Bone effects of epidural and intra-articular glucocorticoids: a systematic literature review / Efectos óseos de los glucocorticoides epidurales e intraarticulares: revisión sistemática de la literatura

Osteoporosis and vertebral and non-vertebral fractures are common in glucocorticoids (GC) treated patients. Oral GC treatment leads to bone loss, particularly of trabecular bone. The benefits of GC used in rheumatological and traumatological disorders are known but they would have possible negative effects on bone. This systematic review aimed to evaluate the effects of epidural steroid injections (ESI), and intra-articular and intramuscular GC administration on bone mineral density (BMD) and fragility fractures. A systematic review of Medline/PubMed, Cochrane, and LILACS up to November 2020 was conducted. Meta-analyses, systematic reviews, randomized and non-randomized controlled trials, and prospective and retrospective studies comparing the effect of ESI, intra-articular or intramuscular GC used compared to a control group or baseline measurements were included. Results: A total of 8272 individuals were included among the 13 selected articles (10 about ESI and 3 about intra-articular GC; no article was found evaluating intramuscular GC). Only a few studies showed a negative effect of ESI on bone in the qualitative analysis considering osteopenia and osteoporosis in lumbar spine, femoral neck and total hip and BMD as surrogate outcomes. On the other hand, the qualitative analysis showed that most studies found an increased risk of fragility fracture. However, only two studies could be included in the quantitative analysis, in which there were no differences between patients exposed to ESI versus controls in all evaluated regions. In conclusion, there was insufficient evidence to suggest that ESI and intra-articular GC, unlike oral GC, negatively affect bone mass. Longitudinal studies are needed to obtain more knowledge regarding the effect of ESI or intra-articular GC on BMD and fragility fractures. (AU)

La osteoporosis y las fracturas vertebrales y no vertebrales son comunes en pacientes tratados con glucocorticoides (GC). El tratamiento oral con GC conduce a la pérdida ósea, particularmente del hueso trabecular. Los beneficios de los GC utilizados en patologías reumatológicas y traumatológicas son conocidos, pero tendrían posibles efectos negativos sobre el hueso. Esta revisión sistemática tuvo como objetivo evaluar los efectos de las inyecciones epidurales de esteroides (ESI), GC intraarticulares e intramusculares sobre la densidad mineral ósea (DMO) y las fracturas por fragilidad. Se realizó una revisión sistemática de Medline/PubMed, Cochrane y LILACS hasta noviembre de 2020. Se incluyeron metanálisis, revisiones sistemáticas, ensayos controlados aleatorizados y no aleatorizados, estudios prospectivos y retrospectivos que compararon el efecto de ESI, GC intraarticular o intramuscular utilizado en comparación con un grupo de control o mediciones iniciales. Resultados: Se incluyeron un total de 8272 individuos entre los 13 artículos seleccionados (10 sobre ESI y 3 sobre GC intraarticular; no se encontró ningún artículo que evaluara GC intramuscular). Solo unos pocos estudios mostraron un efecto negativo del ESI sobre el hueso en el análisis cualitativo considerando la osteopenia y la osteoporosis en la columna lumbar, el cuello femoral y la cadera total y la DMO como un resultado indirecto. Por otro lado, el análisis cualitativo mostró que la mayoría de los estudios encontraron un mayor riesgo de fractura por fragilidad. Sin embargo, solo dos estudios pudieron incluirse en el análisis cuantitativo, en los que no hubo diferencias entre los pacientes expuestos a ESI versus los controles en todas las regiones evaluadas. En conclusión, no hallamos datos suficientes para sugerir que la ESI y los GC intraarticulares, a diferencia de los GC orales, afectan negativamente a la pérdida ósea. Se necesitan estudios longitudinales para obtener más conocimiento sobre el efecto de ESI o GC intraarticular en la DMO y las fracturas por fragilidad. (AU)

Threshold based on bone mineral density for therapeutic decision-making in postmenopausal women and men over 50 years old under glucocorticoid therapy / Umbral densitométrico de densidad mineral ósea para considerar tratamiento en pacientes mujeres posmenopáusicas y hombres mayores de 50 años en tratamiento con glucocorticoids

Introduction and aim: T-score bone mineral density (BMD) thresholds may influence guidance for treatment in patients under glucocorticoid (GC) therapy. Different BMD thresholds have been described but there is no international consensus. The aim of this study was to find a threshold to help in treatment decision-making in the population under GC therapy. Methods: A working group representing three scientific societies from Argentina was convened. The first team was formed by specialists with expertise in glucocorticoid-induced osteoporosis (GIO) who voted according to summary of evidence. The second team was constituted by a methodology group who coordinated and supervised each stage. We conducted two systematic reviews to synthesize the evidence. The first included trials of drugs used in GIO to analyze the BMD cut-off used as inclusion criteria. In the second, we analyzed the evidence regarding the densitometric thresholds to discriminate between fractured and non-fractured patients under GC treatment. Results: In the first review, 31 articles were included for qualitative synthesis and more than 90% of the trials included patients regardless of their densitometric T-score or range of osteopenia. In the second review, 4 articles were included and more than 80% of the T-scores were in the range −1.6 to −2.0. The summary of findings was analyzed and put to a vote. Conclusions: With more than 80% agreement of the voting expert panel, a T-score≤−1.7 was considered the most appropriate for treatment in postmenopausal women and men over 50 years of age under GC therapy. This study could help in treatment decision-making in patients under GC therapy without fractures but other fracture risk factors should certainly be considered.(AU)

Introducción y objetivo: Los umbrales del T-score de densidad mineral ósea (DMO) podrían influir en el tratamiento de pacientes bajo terapia con glucocorticoides (GC). Se han descrito diferentes umbrales, pero no existe un consenso internacional. El objetivo de este trabajo fue encontrar un umbral que ayude en la decisión terapéutica en la población bajo tratamiento con GC. Métodos: Se convocó un grupo de trabajo en representación de tres sociedades científicas de Argentina. El primer equipo estuvo formado por especialistas con experiencia en osteoporosis inducida por glucocorticoides (OIG), quienes estuvieron a cargo de la votación basada en la evidencia. El segundo equipo estuvo a cargo de la metodología coordinando y supervisando cada etapa. Realizamos dos revisiones sistemáticas: la primera incluyó ensayos de fármacos utilizados en OIG para analizar el T-score considerado como criterio de inclusión. En la segunda, analizamos la evidencia sobre umbrales densitométricos para la discriminación de pacientes fracturados y no fracturados bajo tratamiento con GC. Resultados: En la primera revisión se incluyeron 31 artículos donde se halló que más de 90% de los ensayos incluyeron pacientes independientemente del T-score o en el rango de osteopenia. En la segunda revisión se incluyeron cuatro artículos donde observamos que más de 80% de los valores de T-score se encontraban entre -1,6 y -2,0. Conclusiones: Con un acuerdo superior a 80% del panel de expertos, un T-score ≤ -1,7 se consideró el más adecuado para el tratamiento en mujeres posmenopáusicas y hombres mayores de 50 años bajo tratamiento con GC. Este estudio podría ayudar en la decisión terapéutica en pacientes bajo tratamiento con GC sin fracturas, pero ciertamente deberían considerarse otros factores de riesgos de fracturas complementarios.(AU)

Threshold based on bone mineral density for therapeutic decision-making in postmenopausal women and men over 50 years old under glucocorticoid therapy.

INTRODUCTION AND AIM: T-score bone mineral density (BMD) thresholds may influence guidance for treatment in patients under glucocorticoid (GC) therapy. Different BMD thresholds have been described but there is no international consensus. The aim of this study was to find a threshold to help in treatment decision-making in the population under GC therapy. METHODS: A working group representing three scientific societies from Argentina was convened. The first team was formed by specialists with expertise in glucocorticoid-induced osteoporosis (GIO) who voted according to summary of evidence. The second team was constituted by a methodology group who coordinated and supervised each stage. We conducted two systematic reviews to synthesize the evidence. The first included trials of drugs used in GIO to analyze the BMD cut-off used as inclusion criteria. In the second, we analyzed the evidence regarding the densitometric thresholds to discriminate between fractured and non-fractured patients under GC treatment. RESULTS: In the first review, 31 articles were included for qualitative synthesis and more than 90% of the trials included patients regardless of their densitometric T-score or range of osteopenia. In the second review, 4 articles were included and more than 80% of the T-scores were in the range -1.6 to -2.0. The summary of findings was analyzed and put to a vote. CONCLUSIONS: With more than 80% agreement of the voting expert panel, a T-score≤-1.7 was considered the most appropriate for treatment in postmenopausal women and men over 50 years of age under GC therapy. This study could help in treatment decision-making in patients under GC therapy without fractures but other fracture risk factors should certainly be considered.

Efecto de la yerba mate (ilex paraguariensis) sobre el hueso de ratas ovariectomizadas / Effect of yerba mate (ilex paraguariensis) on bone in ovariectomized rats

El consumo de yerba mate (Ilex paraguariensis) es habitual en la Argentina y otros países de América del Sur. La yerba mate, al igual que el café y el té, contiene xantinas y polifenoles. El consumo de café ha mostrado tener impacto negativo sobre la densidad mineral ósea (DMO), mientras que el té ha mostrado tener efecto protector. En mujeres posmenopáusicas tomadoras de mate se halló mayor DMO de columna lumbar y cuello femoral en comparación con controles que no bebían mate. La DMO también fue mayor en ratas que recibieron una infusión de yerba mate y dieta baja en calcio; sin embargo, este incremento no fue capaz de revertir el efecto negativo del bajo contenido de calcio sobre las propiedades biomecánicas y la conectividad trabecular. El objetivo de este trabajo fue estudiar el tejido óseo de ratas ovariectomizadas (OVX) luego de recibir una infusión de yerba mate por 90 días en reemplazo del agua de bebida. Se utilizaron ratas Sprague Dawley (n=16) hembras divididas en 2 grupos: OVX+agua y OVX+yerba. Otro grupo de ratas (n=6) fue sometido a una cirugía simulada (Sham). El estudio mostró claramente el efecto deletéreo de la ovariectomía sobre todos los parámetros estudiados (DMO, histomorfometría ósea, conectividad trabecular y biomecánica) respecto del grupo Sham. El grupo OVX+yerba no mostró diferencias con el grupo OVX+agua en ninguno de los parámetros analizados, por lo que la yerba mate no produciría efecto alguno sobre el hueso de ratas adultas ovariectomizadas. (AU)

Yerba mate (Ilex paraguariensis) consumption is common in Argentina and other South American countries. Like coffee and tea, yerba mate contains xanthines and polyphenols. It has been reported that caffeine consumption has a negative impact on bone mineral density (BMD) while tea has been shown to have a protective effect. On the other hand, in postmenopausal women that usually consumed yerba mate, lumbar spine and femoral neck BMDs were higher than in non-consumers. BMD was also higher in rats that received a yerba mate infusion and low calcium diet. However, this increase was not sufficient to reverse the negative effect of a low calcium diet on bone biomechanical properties and trabecular connectivity. The aim of this work was to study bone tissue in ovariectomized (OVX) rats receiving an infusion of yerba mate instead of drinking water for 90 days. Female Sprague Dawley rats (n=16) were divided into 2 groups: OVX+water and OVX+yerba. A third group of rats (n=6) was submitted to sham surgery (Sham). Results clearly showed the deleterious effect of ovariectomy on all studied parameters (BMD, bone histomorphometry, trabecular connectivity and biomechanical properties) compared to Sham group. The OVX+yerba group showed no difference with OVX+water group in all analyzed parameters. It is concluded that yerba mate does not produce any effect on the bone of ovariectomized adult rats. (AU)

Effects of Yerba Mate (IIex paraguariensis) on Histomorphometry, Biomechanics, and Densitometry on Bones in the Rat.

Yerba mate (Ilex paraguariensis) is a xanthine-containing beverage, which is also rich in caffeine. Because caffeine has a negative impact on bone mineral density (BMD) mainly associated with low calcium (Ca) diets, there would be expected a negative effect of yerba mate on bone. In this study, Sprague-Dawley rats were used and randomly assigned into four groups (n = 6/group): Control + Ca 0.2 g %; Control + Ca 0.9 g %; Yerba + Ca 0.2 g %; Yerba + Ca 0.9 g %. At the end of the experiment, tibias and femurs were obtained for BMD, morphometric, histomorphometric, and biomechanical analyses. While there was no difference in bone parameters between rats with and without yerba mate consumption, a negative effect of low Ca diet was observed in BMD, morphometric, histomorphometric, and biomechanical results. Interaction between Ca content in the diet and yerba mate was only found in trabecular bone volume, which would indicate that the negative effect of low Ca intake on bone volume is reversed in part by yerba mate infusion. However, yerba mate was not able to reverse the negative effect of low Ca content on biomechanical properties and trabecular connectivity. In summary, at least in our study, yerba mate would not have a negative effect on bone and would be safe for the bone health of consumers.