Sex Differences in Dystonia.

BACKGROUND: Prior studies have indicated that female individuals outnumber male individuals for certain types of dystonia. Few studies have addressed factors impacting these sex differences or their potential biological mechanisms. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate factors underlying sex differences in the dystonias and explore potential mechanisms for these differences. METHODS: Data from individuals with various types of dystonia were analyzed in relation to sex. Data came from two different sources. One source was the Dystonia Coalition database, which contains predominantly idiopathic adult-onset focal and segmental dystonias. The second source was the MDSGene database, which contains predominantly early-onset monogenic dystonias. RESULTS: The 3222 individuals from the Dystonia Coalition included 71% female participants and 29% male participants for an overall female-to-male ratio (F:M) of 2.4. This ratio varied according to body region affected and whether dystonia was task-specific. The female predominance was age-dependent. Sex did not have a significant impact on co-existing tremor, geste antagoniste, depression or anxiety. In the 1377 individuals from the MDSGene database, female participants outnumbered male participants for some genes (GNAL, GCH1, and ANO3) but not for other genes (THAP1, TH, and TOR1A). CONCLUSIONS: These results are in keeping with prior studies that have indicated female individuals outnumber male individuals for both adult-onset idiopathic and early onset monogenic dystonias. These results extend prior observations by revealing that sex ratios depend on the type of dystonia, age, and underlying genetics.

Can symptoms or signs of cervical dystonia occur without abnormal movements of the head or neck?

INTRODUCTION: Cervical dystonia is defined by excessive contraction of muscles that produce abnormal postures and movements of the head, neck, and sometimes the shoulders. Many affected individuals also have pain, local muscle hypertrophy, and/or abnormally increased EMG activity. However, abnormal movements are considered the defining feature. CASES: Three cases are described suggesting that some features of cervical dystonia may occur without abnormal movements. In these cases, the only clinical features are pain, local muscle hypertrophy, or abnormal EMG activity. These features may occur years before abnormal movements emerge, or they may occur coincidentally with dystonia affecting regions other than the neck. In some cases, some features associated with cervical dystonia may occur without any obvious abnormal movements. CONCLUSIONS: Some symptoms of cervical dystonia may occur without abnormal movements of the head or neck. The purpose of this report is not to question current diagnostic criteria for cervical dystonia, but to call attention to a phenomenon that deserves further attention. Such cases may be considered to have a pro-dromal form of cervical dystonia or a formes fruste of cervical dystonia. Whatever diagnostic label is applied, the phenomenon is important to recognize, because symptoms may be readily alleviated with botulinum toxin.

Blood-Based Proteomics for Adult-Onset Focal Dystonias.

OBJECTIVES: The adult-onset focal dystonias are characterized by over-active muscles leading to abnormal movements. For most cases, the etiology and pathogenesis remain unknown. In the current study, unbiased proteomics methods were used to identify potential changes in blood plasma proteins. METHODS: A large-scale unbiased proteomics screen was used to compare proteins (N = 6,345) in blood plasma of normal healthy controls (N = 49) with adult-onset focal dystonia (N = 143) consisting of specific subpopulations of cervical dystonia (N = 45), laryngeal dystonia (N = 49), and blepharospasm (N = 49). Pathway analyses were conducted to identify relevant biological pathways. Finally, protein changes were used to build a prediction model for dystonia. RESULTS: After correction for multiple comparisons, 15 proteins were associated with adult-onset focal dystonia. Subgroup analyses revealed some proteins were shared across the dystonia subgroups while others were unique to 1 subgroup. The top biological pathways involved changes in the immune system, metal ion transport, and reactive oxygen species. A 4-protein model showed high accuracy in discriminating control individuals from dystonia cases [average area under the curve (AUC) = 0.89]. INTERPRETATION: These studies provide novel insights into the etiopathogenesis of dystonia, as well as novel potential biomarkers. ANN NEUROL 2024.

Very Early Levodopa May Prevent Self-Injury in Lesch-Nyhan Disease.

BACKGROUND: In Lesch-Nyhan disease (LND), early dopamine deficiency is thought to contribute to dystonia and self-injury, gradually developing over the first years of life. Previous attempts to restore dopamine levels in older patients have been unsuccessful. Based on the hypothesis that very early dopamine replacement can prevent full phenotypic development, we treated three patients with LND from infancy with levodopa. METHODS: Levodopa/carbidopa (4:1) was started at age 11 to 13 months, aiming at escalating to 5 to 6 mg/kg levodopa per day. Follow-up focused on dystonia severity and whether self-injury occurred. In addition, the literature was reviewed to delineate the age at onset of self-injury for all reported cases to date. RESULTS: During long-term follow-up, self-injury appears to have been prevented in two patients (now aged 14 and 15.5 years), as their HPRT1 gene mutations had been invariably associated with self-injury before. Future self-injury is unlikely, as only 1.1% of 264 published cases had self-injury onset later in life than these patients' current ages. The third patient started self-injury at age 1.5 years, while on a substantially lower levodopa dose. A clear effect of levodopa on dystonia could not be determined. CONCLUSIONS: Our observations suggest that levodopa, given early enough and sufficiently dosed, might be able to prevent self-injury in LND. Therefore, levodopa could be considered in patients with LND as early as possible, at least before the self-injury appears. Further research is needed to establish very early levodopa as an effective treatment strategy in LND, and to optimize timing and dosing.

Exploration of potential immune mechanisms in cervical dystonia.

BACKGROUND: Although there are many possible causes for cervical dystonia (CD), a specific etiology cannot be identified in most cases. Prior studies have suggested a relationship between autoimmune disease and some cases of CD, pointing to possible immunological mechanisms. OBJECTIVE: The goal was to explore the potential role of multiple different immunological mechanisms in CD. METHODS: First, a broad screening test compared neuronal antibodies in controls and CD. Second, unbiased blood plasma proteomics provided a broad screen for potential biologic differences between controls and CD. Third, a multiplex immunoassay compared 37 markers associated with immunological processes in controls and CD. Fourth, relative immune cell frequencies were investigated in blood samples of controls and CD. Finally, sequencing studies investigated the association of HLA DQB1 and DRB1 alleles in controls versus CD. RESULTS: Screens for anti-neuronal antibodies did not reveal any obvious abnormalities. Plasma proteomics pointed towards certain abnormalities of immune mechanisms, and the multiplex assay pointed more specifically towards abnormalities in T lymphocytes. Abnormal immune cell frequencies were identified for some CD cases, and these cases clustered together as a potential subgroup. Studies of HLA alleles indicated a possible association between CD and DRB1*15:03, which is reported to mediate the penetrance of autoimmune disorders. CONCLUSIONS: Altogether, the association of CD with multiple different blood-based immune measures point to abnormalities in cell-mediated immunity that may play a pathogenic role for a subgroup of individuals with CD.

Interdisciplinary insights into tremor in dystonia: Navigating clinical controversies, definitional challenges, and pathophysiological complexities.

This review delves into the historical evolution and ongoing controversy surrounding the relationship between tremor and dystonia. The Dystonia Consensus Panel and the International Parkinson's and Movement Disorders Society's Tremor Taskforce have attempted to define these entities, but the complexity arises when patients have a combination of both dystonia and tremor. The term "dystonic tremor" has sparked diverse interpretations, with debates over its clinical features and the need for more objectively defined characteristics. Logistic regression analyses in a large cohort of dystonia patients identified determinants such as body region affected by dystonia, dystonia severity, age, and recruitment site, with unexpected associations emphasizing the subjectivity in detecting and classifying tremor. The study further discovered diverse prevalence of "dystonic tremor" based on different definitions, revealing substantial variability among investigators. The recently convened Dystonia-Tremor panel aimed to address these challenges by proposing a more uniform nomenclature, emphasizing precise and descriptive terms. Despite the complexity, instrumented measures, such as electromyography, temporal discrimination threshold, blink reflex, and trajectory shape analysis, seem to be useful in distinguishing between tremor and dystonia. The pathophysiology debate centers around the involvement of the cerebello-thalamo-cortical and basal ganglia-thalamo-cortical circuits. Evidence supports the role of both circuits in driving the pathophysiology of dystonic tremor, challenging the notion of a clear dichotomy. The review concludes by emphasizing the need for a nuanced understanding, highlighting the intricate interplay between tremor and dystonia, and the potential of instrumental measures in advancing diagnostic accuracy.

An Exploratory, Randomized, Double-Blind Clinical Trial of Dipraglurant for Blepharospasm.

BACKGROUND: Blepharospasm is treated with botulinum toxin, but obtaining satisfactory results is sometimes challenging. OBJECTIVE: The aim is to conduct an exploratory trial of oral dipraglurant for blepharospasm. METHODS: This study was an exploratory, phase 2a, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of 15 participants who were assigned to receive a placebo or dipraglurant (50 or 100 mg) and assessed over 2 days, 1 and 2 hours following dosing. Outcome measures included multiple scales rated by clinicians or participants, digital video, and a wearable sensor. RESULTS: Dipraglurant was well tolerated, with no obvious impact on any of the measurement outcomes. Power analyses suggested fewer subjects would be required for studies using a within-subject versus independent group design, especially for certain measures. Some outcome measures appeared more suitable than others. CONCLUSION: Although dipraglurant appeared well tolerated, it did not produce a trend for clinical benefit. The results provide valuable information for planning further trials in blepharospasm. © 2024 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

A new physiological medium uncovers biochemical and cellular alterations in Lesch-Nyhan disease fibroblasts.

BACKGROUND: Lesch-Nyhan disease (LND) is a severe neurological disorder caused by the genetic deficiency of hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HGprt), an enzyme involved in the salvage synthesis of purines. To compensate this deficiency, there is an acceleration of the de novo purine biosynthetic pathway. Most studies have failed to find any consistent abnormalities of purine nucleotides in cultured cells obtained from the patients. Recently, it has been shown that 5-aminoimidazole-4-carboxamide riboside 5'-monophosphate (ZMP), an intermediate of the de novo pathway, accumulates in LND fibroblasts maintained with RPMI containing physiological levels (25 nM) of folic acid (FA), which strongly differs from FA levels of regular cell culture media (2200 nM). However, RPMI and other standard media contain non-physiological levels of many nutrients, having a great impact in cell metabolism that does not precisely recapitulate the in vivo behavior of cells. METHODS: We prepared a new culture medium containing physiological levels of all nutrients, including vitamins (Plasmax-PV), to study the potential alterations of LND fibroblasts that may have been masked by the usage of non-physiological media. We quantified ZMP accumulation under different culture conditions and evaluated the activity of two known ZMP-target proteins (AMPK and ADSL), the mRNA expression of the folate carrier SLC19A1, possible mitochondrial alterations and functional consequences in LND fibroblasts. RESULTS: LND fibroblasts maintained with Plasmax-PV show metabolic adaptations such a higher glycolytic capacity, increased expression of the folate carrier SCL19A1, and functional alterations such a decreased mitochondrial potential and reduced cell migration compared to controls. These alterations can be reverted with high levels of folic acid, suggesting that folic acid supplements might be a potential treatment for LND. CONCLUSIONS: A complete physiological cell culture medium reveals new alterations in Lesch-Nyhan disease. This work emphasizes the importance of using physiological cell culture conditions when studying a metabolic disorder.

Longitudinal predictors of health-related quality of life in isolated dystonia.

OBJECTIVE: To determine longitudinal predictors of health-related quality of life (HR-QoL) in an international multicenter cohort of patients with isolated dystonia. METHODS: Out of 603 dystonia patients prospectively enrolled in the Natural History Dystonia Coalition study, 155 were assessed three times within 2 years for HR-QoL, symptoms of depression, generalized anxiety disorder (GAD), and social anxiety disorder (SAD), as well as dystonia severity and dystonic tremor. In addition, the impact of botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) injections on HR-QoL was evaluated after 1 year. RESULTS: Depressive symptoms at baseline predicted lower HR-QoL on all subscales after 2 years (all p ≤ 0.001). Higher GAD scores at baseline predicted lower HR-QoL related to general health, pain and emotional well-being, whereas higher SAD scores predicted higher pain-related QoL after 2 years (all p ≤ 0.006). Dystonia severity at baseline predicted social functioning (p = 0.002). Neither dystonic tremor, age, or sex predicted HR-QoL at 2 years. Two latent categories were revealed across the three-time points: Category 1 with higher total HR-QoL scores (mean HR-QoL = 74.4% ± 16.1), susceptible to symptoms of depression and SAD, and Category 2 with lower total HR-QoL scores (mean HR-QoL = 45.5% ± 17.6), susceptible to symptoms of GAD. HR-QoL improved over the course of 1 year irrespective of the use of BoNT. CONCLUSION: The longitudinal impact of psychiatric symptoms on HR-QoL emphasizes the importance of incorporating mental health treatment, in particular also the therapy of anxiety disorders, into treatment regimens for dystonia.

An Empirical Comparison of Commonly Used Universal Rating Scales for Dystonia.

Background: There are several widely used clinical rating scales for documenting the severity and distribution of various types of dystonia. Objectives: The goal of this study was to evaluate the performance of the most commonly used scales in a large group of adults with the most common types of isolated dystonia. Methods: Global Dystonia Rating Scale (GDRS) and the Burke-Fahn-Marsden Dystonia Rating Scale (BFM) scores were obtained for 3067 participants. Most had focal or segmental dystonia, with smaller numbers of multifocal or generalized dystonia. These scales were also compared for 209 adults with cervical dystonia that had Toronto Western Spasmodic Torticollis Rating Scale (TWSTRS) scores and 210 adults with blepharospasm that had Blepharospasm Severity Scale (BSRS) scores. Results: There were strong correlations between the GDRS and BFM total scores (r = 0.79) and moderate correlations for their sub scores (r > 0.5). Scores for both scales showed positive skew, with an overabundance of low scores. BFM sub-scores were not normally distributed, due to artifacts caused by the provoking factor. Relevant sub-scores of the GDRS and BFM also showed moderate correlations with the TWSTRS (r > 0.5) for cervical dystonia and the BSRS (r > 0.5) for blepharospasm. Conclusions: The BFM is more widely used than the GDRS, but these results suggest the GDRS may be preferable for focal and segmental dystonias. The overabundance of very low scores for both scales highlights challenges associated with discriminating very mild dystonia from other abnormal movements or variants of normal behavior.

Spiny projection neurons exhibit transcriptional signatures within subregions of the dorsal striatum.

The dorsal striatum is organized into functional territories defined by corticostriatal inputs onto both direct and indirect spiny projection neurons (SPNs), the major cell types within the striatum. In addition to circuit connectivity, striatal domains are likely defined by the spatially determined transcriptomes of SPNs themselves. To identify cell-type-specific spatiomolecular signatures of direct and indirect SPNs within dorsomedial, dorsolateral, and ventrolateral dorsal striatum, we used RNA profiling in situ hybridization with probes to >98% of protein coding genes. We demonstrate that the molecular identity of SPNs is mediated by hundreds of differentially expressed genes across territories of the striatum, revealing extraordinary heterogeneity in the expression of genes that mediate synaptic function in both direct and indirect SPNs. This deep insight into the complex spatiomolecular organization of the striatum provides a foundation for understanding both normal striatal function and for dissecting region-specific dysfunction in disorders of the striatum.

Anatomical categorization of isolated non-focal dystonia: novel and existing patterns using a data-driven approach.

According to expert consensus, dystonia can be classified as focal, segmental, multifocal, and generalized, based on the affected body distribution. To provide an empirical and data-driven approach to categorizing these distributions, we used a data-driven clustering approach to compare frequency and co-occurrence rates of non-focal dystonia in pre-defined body regions using the Dystonia Coalition (DC) dataset. We analyzed 1,618 participants with isolated non-focal dystonia from the DC database. The analytic approach included construction of frequency tables, variable-wise analysis using hierarchical clustering and independent component analysis (ICA), and case-wise consensus hierarchical clustering to describe associations and clusters for dystonia affecting any combination of eighteen pre-defined body regions. Variable-wise hierarchical clustering demonstrated closest relationships between bilateral upper legs (distance = 0.40), upper and lower face (distance = 0.45), bilateral hands (distance = 0.53), and bilateral feet (distance = 0.53). ICA demonstrated clear grouping for the a) bilateral hands, b) neck, and c) upper and lower face. Case-wise consensus hierarchical clustering at k = 9 identified 3 major clusters. Major clusters consisted primarily of a) cervical dystonia with nearby regions, b) bilateral hand dystonia, and c) cranial dystonia. Our data-driven approach in a large dataset of isolated non-focal dystonia reinforces common segmental patterns in cranial and cervical regions. We observed unexpectedly strong associations between bilateral upper or lower limbs, which suggests that symmetric multifocal patterns may represent a previously underrecognized dystonia subtype.

Assessing the Severity of Cervical Dystonia: Ask the Doctor or Ask the Patient?

Background: Assessing disease severity can be performed using either clinician-rated scales (CRS) or patient-rated outcome (PRO) tools. These two measures frequently demonstrate poor correlations. Objectives: To determine if the correlation between a CRS and PRO for motor features of cervical dystonia (CD) improves by accounting for non-motor features. Methods: Subjects with CD (N = 209) were evaluated using a CRS (Toronto Western Spasmodic Torticollis Rating Scale, TWSTRS) and a PRO (Cervical Dystonia Impact Profile, CDIP-58). Results: Linear regression revealed a weak correlation between the two measures, even when considering only the motor subscales of each. The strength of this relationship improved with a regression model that included non-motor symptoms of pain, depression, and disability. Conclusions: These results argue that the results of motor assessments in a PRO for CD cannot be fully appreciated without simultaneous assessment of non-motor co-morbidities. This conclusion might apply to other disorders, especially those with frequent non-motor co-morbidities.

The functional anatomy of dystonia: Recent developments.

While dystonia has traditionally been viewed as a disorder of the basal ganglia, the involvement of other key brain structures is now accepted. However, just what these structures are remains to be defined. Neuroimaging has been an especially valuable tool in dystonia, yet traditional cross-sectional designs have not been able to separate causal from compensatory brain activity. Therefore, this chapter discusses recent studies using causal brain lesions, and animal models, to converge upon the brain regions responsible for dystonia with increasing precision. This evidence strongly implicates the basal ganglia, thalamus, brainstem, cerebellum, and somatosensory cortex, yet shows that different types of dystonia involve different nodes of this brain network. Nearly all of these nodes fall within the recently identified two-way networks connecting the basal ganglia and cerebellum, suggesting dysfunction of these specific pathways. Localisation of the functional anatomy of dystonia has strong implications for targeted treatment options, such as deep brain stimulation, and non-invasive brain stimulation.

Adult-onset focal dystonias: To lump or split.

The adult-onset focal dystonias are a group of clinically heterogeneous disorders that affect different regions of the body. Although they affect different regions with different clinical manifestations, there is evidence that etiopathogenesis is shared at the anatomical, physiological, and genetic levels. However, there is also evidence that etiopathogenesis varies. This chapter summarizes the evidence for lumping or splitting these apparently different clinical phenotypes. It also includes some potential explanations to explain the similarities and differences.

Dystonia genes and their biological pathways.

High-throughput sequencing has been instrumental in uncovering the spectrum of pathogenic genetic alterations that contribute to the etiology of dystonia. Despite the immense heterogeneity in monogenic causes, studies performed during the past few years have highlighted that many rare deleterious variants associated with dystonic presentations affect genes that have roles in certain conserved pathways in neural physiology. These various gene mutations that appear to converge towards the disruption of interconnected cellular networks were shown to produce a wide range of different dystonic disease phenotypes, including isolated and combined dystonias as well as numerous clinically complex, often neurodevelopmental disorder-related conditions that can manifest with dystonic features in the context of multisystem disturbances. In this chapter, we summarize the manifold dystonia-gene relationships based on their association with a discrete number of unifying pathophysiological mechanisms and molecular cascade abnormalities. The themes on which we focus comprise dopamine signaling, heavy metal accumulation and calcifications in the brain, nuclear envelope function and stress response, gene transcription control, energy homeostasis, lysosomal trafficking, calcium and ion channel-mediated signaling, synaptic transmission beyond dopamine pathways, extra- and intracellular structural organization, and protein synthesis and degradation. Enhancing knowledge about the concept of shared etiological pathways in the pathogenesis of dystonia will motivate clinicians and researchers to find more efficacious treatments that allow to reverse pathologies in patient-specific core molecular networks and connected multipathway loops.

Interrater reliability of motor severity scales for hemifacial spasm.

To compare the inter-rater reliability (IRR) of five clinical rating scales for video-based assessment of hemifacial spasm (HFS) motor severity. We evaluated the video recordings of 45 HFS participants recruited through the Dystonia Coalition. In Round 1, six clinicians with expertise in HFS assessed the participants' motor severity with five scales used to measure motor severity of HFS: the Jankovic rating scale (JRS), Hemifacial Spasm Grading Scale (HSGS), Samsung Medical Center (SMC) grading system for severity of HFS spasms (Lee's scale), clinical grading of spasm intensity (Chen's scale), and a modified version of the Abnormal Involuntary Movement Scale (Tunc's scale). In Round 2, clinicians rated the same cohort with simplified scale wording after consensus training. For each round, we evaluated the IRR using the intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC (2,1) single-rater, absolute-agreement, 2-way random model]. The scales exhibited IRR that ranged from "poor" to "moderate"; the mean ICCs were 0.41, 0.43, 0.47, 0.43, and 0.65 for the JRS, HSGS, Lee's, Chen's, and Tunc's scales, respectively, for Round 1. In Round 2, the corresponding IRRs increased to 0.63, 0.60, 0.59, 0.53, and 0.71. In both rounds, Tunc's scale exhibited the highest IRR. For clinical assessments of HFS motor severity based on video observations, we recommend using Tunc's scale because of its comparative reliability and because clinicians interpret the scale easily without modifications or the need for consensus training.

Striatal Subregion-selective Dysregulated Dopamine Receptor-mediated Intracellular Signaling in a Model of DOPA-responsive Dystonia.

Although the mechanisms underlying dystonia are largely unknown, dystonia is often associated with abnormal dopamine neurotransmission. DOPA-responsive dystonia (DRD) is a prototype disorder for understanding dopamine dysfunction in dystonia because it is caused by mutations in genes necessary for the synthesis of dopamine and alleviated by the indirect-acting dopamine agonist l-DOPA. Although adaptations in striatal dopamine receptor-mediated intracellular signaling have been studied extensively in models of Parkinson's disease, another movement disorders associated with dopamine deficiency, little is known about dopaminergic adaptations in dystonia. To identify the dopamine receptor-mediated intracellular signaling associated with dystonia, we used immunohistochemistry to quantify striatal protein kinase A activity and extracellular signal-related kinase (ERK) phosphorylation after dopaminergic challenges in a knockin mouse model of DRD. l-DOPA treatment induced the phosphorylation of both protein kinase A substrates and ERK largely in D1 dopamine receptor-expressing striatal neurons. As expected, this response was blocked by pretreatment with the D1 dopamine receptor antagonist SCH23390. The D2 dopamine receptor antagonist raclopride also significantly reduced the phosphorylation of ERK; this contrasts with models of parkinsonism in which l-DOPA-induced ERK phosphorylation is not mediated by D2 dopamine receptors. Further, the dysregulated signaling was dependent on striatal subdomains whereby ERK phosphorylation was largely confined to dorsomedial (associative) striatum while the dorsolateral (sensorimotor) striatum was unresponsive. This complex interaction between striatal functional domains and dysregulated dopamine-receptor mediated responses has not been observed in other models of dopamine deficiency, such as parkinsonism, suggesting that regional variation in dopamine-mediated neurotransmission may be a hallmark of dystonia.