The design of chronic toxicology studies of monoclonal antibodies: implications for the reduction in use of non-human primates.

The changing environment of monoclonal antibody (mAb) development is impacting on the cost of drug development and the use of experimental animals, particularly non-human primates (NHPs). The drive to reduce these costs is huge and involves rethinking and improving nonclinical studies to make them more efficient and more predictive of man. While NHP use might be unavoidable in many cases because of the exquisite specificity and consequent species selectivity of mAbs, our increasing knowledge base can be used to improve drug development and maximise the output of experimental data. Data on GLP regulatory toxicology studies for 58mAbs were obtained from 10 companies across a wide range of therapeutic indications. These data have been used to investigate current practice and identify study designs that minimise NHP use. Our analysis shows that there is variation in the number of animals used for similar studies. This information has been used to develop practical guidance and make recommendations on the use of science-based rationale to design studies using fewer animals taking into account the current regulatory guidance. There are eight recommendations intended to highlight areas for consideration. They include guidance on the main group size, the inclusion of recovery groups and the number of dose groups used in short and long term chronic toxicology studies.

In vitro cytokine release assays: reducing the risk of adverse events in man.

The induction of cytokine release is a common consequence of the administration of therapeutic antibodies and in most cases is either tolerated by the patient or can be managed clinically by the administration of corticosteroids. However, in 2006, the administration of TGN1412 to six patients in a Phase I trial resulted in a unprecedentedly high level of cytokine release, systemic organ failure and the hospitalization of the subjects. Whilst the path to failure in this incident was multifactorial, at least one contributing factor was the lack of a robust in vitro model that would allow the prediction of the in vivo activity of a therapeutic antibody. In this article we review the current 'state of the art' of in vitro cytokine release assays and explore potential future developments.