ABSTRACT
Cells can use self recognition to achieve cooperative behaviors. Self-recognition genes are thought to principally evolve in tandem with partner self-recognition alleles. However, other constraints on protein evolution could exist. Here, we have identified an interaction outside self-recognition loci that could constrain the sequence variation of a self-recognition protein. We show that during collective swarm expansion in Proteus mirabilis, self-recognition signaling co-opts SdaC, a serine transporter. Serine uptake is crucial for bacterial survival and colonization. Single-residue variants of SdaC reveal that self recognition requires an open conformation of the protein; serine transport is dispensable. A distant ortholog from Escherichia coli is sufficient for self recognition; however, a paralogous serine transporter, YhaO, is not. Thus, SdaC couples self recognition and serine transport, likely through a shared molecular interface. Self-recognition proteins may follow the framework of a complex interaction network rather than an isolated two-protein system. Understanding the molecular and ecological constraints on self-recognition proteins lays the groundwork for insights into the evolution of self recognition and emergent collective behaviors. IMPORTANCE Bacteria can receive secret messages from kin during migration. For Proteus mirabilis, these messages are necessary for virulence in multispecies infections. We show that a serine transporter, conserved among gammaproteobacteria, enables self-recognition. Molecular co-option of nutrient uptake could limit the sequence variation of these message proteins. SdaC is the primary transporter for l-serine, a vital metabolite for colonization during disease. Unlike many self-recognition receptors, SdaC is sufficiently conserved between species to achieve recognition. The predicted open conformation is shared by transport and recognition. SdaC reveals the interdependence of communication and nutrient acquisition. As the broader interactions of self-recognition proteins are studied, features shared among microbial self-recognition systems, such as those of Dictyostelium spp. and Neurospora spp., could emerge.
Subject(s)
Bacterial Proteins/metabolism , Gene Expression Regulation, Bacterial/physiology , Membrane Proteins/metabolism , Proteus mirabilis/metabolism , Bacterial Proteins/genetics , Biological Transport , Locomotion , Membrane Proteins/genetics , Proteus mirabilis/geneticsABSTRACT
To thrive in dense communities, organisms have to navigate neighbors and resources. A new study reveals that bacteria integrate cues of communal living through stress pathways. The primary source of the stress - at least for one bacterium - is a direct conflict with neighbors.
Subject(s)
Bacteria , Biofilms , Bacteria/geneticsABSTRACT
Many bacteria take part in self recognition and kin discrimination behavior using contact-dependent effectors. Understanding the effects these effectors cause is important to explain bacterial community formation and population dynamics. Typically, kin discrimination effectors are toxins that kill target cells; their effect is therefore obvious and easily measurable. However, many self-recognition effectors, such as the Proteus mirabilis Ids system, are non-lethal and do not cause obvious physiological changes in target cells. Previously, experimental techniques to probe cells experiencing non-lethal kin recognition have been limited. Here we describe a technique to reliably isolate cells deemed self and non-self through Ids self-recognition for downstream phenotypic analysis. Liquid cultures of fluorescently labeled self-recognition mutants are mixed together and inoculated on swarm-permissive agar. Mixed swarms are harvested, and each strain is isolated through fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS). The growth rate of each strain is measured on a plate reader. This protocol is adaptable for other bacterial species. We describe briefly how sorted particles can be used for other analyses such as RNA-Seq library preparation.
ABSTRACT
The opportunistic pathogen Proteus mirabilis engages in visually dramatic and dynamic social behaviors. Populations of P. mirabilis can rapidly occupy surfaces, such as high-percentage agar and latex, through a collective surface-based motility termed swarming. When in these surface-occupying swarm colonies, P. mirabilis can distinguish between clonal siblings (self) and foreign P. mirabilis strains (nonself). This ability can be assessed by at least two standard methods: boundary formation, aka a Dienes line, and territorial exclusion. Here we describe methods for quantitative analysis of swarm colony expansion, of boundary formation, and of territorial exclusion. These assays can be employed to assess several aspects of P. mirabilis sociality including collective swarm motility, competition, and self versus nonself recognition.
Subject(s)
Bacteriological Techniques/methods , Proteus mirabilis/physiology , Microbial Interactions , Surface PropertiesABSTRACT
Colonies of the opportunistic pathogen Proteus mirabilis can distinguish self from non-self: in swarming colonies of two different strains, one strain excludes the other from the expanding colony edge. Predominant models characterize bacterial kin discrimination as immediate antagonism towards non-kin cells, typically through delivery of toxin effector molecules from one cell into its neighbor. Upon effector delivery, receiving cells must either neutralize it by presenting a cognate anti-toxin as would a clonal sibling, or suffer cell death or irreversible growth inhibition as would a non-kin cell. Here we expand this paradigm to explain the non-lethal Ids self-recognition system, which stops access to a social behavior in P. mirabilis by selectively and transiently inducing non-self cells into a growth-arrested lifestyle incompatible with cooperative swarming. This state is characterized by reduced expression of genes associated with protein synthesis, virulence, and motility, and also causes non-self cells to tolerate previously lethal concentrations of antibiotics. We show that temporary activation of the stringent response is necessary for entry into this state, ultimately resulting in the iterative exclusion of non-self cells as a swarm colony migrates outwards. These data clarify the intricate connection between non-lethal recognition and the lifecycle of P. mirabilis swarm colonies.
Subject(s)
Microbial Interactions/physiology , Proteus mirabilis/physiology , Proteus mirabilis/pathogenicity , Animals , Drug Resistance, Bacterial/genetics , Drug Resistance, Bacterial/physiology , Genes, Bacterial , Humans , Microbial Interactions/genetics , Models, Biological , Proteus Infections/microbiology , Proteus mirabilis/genetics , Transcription, Genetic , Type VI Secretion Systems/genetics , Type VI Secretion Systems/physiology , Urinary Tract Infections/microbiology , Virulence/genetics , Virulence/physiologyABSTRACT
Swarming on rigid surfaces requires movement of cells as individuals and as a group of cells. For the bacterium Proteus mirabilis, an individual cell can respond to a rigid surface by elongating and migrating over micrometer-scale distances. Cells can form groups of transiently aligned cells, and the collective population is capable of migrating over centimeter-scale distances. To address how P. mirabilis populations swarm on rigid surfaces, we asked whether cell elongation and single-cell motility are coupled to population migration. We first measured the relationship between agar concentration (a proxy for surface rigidity), single-cell phenotypes, and swarm colony phenotypes. We find that cell elongation and single-cell motility are coupled with population migration on low-percentage hard agar (1% to 2.5%) and become decoupled on high-percentage hard agar (>2.5%). Next, we evaluate how disruptions in lipopolysaccharide (LPS), specifically the O-antigen components, affect responses to hard agar. We find that LPS is not essential for elongation and motility of individual cells, as predicted, and instead functions to broaden the range of agar concentrations on which cell elongation and motility are coupled with population migration. These findings demonstrate that cell elongation and motility are coupled with population migration under a permissive range of surface conditions; increasing agar concentration is sufficient to decouple these behaviors. Since swarm colonies cover greater distances when these steps are coupled than when they are not, these findings suggest that collective interactions among P. mirabilis cells might be emerging as a colony expands outwards on rigid surfaces.IMPORTANCE How surfaces influence cell size, cell-cell interactions, and population migration for robust swarmers like P. mirabilis is not fully understood. Here, we have elucidated how cells change length along a spectrum of sizes that positively correlates with increases in agar concentration, regardless of population migration. Single-cell phenotypes can be decoupled from collective population migration simply by increasing agar concentration. A cell's lipopolysaccharides function to broaden the range of agar conditions under which cell elongation and single-cell motility remain coupled with population migration. In eukaryotes, the physical environment, such as a surface matrix, can impact cell development, shape, and migration. These findings support the idea that rigid surfaces similarly act on swarming bacteria to impact cell shape, single-cell motility, and collective population migration.
Subject(s)
Agar/pharmacology , Lipopolysaccharides/chemistry , Proteus mirabilis/drug effects , Agar/chemistry , Biomechanical Phenomena , Movement/drug effects , Movement/physiology , Phenotype , Proteus mirabilis/chemistry , Proteus mirabilis/physiology , Proteus mirabilis/ultrastructure , Single-Cell Analysis , Surface PropertiesABSTRACT
Individual cells of the bacterium Proteus mirabilis can elongate up to 40-fold on surfaces before engaging in a cooperative surface-based motility termed swarming. How cells regulate this dramatic morphological remodeling remains an open question. In this paper, we move forward the understanding of this regulation by demonstrating that P. mirabilis requires the gene rffG for swarmer cell elongation and subsequent swarm motility. The rffG gene encodes a protein homologous to the dTDP-glucose 4,6-dehydratase protein of Escherichia coli, which contributes to enterobacterial common antigen biosynthesis. Here, we characterize the rffG gene in P. mirabilis, demonstrating that it is required for the production of large lipopolysaccharide-linked moieties necessary for wild-type cell envelope integrity. We show that the absence of the rffG gene induces several stress response pathways, including those controlled by the transcriptional regulators RpoS, CaiF, and RcsB. We further show that in rffG-deficient cells, the suppression of the Rcs phosphorelay, via loss of RcsB, is sufficient to induce cell elongation and swarm motility. However, the loss of RcsB does not rescue cell envelope integrity defects and instead results in abnormally shaped cells, including cells producing more than two poles. We conclude that an RcsB-mediated response acts to suppress the emergence of shape defects in cell envelope-compromised cells, suggesting an additional role for RcsB in maintaining cell morphology under stress conditions. We further propose that the composition of the cell envelope acts as a checkpoint before cells initiate swarmer cell elongation and motility.IMPORTANCEProteus mirabilis swarm motility has been implicated in pathogenesis. We have found that cells deploy multiple uncharacterized strategies to handle cell envelope stress beyond the Rcs phosphorelay when attempting to engage in swarm motility. While RcsB is known to directly inhibit the master transcriptional regulator for swarming, we have shown an additional role for RcsB in protecting cell morphology. These data support a growing appreciation that the Rcs phosphorelay is a multifunctional regulator of cell morphology in addition to its role in microbial stress responses. These data also strengthen the paradigm that outer membrane composition is a crucial checkpoint for modulating entry into swarm motility. Furthermore, the rffG-dependent moieties provide a novel attractive target for potential antimicrobials.
Subject(s)
Antigens, Bacterial/genetics , Bacterial Proteins/genetics , Proteus mirabilis/genetics , Proteus mirabilis/physiology , Bacterial Proteins/physiology , Escherichia coli/genetics , Escherichia coli/physiology , Escherichia coli Proteins/genetics , Gene Expression Regulation, Bacterial , Hydro-Lyases/genetics , MutationABSTRACT
The bacterium Proteus mirabilis can communicate identity through the secretion of the self-identity protein IdsD via the type VI secretion (T6S) system. IdsD secretion is essential for self-versus-nonself recognition behaviors in these populations. Here we provide an answer to the unresolved question of how the activity of a T6S substrate, such as IdsD, is regulated before secretion. We demonstrate that IdsD is found in clusters that form independently of the T6S machinery and activity. We show that the IdsC protein, which is a member of the proposed DUF4123 chaperone family, is essential for the maintenance of these clusters and of the IdsD protein itself. We provide evidence that amino acid disruptions in IdsC are sufficient to disrupt IdsD secretion but not IdsD localization into subcellular clusters, strongly supporting the notion that IdsC functions in at least two different ways: maintaining IdsD levels and secreting IdsD. We propose that IdsC, and likely other DUF4123-containing proteins, functions to regulate T6S substrates in the donor cell both by maintaining protein levels and by mediating secretion at the T6S machinery.IMPORTANCE Understanding the subcellular dynamics of self-identity proteins is crucial for developing models of self-versus-nonself recognition. We directly addressed how a bacterium restricts self-identity information before cell-cell exchange. We resolved two conflicting models for type VI secretion (T6S) substrate regulation by focusing on the self-identity protein IdsD. One model is that a cognate immunity protein binds the substrate, inhibiting activity before transport. Another model proposes that DUF4123 proteins act as chaperones in the donor cell, but no detailed molecular mechanism was previously known. We resolve this discrepancy and propose a model wherein a chaperone couples IdsD sequestration with its localization. Such a molecular mechanism restricts the communication of identity, and possibly other T6S substrates, in producing cells.
Subject(s)
Bacterial Proteins/metabolism , Escherichia coli/metabolism , Proteus mirabilis/metabolism , Quorum Sensing/physiology , Type VI Secretion Systems/physiology , Bacterial Proteins/genetics , Gene Expression Regulation, Bacterial/physiology , Molecular ChaperonesABSTRACT
The type VI secretion (T6S) system is a molecular device for the delivery of proteins from one cell into another. T6S function depends on the contractile sheath comprised of TssB/VipA and TssC/VipB proteins. We previously reported on a mutant variant of TssB that disrupts T6S-dependent export of the self-identity protein, IdsD, in the bacterium Proteus mirabilis. Here we determined the mechanism underlying that initial observation. We show that T6S-dependent export of multiple self-recognition proteins is abrogated in this mutant strain. We have mapped the mutation, which is a single amino acid change, to a region predicted to be involved in the formation of the TssB-TssC sheath. We have demonstrated that this mutation does indeed inhibit sheath formation, thereby explaining the global disruption of T6S activity. We propose that this mutation could be utilized as an important tool for studying functions and behaviors associated with T6S systems.
Subject(s)
Point Mutation , Proteus mirabilis/genetics , Base Sequence , Proteus mirabilis/metabolismABSTRACT
Proteus mirabilis is a social bacterium that is capable of self (kin) versus nonself recognition. Swarming colonies of this bacterium expand outward on surfaces to centimeter-scale distances due to the collective motility of individual cells. Colonies of genetically distinct populations remain separate, while those of identical populations merge. Ids proteins are essential for this recognition behavior. Two of these proteins, IdsD and IdsE, encode identity information for each strain. These two proteins bind in vitro in an allele-restrictive manner. IdsD-IdsE binding is correlated with the merging of populations, whereas a lack of binding is correlated with the separation of populations. Key questions remained about the in vivo interactions of IdsD and IdsE, specifically, whether IdsD and IdsE bind within single cells or whether IdsD-IdsE interactions occur across neighboring cells and, if so, which of the two proteins is exchanged. Here we demonstrate that IdsD must originate from another cell to communicate identity and that this nonresident IdsD interacts with IdsE resident in the recipient cell. Furthermore, we show that unbound IdsD in recipient cells does not cause cell death and instead appears to contribute to a restriction in the expansion radius of the swarming colony. We conclude that P. mirabilis communicates IdsD between neighboring cells for nonlethal kin recognition, which suggests that the Ids proteins constitute a type of cell-cell communication. IMPORTANCE: We demonstrate that self (kin) versus nonself recognition in P. mirabilis entails the cell-cell communication of an identity-encoding protein that is exported from one cell and received by another. We further show that this intercellular exchange affects swarm colony expansion in a nonlethal manner, which adds social communication to the list of potential swarm-related regulatory factors.
Subject(s)
Bacterial Proteins/metabolism , Proteus mirabilis/growth & development , Proteus mirabilis/metabolism , Bacterial Proteins/genetics , Gene Expression Regulation, Bacterial , Microbial Viability , Proteus mirabilis/geneticsABSTRACT
UNLABELLED: Self- versus nonself-recognition in bacteria has been described recently through genetic analyses in multiple systems; however, understanding of the biochemical properties and mechanisms of recognition-determinant proteins remains limited. Here we extend the molecular and biochemical understanding of two recognition-determinant proteins in bacteria. We have found that a heterotypic complex is formed between two bacterial self-recognition proteins, IdsD and IdsE, the genes of which have been shown to genetically encode the determinants for strain-specific identity in the opportunistic bacterial pathogen Proteus mirabilis. This IdsD-IdsE complex forms independently of other P. mirabilis-encoded self-recognition proteins. We have also shown that the binding between IdsD and IdsE is strain- and allele-specific. The specificity for interactions is encoded within a predicted membrane-spanning subdomain within each protein that contains stretches of unique amino acids in each P. mirabilis variant. Finally, we have demonstrated that this in vitro IdsD-IdsE binding interaction correlates to in vivo population identity, suggesting that the binding interactions between IdsD and IdsE are part of a cellular pathway that underpins self-recognition behavior in P. mirabilis and drives bacterial population sociality. IMPORTANCE: Here we demonstrate that two proteins, the genes of which were genetically shown to encode determinants of self-identity in bacteria, bind in vitro in an allele-restricted interaction, suggesting that molecular recognition between these two proteins is a mechanism underpinning self-recognition behaviors in P. mirabilis. Binding specificity in each protein is encapsulated in a variable region subdomain that is predicted to span the membrane, suggesting that the interaction occurs in the cell envelope. Furthermore, conversion of binding affinities in vitro correlates with conversion of self-identity in vivo, suggesting that this molecular recognition might help to drive population behaviors.
Subject(s)
Bacterial Proteins/genetics , Bacterial Proteins/metabolism , Protein Multimerization , Proteus mirabilis/genetics , Proteus mirabilis/metabolism , Alleles , Protein Binding , Protein Structure, TertiaryABSTRACT
The 5th American Society for Microbiology Conference on Cell-Cell Communication in Bacteria (CCCB-5), which convened from October 18 - 21, 2014 in San Antonio, Texas, highlighted recent advances in our understanding of microbial intercellular signaling. While the CCCB meetings arose from interests in pheromone signaling and quorum sensing, it was evident at CCCB-5 that the cell-cell communication field is continuing to mature, expanding into new areas and integrating cutting-edge technologies. In this review, we recap some of the research discussed at CCCB-5 as well as the questions that have arisen from it.
ABSTRACT
We announce the complete genome sequence for Proteus mirabilis strain BB2000, a model system for self recognition. This opportunistic pathogen contains a single, circular chromosome (3,846,754 bp). Comparisons between this genome and that of strain HI4320 reveal genetic variations corresponding to previously unknown physiological and self-recognition differences.
ABSTRACT
UNLABELLED: Swarming colonies of the bacterium Proteus mirabilis are capable of self-recognition and territorial behavior. Swarms of independent P. mirabilis isolates can recognize each other as foreign and establish a visible boundary where they meet; in contrast, genetically identical swarms merge. The ids genes, which encode self-identity proteins, are necessary but not sufficient for this territorial behavior. Here we have identified two new gene clusters: one (idr) encodes rhs-related products, and another (tss) encodes a putative type VI secretion (T6S) apparatus. The Ids and Idr proteins function independently of each other in extracellular transport and in territorial behaviors; however, these self-recognition systems are linked via this type VI secretion system. The T6S system is required for export of select Ids and Idr proteins. Our results provide a mechanistic and physiological basis for the fundamental behaviors of self-recognition and territoriality in a bacterial model system. IMPORTANCE: Our results support a model in which self-recognition in P. mirabilis is achieved by the combined action of two independent pathways linked by a shared machinery for export of encoded self-recognition elements. These proteins together form a mechanistic network for self-recognition that can serve as a foundation for examining the prevalent biological phenomena of territorial behaviors and self-recognition in a simple, bacterial model system.
Subject(s)
Bacterial Proteins/metabolism , Bacterial Secretion Systems/genetics , Locomotion , Proteus mirabilis/physiology , DNA, Bacterial/chemistry , DNA, Bacterial/genetics , Molecular Sequence Data , Multigene Family , Proteus mirabilis/genetics , Proteus mirabilis/metabolism , Sequence Analysis, DNAABSTRACT
Swarming colonies of independent Proteus mirabilis isolates recognize each other as foreign and do not merge together, whereas apposing swarms of clonal isolates merge with each other. Swarms of mutants with deletions in the ids gene cluster do not merge with their parent. Thus, ids genes are involved in the ability of P. mirabilis to distinguish self from nonself. Here we have characterized expression of the ids genes. We show that idsABCDEF genes are transcribed as an operon, and we define the promoter region upstream of idsA by deletion analysis. Expression of the ids operon increased in late logarithmic and early stationary phases and appeared to be bistable. Approaching swarms of nonself populations led to increased ids expression and increased the abundance of ids-expressing cells in the bimodal population. This information on ids gene expression provides a foundation for further understanding the molecular details of self-nonself discrimination in P. mirabilis.
Subject(s)
Bacterial Proteins/metabolism , Gene Expression , Proteus mirabilis/physiology , DNA Mutational Analysis , Locomotion , Operon , Promoter Regions, Genetic , Proteus mirabilis/genetics , Sequence Deletion , Transcription, GeneticABSTRACT
The bacterium Proteus mirabilis is capable of movement on solid surfaces by a type of motility called swarming. Boundaries form between swarming colonies of different P. mirabilis strains but not between colonies of a single strain. A fundamental requirement for boundary formation is the ability to discriminate between self and nonself. We have isolated mutants that form boundaries with their parent. The mutations map within a six-gene locus that we term ids for identification of self. Five of the genes in the ids locus are required for recognition of the parent strain as self. Three of the ids genes are interchangeable between strains, and two encode specific molecular identifiers.
Subject(s)
Genes, Bacterial , Proteus mirabilis/genetics , Proteus mirabilis/physiology , Amino Acid Sequence , Bacterial Proteins/genetics , Bacterial Proteins/physiology , Genetic Complementation Test , Genome, Bacterial , Molecular Sequence Data , Movement , Multigene Family , Mutagenesis, Insertional , Mutation , Sequence Analysis, DNA , Species SpecificityABSTRACT
Advanced techniques for observing protein localization in live bacteria show that the distributions are dynamic. For technical reasons, most such techniques have not been applied to outer membrane proteins in Gram-negative bacteria. We have developed two novel live-cell imaging techniques to observe the surface distribution of LamB, an abundant integral outer membrane protein in Escherichia coli responsible for maltose uptake and for attachment of bacteriophage lambda. Using fluorescently labelled bacteriophage lambda tails, we quantitatively described the spatial distribution and dynamic movement of LamB in the outer membrane. LamB accumulated in spiral patterns. The distribution depended on cell length and changed rapidly. The majority of the protein diffused along spirals extending across the cell body. Tracking single particles, we found that there are two populations of LamB--one shows very restricted diffusion and the other shows greater mobility. The presence of two populations recalls the partitioning of eukaryotic membrane proteins between 'mobile' and 'immobile' populations. In this study, we have demonstrated that LamB moves along the bacterial surface and that these movements are restricted by an underlying dynamic spiral pattern.