Therapeutic Exercise on Metabolic and Renal Outcomes in Patients with Chronic Kidney Disease: A Narrative Review.

BACKGROUND: Chronic kidney disease (CKD) affects 11-13% of the world population. The main risk factors for CKD include diabetes, hypertension, and obesity. Metabolic syndrome (MS) is associated with the onset of CKD in the nondiabetic population. Obesity and MS are also risk factors for a worse progression of established CKD. Therapeutic exercise is an effective option to treat and manage obesity, MS, and diabetes in the general population. However, the evidence on the effect of exercise on patients with CKD, obesity, and MS is scarce. SUMMARY: We evaluated available evidence on the effect of therapeutic exercise in patients with CKD, excluding dialysis, particularly in improving the metabolic risk factors and main renal outcomes: renal function loss and albuminuria/proteinuria. This review includes prospective studies and clinical trials. A total of 44 studies were analysed in 1,700 subjects with renal disease (2-5), including patients with renal transplantation. Most studies did not prove a major effect of exercise on albuminuria/proteinuria, glomerular filtration rate (GFR), obesity, or MS. These results are intriguing and deserve attention. The exploratory nature of most studies, including a low number of cases and short follow-up, might explain the lack of efficacy of exercise in our analysis. Specific aspects like the type of exercise, frequency, intensity, duration, accommodation during follow-up, individualization, safety, and adherence are crucial to the success of therapeutic exercise. The beneficial role of exercise in patients with CKD remains to be determined. KEY MESSAGES: Key messages of this review are as follows. (1) The effect of therapeutic exercise on renal and metabolic outcomes in patients with CKD remains to be determined. (2) According to the evidence selected, therapeutic exercise seems to be safe to treat patients with CKD. (3) Most studies are exploratory by nature, with results that need further investigation. (4) Therapeutic exercise is a complex procedure that must be specifically designed to treat patients with CKD.

Early glomerular filtration rate changes in living kidney donors and recipients: an example of renal plasticity.

Background: In living kidney transplantation there are two different individuals, a healthy donor and a renal transplant recipient. This is an excellent human model to study factors that influence kidney function in the context of reduced renal mass and the adaptation of two comparable kidneys to different metabolic demands. Methods: We analyzed the changes in measured glomerular filtration rate (GFR, iohexol) from pretransplantation to 12 months after transplantation in 30 donor-recipient pairs. Each donor was compared with his/her recipient. We defined a priori three different groups based on GFR differences at 12 months: donor > recipient (Group A; 78 ± 8 versus 57 ± 8 mL/min), donor < recipient (Group B; 65 ± 11 versus 79 ± 11 mL/min) and donor ≈ recipient (Group C; 66 ± 7 versus 67 ± 7 mL/min). Other factors like donor/recipient mismatches in body mass index (BMI), surface area and gender were evaluated. Results: In Group A donors were mostly male and recipients were female (75% each). Donors had a higher baseline weight than their recipients. During follow-up, weight remained stable in donors but increased 7% in recipients. In Group B donors were mostly female (60%) and recipients male. At baseline, donors had a lower weight than recipients. At 12 months, weight was stable in donors but increased in recipients. In Group C donors were mostly (75%) female and recipients male. At baseline, donors had a higher BMI than their recipients. At 12 months, BMI was stable in donors but increased 14% in recipients. In multivariable analysis, higher GFR at 12 months was associated with higher baseline weight and GFR in donors and with male gender and higher baseline weight in recipients. Conclusions: Kidneys from living donors are more 'plastic' than originally thought and respond to metabolic demands and weight changes of their new host. These changes should be taken into account when assessing GFR outcomes in this population.

Estimated GFR in autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease: errors of an unpredictable method.

BACKGROUND: Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) causes about 10% of cases of end stage renal disease. Disease progression rate is heterogeneous. Tolvaptan is presently the only specific therapeutic option to slow kidney function decline in adults at risk of rapidly progressing ADPKD with chronic kidney disease (CKD) stages 1-4. Thus, a reliable evaluation of kidney function in patients with ADPKD is needed. METHODS: We evaluated the agreement between measured (mGFR) and estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) by 61 formulas based on creatinine and/or cystatin-C (eGFR) in 226 ADPKD patients with diverse GFR values, from predialysis to glomerular hyperfiltration. Also, we evaluated whether incorrect categorization of CKD using eGFR may interfere with the indication and/or reimbursement of Tolvaptan treatment. RESULTS: No formula showed acceptable agreement with mGFR. Total Deviation Index averaged about 50% for eGFR based on creatinine and/or cystatin-C, indicating that 90% of the estimations of GFR showed bounds of error of 50% when compared with mGFR. In 1 out of 4 cases with mGFR < 30 ml/min, eGFR provided estimations above this threshold. Also, in half of the cases with mGFR between 30 and 40 ml/min, formulas estimated values < 30 ml/min. CONCLUSIONS: The evaluation of renal function with formulas in ADPKD patients is unreliable. Extreme deviation from real renal function is quite frequent. The consequences of this error deserve attention, especially in rapid progressors who may benefit from starting treatment with tolvaptan and in whom specific GFR thresholds are needed for the indication or reimbursement. Whenever possible, mGFR is recommended.

Estimated GFR Slope in Kidney Transplant Patients: When the Error Is Random.

BACKGROUND: The evaluation of renal function changes over time is crucial in day-to-day renal transplant care, and the slope of renal function is a major outcome in clinical trials. Little is known about the reliability of estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) in reflecting real glomerular filtration rate (GFR) changes. METHODS: We analyzed the variability of eGFR slope by 63 equations in estimating measured GFR (mGFR) changes in 110 renal transplant patients. The agreement between eGFR and mGFR slopes was evaluated by the concordance correlation coefficient and the limits of agreement. Patients were grouped based on mGFR slope in rapid GFR loss: faster than -3 mL/min/y; stable renal function: -3 to +3 mL/min/y; and improvement in GFR: higher than +3 mL/min/y. RESULTS: Concordance correlation coefficient averaged 0.36 and limits of agreement ±10 mL/min/y, indicating very poor agreement between eGFR and mGFR slopes. The eGFR slope classified patients into the same group of mGFR slope only in 25% of the cases. In about two-thirds of patients, the eGFR slope was either markedly faster or slower than the mGFR slope. In half of these cases, the discrepancy between mGFR and eGFR slopes was ≥50%. CONCLUSIONS: Formulas are neither accurate nor precise in reflecting real GFR decline in renal transplant patients, making them unreliable for clinical practice and trials.