Your browser doesn't support javascript.
loading
Show: 20 | 50 | 100
Results 1 - 20 de 24
Filter
Add more filters










Publication year range
1.
IEEE Trans Biomed Eng ; 71(4): 1104-1114, 2024 Apr.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-37874730

ABSTRACT

OBJECTIVE: In the process of cochlear implantation surgery, it is crucial to develop a method to control the temperature during the drilling of the implant channel since high temperatures can result in damage to bone and nerve tissue. METHODS: This paper simplified the traditional point heat source temperature rise model and proposed a novel extreme peck drilling model to quantitatively calculate the maximum temperature rise value. It is also innovatively introduced a new method for calculating the best peck drilling duty cycle to strictly control the maximum temperature rise value. Besides, the neural network is trained with virtual data to identify two important thermal parameters in the temperature rise model. RESULTS: In the experiment of epoxy resin and temporal bone, the difference between predicted maximum temperature and actual maximum temperature was less than 1.5 °C, and the error rate was less than 10%. And the error source was analyzed by variational mode decomposition, along with discussion of potential solutions. In the temperature control experiment, the model successfully controlled the maximum temperature rise within 10 °C.For cochlear implantation surgery, we also divide the implantation channel into different stages based on the bone density in CT images to identify thermal parameters and calculate drilling strategies. CONCLUSION: This method provides a new strategy for accurate and effective control of borehole heat generation. SIGNIFICANCE: These achievements provide new ideas and directions for research in cochlear implantation surgery and related fields, and are expected to have extensive application in medical practice.


Subject(s)
Cochlear Implantation , Temperature , Cochlear Implantation/methods , Bone and Bones , Hot Temperature
2.
Comput Methods Programs Biomed ; 209: 106333, 2021 Sep.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-34391999

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: The decompressive laminectomy is one of the most common operations to treat lumbar spinal stenosis by removing the laminae above the spinal nerve. Recently, an increasing number of robots are deployed during the surgical process to reduce the burden on surgeons and to reduce complications. However, for the robot-assisted decompressive laminectomy, an accurate 3D model of laminae from a CT image is highly desired. The purpose of this paper is to precisely segment the laminae with fewer calculations. METHODS: We propose a two-stage neural network SegRe-Net. In the first stage, the entire intraoperative CT image is inputted to acquire the coarse segmentation of vertebrae with low resolution and the probability map of the laminar centers. The second stage is trained to refine the segmentation of laminae. RESULTS: Three public available datasets were used to train and validate the models. The experimental results demonstrated the effectiveness of the proposed network on laminar segmentation with an average Dice coefficient of 96.38% and an average symmetric surface distance of 0.097 mm. CONCLUSION: The proposed two-stage network can achieve better results than those baseline models in the laminae segmentation task with less calculation amount and learnable parameters. Our methods improve the accuracy of laminar models and reduce the image processing time. It can be used to provide a more precise planning trajectory and may promote the clinical application for the robot-assisted decompression laminectomy surgery.


Subject(s)
Robotics , Image Processing, Computer-Assisted , Laminectomy , Neural Networks, Computer , Spine
3.
Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg ; 16(3): 485-494, 2021 Mar.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-33507483

ABSTRACT

PURPOSE: Grinding trajectory planning for robot-assisted laminectomy is a complicated and cumbersome task. The purpose of this research is to automatically obtain the surgical target area from the CT image, and based on this, formulate a reasonable robotic grinding trajectory. METHODS: We propose a deep neural network for laminae positioning, a trajectory generation strategy, and a grinding speed adjusting strategy. These algorithms can obtain surgical information from CT images and automatically complete grinding trajectory planning. RESULTS: The proposed laminae positioning network can reach a recognition accuracy of 95.7%, and the positioning error is only 1.12 mm in the desired direction. The simulated surgical planning on the public dataset has achieved the expected results. In a set of comparative robotic grinding experiments, those using the speed adjustment algorithm obtained a smoother grinding force. CONCLUSION: Our work can automatically extract laminar centers from the CT image precisely to formulate a reasonable surgical trajectory plan. It simplifies the surgical planning process and reduces the time needed for surgeons to perform such a cumbersome operation manually.


Subject(s)
Laminectomy/instrumentation , Robotic Surgical Procedures/instrumentation , Surgery, Computer-Assisted/instrumentation , Algorithms , Humans , Laminectomy/methods , Neural Networks, Computer , Normal Distribution , Reproducibility of Results , Robotic Surgical Procedures/methods , Robotics/methods , Spinal Stenosis/diagnostic imaging , Spinal Stenosis/physiopathology , Surgery, Computer-Assisted/methods , Tomography, X-Ray Computed/methods
4.
Surg Endosc ; 35(4): 1667-1674, 2021 04.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-32514830

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND: Handheld robotic laparoscopic instruments fill the gap between robotic and conventional instruments, combining the advantages of degrees of freedom and low price. The difficulty and value in learning these new instruments require detailed investigation. METHODS: Forty novice surgeons with no laparoscopic experience were randomly assigned to two groups: conventional instrument group (Group Conv) and robotic instrument group (Group Rob). The same training protocol was used in both groups: after viewing a standard operation film, laparoscopic suture training was administered using the corresponding instruments. After each training period, surgeons were tested using a force-sensing test platform. Maximum force (MF) and impulse (IMP) of operators through each ring were recorded. Learning curves based on MF and IMP for both instruments were compared. Institutional review board approval is not needed for this study. RESULTS: MF and IMP of both groups decreased with increased training time; the learning curve of Group Conv decreased faster than that of Group Rob. When training time reached 13 h, the MF of Group Rob was significantly lower than that of Group Conv (P < 0.05), while IMP showed no significant difference between the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: Effective training reduces operator MF and IMP, possibly decreasing damage to tissues with both conventional and handheld robotic needle holders. Group Rob took longer to reach a plateau, but subsequently had lower suture tension than did Group Conv. MF is more sensitive than IMP for measuring performance progress.


Subject(s)
Robotic Surgical Procedures/education , Robotic Surgical Procedures/instrumentation , Clinical Competence , Female , Humans , Laparoscopy/education , Laparoscopy/instrumentation , Learning Curve , Male , Surgeons/education , Time Factors , Video Recording , Young Adult
5.
Surg Endosc ; 34(2): 719-727, 2020 02.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-31209612

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND: Handheld laparoscopic robotized instruments have been developed to combine the advantages of a robotic operation system and conventional laparoscopic instruments. Direct objective standards are needed to quantify surgeons' skill level and validate the advantages of new instruments. This study describes and objectively evaluates the use of a robotized instrument using a force-sensing test platform. METHODS: The test platform consists of 12 rings on a hypersensitive force sensor. Forty volunteers were recruited: the expert group included 20 laparoscopic experts and the novice group included 20 medical students in their 4th year without laparoscopic skills. The baseline of the two groups was identified using a conventional needle holder. Participants then repeated the test with the robotized needle holder after training. The maximum force and impulse of each ring were analyzed for each group. Institutional review board approval is not needed for this study. RESULTS: Significantly lower maximum force and impulse were observed in the expert group than in the novice group during the baseline test (all P < 0.05). After training, a significant difference remained in maximum force and impulse between the two groups using the robotized needle holder (all P < 0.05). Within each group, there was no difference in maximum force or impulse using the robotized needle holder after training compared to that on using the conventional needle holder (all P > 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: The maximum force and impulse recorded by a test platform can accurately identify participants' laparoscopic skill level. Six hours' training can ensure that experts master the use of the robotized needle holder, but this training session is too short for novices to improve their performance with a new instrument. The force-sensing test platform can reflect the suturing characteristics of users based on the skill level and is useful for laparoscopic suture training.


Subject(s)
Exoskeleton Device , Laparoscopy , Robotics/instrumentation , Surgeons , Surgical Instruments , Clinical Competence , Humans , Laparoscopy/instrumentation , Laparoscopy/methods , Needs Assessment , Surgeons/education , Surgeons/standards , Suture Techniques/instrumentation
6.
Sensors (Basel) ; 19(2)2019 Jan 21.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-30669638

ABSTRACT

Methods of point cloud registration based on ICP algorithm are always limited by convergence rate, which is related to initial guess. A good initial alignment transformation can sharply reduce convergence time and raise efficiency. In this paper, we propose a global registration method to estimate the initial alignment transformation based on HEALPix (Hierarchical Equal Area isoLatitude Pixelation of a sphere), an algorithm for spherical projections. We adopt EGI (Extended Gaussian Image) method to map the normals of the point cloud and estimate the transformation with optimized point correspondence. Cross-correlation method is used to search the best alignment results in consideration of the accuracy and robustness of the algorithm. The efficiency and accuracy of the proposed algorithm were verified with created model and real data from various sensors in comparison with similar methods.

7.
Int J Med Robot ; 15(2): e1974, 2019 Apr.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-30471653

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND: Open surgical consoles widely employed in minimally invasive surgery have better ergonomics than closed consoles. To enhance surgical robots' ergonomics, operational efficiency, and safety, an effective master-slave motion alignment model should be established. METHODS: The kinematic model of the robot system based on laparoscopic camera coordinate system is built in the first place. Then, the relative pose between the operator's eyes and the display is measured by Tobii Eye Tracking Sensor and is subsequently used to improve the master-slave motion alignment model. RESULTS: Robot threading experiments are conducted by two doctors and three testers to verify the kinematic model. As a result, in contrast to the original model, the improved model reduces both operation time and the number of collisions. CONCLUSIONS: The improved master-slave motion alignment model, in which the transformation matrix between the operator's eyes and the display is employed, raises the ergonomics, operational efficiency, and safety.


Subject(s)
Robotic Surgical Procedures/methods , Biomechanical Phenomena , Humans
8.
Sensors (Basel) ; 18(11)2018 Nov 05.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-30400670

ABSTRACT

This paper addresses a detection problem where sparse measurements are utilized to estimate the source parameters in a mixed multi-modal radiation field. As the limitation of dimensional scalability and the unimodal characteristic, most existing algorithms fail to detect the multi-point sources gathered in narrow regions, especially with no prior knowledge about intensity and source number. The proposed Peak Suppressed Particle Filter (PSPF) method utilizes a hybrid scheme of multi-layer particle filter, mean-shift clustering technique and peak suppression correction to solve the major challenges faced by current existing algorithms. Firstly, the algorithm realizes sequential estimation of multi-point sources in a cross-mixed radiation field by using particle filtering and suppressing intensity peak value, while existing algorithms could just identify single point or spatially separated point sources. Secondly, the number of radioactive sources could be determined in a non-parametric manner as the fact that invalid particle swarms would disperse automatically. In contrast, existing algorithms either require prior information or rely on expensive statistic estimation and comparison. Additionally, to improve the prediction stability and convergent performance, distance correction module and configuration maintenance machine are developed to sustain the multimodal prediction stability. Finally, simulations and physical experiments are carried out in aspects such as different noise level, non-parametric property, processing time and large-scale estimation, to validate the effectiveness and robustness of the PSPF algorithm.

9.
Sensors (Basel) ; 18(7)2018 Jun 28.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-29958441

ABSTRACT

Due to the narrow space and a harsh chemical environment in the sterilization processes for the end-effector of surgical robots, it is difficult to install and integrate suitable sensors for the purpose of effective and precise force control. This paper presents an innovative tension sensor for estimation of grasping force in our laparoscope surgical robot. The proposed sensor measures the tension of cable using fiber gratings (FBGs) which are pasted in the grooves on the inclined cantilevers of the sensor. By exploiting the stain measurement characteristics of FBGs, the small deformation of the inclined cantilevers caused by the cable tension can be measured. The working principle and the sensor model are analyzed. Based on the sensor model, the dimensions of the sensor are designed and optimized. A dedicated experimental setup is established to calibrate and test the sensor. The results of experiments for estimation the grasping force validate the sensor.


Subject(s)
Equipment Design , Laparoscopes/standards , Laparoscopy/instrumentation , Robotics/instrumentation , Surgery, Computer-Assisted/instrumentation , Calibration , Sterilization
10.
Sensors (Basel) ; 18(7)2018 Jun 27.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-29954135

ABSTRACT

As one of the major methods for the diagnosis and treatment of cancers in their early stages, the percutaneous puncture technique has bright prospect in biopsy, ablation, proximity radiotherapy, and drug delivery. Recent years, researchers found the flexible needle cannot realize feedback control during the puncture surgeries only by path planning. To solve this problem, the flexible needle is tried to achieve real-time detection in this paper. Compared with previous methods, the strain gauges glued on the needle surface rather than the medical imaging techniques is used to collect the information to reconstruct the needle curve, which is benefit to integrate the whole system and obtain a more simple and accurate closed-loop control. This paper presented the math model of curve fitting and analyzed the causes of curve fitting errors. To verify the feasibility of this method, an experiment setup was built. Results from the experiments validated the solution in this paper to be effective.

11.
Materials (Basel) ; 11(6)2018 May 29.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-29844276

ABSTRACT

A friction⁻inertial-based rotary motor driven by shear piezoelectric actuators (SPAs) is proposed in this paper, which possesses many superior features, including high resolution, compact size, large load-capacity, and low cost. In order to eliminate the step loss and increase the step size when an external load is applied, the power-function-shape driving signal was used to actuate the rotary motor. According to the step characteristics under this driving signal, two motion modes were observed and defined, namely the stick-shoot motion mode and the stick-slip-shoot motion mode. The former motion mode can realize a large step size while the later one cannot due to the slipping during the rising phase. After analyzing the results from the numerical simulation and the experiment study, it was found that the motion performance of the motor is closely related to the preload and the base number of the driving signal rather than the size of SPAs, which means the motor can be further downsized according to its actual requirements.

12.
Sensors (Basel) ; 18(3)2018 Mar 19.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-29562684

ABSTRACT

To achieve strength augmentation, endurance enhancement, and human assistance in a functional autonomous exoskeleton, control precision, back drivability, low output impedance, and mechanical compactness are desired. In our previous work, two elastic modules were designed for human-robot interaction sensing and compliant control, respectively. According to the intrinsic sensing properties of the elastic module, in this paper, only one compact elastic module is applied to realize both purposes. Thus, the corresponding control strategy is required and evolving internal model control is proposed to address this issue. Moreover, the input signal to the controller is derived from the deflection of the compact elastic module. The human-robot interaction is considered as the disturbance which is approximated by the output error between the exoskeleton control plant and evolving forward learning model. Finally, to verify our proposed control scheme, several experiments are conducted with our robotic exoskeleton system. The experiment shows a satisfying result and promising application feasibility.


Subject(s)
Lower Extremity , Elasticity , Exoskeleton Device , Humans
13.
Sensors (Basel) ; 17(10)2017 Sep 30.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-28974011

ABSTRACT

The tendon driven mechanism using a cable and pulley to transmit power is adopted by many surgical robots. However, backlash hysteresis objectively exists in cable-pulley mechanisms, and this nonlinear problem is a great challenge in precise position control during the surgical procedure. Previous studies mainly focused on the transmission characteristics of the cable-driven system and constructed transmission models under particular assumptions to solve nonlinear problems. However, these approaches are limited because the modeling process is complex and the transmission models lack general applicability. This paper presents a novel position compensation control scheme to reduce the impact of backlash hysteresis on the positioning accuracy of surgical robots' end-effectors. In this paper, a position compensation scheme using a support vector machine based on feedforward control is presented to reduce the position tracking error. To validate the proposed approach, experimental validations are conducted on our cable-pulley system and comparative experiments are carried out. The results show remarkable improvements in the performance of reducing the positioning error for the use of the proposed scheme.


Subject(s)
Laparoscopy , Robotic Surgical Procedures , Tendons
14.
IEEE Int Conf Rehabil Robot ; 2017: 919-924, 2017 07.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-28813938

ABSTRACT

The most important step for lower extremity exoskeleton is to infer human motion intent (HMI), which contributes to achieve human exoskeleton collaboration. Since the user is in the control loop, the relationship between human robot interaction (HRI) information and HMI is nonlinear and complicated, which is difficult to be modeled by using mathematical approaches. The nonlinear approximation can be learned by using machine learning approaches. Gaussian Process (GP) regression is suitable for high-dimensional and small-sample nonlinear regression problems. GP regression is restrictive for large data sets due to its computation complexity. In this paper, an online sparse GP algorithm is constructed to learn the HMI. The original training dataset is collected when the user wears the exoskeleton system with friction compensation to perform unconstrained movement as far as possible. The dataset has two kinds of data, i.e., (1) physical HRI, which is collected by torque sensors placed at the interaction cuffs for the active joints, i.e., knee joints; (2) joint angular position, which is measured by optical position sensors. To reduce the computation complexity of GP, grey relational analysis (GRA) is utilized to specify the original dataset and provide the final training dataset. Those hyper-parameters are optimized offline by maximizing marginal likelihood and will be applied into online GP regression algorithm. The HMI, i.e., angular position of human joints, will be regarded as the reference trajectory for the mechanical legs. To verify the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm, experiments are performed on a subject at a natural speed. The experimental results show the HMI can be obtained in real time, which can be extended and employed in the similar exoskeleton systems.


Subject(s)
Exoskeleton Device , Lower Extremity/physiology , Machine Learning , Self-Help Devices , Algorithms , Equipment Design , Humans , Knee Joint/physiology , Movement/physiology , Normal Distribution
15.
Sensors (Basel) ; 17(4)2017 Apr 12.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-28417944

ABSTRACT

In order to get natural and intuitive physical interaction in the pose adjustment of the minimally invasive surgery manipulator, a hybrid variable admittance model based on Fuzzy Sarsa(λ)-learning is proposed in this paper. The proposed model provides continuous variable virtual damping to the admittance controller to respond to human intentions, and it effectively enhances the comfort level during the task execution by modifying the generated virtual damping dynamically. A fuzzy partition defined over the state space is used to capture the characteristics of the operator in physical human-robot interaction. For the purpose of maximizing the performance index in the long run, according to the identification of the current state input, the virtual damping compensations are determined by a trained strategy which can be learned through the experience generated from interaction with humans, and the influence caused by humans and the changing dynamics in the robot are also considered in the learning process. To evaluate the performance of the proposed model, some comparative experiments in joint space are conducted on our experimental minimally invasive surgical manipulator.


Subject(s)
Minimally Invasive Surgical Procedures , Algorithms , Computer Simulation , Learning , Robotics
16.
ISA Trans ; 67: 389-397, 2017 Mar.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-28108003

ABSTRACT

This paper presents an active disturbance rejection control (ADRC) based strategy, which is applied to track the human gait trajectory for a lower limb rehabilitation exoskeleton. The desired human gait trajectory is derived from the Clinical Gait Analysis (CGA). In ADRC, the total external disturbance can be estimated by the extended state observer (ESO) and canceled by the designed control law. The observer bandwidth and the controller bandwidth are determined by the practical principles. We simulated the proposed methodology in MATLAB. The numerical simulation shows the tracking error comparison and the estimated errors of the extended state observer. Two experimental tests were carried out to prove the performance of the algorithm presented in this paper. The experiment results show that the proposed ADRC behaves a better performance than the regular proportional integral derivative (PID) controller. With the proposed ADRC, the rehabilitation system is capable of tracking the target gait more accurately.

17.
Sensors (Basel) ; 16(12)2016 Nov 30.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-27916869

ABSTRACT

Due to the urgent need for high precision surgical equipment for minimally invasive spinal surgery, a novel robot-assistant system was developed for the accurate placement of pedicle screws in lumbar spinal surgeries. The structure of the robot was based on a macro-micro mechanism, which includes a serial mechanism (macro part) and a bi-planar 5R parallel mechanism (micro part). The macro part was used to achieve a large workspace, while the micro part was used to obtain high stiffness and accuracy. Based on the transfer function of dimension errors, the factors affecting the accuracy of the end effectors were analyzed. Then the manufacturing errors and joint angle error on the position-stance of the end effectors were investigated. Eventually, the mechanism of the strain energy produced by the deformation of linkage via forced assembly and displacements of the output point were calculated. The amount of the transfer errors was quantitatively analyzed by the simulation. Experimental tests show that the error of the bi-planar 5R mechanism can be controlled no more than 1 mm for translation and 1° for rotation, which satisfies the required absolute position accuracy of the robot.

18.
Sensors (Basel) ; 16(9)2016 Sep 02.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-27598160

ABSTRACT

Locomotion mode identification is essential for the control of a robotic rehabilitation exoskeletons. This paper proposes an online support vector machine (SVM) optimized by particle swarm optimization (PSO) to identify different locomotion modes to realize a smooth and automatic locomotion transition. A PSO algorithm is used to obtain the optimal parameters of SVM for a better overall performance. Signals measured by the foot pressure sensors integrated in the insoles of wearable shoes and the MEMS-based attitude and heading reference systems (AHRS) attached on the shoes and shanks of leg segments are fused together as the input information of SVM. Based on the chosen window whose size is 200 ms (with sampling frequency of 40 Hz), a three-layer wavelet packet analysis (WPA) is used for feature extraction, after which, the kernel principal component analysis (kPCA) is utilized to reduce the dimension of the feature set to reduce computation cost of the SVM. Since the signals are from two types of different sensors, the normalization is conducted to scale the input into the interval of [0, 1]. Five-fold cross validation is adapted to train the classifier, which prevents the classifier over-fitting. Based on the SVM model obtained offline in MATLAB, an online SVM algorithm is constructed for locomotion mode identification. Experiments are performed for different locomotion modes and experimental results show the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm with an accuracy of 96.00% ± 2.45%. To improve its accuracy, majority vote algorithm (MVA) is used for post-processing, with which the identification accuracy is better than 98.35% ± 1.65%. The proposed algorithm can be extended and employed in the field of robotic rehabilitation and assistance.


Subject(s)
Algorithms , Exoskeleton Device , Locomotion , Rehabilitation , Robotics , Support Vector Machine , Adult , Humans , Male , Signal Processing, Computer-Assisted
19.
Appl Bionics Biomech ; 2016: 5017381, 2016.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-27069353

ABSTRACT

A lower limb assistive exoskeleton is designed to help operators walk or carry payloads. The exoskeleton is required to shadow human motion intent accurately and compliantly to prevent incoordination. If the user's intention is estimated accurately, a precise position control strategy will improve collaboration between the user and the exoskeleton. In this paper, a hybrid position control scheme, combining sliding mode control (SMC) with a cerebellar model articulation controller (CMAC) neural network, is proposed to control the exoskeleton to react appropriately to human motion intent. A genetic algorithm (GA) is utilized to determine the optimal sliding surface and the sliding control law to improve performance of SMC. The proposed control strategy (SMC_GA_CMAC) is compared with three other types of approaches, that is, conventional SMC without optimization, optimal SMC with GA (SMC_GA), and SMC with CMAC compensation (SMC_CMAC), all of which are employed to track the desired joint angular position which is deduced from Clinical Gait Analysis (CGA) data. Position tracking performance is investigated with cosimulation using ADAMS and MATLAB/SIMULINK in two cases, of which the first case is without disturbances while the second case is with a bounded disturbance. The cosimulation results show the effectiveness of the proposed control strategy which can be employed in similar exoskeleton systems.

20.
Open Biomed Eng J ; 7: 116-24, 2013.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: mdl-24339837

ABSTRACT

This paper proposes a hybrid soft tissue model that consists of a multilayer structure and many spheres for surgical simulation system based on meshless. To improve accuracy of the model, tension is added to the three-parameter viscoelastic structure that connects the two spheres. By using haptic device, the three-parameter viscoelastic model (TPM) produces accurate deformationand also has better stress-strain, stress relaxation and creep properties. Stress relaxation and creep formulas have been obtained by mathematical formula derivation. Comparing with the experimental results of the real pig liver which were reported by Evren et al. and Amy et al., the curve lines of stress-strain, stress relaxation and creep of TPM are close to the experimental data of the real liver. Simulated results show that TPM has better real-time, stability and accuracy.

SELECTION OF CITATIONS
SEARCH DETAIL
...