Introduction of Mouse Embryonic Fibroblasts into Early Embryos: From Confusion to Constructive Discussion. Comment on Savatier, P. Introduction of Mouse Embryonic Fibroblasts into Early Embryos Causes Reprogramming and (Con)fusion. Cells 2021, 10, 772.

We would like to address the issues raised by Pierre Savatier in "Introduction of Mouse Embryonic Fibroblasts into Early Embryos Causes Reprogramming and (Con)Fusion" [...].

Embryonic Environmental Niche Reprograms Somatic Cells to Express Pluripotency Markers and Participate in Adult Chimaeras.

The phenomenon of the reprogramming of terminally differentiated cells can be achieved by various means, like somatic cell nuclear transfer, cell fusion with a pluripotent cell, or the introduction of pluripotency genes. Here, we present the evidence that somatic cells can attain the expression of pluripotency markers after their introduction into early embryos. Mouse embryonic fibroblasts introduced between blastomeres of cleaving embryos, within two days of in vitro culture, express transcription factors specific to blastocyst lineages, including pluripotency factors. Analysis of donor tissue marker DNA has revealed that the progeny of introduced cells are found in somatic tissues of foetuses and adult chimaeras, providing evidence for cell reprogramming. Analysis of ploidy has shown that in the chimaeras, the progeny of introduced cells are either diploid or tetraploid, the latter indicating cell fusion. The presence of donor DNA in diploid cells from chimaeric embryos proved that the non-fused progeny of introduced fibroblasts persisted in chimaeras, which is evidence of reprogramming by embryonic niche. When adult somatic (cumulus) cells were introduced into early cleavage embryos, the extent of integration was limited and only cell fusion-mediated reprogramming was observed. These results show that both cell fusion and cell interactions with the embryonic niche reprogrammed somatic cells towards pluripotency.

Enucleated GV oocytes as recipients of embryonic nuclei in the G1, S, or G2 stages of the cell cycle.

Universal recipients in the G2 phase of mitotic cell cycle (preactivated oocytes, zygotes, blastomeres) accept embryonic nuclei in all the stages of their cell cycle. To test if recipients in the G2 of meiotic cycle (immature oocytes) are universal recipients, mouse germinal vesicle (GV) oocytes were enucleated and reconstructed with blastomere nuclei in the G1, S, or G2 stages. Analysis of their maturation has shown that about 30% of the G1 nuclei and 60% of G2 nuclei allow for normal metaphase II (MII), both in the oocytes with and without the first polar body (1st PB). Among oocytes reconstructed with the S phase nuclei, only 8% or less have normal MII, although 75% of them extrude 1st PB. No phase of donor cell cycle prevented the abnormal acceleration of 1st PB extrusion, found in reconstructed GV oocytes. In conclusion, enucleated GV oocytes are not universal recipients of embryonic nuclei, because they do not accept the S donors. However, both the G1 and G2 donor nuclei can be reprogrammed in the GV oocyte cytoplasm.

Experimental embryology of mammals at the Jastrzebiec Institute of Genetics and Animal Breeding.

Our Department of Experimental Embryology originated from The Laboratory of Embryo Biotechnology, which was organized and directed by Dr. Maria Czlonkowska until her premature death in 1991. Proving successful international transfer of frozen equine embryos and generation of an embryonic sheep-goat chimaera surviving ten years were outstanding achievements of her term. In the 1990s, we produced advanced fetuses of mice after reconstructing enucleated oocytes with embryonic stem (ES) cells, as well as mice originating entirely from ES cells by substitution of the inner cell mass with ES cells. Attempts at obtaining ES cells in sheep resulted in the establishment of embryo-derived epithelioid cell lines from Polish Heatherhead and Polish Merino breeds, producing overt chimaeras upon blastocyst injection. Successful re-cloning was achieved from 8-cell rabbit embryos, and healthy animals were born from the third generation of cloned embryos. Recently mice were born after transfer of 8-cell embryonic nuclei into selectively enucleated zygotes, and mouse blastocysts were produced from selectively enucleated germinal vesicle oocytes surrounded by follicular cells, upon their reconstruction with 2-cell nuclei and subsequent activation. Embryonic-somatic chimaeras were born after transfer of foetal fibroblasts into 8-cell embryos (mouse) and into morulae and blastocysts (sheep). We also regularly perform the following applications: in vitro production of bovine embryos from slaughterhouse oocytes or those recovered by ovum pick up; cryopreservation of oocytes and embryos (freezing: mouse, rabbit, sheep, goat; vitrification: rabbit, cow); and banking of somatic cells from endangered wild mammalian species (mainly Cervidae).

Experimental embryonic-somatic chimaerism in the sheep confirmed by random amplified polymorphic DNA assay.

Developmental potencies of sheep somatic cells (foetal fibroblasts, FFs) in chimaeric animals were analysed. FFs from pigmented Polish Heatherhead (wrzosowka) breed were microsurgically injected into morulae or blastocysts of white Polish Merino breed (5 cells to each embryo). In one experiment the cells were stained with vital fluorescent dye PKH26, and chimaeric blastocysts were cultured in vitro to confirm the presence of fluorescent cells. In the majority of experiments the blastocysts were transferred to synchronized recipient ewes for development until term. Cultured embryonic cells (CEC), earlier known to produce chimaeras, were injected into blastocysts in control experiments. Seven young were born from FF-injected embryos and three were born from CEC-injected ones. All of them were white, but all three control lambs and three experimental lambs showed small areas of skin pigmentation, which indicated Heatherhead CEC or FF contribution. Tissue samples originating from three germ layers were taken from two FFs-originating presumably chimaeric lambs (male and female) at the age of one month for DNA analysis. The random amplified polymorphic DNA-PCR method supplied two markers of chimaerism, which were amplification products of 643 bp and 615 bp long DNA fragments, found in tissues of experimental lambs as well as in FFs, but not in the blood of parents of blastocysts. The 643 bp marker was found in the majority of tissues of both lambs. The 615 bp amplicon was detected in the skin and lungs of the female lamb and in the hooves of the male lamb. Our data show that foetal fibroblasts introduced to sheep blastocysts can participate in development and can contribute to all tissue lineages up to at least one month of age.

Foetal fibroblasts introduced to cleaving mouse embryos contribute to full-term development.

Foetal fibroblasts (FFs) labelled with vital fluorescent dye were microsurgically introduced into eight-cell mouse embryos, three cells to each embryo. FFs were first identified in the inner cell mass (ICM) in about one-third of embryos, whereas in three quarters of embryos FFs were located among trophoblast cells. Some elimination of FFs from trophoblast occurred later on. Eventually, in blastocysts' outgrowths, an equally high contribution from FFs progeny (60%) was found in both ICM and trophoblast. Three days after manipulation, FFs resumed proliferation in vitro. More than three FFs were found in 46.2% of embryos on day 4. On the 7th day in vitro in 70% of embryos more than 12 FFs were found, proving at least three cell divisions. To study postimplantation development, the embryos with FFs were transferred to pseudopregnant recipients a day after manipulation. After implantation, FFs were identified by electrophoresis for isozymes of glucose phosphate isomerase (GPI). A single 11-day embryo delayed to day 8 proved chimeric by expressing both donor isozyme GPI-1B and recipient GPI-1A. Similar chimerism was found in the extraembryonic lineage of 11% of embryos by day 12. Starting from day 11 onwards, in 32% of normal embryos and in 57% of foetal membranes, hybrid GPI-1AB isozyme, as well as recipient isozyme, was present. Hybrid GPI-1AB can only be produced in hybrid cells derived by cell fusion, therefore, we suggest that during postimplantation development, FFs are rescued by fusion with recipient cells. In the mice born, hybrid isozyme was found in several tissues, including brain, lung, gut and kidney. We conclude that somatic cells (FFs) can proliferate in early embryonic environment until early postimplantation stages. Foetuses and the mice born are chimeras between recipient cells and hybrid cells with contributions from the donor FFs. Transdifferentiation as opposed to reprogramming by cell fusion can be considered as underlying cellular processes in these chimeras.

Mouse zygotes as recipients in embryo cloning.

Zygotes have not been recognized as nuclear recipients since enucleated zygotes receiving nuclei from beyond two-cell stage embryos are not able to form blastocysts. In the present study, a new technique of zygote enucleation is presented, which consists in selectively removing the nuclear membrane with genetic material of pronuclei, but leaving other pronuclear components in the cytoplasm. With selective enucleation it is possible - after transfer of eight-cell stage nuclei - to obtain 70.5 and 7.8% of preimplantation and full-term development respectively. Origin of cloned mice from introduced nuclei was confirmed by the coat colour and glucose phosphate isomerase (GPI) isozyme of the donor. We suggest that some pronuclear factors - taken away from the zygotes in the karyoplasts upon classical enucleation - are needed to reprogram the introduced nuclei.

Generation of cloned and chimeric embryos/offspring using the new methods of animal biotechnology.

The article summarizes results of studies concerning: 1/ qualitative evaluation of pig nuclear donor cells to somatic cell cloning, 2/ developmental potency of sheep somatic cells to create chimera, 3/ efficient production of chicken chimera. The quality of nuclear donor cells is one of the most important factors to determine the efficiency of somatic cell cloning. Morphological criteria commonly used for qualitative evaluation of somatic cells may be insufficient for practical application in the cloning. Therefore, different types of somatic cells being the source of genomic DNA in the cloning procedure were analyzed on apoptosis with the use of live-DNA or plasma membrane fluorescent markers. It has been found that morphological criteria are a sufficient selection factor for qualitative evaluation of nuclear donor cells to somatic cell cloning. Developmental potencies of sheep somatic cells in embryos and chimeric animals were studied using blastocyst complementation test. Fetal fibroblasts stained with vital fluorescent dye and microsurgically placed in morulae or blastocysts were later identified in embryos cultured in vitro. Transfer of Polish merino blastocysts harbouring Heatherhead fibroblasts to recipient ewes brought about normal births at term. Newly-born animals were of merino appearance with dark patches on their noses, near the mouth and on their clovens. This overt chimerism shows that fetal fibroblasts introduced to sheep morulae/blastocysts revealed full developmental plasticity. To achieve the efficient production of chicken chimeras, the blastodermal cells from embryos of the donor breeds, (Green-legged Partridgelike breed or GPxAraucana) were transferred into the embryos of the recipient breed (White Leghorn), and the effect of chimerism on the selected reproductive and physiological traits of recipients was examined. Using the model which allowed identification of the chimerism at many loci, it has been found that 93.9% of the examined birds were chimeras. The effect of donor cells on the reproduction and physiology of the recipients was evident.

Meiotic maternal chromosomes introduced to the late mouse zygote are recruited to later embryonic divisions.

The aim of this study was to investigate the fate of an additional female genome introduced to a dividing zygote. Maternal chromatin in the form of karyoplasts containing a metaphase II spindle were fused to zygotes blocked in anaphase or telophase of the first cleavage. Permanent preparations made 20-40 min after fusion at anaphase revealed that the donor maternal chromosomes had entered anaphase or telophase in 16 out of 18 cases. A further two groups of embryos that were fused at either anaphase or anaphase/telophase were cultured to the first division. Division occurred 50 min after fusion in both groups of embryos (86 and 85.1%, respectively), of which most divided to two cells (80 and 71.6% of total) and the remainder divided to three cells. About two thirds of two-cell embryos contained an extra nucleus in one blastomere. Nuclei containing donor maternal chromosomes reached a similar size to recipient nuclei in 68% of embryos derived from anaphase-blocked zygotes, in contrast to 31.1% of embryos derived from anaphase/telophase-blocked embryos. Replication of DNA in donor nuclei closely followed the timing and intensity of that in control embryos. When fixed 24 hr after fusion, one third of embryos were still at the two-cell stage, with one or both blastomeres showing a single metaphase plate of the second cleavage. In the remaining embryos, three or four cells were present, some containing two nuclei. Blastocysts developed in 50% of fused embryos and three young were born after transfer of cleaving hybrid embryos to recipients. Chromosome preparations from bone marrow of the young contained 3-4 tetraploid metaphase plates per several hundred plates counted compared with none in control embryos. In conclusion, additional maternal chromosomes can be introduced at the late-dividing zygote and join the embryonic cell cycles during subsequent divisions. This method may provide a useful approach for studying changes specific to the maternal genome during early cell cycles of the mammalian embryo.

Reconstruction of enucleated mouse germinal vesicle oocytes with blastomere nuclei.

We have investigated the possibility that mitotic nuclei originating from preimplantation stage embryos and placed in the oocyte cytoplasm can undergo remodelling that allows them to undergo meiosis in the mouse. To address this question, we have used enucleated germinal vesicle (GV) ooplasts as recipients and blastomeres from the 2-, 4- or 8-cell stage as nuclear donors. We employed two methods to obtain ooplasts from GV oocytes: cutting and enucleation. Although efficiency of the reconstruction process was higher after enucleation than after cutting (90% and 70% respectively), the developmental potential of the oocytes was independent of how they had been produced. Nuclei from the 2-, 4-, or 8-cell stage embryos supported maturation in about 35%, 55% and 60% of cases, respectively. The time between nuclear envelope breakdown and the first meiotic division was shortened by up to 5 h in reconstructed oocytes, a period equivalent to the mitotic division of control blastomeres. About one-third of oocytes reconstituted with blastomere nuclei divided symmetrically instead of extruding a polar body; however, in the majority of them metaphase plates were found, suggesting that reconstructed oocytes (cybrids) underwent a meiotic rather than mitotic division. The highest percentage of asymmetric divisions accompanied by metaphase plates was found in cybrids with 8-cell-stage blastomere nuclei, suggesting that the nuclei from this stage appear to conform best to the cytoplasmic environment of GV ooplasts. Our results indicate that the oocyte cytoplasm is capable of remodelling blastomere nuclei, allowing them to follow the path of the meiotic cell cycle.

Development of single mouse blastomeres enlarged to zygote size in conditions of nucleo-cytoplasmic synchrony.

The following blastomeres were enlarged to the size of the zygote by one, two or three rounds of blastomere enucleation and electrofusion: (1) from the 2-cell stage (referred to as 2/1 embryos), (2) from the 4-cell stage (referred to as 4/1 embryos), (3) from the 8-cell stage (referred to as 8/1 embryos). Such single enlarged blastomeres developed into blastocysts in vivo in 55.5% (2/1), 28% (4/1) and 6.6% (8/1) of cases. Their mean cell numbers were 45.3, 24.5 and 13.0 in 2/1, 4/1 and 8/1 embryos, respectively. When a blastomere nucleus from another mouse strain (heterologous nucleus) was substituted for a blastomere's own (homologous) one, then fewer blastocysts were formed from 2/1 embryos (34.6%), but not from 4/1 and 8/1 embryos. Five young (10.4%) were born from 2/1 embryos with a homologous nucleus, and nine (8.3%) from 2/1 embryos with heterologous nuclei. Four young (7.1%) were born from 4/1 embryos with heterologous nuclei. No young were obtained from 8/1 embryos. Incorrect cavitation resulting in trophoblastic vesicles and false blastocyst formation was common in 4/1 embryos (18.7% of those with homologous nuclei and 41.3% with heterologous nuclei) and in 8/1 embryos (53.3% and 43.7%, respectively). The results show that neither enlargement to zygote size nor nucleo-cytoplasmic synchrony improve postimplantation development of 4- and 8-cell stage blastomeres when compared with less enlarged non-synchronous ones; therefore, it appears that an insufficient number of inner cell mass cells in blastocysts and not too small a size of isolated blastomeres precludes their postimplantation development.

Decompaction and recompaction of mouse preimplantation embryos.

Early (non-compacted) and late (compacted) 8-cell embryos were observed after few hours of culture in vitro. The former embryos underwent compaction and the latter embryos were found decompacted. Cell counting suggested that decompaction preceded fourth cleavage division of any blastomere and lasted until the blastomeres divided.About one third of mouse morulae, which had about twenty cells, were found non-compacted upon obtaining from females. After few hours of culture in vitro these embryos underwent recompaction and cavitation. Increasing the contributions of mitosis-arrested and cytokinesisarrested cells within the morulae by culture with nocodazole and cytochalasin B respectively, did not delay recompaction.The data show that periods of decompaction and recompaction alternate in preimplantation development.

Effects of cytochalasin B on the cleavage furrow in mouse blastomeres.

Blastomeres isolated from two-cell mouse embryos were cultured until they started to cleave. When the cleavage furrow developed they were subjected to cytochalasin B (CB) and were studied with the electron microscope. The initial response to CB is that the furrow is more folded and microvillous than in the control. Later the blastomeres round up. The protrusions covered with abundant long microvilli are found scattered within their equatorial surface. Extraction with glycerol solution before fixation permits visualization of condensations of felt-like filamentous material in contact with the cleavage furrow during the initial response to CB and in the protrusions of rounded cells. We consider clumping of filaments in surface protrusions to be a specific response to CB treatment of the contractile ring.