Are Internal Fragments Observable in Electron Based Top-Down Mass Spectrometry?

Protein tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) often generates sequence-informative fragments from backbone bond cleavages near the termini. This lack of fragmentation in the protein interior is particularly apparent in native top-down MS. Improved sequence coverage, critical for reliable annotation of posttranslational modifications (PTMs) and sequence variants, may be obtained from internal fragments generated by multiple backbone cleavage events. However, internal fragment assignments can be error prone due to isomeric/isobaric fragments from different parts of a protein sequence. Also, internal fragment generation propensity depends on the chosen MS/MS activation strategy. Here, we examine internal fragment formation in electron capture dissociation (ECD) and electron transfer dissociation (ETD) following native and denaturing MS, as well as liquid chromatography (LC)/MS of several proteins. Experiments were undertaken on multiple instruments, including Q-ToF, Orbitrap, and high-field FT-ICR across four laboratories. ECD was performed at both ultrahigh vacuum and at similar pressure to ETD conditions. Two complementary software packages were used for data analysis. When feasible, ETD-higher-energy collision dissociation (ETD-HCD) MS3 was performed to validate/refute potential internal fragment assignments, including differentiating MS3 fragmentation behavior of radical vs. even-electron primary fragments. We show that, under typical operating conditions, internal fragments cannot be confidently assigned in ECD, nor ETD. On the other hand, such fragments, along with some b-type terminal fragments (not typically observed in ECD/ETD spectra) appear at atypical ECD operating conditions, suggesting they originate from a separate ion-electron activation process. Furthermore, atypical fragment ion types, e.g., x ions, are observed at such conditions as well as upon EThcD, presumably due to vibrational activation of radical z-type ions.

Detection of Lipid-Bound Bacteriorhodopsin Trimer Complex Directly from Purple Membrane by Native Mass Spectrometry.

Native mass spectrometry (MS) was used to detect the membrane protein, bacteriorhodopsin (bR), in its 27 kDa monomeric form and trimeric assemblies directly from lipid-containing purple membranes (PMs) from the halophilic archaeon, Halobacterium salinarum. Trimer bR ion populations bound to lipid molecules were detected with n-octyl ß-d-glucopyranoside as the solubilizing detergent; the use of octyl tetraethylene glycol monooctyl ether or n-dodecyl-ß-d-maltopyranoside resulted in only detection of monomeric bR. The archaeal lipids phosphotidylglycerolphosphate methyl ester and 3-HSO3-Galp-ß1,6-Manp-α1,2-Glcp-α1,1-sn-2,3-diphytanylglycerol were the only lipids in the PMs found to bind to bR, consistent with previous high-resolution structural studies. Removal of the lipids from the sample resulted in the detection of only the bR monomer, highlighting the importance of specific lipids for stabilizing the bR trimer. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report of the detection of the bR trimer with resolved lipid-bound species by MS.

Native Top-Down Mass Spectrometry with Collisionally Activated Dissociation Yields Higher-Order Structure Information for Protein Complexes.

Native mass spectrometry (MS) of proteins and protein assemblies reveals size and binding stoichiometry, but elucidating structures to understand their function is more challenging. Native top-down MS (nTDMS), i.e., fragmentation of the gas-phase protein, is conventionally used to derive sequence information, locate post-translational modifications (PTMs), and pinpoint ligand binding sites. nTDMS also endeavors to dissociate covalent bonds in a conformation-sensitive manner, such that information about higher-order structure can be inferred from the fragmentation pattern. However, the activation/dissociation method used can greatly affect the resulting information on protein higher-order structure. Methods such as electron capture/transfer dissociation (ECD and ETD, or ExD) and ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) can produce product ions that are sensitive to structural features of protein complexes. For multi-subunit complexes, a long-held belief is that collisionally activated dissociation (CAD) induces unfolding and release of a subunit, and thus is not useful for higher-order structure characterization. Here we show not only that sequence information can be obtained directly from CAD of native protein complexes but that the fragmentation pattern can deliver higher-order structural information about their gas- and solution-phase structures. Moreover, CAD-generated internal fragments (i.e., fragments containing neither N-/C-termini) reveal structural aspects of protein complexes.