The cost-effectiveness of IVF in the UK: a comparison of three gonadotrophin treatments.

BACKGROUND: The objective of this study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of women undergoing IVF treatment with recombinant FSH (rFSH) in comparison with highly purified urinary FSH (uFSH-HP) and human menopausal gonadotrophins (HMG). METHODS: A decision-analytic model was used to estimate cost-effectiveness ratios for 'the average cost per ongoing pregnancy' and 'incremental cost per additional pregnancy' for women entering into IVF treatment for a maximum of three cycles. The model was constructed based on a previously published large prospective randomized clinical trial comparing rFSH and uFSH-HP. Where necessary, these data were augmented with a combination of expert opinion, evidence from the literature and observational data relating to the management and cost of IVF treatment in the UK. The cost of rFSH, uFSH-HP and HMG were obtained from National Health Service list prices in the UK. RESULTS: The model predicted a cumulative pregnancy rate after three cycles of 57.1% for rFSH and 44.4% for both uFSH-HP and HMG. The cost of IVF treatment was 5135 pounds sterling for rFSH, 4806 pounds sterling for uFSH-HP and 4202 pounds sterling for HMG. When assessed in association with outcomes, the average cost per ongoing pregnancy was more favourable with rFSH (8992 pounds sterling) than with either uFSH-HP (10 834 pounds sterling) or HMG (9472 pounds sterling). The incremental cost per additional pregnancy was 2583 pounds sterling using rFSH instead of uFSH-HP and 7321 pounds sterling using rFSH instead of HMG. These results were robust to changes in the baseline assumptions of the model. CONCLUSION: rFSH is a cost-effective treatment strategy in ovulation induction prior to IVF.

A randomized, double-blind clinical trial using fixed daily doses of 100 or 200 IU of recombinant FSH in ICSI cycles.

The effect of 100 and 200 IU per day recombinant FSH (rFSH) on numbers of oocytes retrieved and the total dose used in ovarian stimulation before intracytoplasmic sperm injection was investigated in a double-blind, randomized multicentre trial. A total of 91 women was treated with a low-dose protocol and 88 with a high-dose regimen at five centres. For each started cycle, significantly more oocytes were retrieved in the 200 IU group than in 100 IU group (12.0 versus 5.7, P < 0.001); total rFSH consumption was 1121 and 1875 IU in the low- and high-dose groups respectively. Significant variations were noted between centres with regard to numbers of oocytes collected per started cycle, ranging from 2.8 to 7.2 in the 100 IU group and from 9.0 to 19.1 in the high-dose group. Exploratory analyses of secondary outcomes suggested there were no differences in vital pregnancy rates per started cycle (19.2 versus 16.9%) and per embryo transfer (26.2 versus 19.3%) in the low- and high dose groups respectively. There were four hospitalizations due to ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome, all in the 200 IU group.

Increasing the daily dose of recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (Puregon) does not compensate for the age-related decline in retrievable oocytes after ovarian stimulation.

A prospective, randomized, double-blind, multicentre (n = 6) study was conducted to compare the influence of either a 150 or 250 IU daily fixed-dose regimen of recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (FSH, Puregon) on the number of oocytes retrieved and the total dose used in down-regulated women between 30 and 39 years of age undergoing ovarian stimulation. In all, 138 women were treated with recombinant FSH, 67 with 150 IU and 71 with 250 IU. The number of oocytes retrieved in the low-dose group was 9.1 compared to 10.6 in the high-dose group (not significant). In the 30-33 years of age class receiving the 250 IU dose, a surplus of 4.2 oocytes (14.8 versus 10.6) was found, whereas in the 37-39 age class nearly one oocyte more was retrieved in the 150 IU group (8.1 versus 7.4). The total dose used to reach the criterion for human chorionic gonadotrophin (HCG) administration was 1727 IU for the women treated with 150 IU daily and 2701 IU for the 250 IU treated women (P < 0. 001). No significant relationships were found between serum FSH concentrations as obtained in the early follicular phase and the number of oocytes collected, or the total dose. It is concluded that in women between 30 and 39 years of age, the decline in number of oocytes retrieved with increasing age cannot be overcome by augmenting the daily dose of recombinant FSH from 150 to 250 IU.

A prospective, randomized, double-blind clinical trial to study the efficacy and efficiency of a fixed dose of recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (Puregon) in women undergoing ovarian stimulation.

A prospective, randomized, double-blind, multicentre (n = 5) study was conducted to compare the influence of either a 100 or 200 IU daily fixed-dose regimen of recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) on the number of oocytes retrieved and the total dose used in down-regulated women undergoing ovarian stimulation. Fertilization was done by intracytoplasmic sperm injection or conventional in-vitro fertilization. A total of 199 women were treated with FSH, 101 subjects with 100 IU and 98 subjects with 200 IU. In subjects of the 200 IU treatment group, significantly more oocytes were retrieved compared to the 100 IU group (10.6 versus 6.2 oocytes, P < 0.001). The total dose needed to develop at least three follicles with a diameter of > or = 17 mm was significantly lower in the 100 IU treatment group (1114 IU versus 1931 IU, P < 0.001). In the low-dose group, significantly lower serum concentrations of oestradiol, progesterone and FSH were observed at the day of human chorionic gonadotrophin administration. Although more cycle cancellations due to low response were seen in the 100 IU group (n = 24 versus n = 3), the clinical pregnancy rate per started cycle was similar (24.7% in the 100 IU group versus 23.3% in the 200 IU group). In the high-dose group, more side-effects, in particular more cases of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome, were noted. It is concluded that compared to 200 IU, the use of a 100 IU fixed dose is less efficacious in terms of the number of oocytes retrieved, but more efficient as indicated by a lower total dose.

A prospective randomized clinical trial comparing recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (Puregon) and human menopausal gonadotrophins (Humegon) in non-down-regulated in-vitro fertilization patients.

A randomized clinical trial was performed comparing recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (rFSH, Puregon, n = 54) and human menopausal gonadotrophin (HMG, Humegon, n = 35) in infertile women undergoing in-vitro fertilization without the use of a gonadotrophin-releasing hormone (GnRH) agonist. Most patients had a tubal or idiopathic infertility, the latter always longer than 4 years' duration. Patients with sperm abnormalities were excluded. None of the between-group differences in treatment outcome was statistically significant. In the rFSH group, a mean number of 11.2 oocytes was retrieved compared with 8.3 in the HMG group. Ongoing pregnancy rates per started cycle were higher in the rFSH group (22.2%) than in the HMG group (17.1%). Implantation rates were 27.5% in the rFSH group in comparison with 16.7% in the HMG group. In the rFSH group, a mean total dose of 1410 IU during 6.2 days was administered compared with 1365 IU in 6.0 days in the HMG group. Oestradiol concentrations on the day of human chorionic gonadotrophin administration were 3889 pmol/l in the rFSH group and 3145 pmol/l in the HMG group. In 15 subjects (rFSH: n = 9, 16.7%; HMG: n = 6, 17.1%) luteinizing hormone concentrations higher than 10 IU/l were seen during stimulation. In two of them, both from the rFSH group, ongoing pregnancies were achieved. The results indicate that rFSH (Puregon) is at least as efficacious as HMG and that acceptable pregnancy rates can be achieved without the use of a GnRH agonist.

Recombinant follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH; Puregon) is more efficient than urinary FSH (Metrodin) in women with clomiphene citrate-resistant, normogonadotropic, chronic anovulation: a prospective, multicenter, assessor-blind, randomized, clinical trial. European Puregon Collaborative Anovulation Study Group.

OBJECTIVE: To compare the safety and efficacy of recombinant FSH (follitropin beta, Puregon; NV Organon, Oss, the Netherlands) and urinary FSH (urofollitropin, Metrodin; Ares-Serono, Geneva, Switzerland). DESIGN: A prospective, multicenter, assessor-blind, randomized, clinical trial. SETTING: Twelve European infertility clinics. PATIENT(S): One hundred seventy-two women (recombinant FSH: n = 105; urinary FSH: n = 67) with clomiphene citrate-resistant normogonadotropic chronic anovulation (World Health Organization group II). INTERVENTION(S): Eligible subjects were randomized (ratio of recombinant to urinary FSH, 3:2) and treated for a maximum of three cycles. A low-dose step-up regimen was used, with 75 IU of FSH given IM daily for a maximum of 14 days and, if needed, weekly increments of half an ampule given thereafter until the threshold dose for follicular development was achieved. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): Cumulative ovulation rate after three cycles, total FSH dose, and treatment period needed to achieve ovulation. RESULT(S): The cumulative ovulation rates after three treatment cycles were 95% and 96% for the recombinant and urinary FSH groups, respectively. Overall, ovulation was seen in 155 of 223 treatment cycles (69.5%) in the recombinant FSH group, compared with 92 of 138 treatment cycles (66.7%) in the urinary FSH group. In the first cycle, a statistically significantly lower total dose (750 versus 1,035 IU) and a shorter treatment period (10 versus 13 days) were needed in the recombinant FSH group to reach ovulation. Only one case of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome led to hospitalization. Two sets of twins (one in each treatment group) and one set of triplets (in the recombinant FSH group) were born. CONCLUSION(S): Recombinant FSH (Puregon) is more efficient than urinary FSH (Metrodin) in inducing follicular development.

Recombinant follicle-stimulating hormone (follitropin beta, Puregon) yields higher pregnancy rates in in vitro fertilization than urinary gonadotropins.

OBJECTIVE: To assess ongoing pregnancy rates (PRs) in IVF after treatment with recombinant FSH (follitropin beta, Puregon; NV Organon, Oss, The Netherlands) as compared with urinary gonadotropins. DESIGN: A combined analysis of three prospective, multicenter, randomized, comparative trials. SETTING: Twenty-five IVF centers in 13 countries. PATIENT(S): Six hundred ninety-seven infertile women receiving recombinant FSH and 463 women receiving hMG or urinary FSH and undergoing one cycle of controlled ovarian hyperstimulation and IVF-ET. INTERVENTION(S): A center-based and study-based analysis weighing the treatment differences in individual centers and studies, respectively. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES(S): Pregnancy rate at least 12 weeks after ET per started cycle. RESULTS(S): In the center-based analysis, the ongoing PR was 22.9% for recombinant FSH and 17.9% for urinary gonadotropins. The 5.0% treatment difference (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.2% to 9.7%) was significant. When the results of the cryoprogram were included, the treatment difference increased to 6.4% (95% CI, 1.4% to 11.3%). Also in the study-based analysis, significantly higher PRs were seen after follitropin beta treatment. CONCLUSION(S): Follitropin beta (Puregon) used for controlled ovarian hyperstimulation in IVF yields significantly higher PRs compared with urinary gonadotropins.

Cryopreservation: the practicalities of evaluation.

An attempt was made to integrate data from cryopreserved embryos with those from fresh embryos to obtain a realistic assessment of the role of cryopreservation in assisted reproductive treatment. Principles were applied to previously published data from a large prospective randomized multicentre study comprising recombinant and urinary follicle stimulating hormone in in-vitro fertilization.

A prospective, randomized study to assess the tolerance and efficacy of intramuscular and subcutaneous administration of recombinant follicle-stimulating hormone (Puregon).

OBJECTIVE: To compare local tolerance and clinical efficacy after i.m. or s.c. injection of recombinant FSH (Puregon; NV Organon, Oss, The Netherlands). DESIGN: An open-label, prospective, randomized, group-comparative, multicenter study. SETTING: Twelve IVF clinics in 10 countries. PATIENT(S): Two hundred eighteen infertile pituitary-suppressed women undergoing IVF-ET were randomized, of whom 195 (i.m., n = 77; s.c., n = 118) received recombinant FSH. INTERVENTION(S): One cycle of controlled ovarian hyperstimulation induced by either i.m. or s.c. injection of recombinant FSH, followed by IVF-ET. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): Local tolerance symptoms, number of oocytes retrieved, ongoing pregnancy rate. RESULT(S): The incidences after i.m. injection of bruising, pain, redness, swelling, and itching were 37.7%, 31.2%, 13.0%, 7.8%, and 6.5%; after s.c. injection, the corresponding figures were 54.2%, 28.0%, 16.1%, 5.9%, and 3.4%. Only bruising was significantly lower in the i.m. group, which could be attributed to the more visible superficial injection site with s.c. administration. The overall occurrence of local symptoms were 63.6% after i.m. injection and 68.6% after s.c. injection. The mean numbers of oocytes recovered were 9.8 (i.m) and 10.4 (s.c.) and the ongoing pregnancy rates per attempt were 27.1% (i.m.) and 26.1% (s.c.), respectively. CONCLUSION(S): There were no marked differences in local tolerance symptoms and clinical efficacy between i.m. and s.c. administration of recombinant FSH.

Pharmacodynamics and pharmacokinetics after repeated subcutaneous administration of three gonadotrophin preparations.

Recently, several new urinary gonadotrophin preparations have been developed, containing less luteinizing hormone (LH) activity than human menopausal gonadotrophin. Normegon is a gonadotrophin preparation with a follicle stimulating hormone (FSH)/LH ratio of 3:1; Follegon and Metrodin-HP are purified FSH preparations. The aim of the present randomized study was to compare pharmaco-dynamics, -kinetics and local tolerance of these preparations after repeated s.c. administration. Thirty-six healthy female subjects were treated with Lyndiol contraceptive pills for 5 weeks to suppress endogenous gonadotrophin concentrations. After 3 weeks of Lyndiol treatment, 150 IU of Normegon, Follegon or Metrodin HP were administered once daily, s.c. for 7 days. Blood samples were collected once daily during the fourth and fifth weeks of the study and assayed for FSH and oestradiol. After the last gonadotrophin injection, blood samples were collected more frequently to determine pharmacokinetic parameters of FSH. During the fourth and fifth study weeks, daily ultrasound measurements of follicular growth were performed. Endogenous FSH and LH values were extremely suppressed during Lyndiol treatment. Serum FSH values showed similar patterns in the three groups. The maximum FSH concentration was reached 9-11 h post-injection, the terminal half-life was 43-47 h. The preparations were bioequivalent with respect to FSH immunoreactivity. The number of follicles tended to be larger after Normegon than after Follegon and Metrodin HP treatment, though this was not statistically significant. Serum oestradiol concentrations were significantly higher after Normegon treatment. In general, s.c injections were well tolerated. In conclusion, the three preparations were bioequivalent with respect to FSH immunoreactivity. Nevertheless, the biological activity of Normegon tended to be higher than that of Follegon and Metrodin HP in Lyndiol-suppressed women.

Clinical profiling of recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (rFSH; Puregon): relationship between serum FSH and efficacy.

Single-dose and multiple-rising dose studies of recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (rFSH) in hypogonadotrophic male and female volunteers demonstrated that the rate of FSH absorption after i.m. injection is higher in men than in women. In the absence of endogenous FSH, a correlation between serum FSH and body weight became apparent. The elimination half-life of rFSH was not different between the sexes and was comparable with urinary FSH. However, the in-vitro bio:immuno ratio of serum FSH was significantly higher after the administration of rFSH than after urinary FSH. When rFSH was administered daily with a fixed dose, steady state levels were reached within 3-5 days. Serum FSH concentrations increased in a dose-dependent manner when the daily dose was increased weekly over 3 weeks from 75 to 225 IU. In hypogonadotrophic women, rFSH induced normal follicular growth whereas oestrogen synthesis was impaired. In women pituitary suppressed by a high-dose oral contraceptive, the daily administration of 150 IU rFSH for 1 week induced more and larger antral follicles than the same regimen with urinary FSH, whereas the serum immunoactive FSH concentrations measured 24 h after each dosing were similar. It is concluded that even though equal or lower serum immunoactive FSH concentrations were obtained following the administration of rFSH compared with urinary FSH, circulating bioactive FSH concentrations were higher. Therefore, the conventional idea that serum immunoreactive FSH correlates positively with the magnitude of the ovarian response should be reconsidered.

Recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (rFSH; Puregon) in assisted reproduction: more oocytes, more pregnancies. Results from five comparative studies.

The clinical assessment of recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (rFSH; Puregon) in assisted reproduction technologies such as in-vitro fertilization (IVF) has probably been the most extensive clinical trial programme ever performed for the evaluation of a new fertility drug. It started with a pilot study to evaluate the potential of rFSH to stimulate the ovaries in the absence of luteinizing hormone (LH) using various gonadotrophin-releasing hormone (GnRH) agonists. After it became clear that FSH-induced steroidogenesis was not jeopardized even after severe pituitary suppression, comparisons between rFSH and urinary FSH or human menopausal gonadotrophins were made using different GnRH agonists or no agonists at all. In addition, the effects of the route of administration (s.c. or i.m.) were assessed. The study with the strongest statistical power to truly assess clinically relevant differences between rFSH and urinary FSH included approximately 1000 patient cycles. It indicated that after rFSH treatment, significantly more oocytes were retrieved, more embryos obtained and, as a result, more pregnancies achieved when the results of the cryoprogramme were included.

A bioequivalence study of two urinary follicle stimulating hormone preparations: Follegon and Metrodin.

The purpose of this study was to demonstrate bioequivalence between two follicle stimulating hormone (FSH)-only gonadotrophin preparations (Follegon(R) and Metrodin(R)) after a single i.m. injection of IU FSH in-vivo bioactivity. A total of 16 healthy normally cycling females were treated for 7 weeks with a high-dose oral contraceptive containing 50 microg ethinyl oestradiol plus 2.5 mg lynestrenol (Lyndiol(R)) to suppress endogenous gonadotrophin production. After 3 and 5 weeks or oral contraceptive treatment, each subject received 300 IU Follegon or Metrodin in a random order. Frequent blood sampling was performed to measure immunoreactive FSH for pharmacokinetic analysis. After normalization for the immunodose administered, Follegon and Metrodin were bioequivalent with respect to the extent and the rate of absorption, the elimination half-life and plasma clearance per kg. The time taken to reach peak plasma FSH concentrations was shorter with Follegon than with Metrodin. Because bioequivalence was proved for the major pharmacokinetic variables, it can be assumed that Follegon and Metrodin are also equally effective inovulation induction, in-vitro fertilization and embryo transfer programmes and the treatment of male infertility.