A selectable system for mutation detection in the Big Blue lacI transgenic mouse system: what happens to the mutational spectra over time.

Transgenic animals offer a powerful tool to study the mechanisms of spontaneous and induced mutagenesis in vivo. Herein we used a test version of a growth selectable assay to obtain spontaneous mutants in a lacI target transgene recovered from lacI transgenic B6C3F1 mice (Big Blue). This selection system may have certain advantages relative to the more established plaque screening system for mutation detection because: (1) the plating density of the phage is up to 60 times higher in the selectable assay, reducing the number of plates needed to be screened for a comparable amount of mutants; and (2) the mutant frequency obtained from the selectable assay is higher compared to the plaque assay, possibly due to a higher sensitivity for weaker mutants. However, the longer incubation time of the growth selectable assay might allow E. coli host derived mutants to appear. To address this issue, we investigated the sequence changes in the amino-terminal domain of the lacI gene of 405 mutants derived from the liver, spleen, brain, germ cells and skin of five untreated 6-week-old mice. The mutant colonies were isolated after 60, 84, 108 and 150 h of incubation under growth selectable conditions. Tissue-specific differences in the mutational pattern obtained after 60 and 84 h disappear after a longer time of incubation, possibly due to an increasing contribution of E. coli derived mutants. The evolving selectable systems offer the potential to increase screening efficiency, but the results suggest caution in interpreting data from this system because repair by E. coli of DNA lesions or mismatched heteroduplexes either originating in mouse in vivo or produced by ex vivo manipulation as well as de novo mutations in E. coli might contribute significantly to the observed mutational spectra at each timepoint.

Spontaneous mutations in lacI-containing lambda lysogens derived from transgenic mice: the observed patterns differ in liver and spleen.

The pattern of somatic mutation observed in tumor suppressor genes, such as the p53 gene, vary dramatically with tumor type. Some of the observed differences are due to tissue specific effects of mutagens, but it is also possible that some differences may reflect the tissue/cell type specificity of spontaneous mutation. Transgenic mouse models with recombinant shuttle vectors containing the lacI or lacZ target genes may shed light on the extent to which spontaneous mutation displays tissue specificity. Herein we utilize a recently described selectable system to obtain spontaneous mutants for analysis of the molecular lesions. Spontaneous mutations were isolated in the lacI gene recovered from five transgenic mice carrying a lambda shuttle vector. Seventy-three and 67 independent mutations derived from liver and spleen DNA, respectively, were defined in the amino terminal region of lacI. Although technical barriers preclude a direct assessment of the E. coli derived pattern of mutation in this system, five pieces of circumstantial evidence suggest that many of the mutations arose in mouse rather than in E. coli. In DNA from both liver and spleen, mutations at CpG dinucleotides predominate (58% and 51%, respectively). In spleen, most of the mutations at CpG are transitions, while in liver most are transversions. In addition, liver has a higher frequency of GC-->TA transversions at non-CpG dinucleotides while spleen had a higher frequency of deletions and insertions. The data provide evidence that the spontaneous pattern of mutation is tissue specific. In addition, the high frequency of transversions at CpG suggests the need to reevaluate the mechanisms by which mutations occur at this methylated dinucleotide.

The use of shuttle vectors for mutation analysis in transgenic mice and rats.

The establishment in recent years of transgenic shuttle vector-based mutagenicity assays has provided improved systems for analysis of mutagenic and carcinogenic processes. Results in the mouse have stimulated the development of an alternate species suitable for mutation analysis and have increased our understanding of the existing models. A previously described shuttle vector (lambda LIZ), based on a lacI target gene, was constructed in this laboratory for the study of mutagenesis in transgenic mice and in cultured cell lines. The shuttle vector allows for several options in its recovery from the host genome and in mutant identification. Of the 9 transgenic lineages that were generated with the lambda LIZ vector, one was chosen for use in a standardized mutagenicity assay (Big Blue, mouse lineage A1). Characterization of this lineage included copy-number determination, chromosomal localization of transgene integration and analysis of copy-number stability. As part of the validation process, the standardized color-screening assay has been tested in the mouse, both for spontaneous mutant frequencies and with a variety of model mutagenic compounds, and has been shown to identify most major classes of mutations as evidenced by mutant spectra data. A discussion of the relative sensitivity of the shuttle vector to each of these classes of mutations is included. These studies have now been extended to the generation of transgenic rats containing the same shuttle vector for cross-species analysis. Spontaneous mutant frequencies in two transgenic rat lineages were measured in liver and in germ cells. Preliminary data suggest that spontaneous mutant frequencies in somatic tissue are lower in rats than in mice, a result consistent with historical observations of DNA damage and repair in these two species. Also under evaluation are alternative selectable systems for mutant identification, and hybrid animals obtained from mating lambda LIZ transgenics with genetically engineered mice possessing an inactivated tumor suppressor gene. It is expected that each of these widely varying endeavors will contribute, not only in furthering our understanding of the role transgenic systems should play in human risk assessment, but in illuminating the mechanisms of mutation in general.

Transgenic systems for in vivo mutation analysis.

Transgenic mice carrying shuttle vectors containing the lacI gene as the target permit the in vivo measurement of mutations in multiple tissues and have been used to test the mutagenic effects of several compounds. Tissue-specific and time-dependent responses have been observed, and the spectrum of mutations determined by sequencing allows analysis of the role of expression time in mutagenesis. The results obtained from sequencing analysis have demonstrated spectra paralleling those observed in alternative in vivo assays. In addition to color screening, modifications to this system have permitted direct selection for mutations in the lacI target by a variety of methods. Transgenic rats containing the same lambda/lacI shuttle vector have been developed for inter-species comparison of mutagenesis testing results, which may offer a better understanding of the specific mechanisms involved in mutagenesis at the molecular level in vivo.

The use of selection in recovery of transgenic targets for mutation analysis.

Transgenic animal mutagenesis assays using lambda shuttle vectors have recently been described for isolation and characterization of spontaneous and chemical induced DNA mutations. Extensive information on lambda and E. coli genetics provides a wealth of techniques to allow selection of mutant target genes. Here we describe the modification of an E. coli host which permits two methods for the direct selection of mutant genes. These methods reduce the number of plates needed to be screened for a comparable amount of frequency data by 20-100-fold and thus provide a significant savings of the materials and time required for the screening of mutations. In addition, mutants selected by these approaches described here may alter or broaden the spectrum of mutations that are recoverable. Ultimately, a combination of selective and nonselective techniques may prove valuable for the analysis of mutations produced in vivo in transgenic animals.

Spectra of spontaneous and mutagen-induced mutations in the lacI gene in transgenic mice.

Transgenic mice with a lambda shuttle vector containing a lacI target gene were generated for use as a short-term, in vivo mutagenesis assay. The gene is recovered from the treated mice by exposing mouse genomic DNA to in vitro packaging extracts and plating the rescued phage on agar plates containing 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl beta-D-galactopyranoside (X-Gal). Phage with mutations in the lacI gene form blue plaques, whereas phage with a nonmutated lacI form colorless plaques. Spontaneous background mutant rates using this system range from 0.6 x 10(-5) to 1.7 x 10(-5), depending upon tissue analyzed, with germ cells exhibiting less than one-third the background rate of somatic tissue. Treatment of the mice with N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (EtNU), benzo[a]pyrene (B[a]P), or cyclophosphamide caused an induction of mutations over background. Recovery of the lacI target for sequence analysis was performed by genetic excision of a plasmid from the phage using partial filamentous phage origins. The predominant mutations identified from untreated and treated populations were base substitutions. Although it has been shown by others that 70% of all spontaneous mutations within the lacI gene, when replicated in Escherichia coli, occur at a hot spot located at bases 620-632, only 1 of 21 spontaneous mutations has been identified in this region in the transgenic mouse system. In addition, 5 of 9 spontaneous transitions analyzed occur at CpG dinucleotides, whereas no transition mutations were identified at the prokaryotic deamination hot spots occurring at dcm sites (CCA/TGG) within the lacI gene. For EtNU, approximately equal amounts of transitions and transversions were observed, contrasting with B[a]P-induced mutations, in which only transversions were obtained. In addition, B[a]P mutagenesis showed a predominance of mutations (81%) involving cytosines and/or guanines, consistent with its known mode of action. The discovery of a spontaneous mutation spectrum different from that of bacterial assays, coupled with the concordance of EtNU and B[a]P base mutations with the known mechanisms of activity for these mutagens, suggests that this transgenic system will be useful as a short-term, in vivo system for mutagen assessment and analysis of mechanisms leading to mutations.

Identification and characterization of a gene responsible for inhibiting propagation of methylated DNA sequences in mcrA mcrB1 Escherichia coli strains.

Identifying and eliminating endogenous bacterial enzyme systems can significantly increase the efficiency of propagation of eukaryotic DNA in Escherichia coli. We have recently examined one such system which inhibits the propagation of lambda DNA rescued from transgenic mouse tissues. This rescue procedure utilizes lambda packaging extracts for excision of the lambda DNA from the transgenic mouse genome, as well as E. coli cells for subsequent infection and propagation. This assay, in combination with conjugal mating, P1 transduction, and gene cloning, was used to identify and characterize the E. coli locus responsible for this difference in efficiency. It was determined that the E. coli K-12 mcrB gene when expressed on a high-copy-number plasmid can cause a decrease in rescue efficiency despite the presence of the mcrB1 mutation, which inactivates the classic McrB restriction activity. (This mutation was verified by sequence analysis.) However, this McrB1 activity is not observed when the cloned mcrB1 gene is inserted into the E. coli genome at one copy per chromosome. A second locus was identified which causes a decrease in rescue efficiency both when expressed on a high-copy-number plasmid and when inserted into the genome. The data presented here suggest that this locus is mrr and that the mrr gene product can recognize and restrict cytosine-methylated sequences. Removal of this DNA region including the mrr gene from E. coli K-12 strains allows high rescue efficiencies equal to those of E. coli C strains. These modified E. coli K-12 plating strains and lambda packaging extract strains should also allow a significant improvement in the efficiency and representation of eukaryotic genomic and cDNA libraries.

Nomenclature relating to restriction of modified DNA in Escherichia coli.

At least three restriction systems that attack DNA containing naturally modified bases have been found in common Escherichia coli K-12 strains. These systems are McrA, McrBC, and Mrr. A brief summary of the genetic and phenotypic properties so far observed in laboratory strains is set forth, together with a proposed nomenclature for describing these properties.

Analysis of spontaneous and induced mutations in transgenic mice using a lambda ZAP/lacI shuttle vector.

A short term, in vivo mutagenesis assay has been developed utilizing a lacl target gene contained within a lambda ZAP shuttle vector which has been incorporated into transgenic mice. Following chemical exposure, the target gene was recovered from mouse genomic DNA by mixing the DNA with in vitro lambda phage packaging extract. Mutations within the lacl target were identified by infecting host E. coli with the packaged phage and plating on indicator plates containing Xgal. Phage plaques with mutations in the lacl appeared blue, while intact phage were colorless. The ratio of blue plaques to colorless plaques is a measure of the mutagenicity of the compound. This system was used to obtain significant induction (up to 74-fold) over background levels for a variety of compounds, including N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea, benzo(a)pyrene (BaP), cyclophosphamide, and methylnitrosourea. Sequence analysis of selected mutant clones derived from this system was accomplished through the use of partial filamentous phage origins which allow rapid transfer of the target gene from phage to plasmid. Sequence analysis of spontaneous mutants derived from the mice primarily found of base substitutions, differing markedly from the previous data for spontaneous mutations in lacl derived from E. coli, where the preponderance of mutations were found at a single site, a repeated tetramer sequence. Upon sequence analysis of BaP derived base substitutions, only transversions were obtained, consistent with the known mechanism of BaP mutagenesis. Use of the well-characterized lacl gene in transgenic mice should allow for extrapolation of the extensive pool of in vitro data to whole animals, as well as provide insight into the tissue specific effects of mutagenic compounds.

The use of transgenic mice for short-term, in vivo mutagenicity testing.

In order to develop a short-term, in vivo assay to study the mutagenic effects of chemical exposure, transgenic mice were generated using a lambda shuttle vector containing a lacZ target gene. Following exposure to mutagens, this target can be rescued efficiently from genomic DNA prepared from tissues of the treated mice using restriction minus, in vitro lambda phage packaging extract and restriction minus Escherichia coli plating cultures. Mutations in the target gene appear as colorless plaques on a background of blue plaques when plated on indicator agar. Spontaneous background levels were approximately 1 x 10(-5) in each of three mouse lineages analyzed. Exposure of lambda transgenic mice to N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea resulted in as much as a 14-fold induction in detected mutations over background levels. The assay is currently being modified to incorporate lacI as the target for ease of mutation detection as well as in vivo excision properties of the Lambda ZAP vector, facilitating sequence analysis of mutant plaques.

Development of a short-term, in vivo mutagenesis assay: the effects of methylation on the recovery of a lambda phage shuttle vector from transgenic mice.

Transgenic mice suitable for the in vivo assay of suspected mutagens at the chromosome level have been constructed by stable integration of a lambda phage shuttle vector. The shuttle vector, which contains a beta-galactosidase (beta-gal) target gene, can be rescued from genomic DNA with in vitro packaging extracts. Mutations in the target gene are detected by a change in lambda phage plaque color on indicator agar plates. Initial rescue efficiencies of less than 1 plaque forming unit (pfu)/100 micrograms of genomic DNA were too low for mutation analysis. We determined the cause of the low rescue efficiencies by examining primary fibroblast cultures prepared from fetuses of lambda transgenic animals. The rescue efficiency of 5-azacytidine-treated cells increased 50-fold over non-treated controls indicating that methylation was inhibiting rescue. The inhibitory role of methylation was supported by the observation that mcr deficient E. coli plating strains and mcr deficient lambda packaging extracts further improved lambda rescue efficiency. Present rescue efficiencies of greater than 2000 pfu/copy/micrograms of genomic DNA represent a 100,000-fold improvement over initial rescue efficiencies, permitting quantitative mutational analysis. The background mutagenesis rate was estimated at 1 x 10(-5) in two separate lineages. Following treatment with the mutagen N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (EtNU), a dose dependent increase in the mutation rate was observed in DNA isolated from mouse spleen, with significant induction also observed in mouse testes DNA.

Cloning of the riboB locus of Aspergillus nidulans.

We have complemented the riboB2 mutation of Aspergillus nidulans by transformation with a plasmid library of wild-type (wt) sequences. We have isolated, by marker rescue from a riboB+ transformant, a plasmid that complements riboB2 efficiently. From this plasmid we have subcloned an A. nidulans sequence that complements riboB2 efficiently and that integrates by homologous recombination at a site closely linked to the riboB locus. We conclude that this sequence contains the wt riboB+ allele.