ABSTRACT
The most frequently reported definition of cystic ovarian disease in cattle is an abnormally persistent follicle (>7 to 10 d) with a diameter >25 mm. Discrimination between luteal and follicular ovarian cystic structures has traditionally been conducted by measuring the rim width of luteal tissue. The most common practice used in the field for diagnosis of cystic ovarian disease is examination by rectal palpation with or without the use of a B-mode ultrasound. Color Doppler ultrasound technology allows assessment of blood flow area measurements in the ovary, which has been proposed as a potential indirect measure for plasma progesterone (P4) concentrations. The objective of this study was to compare the diagnostic accuracy of differentiating luteal structures from follicular ovarian cysts using measures collected with B-mode and color Doppler transrectal ultrasonography. The definition of an ovarian cyst was a follicle greater than 20 mm in diameter in the absence of a corpus luteum that persisted for at least 10 d. A 3-mm luteal rim width was used to differentiate follicular and luteal cysts. A total of 36 cows were enrolled in the study during routine herd reproductive examination visits, with 26 and 10 having follicular and luteal cysts, respectively. Cows enrolled in the study were examined using a Mini-ExaPad mini ultrasound with color Doppler capabilities (IMV Imaging Ltd.). Blood samples were collected from each cow to measure P4 serum concentrations. History and signalment of each cow, including days in milk, lactation, times bred, days since last heat, milk composition, and somatic cell counts, were retrieved from an online database (DairyComp 305, Valley Agricultural Software). The accuracy of diagnosing follicular from luteal cysts based on luteal rim thickness was analyzed by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve using P4 as the gold standard, where P4 concentrations exceeding 1 ng/mL was defined as luteal, and all other structures with less P4 were considered follicular. Luteal rim and blood flow area were selected for further analysis because they presented the best ROC curves for differentiating cystic ovarian structures, with areas under the curve of 0.80 and 0.76, respectively. Luteal rim width of 3 mm was used as the cutoff standard in the study, resulting in sensitivity and specificity of 50% and 86%, respectively. Blood flow area of 0.19 cm2 was used as the cutoff standard in the study, resulting in sensitivity and specificity of 79% and 86%, respectively. When combining the use of luteal rim width and blood flow area to differentiate cystic ovarian structures, a parallel approach resulted in sensitivity and specificity of 73% and 93%, respectively, whereas an in-series approach resulted in sensitivity and specificity of 35% and 100%, respectively. In conclusion, the use of color Doppler ultrasonography when discriminating between luteal and follicular ovarian cysts in dairy cattle resulted in higher diagnostic accuracy compared with using B-mode ultrasonography alone.
