A Polymorphic Gene within the Mycobacterium smegmatis esx1 Locus Determines Mycobacterial Self-Identity and Conjugal Compatibility.

Mycobacteria mediate horizontal gene transfer (HGT) by a process called distributive conjugal transfer (DCT) that is mechanistically distinct from oriT-mediated plasmid transfer. The transfer of multiple, independent donor chromosome segments generates transconjugants with genomes that are mosaic blends of their parents. Previously, we had characterized contact-dependent conjugation between two independent isolates of Mycobacterium smegmatis. Here, we expand our analyses to include five independent isolates of M. smegmatis and establish that DCT is both active and prevalent among natural isolates of M. smegmatis. Two of these five strains were recipients but exhibited distinct conjugal compatibilities with donor strains, suggesting an ability to distinguish between potential donor partners. We determined that a single gene, Msmeg0070, was responsible for conferring mating compatibility using a combination of comparative DNA sequence analysis, bacterial genome-wide association studies (GWAS), and targeted mutagenesis. Msmeg0070 maps within the esx1 secretion locus, and we establish that it confers mycobacterial self-identity with parallels to kin recognition. Similar to other kin model systems, orthologs of Msmeg0070 are highly polymorphic. The identification of a kin recognition system in M. smegmatis reinforces the concept that communication between cells is an important checkpoint prior to DCT commitment and implies that there are likely to be other, unanticipated forms of social behaviors in mycobacteria. IMPORTANCE Conjugation, unlike other forms of HGT, requires direct interaction between two viable bacteria, which must be capable of distinguishing between mating types to allow successful DNA transfer from donor to recipient. We show that the conjugal compatibility of Mycobacterium smegmatis isolates is determined by a single, polymorphic gene located within the conserved esx1 secretion locus. This gene confers self-identity; the expression of identical Msmeg0070 proteins in both donor-recipient partners prevents DNA transfer. The presence of this polymorphic locus in many environmental mycobacteria suggests that kin identification is important in promoting beneficial gene flow between nonkin mycobacteria. Cell-cell communication, mediated by kin recognition and ESX secretion, is a key checkpoint in mycobacterial conjugation and likely plays a more global role in mycobacterial biology.

A Mycobacterial Systems Resource for the Research Community.

Functional characterization of bacterial proteins lags far behind the identification of new protein families. This is especially true for bacterial species that are more difficult to grow and genetically manipulate than model systems such as Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis To facilitate functional characterization of mycobacterial proteins, we have established a Mycobacterial Systems Resource (MSR) using the model organism Mycobacterium smegmatis This resource focuses specifically on 1,153 highly conserved core genes that are common to many mycobacterial species, including Mycobacterium tuberculosis, in order to provide the most relevant information and resources for the mycobacterial research community. The MSR includes both biological and bioinformatic resources. The biological resource includes (i) an expression plasmid library of 1,116 genes fused to a fluorescent protein for determining protein localization; (ii) a library of 569 precise deletions of nonessential genes; and (iii) a set of 843 CRISPR-interference (CRISPRi) plasmids specifically targeted to silence expression of essential core genes and genes for which a precise deletion was not obtained. The bioinformatic resource includes information about individual genes and a detailed assessment of protein localization. We anticipate that integration of these initial functional analyses and the availability of the biological resource will facilitate studies of these core proteins in many Mycobacterium species, including the less experimentally tractable pathogens M. abscessus, M. avium, M. kansasii, M. leprae, M. marinum, M. tuberculosis, and M. ulceransIMPORTANCE Diseases caused by mycobacterial species result in millions of deaths per year globally, and present a substantial health and economic burden, especially in immunocompromised patients. Difficulties inherent in working with mycobacterial pathogens have hampered the development and application of high-throughput genetics that can inform genome annotations and subsequent functional assays. To facilitate mycobacterial research, we have created a biological and bioinformatic resource (https://msrdb.org/) using Mycobacterium smegmatis as a model organism. The resource focuses specifically on 1,153 proteins that are highly conserved across the mycobacterial genus and, therefore, likely perform conserved mycobacterial core functions. Thus, functional insights from the MSR will apply to all mycobacterial species. We believe that the availability of this mycobacterial systems resource will accelerate research throughout the mycobacterial research community.

Tipping the balance between replicative and simple transposition.

The bacterial insertion sequence IS903 has the unusual ability to transpose both replicatively and non-replicatively. The majority of products are simple insertions, while co-integrates, the product of replicative transposition, occur at a low frequency (<0.1% of simple insertions). In order to define the critical steps that determine the outcome of IS903 transposition, we have isolated mutants that specifically increase the rate of replicative transposition. Here we show that the nucleotide immediately flanking the transposon influences both overall transposition frequency and co-integrate formation. In particular, when the 3'-flanking nucleotide is A, co-integrates are increased 500-fold compared with a 3' C. In addition, we have isolated five transposase mutants that increase replicative transposition. These residues are close to the catalytic residues and are thus likely to be part of the active site. These are the first transposase mutations described that affect the product of transposition. Our results are consistent with the hypothesis that a delay in cleavage of the 5'-flanking DNA will increase the effective half-life of the 3'-nicked transposon intermediate and consequently enhance co-integrate formation.

Anatomy of a preferred target site for the bacterial insertion sequence IS903.

Like many transposons the bacterial insertion sequence IS903 was thought to insert randomly. However, using both genetic and statistical approaches, we have derived a target site for IS903 that is used 84% of the time. Computational and genetic analyses of multiple IS903 insertion sites predicted a preferred target consisting of a 21 bp palindromic pattern centered on the 9 bp target duplication generated during transposition. Here we show that targeting can be dissected into four components: the 5 bp flanking sequences, the most important sequences required for site-specific insertion; the 7 bp palindromic core within the target duplication; the dinucleotide pair at the transposon-target junction; and the local DNA context. Finally, using a substrate with multiple target sites we show that a target site is more likely found by a local bind-and-slide model and not by extended DNA tracking.

Construction and application of mycobacterial reporter transposons.

The transposon Tn5367, which is a derivative of the mycobacterial insertion sequence IS1096, was modified by introducing novel genes to produce reporter transposons which can be used to generate transposon insertion libraries containing mycobacterial gene or operon fusions. A plasmid that is temperature-sensitive for replication in mycobacteria was used to deliver promoterless lacZ or aph reporter genes to Mycobacterium smegmatis as transcriptional (lacZ), or translational ('aph) fusions. Mutants containing lacZ produced varying intensities of blue colour on indicator media. This reporter activity could be used as a quantitative measure of promoter strength. Mutants displaying varying levels of resistance to kanamycin were obtained by transpositional insertion of the 'aph reporter lacking a promoter, ribosome binding site and start codon to form functionally active translational fusions. Finally, inclusion of the R6Kgamma origin within Tn5367 allowed transposon insertions to be rescued in an Escherichia coli host strain permissive for the replication of this origin. This study demonstrates that transcriptional and translational reporter derivatives of Tn5367 are functional, and they supplement the growing range of molecular tools available for the study of mycobacteria.

Direct selection of IS903 transposon insertions by use of a broad-host-range vector: isolation of catalase-deficient mutants of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans.

Transposon mutagenesis in bacteria generally requires efficient delivery of a transposon suicide vector to allow the selection of relatively infrequent transposition events. We have developed an IS903-based transposon mutagenesis system for diverse gram-negative bacteria that is not limited by transfer efficiency. The transposon, IS903phikan, carries a cryptic kan gene, which can be expressed only after successful transposition. This allows the stable introduction of the transposon delivery vector into the host. Generation of insertion mutants is then limited only by the frequency of transposition. IS903phikan was placed on an IncQ plasmid vector with the transposase gene located outside the transposon and expressed from isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG)-inducible promoters. After transposase induction, IS903phikan insertion mutants were readily selected in Escherichia coli by their resistance to kanamycin. We used IS903phikan to isolate three catalase-deficient mutants of the periodontal pathogen Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans from a library of random insertions. The mutants display increased sensitivity to hydrogen peroxide, and all have IS903phikan insertions within an open reading frame whose predicted product is closely related to other bacterial catalases. Nucleotide sequence analysis of the catalase gene (designated katA) and flanking intergenic regions also revealed several occurrences of an 11-bp sequence that is closely related to the core DNA uptake signal sequence for natural transformation of Haemophilus influenzae. Our results demonstrate the utility of the IS903phikan mutagenesis system for the study of A. actinomycetemcomitans. Because IS903phikan is carried on a mobilizable, broad-host-range IncQ plasmid, this system is potentially useful in a variety of bacterial species.

In vitro transposition of Tn552: a tool for DNA sequencing and mutagenesis.

We have explored the potential of the Tn 552 in vitro transposition reaction as a genetic tool. The reaction is simple (requiring a single protein component), robust and efficient, readily producing insertions into several percent of target DNA. Most importantly, Tn 552 insertions in vitro appear to be essentially random. Extensive analyses indicate that the transposon exhibits no significant regional or sequence specificity for target DNA and leaves no discernible 'cold' spots devoid of insertions. The utility of the in vitro reaction for DNA sequencing was demonstrated with a cosmid containing the Mycobacterium smegmatis recBCD gene cluster. The nucleotide sequence of the entire operon was determined using 71 independent Tn 552 insertions, which generated over 13.5 kb of unique sequence and simultaneously provided a comprehensive collection of insertion mutants. The relatively short ends of Tn 552 make construction of novel transposons a simple process and we describe several useful derivatives. The data presented suggest that Tn 552 transposition is a valuable addition to the arsenal of tools available for molecular biology and genomics.

IS903 transposase mutants that suppress defective inverted repeats.

The inverted repeats (IRs) of the insertion element IS903 are composed of two functional regions. An inner region, consisting of basepairs 6-18, is the transposase binding site. The outer region (positions 1-3) is not contacted during initial transposase binding, but is essential for efficient transposition. We have examined the interaction of the IR with the transposase by isolating transposase suppressors of IR mutations. These suppressors define two patches within the N-terminus of the protein. One class of suppressors, which rescued the majority of outer IR mutants tested, contained mutations in close proximity to an aspartate residue (D121) believed to form part of the catalytic DDE motif, suggesting that their suppressive effect is in the positioning of the catalytic site at the terminus of the transposon. The hypertransposition phenotype of mutant VA119 is also consistent with this hypothesis. The second class was more allele specific and preferentially suppressed a mutation at position 3 of the IR. Finally, we showed that mutations at the termini of the IR elevate the frequency of cointegrate formation by IS903. Other outer IR mutations did not have this effect. These data are consistent with the terminal bases of the transposon playing multiple and distinct roles in transposition.

Conjugal transfer of chromosomal DNA in Mycobacterium smegmatis.

The genus Mycobacterium includes the major human pathogens Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Mycobacterium leprae. The development of rational drug treatments for the diseases caused by these and other mycobacteria requires the establishment of basic molecular techniques to determine the genetic basis of pathogenesis and drug resistance. To date, the ability to manipulate and move DNA between mycobacterial strains has relied on the processes of transformation and transduction. Here, we describe a naturally occurring conjugation system present in Mycobacterium smegmatis, which we anticipate will further facilitate the ability to manipulate the mycobacterial genome. Our data rule out transduction and transformation as possible mechanisms of gene transfer in this system and are most consistent with conjugal transfer. We show that recombinants are not the result of cell fusion and that transfer occurs from a distinct donor to a recipient. One of the donor strains is mc(2)155, a highly transformable derivative that is considered the prototype laboratory strain for mycobacterial genetics; the demonstration that it is conjugative should increase its genetic manipulability dramatically. During conjugation, extensive regions of chromosomal DNA are transferred into the recipient and then integrated into the recipient chromosome by multiple recombination events. We propose that DNA transfer is occurring by a mechanism similar to Hfr conjugation in Escherichia coli.

Target choice and orientation preference of the insertion sequence IS903.

We have examined the targeting preference of the bacterial insertion element IS903 by determining the sites of insertion of a large number of transposition events into the 55-kb conjugative plasmid pOX38. Despite the large target size, all the insertions were clustered in four small distinct regions associated with conjugal DNA transfer. Within these regions, many different sites were used for insertion; however, there were a few sites that IS903 inserted into more than once. Alignment of the insertion sites showed that there was no consensus sequence within the 9-bp target duplication but that there were preferred sequences located symmetrically on either side of the target. This is consistent with target recognition by a dimer or multimer of transposase, with either sequence-specific or structure-specific interactions on both sides of the target. We show further that when one of these preferred regions was cloned into a second conjugative plasmid, pUB307, it was still a preferred target, implying that all the sequences necessary for target selection are contained within this DNA segment. Also, we observed a very strong preference for insertion in a single orientation in pUB307. We examined the possibility that either DNA replication from the origin of vegetative replication, oriV, or the origin of transfer, oriT, might determine this orientation effect. We find that reversing the direction of vegetative replication had no effect on the orientation of transposon insertions; however, reversing the direction of DNA transfer abolished the orientation effect. This supports the idea that conjugal DNA transfer imparts a polarity on the target that is sensed by the transposon.

Defining functional regions of the IS903 transposase.

The insertion sequence IS903 encodes a 307 amino acid residue protein, transposase, that is essential for transposition. It is a multi-functional DNA-binding protein that specifically recognizes the 18 bp inverted repeats at the ends of the element and also recognizes DNa non-specifically when it captures a target site. In addition, transposase performs catalytic functions when it mediates the cleavage and religation steps of transposition. We have carried out deletion and mutational analyses to define functional domains of the transposase protein. The deletion studies delineate a 99 residue region of the protein (residues 31 to 129) that specifies binding to the inverted repeat. A slightly larger maltose-binding protein-transposase fusion that includes residues 22 to 139 (Tnp 22-139) binds as efficiently and with the same specificity as the full-length transposase protein. Tnp 22-139 also induces a DNA bend similar to that of the wild-type protein, and so we conclude that all binding and bending specificity is contained within the N-terminal domain of the protein. Unlike full-length transposase, Tnp 22-139 forms additional higher-order complexes in band-shift gels suggesting that the deletion has exposed a surface(s) capable of participating in protein-protein interactions. Six highly conserved residues in the C-terminal portion of the protein were mutated to alanine. Each mutant protein was binding-proficient but defective in transposition. The phenotype of these substitutions, and their alignment with residues shown to abolish catalysis of other transposases and integrases, suggest that these are residues responsible for catalytic steps in transposition of IS903; we believe three of these residues comprise the DDE motif, conserved in transposases and integrases. Our data are consistent with IS903 transposase being composed of two domains: an N-terminal domain primarily involved in DNA binding and a C-terminal domain that is involved in catalysis.

Cis preference of the IS903 transposase is mediated by a combination of transposase instability and inefficient translation.

The transposase protein encoded by the insertion element IS903 belongs to an unusual class of DNA-binding proteins, termed cis-acting proteins, that act preferentially at their site of synthesis. Previous work had led us to propose that instability of the IS903 transposase was a major determinant of its cis preference. Here we describe the isolation of two classes of mutations within the transposase gene that increased action in trans. One class specifically increased trans action without increasing the level of transposition when the mutant gene was located in cis to the transposon. In particular, a threonine-to-proline substitution at amino acid 25 (T25P) reduced cis preference about 60-fold. The half-life of this mutant transposase was significantly longer than that of the wild-type transposase, confirming the critical role of protein instability. The second, larger, class of mutations increased the level of transposition both in trans and in cis. The behaviour and location of these mutations were consistent with an increase in gene expression by improving translational initiation. Several of these mutations exerted a disproportionate effect on the action of transposase in trans, implying that translation efficiency may affect more than just the amount of transposase made. Our results indicate that cis preference of the IS903 transposase is mediated by a combination of transposase instability and inefficient translation initiation.

An IS903-based vector for transposon mutagenesis and the isolation of gene fusions.

A derivative of the IS903 transposon (Tn) is described that is capable of creating lacZ gene fusions upon transposition. It should find wide use as a tool for Tn mutagenesis in bacteria since it can be used both to generate mutants and to examine gene expression. The transposase-encoding gene (tnp) is located outside the Tn in the vector, thus Tn insertions into a genome are stably maintained in the absence of its cis-acting transposase (Tnp). The element carries a KmR gene allowing for the direct selection of transposition events in hosts that cannot support pBR322 plasmid replication and facilitating the subcloning of genes into which the Tn has inserted.

Binding of the IS903 transposase to its inverted repeat in vitro.

We have purified the transposase of IS903 in three different ways. We find that transposase expressed as a fusion protein with either glutathione-S-transferase or maltose-binding protein is soluble and can be purified rapidly using affinity chromatography. The third purification requires extracting the native transposase from an insoluble pellet using an alkaline pH buffer. All three proteins bind specifically to the ends of IS903 and give identical patterns of protection when challenged with DNase I. We have used the more stable fusion proteins to examine transposase--DNA interactions in vitro. Methylation interference experiments have identified critical bases for transposase binding; methylated purines that inhibit binding all lie within the inner part of the 18 bp inverted repeat (bp 7-16). Moreover, the positions and identities of these purines suggest that the transposase interacts with base pairs in adjacent major and minor grooves. Binding assays with mutant inverted repeats confirm that transposase binding is sensitive to sequence changes only within this inner region. We propose that the transposase binding site is limited to this domain of the inverted repeat. These data are consistent with our previous analysis of the behaviour of mutant ends in vivo, from which we postulated that the inverted repeat was composed of two functional domains; an inner binding domain (bp 6-18), which included a region of minor groove interactions, and an outer domain that was involved in a step subsequent to transposase binding.

Role of instability in the cis action of the insertion sequence IS903 transposase.

An unusual subset of DNA-binding proteins, termed cis-acting proteins, has been shown to act preferentially at their site of synthesis; the transposases of several bacterial insertion sequences (ISs) fall into this class. The transposase of IS903 exhibits a strong preference for action in cis: complementation of defective transposons in trans occurs at less than 1%. Furthermore, transposition mediated by transposase acting in cis is extremely sensitive to the distance between the 3' end of the transposase gene and the nearest transposon inverted repeat; we find that an insertion of 1 kilobase of DNA reduces transposition to 1-2% of control levels. Here we show that there is a strong correlation between the stability of transposase and its ability to act in trans. We found that the wild-type transposase is a very unstable protein with a physical half-life of about 3 min. However, a transposase-beta-galactosidase fusion protein has a much greater half-life and can act equally well in cis or in trans. In addition, the native transposase is stabilized in lon- strains of Escherichia coli, and, in these protease-deficient strains, trans action of transposase is increased 10- to 100-fold. These results suggest that instability of the IS903 transposase is a major determinant of its cis action and that the La protease, product of the lon gene, is an important determinant of transposase instability.

Genetic analysis of the interaction of the insertion sequence IS903 transposase with its terminal inverted repeats.

The insertion sequence IS903 has perfect, 18-base-pair terminal repeats that are the presumed binding sites of its transposase. We have isolated mutations throughout this inverted repeat and analyzed their effect on transposition. We show that every position in the inverted repeat (with the possible exception of position 4) is important for efficient transposition. Furthermore, various substitutions at a single position can have a wide range of effects. Analysis of these hierarchical effects suggests that transposase contacts the minor groove in the region from position 13 to position 16 but makes major groove (or more complex) interactions with the outer portion of the inverted repeat. Our data indicate that the transposase exhibits relaxed specificity for the "second" end of a transposed segment; the defect in transposition of virtually all mutant inverted repeats can be rescued by a wild-type end. However, this rescue exhibits a pronounced position effect; in most cases, it is efficient only when the wild-type end is close to the 3' end of the transposase gene. This confirms the cis-acting nature of the transposase protein and suggests the initial transposase-inverted repeat interaction is the rate-limiting step in transposition. From the behavior of transposons with one mutant and one wild-type end, we infer that the inverted repeat contains two functional domains--one for initial complex formation with transposase and the other for effective completion of transpositional recombination. To support this hypothesis we show that an end with a mutation in one domain can significantly rescue an end with a mutation in the other domain.

Mobilization of the non-conjugative plasmid RSF1010: a genetic analysis of its origin of transfer.

The oriT site of the broad host-range multicopy IncQ plasmid RSF1010 was cloned onto the 2.2 kb pBR322-derived vector pED825. By successive subcloning and construction of deletions, the oriT region was localised on an 80-88 bp segment of DNA. This segment was contained within the HaeII fragment of RSF1010 that is known to include the relaxation nick site. The oriT region was sequenced and inverted repeats and sequences homologous to the oriT regions of ColE1 and RK2 were identified. A striking 10 bp inverted repeat at one end of the 88 bp oriT segment may be important for recognition of oriT, and its possible role in transfer is discussed. As for other plasmids, the oriT region served as the site for recA-independent, transfer-dependent, site-specific recombination. This provides genetic evidence that strand breakage and re-joining occur at oriT during transfer. Mobilization was independent of transcription by RNA polymerase in the donor cell, as shown by the lack of effect of rifampicin. Inversion of the oriT site with respect to the plasmid oriV site showed that there was no functional dependence of oriT on oriV for synthesis of primers possibly involved in recipient conjugal DNA synthesis. Alternative mechanisms are discussed.

Mobilization of the non-conjugative plasmid RSF1010: a genetic and DNA sequence analysis of the mobilization region.

The entire region required for mobilization of the non-conjugative plasmid RSF1010 has been cloned into a mobilization-deficient pBR322 derivative. The segment of DNA cloned was approximately 1.8 kb and included the origin of conjugal DNA transfer (oriT). The DNA sequence of the mobilization region has been determined, and revealed the presence of several overlapping reading frames. The isolation and mapping of both Tn1725 and BamH1-linker insertions and comparison with the DNA sequence data has allowed the identification of three genes required for mobilization. Two of these genes are overlapping and encode proteins of 16 kDa and greater than 65 kDa (although the truncated protein is functional, the gene extends outside the region cloned). The third gene is transcribed in the opposite direction. Promoters capable of transcribing these genes were located by S1 mapping in the inter-cistronic region between these divergently transcribed genes. The oriT site is located in this region, and the transcriptional patterns observed for mob+ and mob- plasmids implied that the promoters may be regulated by two of the mobilization proteins binding to the oriT site.

A simple and efficient procedure for saturation mutagenesis using mixed oligodeoxynucleotides.

A method is described for the efficient saturation mutagenesis of a segment of DNA. A pool of mixed oligodeoxynucleotides (oligos) is generated in a single synthesis by deliberately contaminating each nucleotide reservoir with a low concentration of the other three monomers. The concentration at which a particular level of substitution (i.e. single, double, etc.) is favored can be calculated from simple probability. The pool of single-stranded, mixed oligos is then cloned directly into a double-stranded vector. This is achieved by designing the oligo such that it has ends which are complementary to those left by restriction enzymes generating 5' and 3' overhanging ends. The efficiency of the cloning procedure that we describe is greater than 90%. As a result, direct sequence analysis of transformant clones is justified. In the example described, 2/3 of M13 plaques containing an inserted oligo carried one or more mutations. Mutations generated by this method are randomly distributed throughout the inserted DNA and include all types of substitution. The ease and efficiency of the procedure eliminate any requirement for genetic selection of mutants and thus allow phenotypically silent mutations to be obtained.