Biallelic mutations in the TOGARAM1 gene cause a novel primary ciliopathy.

BACKGROUND: Dysfunction in non-motile cilia is associated with a broad spectrum of developmental disorders characterised by clinical heterogeneity. While over 100 genes have been associated with primary ciliopathies, with wide phenotypic overlap, some patients still lack a molecular diagnosis. OBJECTIVE: To investigate and functionally characterise the molecular cause of a malformation disorder observed in two sibling fetuses characterised by microphthalmia, cleft lip and palate, and brain anomalies. METHODS: A trio-based whole exome sequencing (WES) strategy was used to identify candidate variants in the TOGARAM1 gene. In silico, in vitro and in vivo (Caenorhabditis elegans) studies were carried out to explore the impact of mutations on protein structure and function, and relevant biological processes. RESULTS: TOGARAM1 encodes a member of the Crescerin1 family of proteins regulating microtubule dynamics. Its orthologue in C. elegans, che-12, is expressed in a subset of sensory neurons and localises in the dendritic cilium where it is required for chemosensation. Nematode lines harbouring the corresponding missense variant in TOGARAM1 were generated by CRISPR/Cas9 technology. Although chemotaxis ability on a NaCl gradient was not affected, che-12 point mutants displayed impaired lipophilic dye uptake, with shorter and altered cilia in sensory neurons. Finally, in vitro analysis of microtubule polymerisation in the presence of wild-type or mutant TOG2 domain revealed a faster polymerisation associated with the mutant protein, suggesting aberrant tubulin binding. CONCLUSIONS: Our data are in favour of a causative role of TOGARAM1 variants in the pathogenesis of this novel disorder, connecting this gene with primary ciliopathy.

Array-Comparative Genomic Hybridization Analysis in Fetuses with Major Congenital Malformations Reveals that 24% of Cases Have Pathogenic Deletions/Duplications.

Karyotyping and aCGH are routinely used to identify genetic determinants of major congenital malformations (MCMs) in fetal deaths or terminations of pregnancy after prenatal diagnosis. Pathogenic rearrangements are found with a variable rate of 9-39% for aCGH. We collected 33 fetuses, 9 with a single MCM and 24 with MCMs involving 2-4 organ systems. aCGH revealed copy number variants in 14 out of 33 cases (42%). Eight were classified as pathogenic which account for a detection rate of 24% (8/33) considering fetuses with 1 or more MCMs and 33% (8/24) taking into account fetuses with multiple malformations only. Three of the pathogenic variants were known microdeletion syndromes (22q11.21 deletion, central chromosome 22q11.21 deletion, and TAR syndrome) and 5 were large rearrangements, adding up to >11 Mb per subject and comprising strong phenotype-related genes. One of those was a de novo complex rearrangement, and the remaining 4 duplications and 2 deletions were 130-900 kb in size, containing 1-7 genes, and were classified as variants of unknown clinical significance. Our study confirms aCGH as a powerful technique to ascertain the genetic etiology of fetal major congenital malformations.

Large cryptic genomic rearrangements with apparently normal karyotypes detected by array-CGH.

BACKGROUND: Conventional karyotyping (550 bands resolution) is able to identify chromosomal aberrations >5-10 Mb, which represent a known cause of intellectual disability/developmental delay (ID/DD) and/or multiple congenital anomalies (MCA). Array-Comparative Genomic Hybridization (array-CGH) has increased the diagnostic yield of 15-20%. RESULTS: In a cohort of 700 ID/DD cases with or without MCA, including 15 prenatal diagnoses, we identified a subgroup of seven patients with a normal karyotype and a large complex rearrangement detected by array-CGH (at least 6, and up to 18 Mb). FISH analysis could be performed on six cases and showed that rearrangements were translocation derivatives, indistinguishable from a normal karyotype as they involved a similar band pattern and size. Five were inherited from a parent with a balanced translocation, whereas two were apparently de novo. Genes spanning the rearrangements could be associated with some phenotypic features in three cases (case 3: DOCK8; case 4: GATA3, AKR1C4; case 6: AS/PWS deletion, CHRNA7), and in two, likely disease genes were present (case 5: NR2F2, TP63, IGF1R; case 7: CDON). Three of our cases were prenatal diagnoses with an apparently normal karyotype. CONCLUSIONS: Large complex rearrangements of up to 18 Mb, involving chromosomal regions with similar size and band appearance may be overlooked by conventional karyotyping. Array-CGH allows a precise chromosomal diagnosis and recurrence risk definition, further confirming this analysis as a first tier approach to clarify molecular bases of ID/DD and/or MCA. In prenatal tests, array-CGH is confirmed as an important tool to avoid false negative results due to karyotype intrinsic limit of detection.

Bilaterally cleft lip and bilateral thumb polydactyly with triphalangeal component in a patient with two de novo deletions of HSA 4q32 and 4q34 involving PDGFC, GRIA2, and FBXO8 genes.

We report on a newborn boy with a bilateral cleft of the primary palate, duplicated triphalangeal thumbs, and a patent foramen ovale. During childhood he had moderate developmental delay. Brain MRI at 4 years was normal. The concurrence of non-syndromic clefts of the lip/palate (CL/P) and duplicated thumbs with triphalangeal component has, to our knowledge, not been reported so far. In our case, array-CGH analysis documented two de novo deletions (∼1.2 Mb and ∼400 Kb) of the long arm of chromosome 4, containing four genes: platelet-derived growth factor C (PDGFC), glycine receptor beta subunit (GLRB), glutamate receptor ionotropic AMPA2 (GRIA2), and F-box protein 8 gene (FBXO8). PDGFC codes for a mesenchymal cell growth factor already known to be associated with clefts of the lip. Pdgfc(-/-) mice have skeletal anomalies, and facial schisis resembling human cleft/lip palate. GRIA2 codes for a ligand-activated cation channel that mediates the fast component of postsynaptic excitatory currents in neurons, and may be linked to cognitive dysfunction. FBXO8, a gene of unknown function, is a member of the F-box gene family, among which FBXW4, within the minimal duplicated region associated with human split-hand/foot malformation type 3 (SHFM type 3). The presence of overlapping deletions in patients who do not share the same phenotype of our case suggests incomplete penetrance, and a possible effect of modifier genetic factors.