ABSTRACT
The endogenous metabolism of estrogens is primarily oxidative and involves hydroxylation of the steroid at either C2 (2-OHE1) or C16 (16-OHE1). While the 2-OHE1 metabolites are essentially devoid of peripheral biological activity, 16-OHE1 is an estrogen agonist. There is evidence of an association between the 2-OHE1/16-OHE1 metabolites ratio and breast cancer risk. The CYP1A1 gene may play a role in the 2-hydroxylation (2-OH) of estradiol. African-American women with the wild-type CYP1A1 gene showed a significant increase in the 2-OHE1/16-OHE1 ratio, from 1.35 +/- 0.56 at baseline to 2.39 +/- 0.98 (p = 0.006) after 5 days of treatment with indole-3-carbinol (400 mg/day), a 2-OHE1 inducer. Women with the Msp1 polymorphism showed no significant increase, (0.37% +/- 0.17%). In a case-control study involving 57 women with breast cancer and 312 female controls, the frequency of the homozygous Msp1 polymorphism was 4.2% in African-American controls and 16% in African-American breast cancer cases. The odds ratio of breast cancer with the Msp1 homozygous variant was 8.4 (95% confidence interval: 1.7-41.7). This association was not observed in Caucasian women. The other CYP1A1 polymorphisms were not associated with breast cancer. The CYP1A1 Msp1 polymorphism may be a marker of altered estradiol metabolism and of increased susceptibility to estrogen-related breast cancer in African-Americans.
Subject(s)
Breast Neoplasms/metabolism , Cytochrome P-450 CYP1A1/genetics , Estradiol/metabolism , Adult , Black People/genetics , Breast Neoplasms/genetics , Case-Control Studies , Estradiol/physiology , Estrogen Antagonists/pharmacology , Female , Gene Expression Regulation, Neoplastic , Genotype , Humans , Hydroxyestrones/metabolism , Indoles/pharmacology , Male , Middle Aged , Polymorphism, Genetic , RNA, Messenger/genetics , RNA, Messenger/metabolism , Risk Factors , White People/geneticsABSTRACT
This study investigated the relationship in human placenta between polycyclic aromatic hydrocabon (PAH)-DNA adduct levels and two biomarkers of cytochrome P4501A1 (CYP1A1): gene induction evidenced by CYP1A1 mRNA, and a genetic polymorphism, the CYP1A1 MspI RFLP. CYP1A1 codes for an inducible enzyme system that catalyzes the bioactivation of PAHs. Prior research found a high correlation in human lung tissue between CYP1A1 activity and DNA damage from PAHs. The CYP1A1 Mspi RFLP has been linked in some studies to risk of lung cancer. The relationships in human placenta between DNA damage, CYP1A1 activity and genotype have not been well characterized and may be relevant to risks from transplacental PAH exposure. The study cohort consisted of 70 newborns from Krakow, Poland, a city with elevated air pollution, and 90 newborns from nearby Limanowa, an area with lower air pollution but greater indoor coal use. Contrary to results seen previously in lung tissue, CYP1A1 mRNA was not significantly correlated with PAH-DNA adduct levels in the placenta. Smoking (self-reported maternal and infant plasma cotinine) was significantly associated with CYP1A1 mRNA levels (P < 0.01), but not with PAH-DNA adduct levels. Placental PAH-DNA adduct levels were significantly higher in infants with the CYP1A1 MspI restriction site compared with infants without the restriction site (P < 0.01), implicating a genetic factor in inter-individual variation in DNA damage in human placenta. Further studies are needed to determine the relevance of this finding to risk of transplacental carcinogenesis.
Subject(s)
Cytochrome P-450 CYP1A1/metabolism , DNA Adducts/metabolism , Placenta/metabolism , Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons/metabolism , Adult , Biomarkers , Cohort Studies , Cytochrome P-450 CYP1A1/genetics , Enzyme Induction , Female , Genotype , Humans , Infant, Newborn , Polymorphism, Restriction Fragment Length , RNA, Messenger/metabolismABSTRACT
Industrialized regions in Poland are characterized by high ambient pollution, including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) from coal burning for industry and home heating. In experimental bioassays, certain PAHs are transplacental carcinogens and developmental toxicants. Biologic markers can facilitate evaluation of effects of environmental PAHs on the developing infant. We measured the amount of PAHs bound to DNA (PAH-DNA adducts) in maternal and umbilical white blood cells. The cohort consisted of 70 mothers and newborns from Krakow, Poland, an industrialized city with elevated air pollution. Modulation of adduct levels by genotypes previously linked to risk of lung cancer, specifically glutathione S-transferase MI (GSTM1) and cytochrome P4501A1 (CYP1A1) Msp restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP), was also investigated. There was a dose-related increase in maternal and newborn adduct levels with ambient pollution at the women's place of residence among subjects who were not employed away from home (p < or = 0.05). Maternal smoking (active and passive) significantly increased maternal (p < or = 0.01) but not newborn adduct levels. Neither CYP1A1 Msp nor GSTM1 polymorphisms was associated with maternal adducts. However, adducts were significantly higher in newborns heterozygous or homozygous for the CYP1A1 Msp RFLP compared to newborns without the RFLP (p = 0.04). Results indicate that PAH-induced DNA damage in mothers and newborns is increased by ambient air pollution. In the fetus, this damage appears to be enhanced by the CYP1A1 Mspl polymorphism.
Subject(s)
Air Pollutants/adverse effects , DNA Damage , Environmental Exposure/adverse effects , Adult , Air Pollutants/analysis , Biomarkers/blood , Cytochrome P-450 CYP1A1/genetics , DNA Adducts/blood , Environmental Exposure/analysis , Environmental Exposure/classification , Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay , Female , Genotype , Glutathione Transferase/genetics , Humans , Infant, Newborn , Linear Models , Matched-Pair Analysis , Maternal Exposure/adverse effects , Poland , Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons/analysis , Polymerase Chain Reaction , Polymorphism, Restriction Fragment Length , Pregnancy , Prenatal Exposure Delayed Effects , Retrospective Studies , Smoking/adverse effects , Urban HealthABSTRACT
In conducting field studies of human exposure, we have encountered significant methodological challenges. The management strategy our group developed to conduct two recent studies of environmental health utilizes a collaborative study design process and innovative protocol management tools, and emphasizes community outreach. We present here the phases of planning, development and realization of two studies--one conducted in an environmentally contaminated area, and another in an occupational setting. We show how the use of this management strategy increases the efficiency of field operations and improves variability assessment.
Subject(s)
Community Health Planning/organization & administration , Environmental Exposure , Molecular Epidemiology/trends , Occupational Exposure , Bulgaria/epidemiology , Chromium/adverse effects , Epidemiologic Methods , Formaldehyde/adverse effects , Humans , Interprofessional Relations , Molecular Epidemiology/organization & administration , New Jersey/epidemiology , Research DesignSubject(s)
Black People/genetics , Cytochrome P-450 Enzyme System/genetics , Lung Neoplasms/epidemiology , Lung Neoplasms/genetics , Polymorphism, Genetic , Black or African American/statistics & numerical data , Disease Susceptibility , Humans , Risk Factors , Smoking , Socioeconomic Factors , United StatesABSTRACT
The rat tracheal implant model was used to characterize the role of activated Ha-ras in the neoplastic progression of heterogeneous rat tracheal epithelial (RTE) cell populations. An activated Ha-ras-containing cell line, RTE 2-2, and its subclone, RTE 2-2n, which possesses only Ha-ras proto-oncogene alleles, were studied to determine whether activated ras could interact with the downstream signal transduction targets fos and myc and alter their cell-cycle-dependent expression in vitro. Transformed RTE cell lines with activated Ha-ras displayed earlier fos expression, with a peak at 15 min after serum stimulation. These cell lines also displayed a more accelerated loss of fos mRNA than seen in cells without activated Ha-ras. The effects on fos expression kinetics were seen only in cell lines with activated ras and were not related to the transformed phenotype of the cells. No change in myc expression kinetics were observed in any RTE cell line. These results suggest that mutations in ras can lead to alterations in nuclear components of the ras signaling pathway at the level of gene transcription.
Subject(s)
Gene Expression Regulation, Neoplastic , Genes, fos , Genes, ras , Mutation , Trachea/physiology , Animals , Cell Cycle , Cell Transformation, Neoplastic/genetics , Cells, Cultured , Epithelium/metabolism , Epithelium/pathology , Epithelium/physiology , Genes, myc , RNA, Messenger/genetics , RNA, Messenger/metabolism , Rats , Rats, Inbred F344 , Trachea/metabolism , Trachea/pathologyABSTRACT
We present the genotype distribution of the CYP1A1 gene in a sample of over 300 subjects of various ethnic origins. Genotypes are presented as composites of eight possible alleles, taking into account the three major polymorphisms, including a recently described African-American-specific MspI RFLP. A new nomenclature system is presented for clarifying the various haplotypes. Interesting interracial differences in allelic frequencies and admixture rates were observed for the three polymorphisms. Because of the importance of the CYP1A1 gene (which encodes the aromatic hydrocarbon hydroxylase) as a biomarker of genetic susceptibility to environmental carcinogens such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, these data may provide a useful reference for future studies of relationships between CYP1A1 genotype and disease susceptibility.
Subject(s)
Anemia, Sickle Cell/genetics , Black People/genetics , Cytochrome P-450 CYP1A1/genetics , Polymorphism, Genetic , White People/genetics , Africa, Western , Alleles , Gene Frequency , Genotype , Haplotypes , Humans , United StatesABSTRACT
Radiation carcinogenesis almost certainly involves multiple genetic alterations. Identification of such genetic alterations would provide information to help understand better the molecular mechanism of radiation carcinogenesis. The energy released by ionizing radiation has the potential to produce DNA strand breaks, major gene deletions or rearrangements, and other base damages. Alterations of the p53 gene, a common tumour suppressor gene altered in human cancers, were examined in radiation-induced rat skin cancers. Genomic DNA from a total of 33 rat skin cancers induced by ionizing radiation was examined by Southern blot hybridization for abnormal restriction fragment patterns in the p53 gene. An abnormal p53 restriction pattern was found in one of 16 cancers induced by electron radiation and in one of nine cancers induced by neon ions. The genomic DNA from representative cancers, including the two with an abnormal restriction pattern, was further examined by polymerase chain reaction amplification and direct sequencing in exons 5-8 of the p53 gene. The results showed that one restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP)-positive cancer induced by electron radiation had a partial gene deletion which was defined approximately between exons 2-8, while none of the other cancers showed sequence changes. Our results indicate that the alterations in the critical binding region of the p53 gene are infrequent in rat skin cancers induced by either electron or neon ion radiation.
Subject(s)
Genes, p53 , Mutation , Neoplasms, Radiation-Induced/genetics , Skin Neoplasms/genetics , Animals , Base Sequence , DNA Primers , Humans , Molecular Sequence Data , Radiation, Ionizing , RatsABSTRACT
Expression of the metallothionein (MT) gene in frozen human lymphocytes has been developed as a new molecular biomarker of heavy metal exposure. Workers at a Polish battery factory with high exposure to cadmium were monitored for airborne exposure and blood cadmium levels. A novel quantitative reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR) technique, making use of a homologous internal standard, was used to assess the level of MT-specific mRNA in frozen stored aliquots of blood samples taken from exposed and control workers. Results from this assay showed a statistically significant 2.5-fold increase in MT mRNA in exposed compared to control workers. The RT-PCR results also showed significant correlation with airborne cadmium, as registered on personal monitors and with blood cadmium levels. The results suggest that gene induction measured by quantitative RT-PCR is a promising approach for application as a biomarker of biologically effective dose in small samples of frozen tissues or cells.
Subject(s)
Biomarkers/blood , Cadmium/adverse effects , Metallothionein/genetics , Occupational Diseases/genetics , Occupational Exposure/adverse effects , Polymerase Chain Reaction/methods , RNA, Messenger/analysis , Base Sequence , Blotting, Northern , Cadmium/blood , Gene Expression Regulation/drug effects , Humans , Lymphocytes/metabolism , Male , Metallothionein/blood , Molecular Sequence Data , Occupational Diseases/blood , Occupational Diseases/chemically induced , Transcriptional ActivationABSTRACT
Induction of gene transcription is a complex process involving a diverse set of transcription factors and regulatory steps. We have taken a kinetic approach to analysis of metallothionein gene induction in human peripheral blood lymphocytes. By repeated measurements of MT mRNA after incubation of cells in vitro with CdCl2, we were able to determine individual-specific time related constants. The kinetics of induction for 3 individuals followed an S shaped curve and the data was fitted to a modified kinetic model of gene transcription. From this model, which assumes a cooperativity effect, transcriptional and RNA degradation rate constants could be calculated. The rate constant for transcription was doubled with the doubling of CdCl2 concentration, but the rate constant for RNA degradation was independent of Cd concentration.
Subject(s)
Cadmium/pharmacology , Gene Expression Regulation, Enzymologic/drug effects , Lymphocytes/drug effects , Metallothionein/genetics , Transcription, Genetic/drug effects , Adult , Cells, Cultured , Homeostasis , Humans , Kinetics , Lymphocytes/metabolism , Male , Models, Genetic , Transcriptional ActivationABSTRACT
We examined the role of CYP1A1 polymorphisms as potential molecular markers of breast cancer susceptibility in Caucasian and African-American women. The case-control study involved 51 women with breast cancer and 269 female controls. In African-Americans, the frequency of the homozygous MspI polymorphism was 3.5% in controls and 19% in breast cancer cases. The odds ratio of breast cancer with the MspI homozygous variant was 9.7 (95% confidence interval: 2.0-47.9). This association was not observed in Caucasian women. The exon 7 and AA polymorphisms were not associated with breast cancer in either group. The mechanism for the observed association between the MspI polymorphism and breast cancer is unclear. It is possible that the CYP1A1 MspI RFLP is linked with other polymorphisms in the African-American population, either in the CYP1A1 gene, which is involved in estrogen metabolism, or other genes related to risk of breast cancer.
Subject(s)
Black People/genetics , Breast Neoplasms/genetics , Cytochrome P-450 Enzyme System/genetics , Polymorphism, Restriction Fragment Length , Adult , Aged , Breast Neoplasms/enzymology , Breast Neoplasms/ethnology , Case-Control Studies , Disease Susceptibility , Female , Genotype , Humans , Middle Aged , United States , White PeopleABSTRACT
The cytochrome P450 1A1 (CYP1A1) gene may be of critical importance in determining individual cancer susceptibility to aromatic hydrocarbons such as those in tobacco smoke. We compared the frequencies of CYP1A1 haplotypes, and complete genotypes, taking into account polymorphisms at 3 sites, including an African-specific polymorphism. No concordance was observed in Africans or African-Americans between any of the 3 polymorphisms, (Msp1 restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP)--'M', exon 7--'E', new RFLP--'A') in contrast to the concordance seen between the M and E polymorphisms in Caucasians and Asians. We observed an effect of the E polymorphism on enzyme activity and mRNA induction in Asians and Caucasians.
Subject(s)
Cytochrome P-450 Enzyme System/genetics , Racial Groups/genetics , Asian People/genetics , Base Sequence , Black People/genetics , Genetics, Population , Genotype , Humans , Molecular Sequence Data , Polymorphism, Genetic , White People/geneticsABSTRACT
The human CYP1A1 gene codes for an inducible enzyme system involved in biotransformation of certain xenobiotics, including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons; some of the metabolites are carcinogenic and mutagenic. Effects of environmental exposures (smoking, air pollution, and diet) on CYP1A1 gene induction in placental tissue and the modulation of induction by the CYP1A1 MspI RFLP were evaluated in two groups from Poland: 70 mother-child pairs from Krakow, a city with elevated air pollution; and 90 pairs from Limanowa, a less polluted area. Compared to placentas from nonsmoking women, CYP1A1 mRNA levels were significantly increased in placentas from current smokers (P < 0.001). Ex-smokers also had significantly higher placental mRNA levels, including women who quit smoking prior to pregnancy (P < 0.01). A marginal increase in CYP1A1 mRNA with environmental tobacco smoke exposure was evident. Within Krakow, there was an increase in CYP1A1 mRNA with ambient pollution at the place of residence for each woman, which was significant among women who were not employed away from the home (P < 0.05 controlling for smoking status, diet, and use of coal for heating). Significant increases in mRNA were associated with dietary consumption of smoked meat, cheese, and fish (P < 0.01). The CYP1A1 MspI RFLP was not a significant determinant of CYP1A1 mRNA levels after controlling for smoking and other variables. Human placenta provides a readily available and responsive system that can serve as a model for evaluating environmental and genetic determinants of CYP1A1 induction.
Subject(s)
Cytochrome P-450 Enzyme System/genetics , Environmental Exposure , Placenta/metabolism , RNA, Messenger/genetics , Adult , Air Pollution , Biomarkers/analysis , Coal , Cohort Studies , Cotinine/blood , Cytochrome P-450 Enzyme System/metabolism , Feeding Behavior , Female , Gene Expression Regulation/genetics , Humans , Infant, Newborn , Poland , Polymorphism, Restriction Fragment Length , RNA, Messenger/analysis , Smoking/metabolism , Transcriptional ActivationABSTRACT
A case-control study on lung cancer in African-Americans has been conducted to assess whether a novel African-American-specific polymorphism in the CYP1A1 gene increases the susceptibility to tobacco-related lung cancer. The prevalence of the AA RFLP was 17.1% in the DNA extracted from archived tissue blocks from 76 incident cases of lung cancer, and was 16.3% in peripheral blood lymphocyte DNA of 123 healthy African-American volunteers recruited from a community in the eastern United States. The analysis by histological type showed an association between adenocarcinoma (AC) of the lung and the AA RFLP (odds ratio, 2.6; 95% confidence interval, 1.1-6.3). One homozygous variant subject was present among the AC cases. The risk of AC in subjects who both smoke and carry the AA RFLP was more than double, in comparison to subjects who only smoke (relative interaction magnitude under the additive model, 24%). The mean value of pack-year in AC with the polymorphism was 5.0 +/- 2.5 and in AC without the polymorphism was 37.2 +/- 6.5 (P < 0.05). Our data suggest that a selective association exists between the AA polymorphism and adenocarcinoma of the lung and that a lower dose of tobacco is sufficient to exert carcinogenic effects on the adenomatous tissue of subjects carrying the AA polymorphism.
Subject(s)
Adenocarcinoma/genetics , Black People/genetics , Cytochrome P-450 Enzyme System/genetics , Lung Neoplasms/genetics , Polymorphism, Restriction Fragment Length , Base Sequence , Carcinoma, Large Cell/genetics , Carcinoma, Small Cell/genetics , Carcinoma, Squamous Cell/genetics , DNA/blood , DNA Primers , Humans , Lymphocytes/cytology , Molecular Sequence Data , Polymerase Chain Reaction , United StatesABSTRACT
At least two different polymorphisms in the human CYP1A1 gene have been associated with an increased risk for tobacco-related lung cancer; however, the functional significance of these polymorphisms has not been determined. We measured CYP1A1 genotypes, gene expression levels and enzymatic activity levels in mitogen-stimulated lymphocytes to determine whether genetic polymorphisms in CYP1A1 alter transcriptional and/or post-transcriptional regulation of the gene. Genotypes were determined at two sites previously associated with lung cancer: a point mutation in exon 7 near the catalytic region of the enzyme and an Msp1 RFLP in the 3' non-coding region of the gene. Variant genotypes at the Msp1 site had no effect on CYP1A1 gene induction, however, variant genotypes at the exon 7 site were significantly associated with increased CYP1A1 gene inducibility. We also observed a significant interaction between the exon 7 polymorphism and smoking on mRNA levels. There was a 3-fold elevation in CYP1A1 enzymatic activity in exon 7 variant genotypes. When Msp1 and exon 7 genotypes were combined, there was an increased CYP1A1 inducibility and enzymatic activity in subjects with the exon 7 polymorphism, and in subjects with both polymorphisms.
Subject(s)
Polymorphism, Genetic , Adult , Aryl Hydrocarbon Hydroxylases/analysis , Base Sequence , Cytochrome P-450 Enzyme System , Enzyme Induction , Exons , Female , Genetic Predisposition to Disease , Genotype , Humans , Lung Neoplasms/enzymology , Lung Neoplasms/genetics , Lymphocyte Activation , Male , Middle Aged , Molecular Sequence Data , Polymorphism, Restriction Fragment Length , Racial Groups/genetics , Smoking , Transcription, GeneticABSTRACT
DNA fingerprinting analysis was performed on rat skin tumors induced by high linear energy transfer neon ion radiation. Most of these tumors (13/15) showed DNA-fingerprint variability between independently isolated tumors from the same animal. These changes include multiple band shifts and extra bands. Comparisons of DNA fingerprints were also made on successive biopsy samples from the same tumor. Each of 3 neon-induced tumors and 2 of 8 electron (low LET) induced tumors showed progressive loss of amplified sequences, gain of amplified sequences, deletions, band shifts, and the appearance of extra bands in progressive biopsies. These results provide evidence for LET-specific effects on genomic instability in radiation-induced rat skin tumors.
Subject(s)
DNA Fingerprinting , DNA, Neoplasm/analysis , Neoplasms, Radiation-Induced/chemistry , Skin Neoplasms/chemistry , Animals , Biopsy , Blotting, Southern , Male , Mutation , Neoplasms, Radiation-Induced/pathology , Rats , Rats, Sprague-Dawley , Skin Neoplasms/pathologyABSTRACT
Genetic susceptibility factors may play a role in determining adverse effects of exposure to environmental toxins. As a preliminary step to a molecular epidemiological study in a population exposed to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-para-dioxin (TCDD), we investigated 20 healthy Caucasian volunteers with a set of putative susceptibility markers including a CYP1A1 Msp I restriction fragment length genetic polymorphism (RFLP), CYP1A1 mRNA expression, and ethoxyresorufin-O-deethylase (EROD) activity in cultured and mitogen-activated blood lymphocytes. Both basal (p = 0.008) and induced (p = 0.0001) EROD activity was significantly higher among persons with a mutation in one or both alleles of the CYP1A1 gene (variant CYP1A1 genotype). Induction in vitro by TCDD significantly increased EROD activity in both variant and wild-type CYP1A1 subjects; however, the absolute increase was greater in subjects with variant genotypes. An additive interaction between genotype and TCDD induction was suggested. Expression of CYP1A1 mRNA, both basal and induced, did not vary significantly across the genotypes.
Subject(s)
Aryl Hydrocarbon Hydroxylases/genetics , RNA, Messenger/genetics , Adult , Aryl Hydrocarbon Hydroxylases/biosynthesis , Aryl Hydrocarbon Hydroxylases/metabolism , Base Sequence , Cytochrome P-450 CYP1A1 , Cytochrome P-450 Enzyme System/metabolism , DNA Primers , Enzyme Induction , Female , Genotype , Humans , Lymphocytes/enzymology , Male , Middle Aged , Molecular Sequence Data , Oxidoreductases/metabolism , Polychlorinated Dibenzodioxins/toxicity , Polymorphism, GeneticABSTRACT
In the multistage theory of carcinogenesis, cells progress to cancer through a series of discrete, irreversible, heritable genetic alterations or mutations. However data on radiation-induced cancer incidence in rat skin suggests that some part of an intermediate repairable alteration may occur. Data are presented on cancer induction in rat skin exposed to the following radiations: 1. an electron beam (LET=0.34 keV/um, 2. a neon ion beam (LET=25 keV/um and 3. an argon ion beam (LET=125 keV/um. The latter 2 beams were generated by the Bevalac at the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, Berkeley, CA. About 6.0 cm2 of skin was irradiated per rat. The rats were observed every 6 weeks for at least 78 weeks and tumors were scored at first occurrence. Several histological types of cancer, including squamous and basal cell carcinomas, were induced. The cancer yield versus radiation dose was fitted by the quadratic equation (Y(D)=CLD+BD2), and the parameters C and B were estimated for each type of radiation. Analysis of the DNA from the electron-induced carcinomas indicated that K-ras and/or c-myc oncogenes were activated in all tumors tested, although only a small proportion of neon-induced tumors showed similar activation. In situ hybridization indicated that the cancers contain subpopulations of cells with differing amounts of c-myc and H-ras amplification. The results are consistent with the idea that ionizing radiation produces carcinogenically relevant lesions via 2 repairable events at low LET and via a non-repairable, linked event pathway at high LET; either pathway may advance the cell by 1 stage in the multistage model. The model, if validated, permits the direct calculation of cancer risk in rat skin in a way that can be subjected to experimental testing.