Host stress drives tolerance and persistence: The bane of anti-microbial therapeutics.

Antibiotic resistance, typically associated with genetic changes within a bacterial population, is a frequent contributor to antibiotic treatment failures. Antibiotic persistence and tolerance, which we collectively term recalcitrance, represent transient phenotypic changes in the bacterial population that prolong survival in the presence of typically lethal concentrations of antibiotics. Antibiotic recalcitrance is challenging to detect and investigate-traditionally studied under in vitro conditions, our understanding during infection and its contribution to antibiotic failure is limited. Recently, significant progress has been made in the study of antibiotic-recalcitrant populations in pathogenic species, including Mycobacterium tuberculosis, Staphylococcus aureus, Salmonella enterica, and Yersiniae, in the context of the host environment. Despite the diversity of these pathogens and infection models, shared signals and responses promote recalcitrance, and common features and vulnerabilities of persisters and tolerant bacteria have emerged. These will be discussed here, along with progress toward developing therapeutic interventions to better treat recalcitrant pathogens.

In-patient evolution of a high-persister Escherichia coli strain with reduced in vivo antibiotic susceptibility.

Gram-negative bacterial bloodstream infections (GNB-BSI) are common and frequently lethal. Despite appropriate antibiotic treatment, relapse of GNB-BSI with the same bacterial strain is common and associated with poor clinical outcomes and high healthcare costs. The role of persister cells, which are sub-populations of bacteria that survive for prolonged periods in the presence of bactericidal antibiotics, in relapse of GNB-BSI is unclear. Using a cohort of patients with relapsed GNB-BSI, we aimed to determine how the pathogen evolves within the patient between the initial and subsequent episodes of GNB-BSI and how these changes impact persistence. Using Escherichia coli clinical bloodstream isolate pairs (initial and relapse isolates) from patients with relapsed GNB-BSI, we found that 4/11 (36%) of the relapse isolates displayed a significant increase in persisters cells relative to the initial bloodstream infection isolate. In the relapsed E. coli strain with the greatest increase in persisters (100-fold relative to initial isolate), we determined that the increase was due to a loss-of-function mutation in the ptsI gene encoding Enzyme I of the phosphoenolpyruvate phosphotransferase system. The ptsI mutant was equally virulent in a murine bacteremia infection model but exhibited 10-fold increased survival to antibiotic treatment. This work addresses the controversy regarding the clinical relevance of persister formation by providing compelling data that not only do high-persister mutations arise during bloodstream infection in humans but also that these mutants display increased survival to antibiotic challenge in vivo.

Inflammasome-mediated glucose limitation induces antibiotic tolerance in Staphylococcus aureus.

Staphylococcus aureus is a leading human pathogen that frequently causes relapsing infections. The failure of antibiotics to eradicate infection contributes to infection relapse. Host-pathogen interactions have a substantial impact on antibiotic susceptibility and the formation of antibiotic tolerant cells. In this study, we interrogate how a major S. aureus virulence factor, α-toxin, interacts with macrophages to alter the microenvironment of the pathogen, thereby influencing its susceptibility to antibiotics. We find α-toxin-mediated activation of the NLRP3 inflammasome induces antibiotic tolerance. Induction of tolerance is driven by increased glycolysis in the host cells, resulting in glucose limitation and ATP depletion in S. aureus. Additionally, inhibition of NLRP3 activation improves antibiotic efficacy in vitro and in vivo, suggesting that this strategy has potential as a host-directed therapeutic to improve outcomes. Our findings identify interactions between S. aureus and the host that result in metabolic crosstalk that can determine the outcome of antimicrobial therapy.

Hydrogen Peroxide, Povidone-Iodine and Chlorhexidine Fail to Eradicate Staphylococcus aureus Biofilm from Infected Implant Materials.

Hydrogen peroxide, povidone-iodine, and chlorhexidine are antiseptics that are commonly added to irrigants to either prevent or treat infection. There are little clinical data available that demonstrate efficacy of adding antiseptics to irrigants in the treatment of periprosthetic joint infection after biofilm establishment. The objective of the study was to assess the bactericidal activity of the antiseptics on S. aureus planktonic and biofilm. For planktonic irrigation, S. aureus was exposed to different concentrations of antiseptics. S. aureus biofilm was developed by submerging a Kirschner wire into normalized bacteria and allowing it to grow for forty-eight hours. The Kirschner wire was then treated with irrigation solutions and plated for CFU analysis. Hydrogen peroxide, povidone-iodine, and chlorhexidine were bactericidal against planktonic bacteria with over a 3 log reduction (p < 0.0001). Unlike cefazolin, the antiseptics were not bactericidal (less than 3 log reduction) against biofilm bacteria but did have a statistical reduction in biofilm as compared to the initial time point (p < 0.0001). As compared to cefazolin treatment alone, the addition of hydrogen peroxide or povidone-iodine to cefazolin treatment only additionally reduced the biofilm burden by less than 1 log. The antiseptics demonstrated bactericidal properties with planktonic S. aureus; however, when used to irrigate S. aureus biofilms, these antiseptics were unable to decrease biofilm mass below a 3 log reduction, suggesting that S. aureus biofilm has a tolerance to antiseptics. This information should be considered when considering antibiotic tolerance in established S. aureus biofilm treatment.

Antibiotic-induced accumulation of lipid II synergizes with antimicrobial fatty acids to eradicate bacterial populations.

Antibiotic tolerance and antibiotic resistance are the two major obstacles to the efficient and reliable treatment of bacterial infections. Identifying antibiotic adjuvants that sensitize resistant and tolerant bacteria to antibiotic killing may lead to the development of superior treatments with improved outcomes. Vancomycin, a lipid II inhibitor, is a frontline antibiotic for treating methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus and other Gram-positive bacterial infections. However, vancomycin use has led to the increasing prevalence of bacterial strains with reduced susceptibility to vancomycin. Here, we show that unsaturated fatty acids act as potent vancomycin adjuvants to rapidly kill a range of Gram-positive bacteria, including vancomycin-tolerant and resistant populations. The synergistic bactericidal activity relies on the accumulation of membrane-bound cell wall intermediates that generate large fluid patches in the membrane leading to protein delocalization, aberrant septal formation, and loss of membrane integrity. Our findings provide a natural therapeutic option that enhances vancomycin activity against difficult-to-treat pathogens, and the underlying mechanism may be further exploited to develop antimicrobials that target recalcitrant infection.

Persistent Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus Bacteremia: Host, Pathogen, and Treatment.

Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) is a devastating pathogen responsible for a variety of life-threatening infections. A distinctive characteristic of this pathogen is its ability to persist in the bloodstream for several days despite seemingly appropriate antibiotics. Persistent MRSA bacteremia is common and is associated with poor clinical outcomes. The etiology of persistent MRSA bacteremia is a result of the complex interplay between the host, the pathogen, and the antibiotic used to treat the infection. In this review, we explore the factors related to each component of the host-pathogen interaction and discuss the clinical relevance of each element. Next, we discuss the treatment options and diagnostic approaches for the management of persistent MRSA bacteremia.

Antibiotic Tolerance and Treatment Outcomes in Cystic Fibrosis Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus Infections.

Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) is highly prevalent in U.S. cystic fibrosis (CF) patients and is associated with worse clinical outcomes in CF. These infections often become chronic despite repeated antibiotic therapy. Here, we assessed whether bacterial phenotypes, including antibiotic tolerance, can predict the clinical outcomes of MRSA infections. MRSA isolates (n = 90) collected at the incident (i.e., acute) and early infection states from 57 patients were characterized for growth rates, biofilm formation, hemolysis, pigmentation, and vancomycin tolerance. The resistance profiles were consistent with those in prior studies. Isolates from the early stage of infection were found to produce biofilms, and 70% of the isolates exhibited delta-hemolysis, an indicator of agr activity. Strong vancomycin tolerance was present in 24% of the isolates but was not associated with intermediate vancomycin susceptibility. There were no associations between these phenotypic measures, antibiotic tolerance, and MRSA clearance. Our research suggests that additional factors may be relevant for predicting the clearance of MRSA. IMPORTANCE Chronic MRSA infections remain challenging to treat in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF). The ability of the bacterial population to survive high concentrations of bactericidal antibiotics, including vancomycin, despite lacking resistance is considered one of the main reasons for treatment failures. The connection between antibiotic tolerance and treatment outcomes remains unexplored and can be crucial for prognosis and regimen design toward eradication. In this study, we measured the capacity of 90 MRSA isolates from CF patients to form vancomycin-tolerant persister cells and evaluated their correlation with the clinical outcomes. Additionally, various traits that could reflect the metabolism and/or virulence of those MRSA isolates were systematically phenotyped and included for their predictive power. Our research highlights that despite the importance of antibiotic tolerance, additional factors need to be considered for predicting the clearance of MRSA.

The Use of Acute Immunosuppressive Therapy to Improve Antibiotic Efficacy against Intracellular Staphylococcus aureus.

Interactions between Staphylococcus aureus and the host immune system can have significant impacts on antibiotic efficacy, suggesting that targeting and modulating the immune response to S. aureus infection may improve antibiotic efficacy and improve infection outcome. As we've previously shown, high levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS), associated with an M1-like proinflammatory macrophage response, potently induce antibiotic tolerance in S. aureus. Although the proinflammatory immune response is critical for initial control of pathogen burden, recent studies demonstrate that modulation of the macrophage response to an anti-inflammatory, or M2-like, response facilitates resolution of established S. aureus skin and soft tissue infections, arthritis, and bacteremia. Here, we evaluated the impact of host-directed immunosuppressive chemotherapeutics and anti-inflammatory agents on antibiotic efficacy against S. aureus. IMPORTANCE Staphylococcus aureus is the leading cause of hospital-acquired infections in the United States with high rates of antibiotic treatment failure. Macrophages represent an important intracellular niche in experimental models of S. aureus bacteremia. Although a proinflammatory macrophage response is critical for controlling infection, previous studies have identified an antagonistic relationship between antibiotic treatment and the proinflammatory macrophage response. Reactive oxygen species, produced by macrophages during respiratory burst, coerce S. aureus into an antibiotic tolerant state, leading to poor treatment outcome. Here, we aimed to determine the potential of host-directed immunomodulators that reduce the production of reactive oxygen species to improve antibiotic efficacy against intracellular S. aureus.

Fibrin(ogen) engagement of S. aureus promotes the host antimicrobial response and suppression of microbe dissemination following peritoneal infection.

The blood-clotting protein fibrin(ogen) plays a critical role in host defense against invading pathogens, particularly against peritoneal infection by the Gram-positive microbe Staphylococcus aureus. Here, we tested the hypothesis that direct binding between fibrin(ogen) and S. aureus is a component of the primary host antimicrobial response mechanism and prevention of secondary microbe dissemination from the peritoneal cavity. To establish a model system, we showed that fibrinogen isolated from FibγΔ5 mice, which express a mutant form lacking the final 5 amino acids of the fibrinogen γ chain (termed fibrinogenγΔ5), did not support S. aureus adherence when immobilized and clumping when in suspension. In contrast, purified wildtype fibrinogen supported robust adhesion and clumping that was largely dependent on S. aureus expression of the receptor clumping factor A (ClfA). Following peritoneal infection with S. aureus USA300, FibγΔ5 mice displayed worse survival compared to WT mice coupled to reduced bacterial killing within the peritoneal cavity and increased dissemination of the microbes into circulation and distant organs. The failure of acute bacterial killing, but not enhanced dissemination, was partially recapitulated by mice infected with S. aureus USA300 lacking ClfA. Fibrin polymer formation and coagulation transglutaminase Factor XIII each contributed to killing of the microbes within the peritoneal cavity, but only elimination of polymer formation enhanced systemic dissemination. Host macrophage depletion or selective elimination of the fibrin(ogen) ß2-integrin binding motif both compromised local bacterial killing and enhanced S. aureus systemic dissemination, suggesting fibrin polymer formation in and of itself was not sufficient to retain S. aureus within the peritoneal cavity. Collectively, these findings suggest that following peritoneal infection, the binding of S. aureus to stabilized fibrin matrices promotes a local, macrophage-mediated antimicrobial response essential for prevention of microbe dissemination and downstream host mortality.

Stimulating Aminoglycoside Uptake to Kill Staphylococcus aureus Persisters.

Aminoglycosides are bactericidal drugs which require a proton motive force (PMF) for uptake into the bacterial cell. Low energy cells, such as persisters, maintain a PMF below the threshold for drug uptake and are tolerant to aminoglycosides. In this chapter, we discuss mechanisms to target the bacterial membrane and stimulate aminoglycoside uptake to kill Staphylococcus aureus persisters.

Shooting yourself in the foot: How immune cells induce antibiotic tolerance in microbial pathogens.

Antibiotic treatment failure of infection is common and frequently occurs in the absence of genetically encoded antibiotic resistance mechanisms. In such scenarios, the ability of bacteria to enter a phenotypic state that renders them tolerant to the killing activity of multiple antibiotic classes is thought to contribute to antibiotic failure. Phagocytic cells, which specialize in engulfing and destroying invading pathogens, may paradoxically contribute to antibiotic tolerance and treatment failure. Macrophages act as reservoirs for some pathogens and impede penetration of certain classes of antibiotics. In addition, increasing evidence suggests that subpopulations of bacteria can survive inside these cells and are coerced into an antibiotic-tolerant state by host cell activity. Uncovering the mechanisms that drive immune-mediated antibiotic tolerance may present novel strategies to improving antibiotic therapy.

Macrophage-Produced Peroxynitrite Induces Antibiotic Tolerance and Supersedes Intrinsic Mechanisms of Persister Formation.

Staphylococcus aureus is a leading human pathogen that frequently causes chronic and relapsing infections. Antibiotic-tolerant persister cells contribute to frequent antibiotic failure in patients. Macrophages represent an important niche during S. aureus bacteremia, and recent work has identified a role for oxidative burst in the formation of antibiotic-tolerant S. aureus. We find that host-derived peroxynitrite, the reaction product of superoxide and nitric oxide, is the main mediator of antibiotic tolerance in macrophages. Using a collection of S. aureus clinical isolates, we find that, despite significant variation in persister formation in pure culture, all strains were similarly enriched for antibiotic tolerance following internalization by activated macrophages. Our findings suggest that host interaction strongly induces antibiotic tolerance and may negate bacterial mechanisms of persister formation established in pure culture. These findings emphasize the importance of studying antibiotic tolerance in the context of bacterial interaction with the host and suggest that modulation of the host response may represent a viable therapeutic strategy to sensitize S. aureus to antibiotics.

Harnessing ultrasound-stimulated phase change contrast agents to improve antibiotic efficacy against methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus biofilms.

Bacterial biofilms, often associated with chronic infections, respond poorly to antibiotic therapy and frequently require surgical intervention. Biofilms harbor persister cells, metabolically indolent cells, which are tolerant to most conventional antibiotics. In addition, the biofilm matrix can act as a physical barrier, impeding diffusion of antibiotics. Novel therapeutic approaches frequently improve biofilm killing, but usually fail to achieve eradication. Failure to eradicate the biofilm leads to chronic and relapsing infection, is associated with major financial healthcare costs and significant morbidity and mortality. We address this problem with a two-pronged strategy using 1) antibiotics that target persister cells and 2) ultrasound-stimulated phase-change contrast agents (US-PCCA), which improve antibiotic penetration. We previously demonstrated that rhamnolipids, produced by Pseudomonas aeruginosa, could induce aminoglycoside uptake in gram-positive organisms, leading to persister cell death. We have also shown that US-PCCA can transiently disrupt biological barriers to improve penetration of therapeutic macromolecules. We hypothesized that combining antibiotics which target persister cells with US-PCCA to improve drug penetration could improve treatment of methicillin resistant S. aureus (MRSA) biofilms. Aminoglycosides alone or in combination with US-PCCA displayed limited efficacy against MRSA biofilms. In contrast, the anti-persister combination of rhamnolipids and aminoglycosides combined with US-PCCA dramatically improved biofilm killing. This novel treatment strategy has the potential for rapid clinical translation as the PCCA formulation is a variant of FDA-approved ultrasound contrast agents that are already in clinical practice and the low-pressure ultrasound settings used in our study can be achieved with existing ultrasound hardware at pressures below the FDA set limits for diagnostic imaging.

Recalcitrant Staphylococcus aureus Infections: Obstacles and Solutions.

Antibiotic treatment failure of Staphylococcus aureus infections is very common. In addition to genetically encoded mechanisms of antibiotic resistance, numerous additional factors limit the efficacy of antibiotics in vivo Identifying and removing the barriers to antibiotic efficacy are of major importance, as even if new antibiotics become available, they will likely face the same barriers to efficacy as their predecessors. One major obstacle to antibiotic efficacy is the proficiency of S. aureus to enter a physiological state that is incompatible with antibiotic killing. Multiple pathways leading to antibiotic tolerance and the formation of tolerant subpopulations called persister cells have been described for S. aureus Additionally, S. aureus is a versatile pathogen that can infect numerous tissues and invade a variety of cell types, of which some are poorly penetrable to antibiotics. It is therefore unlikely that there will be a single solution to the problem of recalcitrant S. aureus infection. Instead, specific approaches may be required for targeting tolerant cells within different niches, be it through direct targeting of persister cells, sensitization of persisters to conventional antibiotics, improved penetration of antibiotics to particular niches, or any combination thereof. Here, we examine two well-described reservoirs of antibiotic-tolerant S. aureus, the biofilm and the macrophage, the barriers these environments present to antibiotic efficacy, and potential solutions to the problem.

Author Correction: Reactive oxygen species induce antibiotic tolerance during systemic Staphylococcus aureus infection.

An amendment to this paper has been published and can be accessed via a link at the top of the paper.

Reactive oxygen species induce antibiotic tolerance during systemic Staphylococcus aureus infection.

Staphylococcus aureus is a major human pathogen that causes an array of infections ranging from minor skin infections to more serious infections, including osteomyelitis, endocarditis, necrotizing pneumonia and sepsis1. These more serious infections usually arise from an initial bloodstream infection and are frequently recalcitrant to antibiotic treatment1. Phagocytosis by macrophages and neutrophils is the primary mechanism through which S. aureus infection is controlled by the immune system2. Macrophages have been shown to be a major reservoir of S. aureus in vivo3, but the role of macrophages in the induction of antibiotic tolerance has not been explored. Here, we show that macrophages not only fail to efficiently kill phagocytosed S. aureus, but also induce tolerance to multiple antibiotics. Reactive oxygen species generated by respiratory burst attack iron-sulfur cluster-containing proteins, including TCA-cycle enzymes, result in decreased respiration, lower ATP and increased antibiotic tolerance. We further show that respiratory burst induces antibiotic tolerance in the spleen during a murine systemic infection. These results suggest that a major component of the innate immune response is antagonistic to the bactericidal activities of antibiotics.

Ureadepsipeptides as ClpP Activators.

Acyldepsipeptides are a unique class of antibiotics that act via allosterically dysregulated activation of the bacterial caseinolytic protease (ClpP). The ability of ClpP activators to kill nongrowing bacteria represents a new opportunity to combat deep-seated biofilm infections. However, the acyldepsipeptide scaffold is subject to rapid metabolism. Herein, we explore alteration of the potentially metabolically reactive α,ß unsaturated acyl chain. Through targeted synthesis, a new class of phenyl urea substituted depsipeptide ClpP activators with improved metabolic stability is described. The ureadepsipeptides are potent activators of Staphylococcus aureus ClpP and show activity against Gram-positive bacteria, including S. aureus biofilms. These studies demonstrate that a phenyl urea motif can successfully mimic the double bond, maintaining potency equivalent to acyldepsipeptides but with decreased metabolic liability. Although removal of the double bond from acyldepsipeptides generally has a significant negative impact on potency, structural studies revealed that the phenyl ureadepsipeptides can retain potency through the formation of a third hydrogen bond between the urea and the key Tyr63 residue in the ClpP activation domain. Ureadepsipeptides represent a new class of ClpP activators with improved drug-like properties, potent antibacterial activity, and the tractability to be further optimized.

Stochastic Variation in Expression of the Tricarboxylic Acid Cycle Produces Persister Cells.

Chronic bacterial infections are difficult to eradicate, though they are caused primarily by drug-susceptible pathogens. Antibiotic-tolerant persisters largely account for this paradox. In spite of their significance in the recalcitrance of chronic infections, the mechanism of persister formation is poorly understood. We previously reported that a decrease in ATP levels leads to drug tolerance in Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Staphylococcus aureus We reasoned that stochastic fluctuation in the expression of tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle enzymes can produce cells with low energy levels. S. aureus knockouts in glutamate dehydrogenase, 2-oxoketoglutarate dehydrogenase, succinyl coenzyme A (CoA) synthetase, and fumarase have low ATP levels and exhibit increased tolerance of fluoroquinolone, aminoglycoside, and ß-lactam antibiotics. Fluorescence-activated cell sorter (FACS) analysis of TCA genes shows a broad Gaussian distribution in a population, with differences of over 3 orders of magnitude in the levels of expression between individual cells. Sorted cells with low levels of TCA enzyme expression have an increased tolerance of antibiotic treatment. These findings suggest that fluctuations in the levels of expression of energy-generating components serve as a mechanism of persister formation.IMPORTANCE Persister cells are rare phenotypic variants that are able to survive antibiotic treatment. Unlike resistant bacteria, which have specific mechanisms to prevent antibiotics from binding to their targets, persisters evade antibiotic killing by entering a tolerant nongrowing state. Persisters have been implicated in chronic infections in multiple species, and growing evidence suggests that persister cells are responsible for many cases of antibiotic treatment failure. New antibiotic treatment strategies aim to kill tolerant persister cells more effectively, but the mechanism of tolerance has remained unclear until now.

Chemical Induction of Aminoglycoside Uptake Overcomes Antibiotic Tolerance and Resistance in Staphylococcus aureus.

Aminoglycoside antibiotics require proton motive force (PMF) for bacterial internalization. In non-respiring populations, PMF drops below the level required for drug influx, limiting the utility of aminoglycosides against strict and facultative anaerobes. We recently demonstrated that rhamnolipids (RLs), biosurfactant molecules produced by Pseudomonas aeruginosa, potentiate aminoglycoside activity against Staphylococcus aureus. Here, we demonstrate that RLs induce PMF-independent aminoglycoside uptake to restore sensitivity to otherwise tolerant persister, biofilm, small colony variant, and anaerobic populations of S. aureus. Furthermore, we show that this approach represses the rise of resistance, restores sensitivity to highly resistant clinical isolates, and is effective against other Gram-positive pathogens. Finally, while other membrane-acting agents can synergize with aminoglycosides, induction of PMF-independent uptake is uncommon, and distinct to RLs among several compounds tested. In all, small-molecule induction of PMF-independent aminoglycoside uptake circumvents phenotypic tolerance, overcomes genotypic resistance, and expands the utility of aminoglycosides against intrinsically recalcitrant bacterial populations.

Equine or porcine synovial fluid as a novel ex vivo model for the study of bacterial free-floating biofilms that form in human joint infections.

Bacterial invasion of synovial joints, as in infectious or septic arthritis, can be difficult to treat in both veterinary and human clinical practice. Biofilms, in the form of free-floating clumps or aggregates, are involved with the pathogenesis of infectious arthritis and periprosthetic joint infection (PJI). Infection of a joint containing an orthopedic implant can additionally complicate these infections due to the presence of adherent biofilms. Because of these biofilm phenotypes, bacteria within these infected joints show increased antimicrobial tolerance even at high antibiotic concentrations. To date, animal models of PJI or infectious arthritis have been limited to small animals such as rodents or rabbits. Small animal models, however, yield limited quantities of synovial fluid making them impractical for in vitro research. Herein, we describe the use of ex vivo equine and porcine models for the study of synovial fluid induced biofilm aggregate formation and antimicrobial tolerance. We observed Staphylococcus aureus and other bacterial pathogens adapt the same biofilm aggregate phenotype with significant antimicrobial tolerance in both equine and porcine synovial fluid, analogous to human synovial fluid. We also demonstrate that enzymatic dispersal of synovial fluid aggregates restores the activity of antimicrobials. Future studies investigating the interaction of bacterial cell surface proteins with host synovial fluid proteins can be readily carried out in equine or porcine ex vivo models to identify novel drug targets for treatment of prevention of these difficult to treat infectious diseases.