucleotide (nt) pose an architectural and logistical problem for the two domains to interact with their respective DNA termini. Here, crystallographic and kinetic analyses of 2-nt gap-filling DNA synthesis revealed that the fidelity of DNA synthesis depends on local sequence context. This was due to template dynamics that altered which of the two template nucleotides in the gap served as the coding nucleotide. We observed that, when a purine nucleotide was in the first coding position, DNA synthesis fidelity was similar to that observed with a 1-nt gap. However, when the initial templating nucleotide was a pyrimidine, fidelity was decreased. If the first templating nucleotide was a cytidine, there was a significantly higher probability that the downstream template nucleotide coded for the incoming nucleotide. This dNTP-stabilized misalignment reduced base substitution and frameshift deletion fidelities. A crystal structure of a binary DNA product complex revealed that the cytidine in the first templating site was in an extrahelical position, permitting the downstream template nucleotide to occupy the coding position. These results indicate that DNA polymerase ß can induce a strain in the DNA that modulates the position of the coding nucleotide and thereby impacts the identity of the incoming nucleotide. Our findings demonstrate that "correct" DNA synthesis can result in errors when template dynamics induce coding ambiguity.

DNA polymerase beta and other gap-filling enzymes in mammalian base excision repair.

DNA polymerase ß plays a central role in the base excision DNA repair pathway that cleanses the genome of apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) sites. AP sites arise in DNA from spontaneous base loss and DNA damage-specific glycosylases that hydrolyze the N-glycosidic bond between the deoxyribose and damaged base. AP sites are deleterious lesions because they can be mutagenic and/or cytotoxic. DNA polymerase ß contributes two enzymatic activities, DNA synthesis and lyase, during the repair of AP sites; these activities reside on carboxyl- and amino-terminal domains, respectively. Accordingly, its cellular, structural, and kinetic attributes have been extensively characterized and it serves as model enzyme for the nucleotidyl transferase reaction utilized by other replicative, repair, and trans-lesion DNA polymerases.

Eukaryotic Base Excision Repair: New Approaches Shine Light on Mechanism.

Genomic DNA is susceptible to endogenous and environmental stresses that modify DNA structure and its coding potential. Correspondingly, cells have evolved intricate DNA repair systems to deter changes to their genetic material. Base excision DNA repair involves a number of enzymes and protein cofactors that hasten repair of damaged DNA bases. Recent advances have identified macromolecular complexes that assemble at the DNA lesion and mediate repair. The repair of base lesions generally requires five enzymatic activities: glycosylase, endonuclease, lyase, polymerase, and ligase. The protein cofactors and mechanisms for coordinating the sequential enzymatic steps of repair are being revealed through a range of experimental approaches. We discuss the enzymes and protein cofactors involved in eukaryotic base excision repair, emphasizing the challenge of integrating findings from multiple methodologies. The results provide an opportunity to assimilate biochemical findings with cell-based assays to uncover new insights into this deceptively complex repair pathway.

A guardian residue hinders insertion of a Fapy•dGTP analog by modulating the open-closed DNA polymerase transition.

4,6-Diamino-5-formamidopyrimidine (Fapy•dG) is an abundant form of oxidative DNA damage that is mutagenic and contributes to the pathogenesis of human disease. When Fapy•dG is in its nucleotide triphosphate form, Fapy•dGTP, it is inefficiently cleansed from the nucleotide pool by the responsible enzyme in Escherichia coli MutT and its mammalian homolog MTH1. Therefore, under oxidative stress conditions, Fapy•dGTP could become a pro-mutagenic substrate for insertion into the genome by DNA polymerases. Here, we evaluated insertion kinetics and high-resolution ternary complex crystal structures of a configurationally stable Fapy•dGTP analog, ß-C-Fapy•dGTP, with DNA polymerase ß. The crystallographic snapshots and kinetic data indicate that binding of ß-C-Fapy•dGTP impedes enzyme closure, thus hindering insertion. The structures reveal that an active site residue, Asp276, positions ß-C-Fapy•dGTP so that it distorts the geometry of critical catalytic atoms. Removal of this guardian side chain permits enzyme closure and increases the efficiency of ß-C-Fapy•dG insertion opposite dC. These results highlight the stringent requirements necessary to achieve a closed DNA polymerase active site poised for efficient nucleotide incorporation and illustrate how DNA polymerase ß has evolved to hinder Fapy•dGTP insertion.

Transitions in DNA polymerase ß µs-ms dynamics related to substrate binding and catalysis.

DNA polymerase ß (pol ß) plays a central role in the DNA base excision repair pathway and also serves as an important model polymerase. Dynamic characterization of pol ß from methyl-TROSY 13C-1H multiple quantum CPMG relaxation dispersion experiments of Ile and Met sidechains and previous backbone relaxation dispersion measurements, reveals transitions in µs-ms dynamics in response to highly variable substrates. Recognition of a 1-nt-gapped DNA substrate is accompanied by significant backbone and sidechain motion in the lyase domain and the DNA binding subdomain of the polymerase domain, that may help to facilitate binding of the apoenzyme to the segments of the DNA upstream and downstream from the gap. Backbone µs-ms motion largely disappears after formation of the pol ß-DNA complex, giving rise to an increase in uncoupled µs-ms sidechain motion throughout the enzyme. Formation of an abortive ternary complex using a non-hydrolyzable dNTP results in sidechain motions that fit to a single exchange process localized to the catalytic subdomain, suggesting that this motion may play a role in catalysis.

Probing DNA Base-Dependent Leaving Group Kinetic Effects on the DNA Polymerase Transition State.

We examine the DNA polymerase ß (pol ß) transition state (TS) from a leaving group pre-steady-state kinetics perspective by measuring the rate of incorporation of dNTPs and corresponding novel ß,γ-CXY-dNTP analogues, including individual ß,γ-CHF and -CHCl diastereomers with defined stereochemistry at the bridging carbon, during the formation of right (R) and wrong (W) base pairs. Brønsted plots of log kpol versus p Ka4 of the leaving group bisphosphonic acids are used to interrogate the effects of the base identity, the dNTP analogue leaving group basicity, and the precise configuration of the C-X atom in R and S stereoisomers on the rate-determining step ( kpol). The dNTP analogues provide a range of leaving group basicity and steric properties by virtue of monohalogen, dihalogen, or methyl substitution at the carbon atom bridging the ß,γ-bisphosphonate that mimics the natural pyrophosphate leaving group in dNTPs. Brønsted plot relationships with negative slopes are revealed by the data, as was found for the dGTP and dTTP analogues, consistent with a bond-breaking component to the TS energy. However, greater multiplicity was shown in the linear free energy relationship, revealing an unexpected dependence on the nucleotide base for both A and C. Strong base-dependent perturbations that modulate TS relative to ground-state energies are likely to arise from electrostatic effects on catalysis in the pol active site. Deviations from a uniform linear Brønsted plot relationship are discussed in terms of insights gained from structural features of the prechemistry DNA polymerase active site.

Mapping Functional Substrate-Enzyme Interactions in the pol ß Active Site through Chemical Biology: Structural Responses to Acidity Modification of Incoming dNTPs.

We report high-resolution crystal structures of DNA polymerase (pol) ß in ternary complex with a panel of incoming dNTPs carrying acidity-modified 5'-triphosphate groups. These novel dNTP analogues have a variety of halomethylene substitutions replacing the bridging oxygen between Pß and Pγ of the incoming dNTP, whereas other analogues have alkaline substitutions at the bridging oxygen. Use of these analogues allows the first systematic comparison of effects of 5'-triphosphate acidity modification on active site structures and the rate constant of DNA synthesis. These ternary complex structures with incoming dATP, dTTP, and dCTP analogues reveal the enzyme's active site is not grossly altered by the acidity modifications of the triphosphate group, yet with analogues of all three incoming dNTP bases, subtle structural differences are apparent in interactions around the nascent base pair and at the guanidinium groups of active site arginine residues. These results are important for understanding how acidity modification of the incoming dNTP's 5'-triphosphate can influence DNA polymerase activity and the significance of interactions at arginines 183 and 149 in the active site.

Modulating the DNA polymerase ß reaction equilibrium to dissect the reverse reaction.

DNA polymerases catalyze efficient and high-fidelity DNA synthesis. While this reaction favors nucleotide incorporation, polymerases also catalyze a reverse reaction, pyrophosphorolysis, that removes the DNA primer terminus and generates deoxynucleoside triphosphates. Because pyrophosphorolysis can influence polymerase fidelity and sensitivity to chain-terminating nucleosides, we analyzed pyrophosphorolysis with human DNA polymerase ß and found the reaction to be inefficient. The lack of a thio-elemental effect indicated that this reaction was limited by a nonchemical step. Use of a pyrophosphate analog, in which the bridging oxygen is replaced with an imido group (PNP), increased the rate of the reverse reaction and displayed a large thio-elemental effect, indicating that chemistry was now rate determining. Time-lapse crystallography with PNP captured structures consistent with a chemical equilibrium favoring the reverse reaction. These results highlight the importance of the bridging atom between the ß- and γ-phosphates of the incoming nucleotide in reaction chemistry, enzyme conformational changes, and overall reaction equilibrium.

Time-lapse crystallography snapshots of a double-strand break repair polymerase in action.

DNA polymerase (pol) µ is a DNA-dependent polymerase that incorporates nucleotides during gap-filling synthesis in the non-homologous end-joining pathway of double-strand break repair. Here we report time-lapse X-ray crystallography snapshots of catalytic events during gap-filling DNA synthesis by pol µ. Unique catalytic intermediates and active site conformational changes that underlie catalysis are uncovered, and a transient third (product) metal ion is observed in the product state. The product manganese coordinates phosphate oxygens of the inserted nucleotide and PPi. The product metal is not observed during DNA synthesis in the presence of magnesium. Kinetic analyses indicate that manganese increases the rate constant for deoxynucleoside 5'-triphosphate insertion compared to magnesium. The likely product stabilization role of the manganese product metal in pol µ is discussed. These observations provide insight on structural attributes of this X-family double-strand break repair polymerase that impact its biological function in genome maintenance.DNA polymerase (pol) µ functions in DNA double-strand break repair. Here the authors use time-lapse X-ray crystallography to capture the states of pol µ during the conversion from pre-catalytic to product complex and observe a third transiently bound metal ion in the product state.

Revealing the role of the product metal in DNA polymerase ß catalysis.

DNA polymerases catalyze a metal-dependent nucleotidyl transferase reaction during extension of a DNA strand using the complementary strand as a template. The reaction has long been considered to require two magnesium ions. Recently, a third active site magnesium ion was identified in some DNA polymerase product crystallographic structures, but its role is not known. Using quantum mechanical/ molecular mechanical calculations of polymerase ß, we find that a third magnesium ion positioned near the newly identified product metal site does not alter the activation barrier for the chemical reaction indicating that it does not have a role in the forward reaction. This is consistent with time-lapse crystallographic structures following insertion of Sp-dCTPαS. Although sulfur substitution deters product metal binding, this has only a minimal effect on the rate of the forward reaction. Surprisingly, monovalent sodium or ammonium ions, positioned in the product metal site, lowered the activation barrier. These calculations highlight the impact that an active site water network can have on the energetics of the forward reaction and how metals or enzyme side chains may interact with the network to modulate the reaction barrier. These results also are discussed in the context of earlier findings indicating that magnesium at the product metal position blocks the reverse pyrophosphorolysis reaction.

Hiding in Plain Sight: The Bimetallic Magnesium Covalent Bond in Enzyme Active Sites.

The transfer of phosphate groups is an essential function of many intracellular biological enzymes. The transfer is in many cases facilitated by a protein scaffold involving two closely spaced magnesium "ions". It has long been a mystery how these "ions" can retain their closely spaced positions throughout enzymatic phosphate transfer: Coulomb's law would dictate large repulsive forces between these ions at the observed distances. Here we show, however, that the electron density can be borrowed from nearby electron-rich oxygens to populate a bonding molecular orbital that is largely localized between the magnesium "ions". The result is that the Mg-Mg core of these phosphate transfer enzymes is surprisingly similar to a metastable [Mg2]2+ ion in the gas phase, an ion that has been identified experimentally and studied with high-level quantum-mechanical calculations. This similarity is confirmed by comparative computations of the electron densities of [Mg2]2+ in the gas phase and the Mg-Mg core in the structures derived from QM/MM studies of high-resolution X-ray crystal structures. That there is a level of covalent bonding between the two Mg "ions" at the core of these enzymes is a novel concept that enables an improved vision of how these enzymes function at the molecular level. The concept is broader than magnesium-other biologically relevant metals (e.g., Mn and Zn) can also form similar stabilizing covalent Me-Me bonds in both organometallic and inorganic crystals.

Impact of Ribonucleotide Backbone on Translesion Synthesis and Repair of 7,8-Dihydro-8-oxoguanine.

Numerous ribonucleotides are incorporated into the genome during DNA replication. Oxidized ribonucleotides can also be erroneously incorporated into DNA. Embedded ribonucleotides destabilize the structure of DNA and retard DNA synthesis by DNA polymerases (pols), leading to genomic instability. Mammalian cells possess translesion DNA synthesis (TLS) pols that bypass DNA damage. The mechanism of TLS and repair of oxidized ribonucleotides remains to be elucidated. To address this, we analyzed the miscoding properties of the ribonucleotides riboguanosine (rG) and 7,8-dihydro-8-oxo-riboguanosine (8-oxo-rG) during TLS catalyzed by the human TLS pols κ and η in vitro The primer extension reaction catalyzed by human replicative pol α was strongly blocked by 8-oxo-rG. pol κ inefficiently bypassed rG and 8-oxo-rG compared with dG and 7,8-dihydro-8-oxo-2'-deoxyguanosine (8-oxo-dG), whereas pol η easily bypassed the ribonucleotides. pol α exclusively inserted dAMP opposite 8-oxo-rG. Interestingly, pol κ preferentially inserted dCMP opposite 8-oxo-rG, whereas the insertion of dAMP was favored opposite 8-oxo-dG. In addition, pol η accurately bypassed 8-oxo-rG. Furthermore, we examined the activity of the base excision repair (BER) enzymes 8-oxoguanine DNA glycosylase (OGG1) and apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease 1 on the substrates, including rG and 8-oxo-rG. Both BER enzymes were completely inactive against 8-oxo-rG in DNA. However, OGG1 suppressed 8-oxo-rG excision by RNase H2, which is involved in the removal of ribonucleotides from DNA. These results suggest that the different sugar backbones between 8-oxo-rG and 8-oxo-dG alter the capacity of TLS and repair of 8-oxoguanine.

Structures of DNA Polymerase Mispaired DNA Termini Transitioning to Pre-catalytic Complexes Support an Induced-Fit Fidelity Mechanism.

High-fidelity DNA synthesis requires that polymerases display a strong preference for right nucleotide insertion. When the wrong nucleotide is inserted, the polymerase deters extension from the mismatched DNA terminus. Twenty-three crystallographic structures of DNA polymerase ß with terminal template-primer mismatches were determined as binary DNA and ternary pre-catalytic substrate complexes. These structures indicate that the mismatched termini adopt various distorted conformations that attempt to satisfy stacking and hydrogen-bonding interactions. The binary complex structures indicate an induced strain in the mismatched template nucleotide. Addition of a non-hydrolyzable incoming nucleotide stabilizes the templating nucleotide with concomitant strain in the primer terminus. Several dead-end ternary complex structures suggest that DNA synthesis might occur as the enzyme transitions from an open to a closed complex. The structures are consistent with an induced-fit mechanism where a mismatched terminus is misaligned relative to the correct incoming nucleotide to deter or delay further DNA synthesis.

Insertion of oxidized nucleotide triggers rapid DNA polymerase opening.

A novel mechanism is unveiled to explain why a pro-mutagenic nucleotide lesion (oxidized guanine, 8-oxoG) causes the mammalian DNA repair polymerase-ß (pol-ß) to rapidly transition to an inactive open conformation. The mechanism involves unexpected features revealed recently in time-lapse crystallography. Specifically, a delicate water network associated with a lesion-stabilizing auxilliary product ion Mg(p) triggers a cascade of events that leads to poor active site geometry and the rupture of crucial molecular interactions between key residues in both the anti(8-oxoG:C) and syn(8-oxoG:A) systems. Once the base pairs in these lesioned systems are broken, dislocation of both Asp192 (a metal coordinating ligand) and the oxoG phosphate group (PO4) interfere with the hydrogen bonding between Asp192 and Arg258, whose rotation toward Asp192 is crucial to the closed-to-open enzyme transition. Energetically, the lesioned open states are similar in energy to those of the corresponding closed complexes after chemistry, in marked contrast to the unlesioned pol-ß anti(G:C) system, whose open state is energetically higher than the closed state. The delicate surveillance system offers a fundamental protective mechanism in the cell that triggers DNA repair events which help deter insertion of oxidized lesions.

Capturing snapshots of APE1 processing DNA damage.

DNA apurinic-apyrimidinic (AP) sites are prevalent noncoding threats to genomic stability and are processed by AP endonuclease 1 (APE1). APE1 incises the AP-site phosphodiester backbone, generating a DNA-repair intermediate that is potentially cytotoxic. The molecular events of the incision reaction remain elusive, owing in part to limited structural information. We report multiple high-resolution human APE1-DNA structures that divulge new features of the APE1 reaction, including the metal-binding site, the nucleophile and the arginine clamps that mediate product release. We also report APE1-DNA structures with a T-G mismatch 5' to the AP site, representing a clustered lesion occurring in methylated CpG dinucleotides. These structures reveal that APE1 molds the T-G mismatch into a unique Watson-Crick-like geometry that distorts the active site, thus reducing incision. These snapshots provide mechanistic clarity for APE1 while affording a rational framework to manipulate biological responses to DNA damage.