10th European immunogenicity platform open symposium on immunogenicity of biopharmaceuticals.

Therapeutic proteins and emerging gene and cell-based therapies are attractive therapeutic tools for addressing unmet medical needs or when earlier conventional treatment approaches failed. However, the development of an immune response directed against therapeutic agents is a significant concern as it occurs in a substantial number of cases across products and indications. The specific anti-drug antibodies that develop can lead to safety adverse events as well as inhibition of drug activity or accelerated clearance, both phenomena resulting in loss of treatment efficacy. The European Immunogenicity Platform (EIP) is a meeting place for experts and newcomers to the immunogenicity field, designed to stimulate discussion amongst scientists across industry and academia, encourage interactions with regulatory agencies and share knowledge and the state-of-the-art of immunogenicity sciences with the broader scientific community. Here we report on the main topics covered during the EIP 10th Open Symposium on Immunogenicity of Biopharmaceuticals held in Lisbon, 26-27 February 2019, and the 1-d training course on practical and regulatory aspects of immunogenicity held ahead of the conference. These main topics included immunogenicity testing, clinical relevance of immunogenicity, immunogenicity prediction, regulatory aspects, tolerance induction as a mean to mitigate immunogenicity and immunogenicity in the context of gene therapy.

Standardizing terms, definitions and concepts for describing and interpreting unwanted immunogenicity of biopharmaceuticals: recommendations of the Innovative Medicines Initiative ABIRISK consortium.

Biopharmaceuticals (BPs) represent a rapidly growing class of approved and investigational drug therapies that is contributing significantly to advancing treatment in multiple disease areas, including inflammatory and autoimmune diseases, genetic deficiencies and cancer. Unfortunately, unwanted immunogenic responses to BPs, in particular those affecting clinical safety or efficacy, remain among the most common negative effects associated with this important class of drugs. To manage and reduce risk of unwanted immunogenicity, diverse communities of clinicians, pharmaceutical industry and academic scientists are involved in: interpretation and management of clinical and biological outcomes of BP immunogenicity, improvement of methods for describing, predicting and mitigating immunogenicity risk and elucidation of underlying causes. Collaboration and alignment of efforts across these communities is made difficult due to lack of agreement on concepts, practices and standardized terms and definitions related to immunogenicity. The Innovative Medicines Initiative (IMI; www.imi-europe.org), ABIRISK consortium [Anti-Biopharmaceutical (BP) Immunization Prediction and Clinical Relevance to Reduce the Risk; www.abirisk.eu] was formed by leading clinicians, academic scientists and EFPIA (European Federation of Pharmaceutical Industries and Associations) members to elucidate underlying causes, improve methods for immunogenicity prediction and mitigation and establish common definitions around terms and concepts related to immunogenicity. These efforts are expected to facilitate broader collaborations and lead to new guidelines for managing immunogenicity. To support alignment, an overview of concepts behind the set of key terms and definitions adopted to date by ABIRISK is provided herein along with a link to access and download the ABIRISK terms and definitions and provide comments (http://www.abirisk.eu/index_t_and_d.asp).

Single-nucleotide polymorphism-defined class I and class III major histocompatibility complex genetic subregions contribute to natural long-term nonprogression in HIV infection.

We performed a genome-wide association study comparing a cohort of 144 human immunodeficiency virus (HIV type 1-infected, untreated white long-term nonprogressors (LTNPs) with a cohort of 605 HIV-1-infected white seroconverters. Forty-seven single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), located from class I to class III major histocompatibility complex (MHC) subregions, show statistical association (false discovery rate, <0.05) with the LTNP condition, among which 5 reached genome-wide significance after Bonferonni correction. The MHC LTNP-associated SNPs are ordered in ≥4 linkage disequilibrium blocks; interestingly, an MHC class III linkage disequilibrium block (defined by the rs9368699 SNP) seems specific to the LTNP phenotype.

False discovery rate estimation for frequentist pharmacovigilance signal detection methods.

Pharmacovigilance systems aim at early detection of adverse effects of marketed drugs. They maintain large spontaneous reporting databases for which several automatic signaling methods have been developed. One limit of those methods is that the decision rules for the signal generation are based on arbitrary thresholds. In this article, we propose a new signal-generation procedure. The decision criterion is formulated in terms of a critical region for the P-values resulting from the reporting odds ratio method as well as from the Fisher's exact test. For the latter, we also study the use of mid-P-values. The critical region is defined by the false discovery rate, which can be estimated by adapting the P-values mixture model based procedures to one-sided tests. The methodology is mainly illustrated with the location-based estimator procedure. It is studied through a large simulation study and applied to the French pharmacovigilance database.

Correlations between molecular profile and radiologic pattern in oligodendroglial tumors.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate possible correlations between tumor location and genetic alterations in a series of oligodendrogliomas. METHODS: A series of 158 consecutive oligodendrogliomas were retrospectively reviewed. In each case, the radiologic picture and the chromosome 1p (chr 1p) status of the tumor detected by the loss of heterozygosity technique were analyzed. Correlation between tumor location and molecular profile was made by chi2 tests. RESULTS: Eighty-eight of the 158 patients had low-grade oligodendrogliomas, and 70 had anaplastic oligodendrogliomas. Overall, oligodendrogliomas with chr 1p loss were located preferentially in the anterior part of the brain, whereas tumors with intact chr 1p affected mainly the posterior part of the brain (p = 0.0038). In terms of lobar involvement, a preferential location of oligodendrogliomas with chr 1p loss was found in the frontal lobes as compared with the temporal, parietal, and occipital tumors (p < 0.01). CONCLUSION: There is a significant correlation between loss of heterozygosity on chromosome 1p and tumor location in oligodendrogliomas, suggesting that subtypes of oligodendrogliomas could derive from site-specific precursors.

Temozolomide as initial treatment for adults with low-grade oligodendrogliomas or oligoastrocytomas and correlation with chromosome 1p deletions.

PURPOSE: To determine the response rate of low-grade oligodendroglial tumors (LGOT) to temozolomide (TMZ) as initial treatment and to evaluate the predictive value of chromosome 1p deletion on the radiologic response. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Adult patients with pathologically proven LGOT with progressive disease on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) were eligible for the study. TMZ was administered at the starting dose of 200 mg/m2/d for 5 days, repeated every 28 days. Response was evaluated clinically and by central review of MRIs. Chromosome 1p and 19q deletions were detected by the loss of heterozygosity technique. RESULTS: Sixty consecutive patients were included in the study. At the time of analysis, the median number of TMZ cycles delivered was 11. Clinically, 51% of patients improved, particularly those with uncontrolled epilepsy. The objective radiologic response rate was 31% (17% partial response and 14% minor response), whereas 61% of patients had stable disease and 8% experienced disease progression. The median time to maximum tumor response was 12 months (range, 5 to 20 months). Myelosuppression was the most frequent side effect, with grade 3 to 4 toxicity in 8% of patients. Loss of chromosome 1p was associated with objective tumor response (P < .004). CONCLUSION: TMZ is well tolerated and provides a substantial rate of response in LGOT. Chromosome 1p loss is correlated with radiographic response and could be a helpful marker for guiding therapeutic decision making in LGOT.

Lack of relationship between EGFR-1 immunohistochemical expression and prognosis in a multicentre clinical trial of 93 patients with advanced primary ovarian epithelial cancer (GINECO group).

Epidermal growth factor receptor 1 (EGFR-1) overexpression is usually described as linked with a worse prognosis in a variety of tumours of epithelial origin. However, its role in ovarian cancer is still controversial. The aim of the present study was to analyse the prognostic impact of EGFR-1 in a retrospective series of 93 stage III-IV primary ovarian epithelial tumours. All patients, enrolled in a multicentre GINECO prospective clinical trial, were treated with the same platinum-based combination chemotherapy, and were followed up with a median of 69 months. Epidermal growth factor receptor 1 plasma membrane expression, assessed by immunohistochemistry on paraffin-embedded tissues, was correlated with clinical parameters as well as immunohistochemical expression results of HER-2 (c-erbB-2), BAX, BCL-2, p53 and anti-Ki-67, previously studied in the same series of patients. Positive immunostaining for EGFR-1 was seen in 31 of the 93 analysed cases (33%). No correlation was found between EGFR-1 expression and clinical parameters. No correlation was found between EGFR-1 expression and other biological markers, except for HER-2, which was limit for significance. Indeed, among the EGFR-1-negative cases, 10.3% expressed HER-2, whereas the HER-2-expressing tumours accounted for 27.6% of EGFR-1-positive cases (P=0.06). Epidermal growth factor receptor 1 overexpression had no prognostic impact on both overall and progression-free survival through univariate and multivariate analyses. The potential effect of EGFR-1 and HER-2 co-expression on targeted therapy against EGFR-1 and/or HER-2 molecules has to be further analysed.

[Multiple comparison procedures: principles, limits. Applications to microarray phenotype-genotype analysis]. / Procédures de comparaisons multiples: principes et limites. Applications à l'étude différentielle de l'expression transcriptionnelle par puces à ADN.

BACKGROUND: When analysing data which simultaneously implicate a large number of statistical tests, one of the main problems is to take into account the multiplicity of these tests. The huge amount of comparisons done in studies of which the aim is to detect, using microarray, genes whose transcriptional changes are related to a biological or clinical outcome leads to a renewed interest for the multiple comparisons problem. However, this problem concerns many other fields such as psychometry, epidemiology, genetics. RESULTS: First, we introduce the multiple comparison framework. Then, we present the main procedures based on a global error rate called the "Family Wise Error Rate" (FWER) and those based on a false discovery rate expectancy (the "False Discovery Rate" (FDR) and the "positive False Discovery Rate" (pFDR)). Next, we apply the different procedures on a real dataset from a breast carcinoma study. Finally, we discuss the main results and we present guidelines for the use of these procedures.

A score test for establishing non-inferiority with respect to short-term survival in two-sample comparisons with identical proportions of long-term survivors.

In recent years randomized trials designed to establish non-inferiority of a new treatment as compared to a standard one have been more widely used. Two-sample statistics have been proposed for this equivalence testing problem. However, they are not suited to situations where a long-term survivor fraction is expected. In this paper we propose a score test designed for establishing non-inferiority for the new treatment as compared to the standard one while assuming identical long-term survivor rates. Simulations results show that the proposed statistic has satisfactory size and power as long as certain restricting conditions are verified. A breast cancer trial is analysed as an example.

Molecular heterogeneity of oligodendrogliomas suggests alternative pathways in tumor progression.

OBJECTIVE: To identify different genetic molecular profiles in oligodendrogliomas and to evaluate their prognostic significance. METHODS: The main genetic alterations reported in glial tumors were investigated in 26 oligodendrogliomas (10 World Health Organization grade II and 16 World Health Organization grade III). Correlation between identified molecular changes and pathologic grade or clinical course was subsequently analyzed using univariate and multivariate statistical analyses. RESULTS: Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) on chromosome 1p, 19q, and 10; P16/CDKN2A homozygous deletion; EGFR (epidermal growth factor receptor) amplification; and TP53 and PTEN mutations were observed in 14 (54%), 15 (58%), 9 (35%), 7 (27%), 5 (19%), 1 (4%), and 0 cases. LOH 1p and 19q were tightly associated (p < 0.0001). A mutual exclusion was found between LOH 1p/19q and EGFR amplification (p = 0.01), P16/CDKN2A deletions (p = 0.001), or LOH on 10q (p = 0.03), suggesting the existence of distinct genetic subsets in oligodendrogliomas. On univariate analysis, age <50 years (p = 0.002) and LOH 1p (p = 0.01) were associated with a longer progression-free survival (PFS) whereas LOH 10q (p = 0.03) and EGFR amplification (p = 0.007) were associated with a worse PFS. In multivariate analyses, age <50 years (p = 0.001) and LOH 1p (p = 0.006) remained independent predictive factors for PFS. CONCLUSION: These results provide evidence for two alternative molecular pathways of progression in oligodendrogliomas. The first one is associated with loss of 1p and 19q and the second one with P16/CDKN2A deletion, 10q loss, and EGFR amplification. The findings confirm the value of loss of 1p as predictor of longer progression-free survival; in addition, the study demonstrates the unfavorable impact of 10q loss and EGFR amplification on the prognosis.

A semiparametric approach for the two-sample comparison of survival times with long-term survivors.

In the two-sample comparison of survival times with long-term survivors, the overall difference between the two distributions reflects differences occurring in early follow-up for susceptible subjects and in long-term follow-up for nonsusceptible subjects. In this setting, we propose statistics for testing (i) no overall, (ii) no short-term, and (iii) no long-term difference between the two distributions to be compared. The statistics are derived as follows. A semiparametric model is defined that characterizes a short-term effect and a long-term effect. By approximating this model about no difference in early survival, a time-dependent proportional hazards model is obtained. The statistics are obtained from this working model. The asymptotic distributions of the statistics for testing no overall or no short-term effects are ascertained, while that of the statistic for testing no long-term effect is valid only when the short-term effect is small. Simulation studies investigate the power properties of the proposed tests for different configurations. The results show the interesting behavior of the proposed tests for situations where a short-term effect is expected. An example investigating the impact of progesterone receptors status on local tumor relapse for patients with early breast cancer illustrates the use of the proposed tests.

Detection of gammopathy by serum protein electrophoresis for predicting and managing therapy of lymphoproliferative disorder in 911 recipients of liver transplants.

Monitoring of posttransplantation lymphoproliferative disorder (LPD) is usually based on imaging, which lacks sensitivity. A prospective study in 911 consecutive recipients of liver transplants was conducted to assess the value of gammopathy monitoring by serum protein electrophoresis (SPE) and to compare it with conventional follow-up methods. Patients systematically underwent SPE testing just before transplantation, at least twice during the first year after transplantation, and once a year thereafter. Patients with LPD underwent SPE testing every month. Immunofixation was done if abnormalities were detected by SPE. Gammopathy was observed in 114 patients, 18 of whom had onset of LPD. In 3 other patients, LPD developed, but no gammopathy was detected before onset of LPD or while LPD was present. Multivariate analyses showed gammopathy (relative risk [RR], 65.3), more than one transplantation (RR, 7.5), and viral cirrhosis (RR, 2.8) to be independent prognostic factors associated with occurrence of LPD. LPD was treated by reducing immunosuppression, with or without chemotherapy, administration of anti-CD20 monoclonal antibody, or surgery. The mortality rate was 24% (5 of 21 patients). Remission, which occurred in 13 patients, was associated with disappearance of gammopathy in 10 patients. In 5 patients, normalization of SPE results preceded the diagnosis of remission based on imaging, by a mean of 4 months. For diagnosis of LPD remission, the positive and negative predictive values of disappearance of gammopathy were 91% and 100%, respectively; and gammopathy monitoring was more sensitive than imaging (100% and 38%, respectively). Gammopathy monitoring is an inexpensive, noninvasive, sensitive way to detect LPD and assess the efficacy of treatment. It could be used routinely in follow-up of recipients of transplants.

Thymidine kinase as a proliferative marker: clinical relevance in 1,692 primary breast cancer patients.

PURPOSE: To assess the prognostic value of thymidine kinase (TK), an enzyme involved in the DNA synthesis salvage pathway, relative to other prognostic factors in primary breast cancer. PATIENTS AND METHODS: This retrospective study involved 1,692 patients with operable breast cancer treated in six institutions (median follow-up, 82 months). Among the 857 node-negative patients, 135 received adjuvant chemotherapy (fluorouracil, doxorubicin, cyclophosphamide [FAC] or fluorouracil, etoposide, and cisplatin [FEC]). TK was assayed in cytosol with a quantitative radioenzymatic technique. Disease-specific survival (DSS), local recurrence-free interval (LRI), and distant-relapse-free interval (DRI) were investigated. RESULTS: High TK levels were associated with large tumor size, high histologic grade, and steroid hormone receptor negativity. Univariate analysis of the entire data set showed that high TK levels were related to shorter DSS (P < 10(-5)), LRI (P < 10(-3)), and DRI (P < 10(-5)). In time-dependent Cox models, high TK levels remained an independent predictor of the three outcomes, both in the overall population and in node-negative patients, although its prognostic value decreased over time. In node-negative patients, the introduction of an interaction term in multivariate analysis suggested that chemotherapy was more efficacious for patients who had tumors with high TK contents. In node-positive patients, high TK levels were related only to an increased risk of LRI. CONCLUSION: High TK values are an important risk factor in node-negative patients and seem to be associated with a beneficial effect of adjuvant FAC or FEC in patients who received adjuvant chemotherapy. The rationale of chemotherapy for patients with slowly proliferating tumors has to be discussed from a risk-benefit point of view.

Cytotoxic synergism of methioninase in combination with 5-fluorouracil and folinic acid.

Potentiation of the cytotoxic activity of 5-fluorouracil (FUra) by folinic acid (5-HCO-H4folate) is due to elevation of the methylene tetrahydrofolate (CH2-H4folate) level, which increases the stability of the ternary complex of thymidylate synthase (TS), fluorodeoxyuridine monophosphate, and CH2-H4folate that inactivates the TS. Methionine deprivation results in the production of tetrahydrofolate (H4folate) and, subsequently, CH2-H4folate from methyl tetrahydrofolate, as a consequence of the induction of methionine synthesis. We hypothesized that the efficacy of FUra could be augmented by the combination of high-concentration 5-HCO-H4folate and recombinant methioninase (rMETase), a methionine-cleaving enzyme. Studies in vitro were performed with the cell line CCRF-CEM. Cytotoxic synergism of FUra + rMETase and FUra + 5-HCO-H4folate + rMETase was demonstrated with the combination index throughout a broad concentration range of FUra and rMETase. A subcytotoxic concentration of rMETase reduced the IC50 of FUra by a factor of 3.6, and by a factor of 7.5, in the absence and in the presence of 5-HCO-H4folate, respectively. 5-HCO-H4folate increased the intracellular concentrations of CH2-H4folate and H4folate from their baseline levels. Concentrations of folates were not changed by exposure to rMETase. Levels of free TS in cells treated with FUra + 5-HCO-H4folate and with FUra + rMETase were lower than those in cells exposed to FUra alone. The decrease of TS was still more pronounced in cells treated with FUra + 5-HCO-H4folate + rMETase. The synergism described in this study will be a basis for further exploration of combinations of fluoropyrimidines, folates, and rMETase.

Treatment of paraneoplastic neurological syndromes with antineuronal antibodies (Anti-Hu, anti-Yo) with a combination of immunoglobulins, cyclophosphamide, and methylprednisolone.

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the effect of a combination of immunoglobulins (IVIg), cyclophosphamide (CTX), and methylprednisolone (MP) on the clinical course of patients with paraneoplastic neurological syndrome (PNS) and antineuronal antibodies (Abs). METHODS: Seventeen patients with paraneoplastic encephalomyelitis/sensory neuropathy (PEM/SN) with anti-Hu Abs (n = 10) or cerebellar degeneration (PCD) with anti-Yo Abs (n = 7) received one to nine cycles (mean 3.5) of a combination of IVIg (0.5 g/kg/day from days 1 to 5), CTX (600 mg/m2 at day 1) and MP (1g/day from day 1 to 3). The Rankin scale (RS) was used to evaluate the response. A positive response was considered as either improvement or stabilisation in patients who were still ambulatory (RS< or =3) at the onset of treatment, whereas only improvement, and not stabilisation, was considered a therapeutic benefit in bedridden patients (RS> or =4). RESULTS: Tolerance was good and no patient experienced grade 3/4 toxicity (World Health Organisation). Sixteen patients were evaluable for response. Of the seven patients with RS> or =4, none improved. Of the nine patients with RS< or =3, none improved but three (two SN and one PCD) stabilised for 4, 35, and 16 months. CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that vigorous immunosuppressive treatment is not useful in severely disabled PNS patients with antineuronal Abs. In a minority of patients (mainly with SN) who are not severely disabled at the onset of treatment, a transient stabilisation is possible and deserves further evaluation.

Second line chemotherapy with docetaxel in patients with recurrent malignant glioma: a phase II study.

The objective of the study was to assess the efficacy of docetaxel in recurrent supratentorial malignant gliomas. The sample size of the study was determined by the Gehan's method for a response rate of 20% and a beta error of 5%. In the first step 14 patients (age 27-69, median 50; Karnofsky index 50-90, median 75) with recurrent malignant glioma after surgery, radiotherapy and nitrosourea, were enrolled (12 glioblastomas, 2 anaplastic astrocytomas). Docetaxel at the initial dose of 80 mg/m2 was administered every 3 weeks until progression or unacceptable toxicity. A total of 41 cycles was administered. Patients received a median of two cycles (range 1-6). No complete or partial response was observed. Therefore, according to the design of the study, no additional patients were enrolled and the trial was terminated. Two stabilizations were observed (14 and 15 weeks). Median TTP was 7 weeks (44 days). Median overall survival from recurrence was 26.5 weeks (6.4 months). Grade 3-4 neutropenia was observed in 8 patients (57%) but no life-threatening toxicity was observed. Other toxicities were uncommon and mild. Dose reduction was performed in 5 patients. This study suggests that docetaxel displayed no significant activity in patients with malignant recurrent gliomas.

Clinical outcome of patients with anti-Hu-associated encephalomyelitis after treatment of the tumor.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate 1) the effect of the tumor treatment on the clinical course of paraneoplastic encephalomyelitis (PEM) with anti-Hu antibodies, 2) the impact of immunotherapy on the tumor evolution, and 3) the outcome of the small cell lung cancer (SCLC) of PEM patients compared with that of patients without PEM. METHODS: The authors retrospectively analyzed 51 PEM patients (42 with SCLC, 9 with other tumors) who received antineoplastic treatment with (25 patients) or without (26) concomitant immunotherapy. Tumor response was assessed at the end of the antineoplastic treatment. Progression of PEM was defined as a change of at least 1 point in the Rankin scale measured at the onset and at the end of the tumor treatment. To evaluate the outcome of SCLC, 27 PEM patients with SCLC were matched one-to-one with SCLC patients without PEM for age, performance status, tumor stage, and type of antineoplastic treatment. RESULTS: Thirty-six (70%) patients were neurologically stable at the end of the tumor treatment. In a logistic regression analysis, tumor complete response was the only predictor of PEM stabilization (OR 7.07; 95% CI 1.68 to 29.76; p = 0.006). Immunotherapy did not modify the outcome of the tumor and PEM. Median survival was similar in SCLC patients with and without PEM, but the probability of survival at 30 months was higher in PEM patients with SCLC (OR 5.26; 95% CI 1.0004 to 27.6902; p = 0.03). CONCLUSIONS: Complete response of the tumor seems to have a favorable influence on the course of paraneoplastic encephalomyelitis (PEM). Concomitant immunotherapy does not adversely affect the tumor outcome. The small cell lung cancer of PEM patients may have a slightly better evolution than that of patients without PEM.

Prognostic value of uPA and p53 accumulation measured by quantitative biochemical assays in 1245 primary breast cancer patients: a multicentre study.

The purpose of this retrospective multicentre study was to assess the prognostic value of urokinase plasminogen activator (uPA) and p53 levels in a large series of primary breast cancer, using an automatic quantitative luminometric method. Samples of 1245 operable breast tumours were collected from seven French institutions and patients were followed for a median of 75 months. The median uPA and p53 levels assayed in cytosols by means of the immunoluminometric technique (LIA) were 0.31 and 0.20 ng mg(-1) of protein respectively. In univariate analysis, high levels of uPA and p53 were associated with shorter disease-specific survival, disease-free interval, and distant recurrence-free interval. The 5-year survival rates were 95.5% among patients with uPA values below the 20th percentile, and 77.5% in those with values above the 80th percentile. The 5-year survival rates were 91.0% in patients with p53 values below the 20th percentile, and 77.6% in those with values above the 80th percentile. In multivariate analysis, the risk of disease-related death increased with uPA levels after adjustment for tumour size, histological grade, lymph node involvement, and estrogen receptor status. A high level of uPA was also related to a shorter disease-free interval and distant recurrence-free interval. In node-negative patients, a high level of uPA remained strongly related to the three outcomes. When adjusted for other prognostic factors, p53 was no longer significantly related to the outcomes. Given its rapidity and simple application to routinely prepared cytosols, this LIA may be useful for evaluating the prognostic impact of uPA in primary breast cancer, particularly in node-negative patients. According to our results, the prognostic value of p53 accumulation is limited when uPA is included in multivariate analysis.

Unobserved covariates in the two-sample comparison of survival times: a maximum efficiency robust test.

In analysing a clinical trial with the logrank test, the hazards between the two groups are usually assumed to be proportional. Nevertheless, this hypothesis is no longer valid with unobserved covariates. As a consequence, there is a loss of power of the logrank test for testing the null hypothesis H(0) of no treatment effect. We propose a test suited for taking into account unobserved covariates. The proposed approach is based on a proportional hazard frailty model whereby the omitted covariates are considered as an unobserved frailty variable. The procedure is as follows. In a first step, the weighted logrank test optimal for testing H(0) against a general proportional hazard frailty model is obtained and its specialization for a gamma frailty variable is derived. In a second step, the proposed test is obtained by combining the maximin efficiency robustness principle and the gamma frailty distribution properties. Simulation studies investigate the power properties of the test for different frailty distributions. A breast cancer clinical trial is analysed as an example. The proposed test might be recommended rather than the logrank for practical situations in which one expects heterogeneity related to omitted covariates.