Using breast radiographers' reports as a second opinion for radiologists' readings of microcalcifications in digital mammography.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to investigate a practical method for incorporating radiographers' reports with radiologists' readings of digital mammograms. METHODS: This simulation study was conducted using data from a free-response receiver operating characteristic observer study obtained with 75 cases (25 malignant, 25 benign and 25 normal cases) of digital mammograms. Each of the rating scores obtained by six breast radiographers was utilized as a second opinion for four radiologists' readings with the radiographers' reports. A logical "OR" operation with various criteria settings was simulated for deciding an appropriate method to select a radiographer's report in all combinations of radiologists and radiographers. The average figure of merit (FOM) of the radiologists' performances was statistically analysed using a jackknife procedure (JAFROC) to verify the clinical utility of using radiographers' reports. RESULTS: Potential improvement of the average FOM of the radiologists' performances for identifying malignant microcalcifications could be expected when using radiographers' reports as a second opinion. When the threshold value of 2.6 in Breast Imaging-Reporting and Data System (BI-RADS®) assessment was applied to adopt/reject a radiographer's report, FOMs of radiologists' performances were further improved. CONCLUSION: When using breast radiographers' reports as a second opinion, radiologists' performances potentially improved when reading digital mammograms. It could be anticipated that radiologists' performances were improved further by setting a threshold value on the BI-RADS assessment provided by the radiographers. ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: For the effective use of a radiographer's report as a second opinion, radiographers' rating scores and its criteria setting for adoption/rejection would be necessary.

Validation of a power-law noise model for simulating small-scale breast tissue.

We have validated a small-scale breast tissue model based on power-law noise. A set of 110 patient images served as truth. The statistical model parameters were determined by matching the radially averaged power-spectrum of the projected simulated tissue with that of the central tomosynthesis patient breast projections. Observer performance in a signal-known exactly detection task in simulated and actual breast backgrounds was compared. Observers included human readers, a pre-whitening observer model and a channelized Hotelling observer model. For all observers, good agreement between performance in the simulated and actual backgrounds was found, both in the tomosynthesis central projections and the reconstructed images. This tissue model can be used for breast x-ray imaging system optimization. The complete statistical description of the model is provided.

Automated detection of mass lesions in dedicated breast CT: a preliminary study.

PURPOSE: To develop an automated method to detect breast masses on dedicated breast CT (BCT) volumes and to conduct a preliminary evaluation of its performance. This method can be used in a computer-aided detection (CADe) system for noncontrast enhanced BCT. METHODS: The database included patient images, which were acquired under an IRB-approved protocol. The database in this study consisted of 132 cases. 50 cases contained 58 malignant masses, and 23 cases contained 24 benign masses. 59 cases did not contain any biopsy-proven lesions. Each case consisted of an unenhanced CT volume of a single breast. First, each breast was segmented into adipose and glandular tissues using a fuzzy c-means clustering algorithm. The glandular breast regions were then sampled at a resolution of 2 mm. At each sampling step, a 3.5-cm(3) volume-of-interest was subjected to constrained region segmentation and 17 characteristic features were extracted, yielding 17 corresponding feature volumes. Four features were selected using step-wise feature selection and merged with linear discriminant analysis trained in the task of distinguishing between normal breast glandular regions and masses. Detection performance was measured using free-response receiver operating characteristic analysis (FROC) with leave-one-case-out evaluation. RESULTS: The feature selection stage selected features that characterized the shape and margin strength of the segmented region. CADe sensitivity per case was 84% (std = 4.2%) at 2.6 (std = 0.06) false positives per volume, or 6 × 10(-3) per slice (at an average of 424 slices per volume in this data set). CONCLUSIONS: This preliminary study demonstrates the feasibility of our approach for CADe for BCT.

On the orientation of mammographic structure.

PURPOSE: Burgess et al. have shown that the power-spectral density of mammographic breast tissue P(f) follows a power-law, P(f) = c∕f(ß).(1) Due to the complexity of the breast anatomy, breast phantoms often make use of power-law backgrounds to approximate the irregular texture of breast images. However, the current methodology of estimating power-law coefficients assumes that the breast structure is isotropic. The purpose of this letter is to demonstrate that breast anatomic structure is not isotropic, but in fact has a preferred orientation. Further, we present a formalism to estimate power-law coefficients ß and c while accounting for tissue orientation in mammographic regions-of-interests (ROIs). We then show the effect of structure orientation on ß and c, as well as on the appearance of simulated power-law backgrounds. METHODS: When breast tissue exhibits a preferred orientation, the radial symmetry in the associated power spectrum is broken. The new symmetry was fit by an ellipsoidal model. Ellipse tilt angle and axis ratio were accounted for in the power-law fit. RESULTS: On average, breast structure was found to point toward the nipple: the average orientation in MLO views was 22.5 °, while it was 5 ° for CC views, and the mean orientation for left breasts was negative while it was positive for right breasts. For both power-law magnitude and exponent, the mean difference was statistically significant (<Δß > = -0.096, <Δlog(c) > =-0.192). CONCLUSIONS: A formalism for quantification of breast structure and structure orientation is provided. The difference in power-law coefficient estimates when accounting for orientation was found to be statistically significant. Examples of statistically defined backgrounds indicate that breast structure is mimicked more closely when structure orientation is accounted for.

Task-based assessment of breast tomosynthesis: effect of acquisition parameters and quantum noise.

PURPOSE: Tomosynthesis is a promising modality for breast imaging. The appearance of the tomosynthesis reconstructed image is greatly affected by the choice of acquisition and reconstruction parameters. The purpose of this study was to investigate the limitations of tomosynthesis breast imaging due to scan parameters and quantum noise. Tomosynthesis image quality was assessed based on performance of a mathematical observer model in a signal-known exactly (SKE) detection task. METHODS: SKE detectability (d') was estimated using a prewhitening observer model. Structured breast background was simulated using filtered noise. Detectability was estimated for designer nodules ranging from 0.05 to 0.8 cm in diameter. Tomosynthesis slices were reconstructed using iterative maximum-likelihood expectation-maximization. The tomosynthesis scan angle was varied between 15 degrees and 60 degrees, the number of views between 11 and 41 and the total number of x-ray quanta was infinity, 6 X 10(5), and 6 x 10(4). Detectability in tomosynthesis was compared to that in a single projection. RESULTS: For constant angular sampling distance, increasing the angular scan range increased detectability for all signal sizes. Large-scale signals were little affected by quantum noise or angular sampling. For small-scale signals, quantum noise and insufficient angular sampling degraded detectability. At high quantum noise levels, angular step size of 3 degrees or below was sufficient to avoid image degradation. At lower quantum noise levels, increased angular sampling always resulted in increased detectability. The ratio of detectability in the tomosynthesis slice to that in a single projection exhibited a peak that shifted to larger signal sizes when the angular range increased. For a given angular range, the peak shifted toward smaller signals when the number of views was increased. The ratio was greater than unity for all conditions evaluated. CONCLUSION: The effect of acquisition parameters on lesion detectability depends on signal size. Tomosynthesis scan angle had an effect on detectability for all signals sizes, while quantum noise and angular sampling only affected the detectability small-scale signals.

Scanning translucent glass-ceramic x-ray storage phosphors.

A simple benchtop apparatus has been built, to measure the x-ray imaging properties of fluorozirconate-based glass-ceramic x-ray storage phosphor materials. The MTF degradation due to stimulating light spreading in the plate is lower in comparison to optically turbid screens resulting in higher image MTF. In addition, the degree of transparency, or the amount of light scattering at the wavelength of the stimulating (laser) light is adjustable by means of the glass preparation process. The amount of stimulating exposure required for plate readout is generally higher than in previous systems, but well within the range of commercially available laser systems, for practical readout times. The effects of flare or unwanted readout due to back-reflection from the imaging plate is also less than in previous systems.A novel telecentric scanning system has been developed that is able to rapidly read out the latent image stored in the translucent imaging plates. This system features a reflective primary scan mirror to achieve telecentricity, optical correction for scan line bow, and the design should enable the construction of a relatively inexpensive scanner system for the translucent x-ray storage plates.

Automated detection of microcalcification clusters for digital breast tomosynthesis using projection data only: a preliminary study.

Digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) is a promising modality for breast imaging in which an anisotropic volume image of the breast is obtained. We present an algorithm for computerized detection of microcalcification clusters (MCCs) for DBT. This algorithm operates on the projection views only. Therefore it does not depend on reconstruction, and is computationally efficient. The algorithm was developed using a database of 30 image sets with microcalcifications, and a control group of 30 image sets without visible findings. The patient data were acquired on the first DBT prototype at Massachusetts General Hospital. Algorithm sensitivity was estimated to be 0.86 at 1.3 false positive clusters, which is below that of current MCC detection algorithms for full-field digital mammography. Because of the small number of patient cases, algorithm parameters were not optimized and one linear classifier was used. An actual limitation of our approach may be that the signal-to-noise ratio in the projection images is too low for microcalcification detection. Furthermore, the database consisted of predominantly small MCC. This may be related to the image quality obtained with this first prototype.

Computerized mass detection for digital breast tomosynthesis directly from the projection images.

Digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) has recently emerged as a new and promising three-dimensional modality in breast imaging. In DBT, the breast volume is reconstructed from 11 projection images, taken at source angles equally spaced over an arc of 50 degrees. Reconstruction algorithms for this modality are not fully optimized yet. Because computerized lesion detection in the reconstructed breast volume will be affected by the reconstruction technique, we are developing a novel mass detection algorithm that operates instead on the set of raw projection images. Mass detection is done in three stages. First, lesion candidates are obtained for each projection image separately, using a mass detection algorithm that was initially developed for screen-film mammography. Second, the locations of a lesion candidate are backprojected into the breast volume. In this feature volume, voxel intensities are a combined measure of detection frequency (e.g., the number of projections in which a given lesion candidate was detected), and a measure of the angular range over which a given lesion was detected. Third, features are extracted after reprojecting the three-dimensional (3-D) locations of lesion candidates into projection images. Features are combined using linear discriminant analysis. The database used to test the algorithm consisted of 21 mass cases (13 malignant, 8 benign) and 15 cases without mass lesions. Based on this database, the algorithm yielded a sensitivity of 90% at 1.5 false positives per breast volume. Algorithm performance is positively biased because this dataset was used for development, training, and testing, and because the number of algorithm parameters was approximately the same as the number.of patient cases. Our results indicate that computerized mass detection in the sequence of projection images for DBT may be effective despite the higher noise level in those images.

Computerized detection of mass lesions in digital breast tomosynthesis images using two- and three dimensional radial gradient index segmentation.

Initial results for a computerized mass lesion detection scheme for digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) images are presented. The algorithm uses a radial gradient index feature for the initial lesion detection and for segmentation of lesion candidates. A set of features is extracted for each segmented partition. Performance of two- and three dimensional features was compared. For gradient features, the additional dimension provided no improvement in classification performance. For shape features, classification using 3D features was improved compared to the 2D equivalent features. The preliminary overall performance was 76% sensitivity at 11 false positives per exam, estimated based on DBT image data of 21 masses. A larger database will allow for further development and improvement in our computer aided detection scheme.

Dependence of computer classification of clustered microcalcifications on the correct detection of microcalcifications.

Our purpose was to study the dependence of computer performance in classifying clustered microcalcifications as malignant or benign on the correct detection of microcalcifications. Specifically, we studied the effects of computer-detected true-positive microcalcifications and computer-detected false-positive microcalcifications in true microcalcification clusters. Using a database of 100 mammograms, we compared computer classification performance obtained from computer-detected microcalcifications to (1) computer classification performance obtained from manually identified microcalcifications, and (2) radiologists' performance. When an artificial neural network (ANN) was trained with manually identified microcalcifications, computer classification performance was comparable to or better than radiologists' performance as the number of computer-detected true-positive microcalcifications decreased to 40% and as the number of computer-detected false-positive microcalcifications increased to 50%. Further loss in computer-detected true-positive microcalcifications degraded classification performance substantially. Moreover, training the ANN with computer-detected microcalcifications also degraded computer classification performance. These results show that computer performance in classifying clustered microcalcifications as malignant or benign is insensitive to moderate decreases in computer-detected true-positive microcalcifications and moderate increases in computer-detected false-positive microcalcifications.

Potential of computer-aided diagnosis to reduce variability in radiologists' interpretations of mammograms depicting microcalcifications.

PURPOSE: To evaluate whether computer-aided diagnosis can reduce interobserver variability in the interpretation of mammograms. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Ten radiologists interpreted mammograms showing clustered microcalcifications in 104 patients. Decisions for biopsy or follow-up were made with and without a computer aid, and these decisions were compared. The computer was used to estimate the likelihood that a microcalcification cluster was due to a malignancy. Variability in the radiologists' recommendations for biopsy versus follow-up was then analyzed. RESULTS: Variation in the radiologists' accuracy, as measured with the SD of the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve, was reduced by 46% with computer aid. Access to the computer aid increased the agreement among all observers from 13% to 32% of the total cases (P <.001), while the kappa value increased from 0.19 to 0.41 (P <.05). Use of computer aid eliminated two-thirds of the substantial disagreements in which two radiologists recommended biopsy and routine screening in the same patient (P <.05). CONCLUSION: In addition to its demonstrated potential to improve diagnostic accuracy, computer-aided diagnosis has the potential to reduce the variability among radiologists in the interpretation of mammograms.

Computer-aided detection and diagnosis of breast cancer.

The limitations of radiologists when interpreting mammogram examinations provides a reasonable, if not compelling, basis for application of computer techniques that have the potential to improve diagnostic performance. Computer algorithms, at their present state of development, show great promise for clinical use. It can be expected that such use will only improve as computer technology and computer methods continue to become more formidable. The eventual role of computers in mammographic detection and diagnosis has not been fully defined, but their effect on practice may one day be very significant.

Radiologists' preferences for digital mammographic display. The International Digital Mammography Development Group.

PURPOSE: To determine the preferences of radiologists among eight different image processing algorithms applied to digital mammograms obtained for screening and diagnostic imaging tasks. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty-eight images representing histologically proved masses or calcifications were obtained by using three clinically available digital mammographic units. Images were processed and printed on film by using manual intensity windowing, histogram-based intensity windowing, mixture model intensity windowing, peripheral equalization, multiscale image contrast amplification (MUSICA), contrast-limited adaptive histogram equalization, Trex processing, and unsharp masking. Twelve radiologists compared the processed digital images with screen-film mammograms obtained in the same patient for breast cancer screening and breast lesion diagnosis. RESULTS: For the screening task, screen-film mammograms were preferred to all digital presentations, but the acceptability of images processed with Trex and MUSICA algorithms were not significantly different. All printed digital images were preferred to screen-film radiographs in the diagnosis of masses; mammograms processed with unsharp masking were significantly preferred. For the diagnosis of calcifications, no processed digital mammogram was preferred to screen-film mammograms. CONCLUSION: When digital mammograms were preferred to screen-film mammograms, radiologists selected different digital processing algorithms for each of three mammographic reading tasks and for different lesion types. Soft-copy display will eventually allow radiologists to select among these options more easily.

Computer-aided diagnosis in radiology: potential and pitfalls.

Computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) may be defined as a diagnosis made by a physician who takes into account the computer output as a second opinion. The purpose of CAD is to improve the diagnostic accuracy and the consistency of the radiologists' image interpretation. This article is to provide a brief overview of some of CAD schemes for detection and differential diagnosis of pulmonary nodules and interstitial opacities in chest radiographs as well as clustered micro-calcifications and masses in mammograms. ROC analysis clearly indicated that the radiologists' performances were significantly improved when the computer output was available. An intelligent CAD workstation was developed for detection of breast lesions in mammograms. Results obtained from the first 10,000 cases indicated the potential of CAD in detecting approximately one-half of 'missed' breast cancer.

Improving breast cancer diagnosis with computer-aided diagnosis.

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to test whether computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) can improve radiologists' performance in breast cancer diagnosis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The computer classification scheme used in this study estimates the likelihood of malignancy for clustered microcalcifications based on eight computer-extracted features obtained from standard-view mammograms. One hundred four histologically verified cases of microcalcifications (46 malignant, 58 benign) in a near-consecutive biopsy series were used in this study. Observer performance was measured on 10 radiologists who read the original standard- and magnification-view mammograms. The computer aid provided a percentage estimate of the likelihood of malignancy. Comparison was made between computer-aided performance and unaided (routine clinical) performance by using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis and by comparing biopsy recommendations. RESULTS: The average ROC curve area (Az) increased from 0.61 without aid to 0.75 with the computer aid (P < .0001). On average, with the computer aid, each observer recommended 6.4 additional biopsies for cases with malignant lesions (P = .0006) and 6.0 fewer biopsies for cases with benign lesions (P = .003). This improvement corresponded to increases in sensitivity (from 73.5% to 87.4%), specificity (from 31.6% to 41.9%), and hypothetical positive biopsy yield (from 46% to 55%). CONCLUSION: CAD can be used to improve radiologists' performance in breast cancer diagnosis.

A genetic algorithm-based method for optimizing the performance of a computer-aided diagnosis scheme for detection of clustered microcalcifications in mammograms.

Computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) schemes have the potential of substantially increasing diagnostic accuracy in mammography by providing the advantages of having a second reader. Our laboratory has developed a CAD scheme for detecting clustered microcalcifications in digital mammograms that is being tested clinically at the University of Chicago Hospitals. Our CAD scheme contains a large number of parameters such as filter weights, threshold levels, and region of interest (ROI) sizes. The choice of these parameter values determines the overall performance of the system and thus must be carefully set. Unfortunately, when the number of parameters becomes large, it is very difficult to obtain the optimal performance, especially when the values of the parameters are correlated with each other. In this study, we address the problem of identifying the optimal overall performance by developing an automated method for the determination of the parameter values that maximize the performance of a mammographic CAD scheme. Our method utilizes a genetic algorithm to search through the possible parameter values, and provides the set of parameters that minimize a cost function which measures the performance of the scheme. Using a database of 89 digitized mammograms, our method demonstrated that the sensitivity of our CAD scheme can be increased from 80% to 87% at a false positive rate of 1.0 per image. We estimate the average performance of our CAD scheme on unknown cases by performing jackknife tests; this was previously not feasible when the parameters of the CAD scheme were determined in a nonautomated manner.

Analysis of methods for reducing false positives in the automated detection of clustered microcalcifications in mammograms.

Clustered microcalcifications are often the first sign of breast cancer in a mammogram. Nevertheless, all clustered microcalcifications are not found by an individual radiologist reading a mammogram. The use of a second reader may find those clusters of microcalcifications not found by the first reader, thereby improving the sensitivity of detecting clustered microcalcifications. Our laboratory has developed a computerized scheme for the detection of clustered microcalcifications, which can act like a second reader, that is undergoing clinical evaluation. This paper concerns the feature analysis stage of the computer scheme, which is designed to remove some of the false-computer detections. We have examined three methods of feature analysis, namely, rule based (the method currently used), an artificial neural network (ANN), and a combined method. In an independent database of 50 images, at a sensitivity of 83%, the average number of false positive (FP) detections per image was: 1.9 for rule-based, 1.6 for ANN, and 0.8 for the combined method. We demonstrate that the combined method performs best because each of the two stages eliminates different types of false positives.

Optimally weighted wavelet transform based on supervised training for detection of microcalcifications in digital mammograms.

We are developing a computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) scheme for detection of clustered microcalcifications in digital mammograms. The use of an empirically chosen wavelet and scale combination for detection of microcalcifications as an initial step of the CAD scheme has been reported by us previously. In this study, we developed a technique for optimizing the weights at individual scales in the wavelet transform to improve the performance of our CAD scheme based on the supervised learning method. In the learning process, an error function was formulated to represent the difference between a desired output and the reconstructed image obtained from weighted wavelet coefficients for a given mammogram. The error function was then minimized by modifying the weights for wavelet coefficients by means of a conjugate gradient algorithm. The Least Asymmetric Daubechies' wavelets were optimized with 297 regions of interest (ROIs) as a training set by a jackknife method. The performance of the optimally weighted wavelets was evaluated by means of receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) analysis by use of the above set of ROIs. The analysis yielded an average area under the ROC curve of 0.92, which outperforms the difference-image technique used in our existing CAD scheme, as well as the partial reconstruction method used in our previous study.

Optimization and FROC analysis of rule-based detection schemes using a multiobjective approach.

Computerized detection schemes have the potential of increasing diagnostic accuracy in medical imaging by alerting radiologists to lesions that they initially overlooked. These schemes typically employ multiple parameters such as threshold values or filter weights to arrive at a detection decision. In order for the system to have high performance, the values of these parameters need to be set optimally. Conventional optimization techniques are designed to optimize a scalar objective function. The task of optimizing the performance of a computerized detection scheme, however, is clearly a multiobjective problem: we wish to simultaneously improve the sensitivity and false-positive rate of the system. In this work we investigate a multiobjective approach to optimizing computerized rule-based detection schemes. In a multiobjective optimization, multiple objectives are simultaneously optimized, with the objective now being a vector-valued function. The multiobjective optimization problem admits a set of solutions, known as the Pareto-optimal set, which are equivalent in the absence of any information regarding the preferences of the objectives. The performances of the Pareto-optimal solutions can be interpreted as operating points on an optimal free-response receiver operating characteristic (FROC) curve, greater than or equal to the points on any possible FROC curve for a given dataset and detection scheme. It is demonstrated that generating FROC curves in this manner eliminates several known problems with conventional FROC curve generation techniques for rule-based detection schemes. We employ the multiobjective approach to optimize a rule-based scheme for clustered microcalcification detection that has been developed in our laboratory.