Dual-Frequency, Ratiometric Approaches to EAB Sensor Interrogation Support the Calibration-Free Measurement of Specific Molecules In Vivo.

Electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors represent the first molecular measurement technology that is both (1) independent of the chemical reactivity of the target, and thus generalizable to many targets and (2) able to function in an accurate, drift-corrected manner in situ in the living body. Signaling in EAB sensors is generated when an electrode-bound aptamer binds to its target ligand, altering the rate of electron transfer from an attached redox reporter and producing an easily detectable change in peak current when the sensor is interrogated using square wave voltammetry. Due to differences in the microscopic surface area of the interrogating electrodes, the baseline peak currents obtained from EAB sensors, however, can be highly variable. To overcome this, we have historically performed single-point calibration using measurements performed in a single sample of known target concentration. Here, however, we explore approaches to EAB sensor operation that negate the need to perform even single-point calibration of individual sensors. These are a ratiometric approach employing the ratio of the peak currents observed at two distinct square wave frequencies, and a kinetic differential measurement approach that employs the difference between peak currents seen at the two frequencies. Using in vivo measurements of vancomycin and phenylalanine as our test bed, we compared the output of these methods with that of the same sensor when single-point calibration was employed. Doing so we find that both methods support accurately drift-corrected measurements in vivo in live rats, even when employing rather crudely handmade devices. By removing the need to calibrate each individual sensor in a sample of known target concentration, these interrogation methods should significantly simplify the use of EAB sensors for in vivo applications.

Codeposition Enhances the Performance of Electrochemical Aptamer-Based Sensors.

Electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors, a minimally invasive means of performing high-frequency, real-time measurement of drugs and biomarkers in situ in the body, have traditionally been fabricated by depositing their target-recognizing aptamer onto an interrogating gold electrode using a "sequential" two-step method involving deposition of the thiol-modified oligonucleotide (typically for 1 h) followed by incubation in mercaptohexanol solution (typically overnight) to complete the formation of a stable, self-assembled monolayer. Here we use EAB sensors targeting vancomycin, tryptophan, and phenylalanine to show that "codeposition", a less commonly employed EAB fabrication method in which the thiol-modified aptamer and the mercaptohexanol diluent are deposited on the electrode simultaneously and for as little as 1 h, improves the signal gain (relative change in signal upon the addition of high concentrations of the target) of the vancomycin and tryptophan sensors without significantly reducing their stability. In contrast, the gain of the phenylalanine sensor is effectively identical irrespective of the fabrication approach employed. This sensor, however, appears to employ binding-induced displacement of the redox reporter rather than binding-induced folding as its signal transduction mechanism, suggesting in turn a mechanism for the improvement observed for the other two sensors. Codeposition thus not only provides a more convenient means of fabricating EAB sensors but also can improve their performance.

The Use of Xenonucleic Acids Significantly Reduces the In Vivo Drift of Electrochemical Aptamer-Based Sensors.

Electrochemical aptamer-based sensors support the high-frequency, real-time monitoring of molecules-of-interest in vivo. Achieving this requires methods for correcting the sensor drift seen during in vivo placements. While this correction ensures EAB sensor measurements remain accurate, as drift progresses it reduces the signal-to-noise ratio and precision. Here, we show that enzymatic cleavage of the sensor's target-recognizing DNA aptamer is a major source of this signal loss. To demonstrate this, we deployed a tobramycin-detecting EAB sensor analog fabricated with the DNase-resistant "xenonucleic acid" 2'O-methyl-RNA in a live rat. In contrast to the sensor employing the equivalent DNA aptamer, the 2'O-methyl-RNA aptamer sensor lost very little signal and had improved signal-to-noise. We further characterized the EAB sensor drift using unstructured DNA or 2'O-methyl-RNA oligonucleotides. While the two devices drift similarly in vitro in whole blood, the in vivo drift of the 2'O-methyl-RNA-employing device is less compared to the DNA-employing device. Studies of the electron transfer kinetics suggested that the greater drift of the latter sensor arises due to enzymatic DNA degradation. These findings, coupled with advances in the selection of aptamers employing XNA, suggest a means of improving EAB sensor stability when they are used to perform molecular monitoring in the living body.

High-Affinity Aptamers for In Vitro and In Vivo Cocaine Sensing.

The ability to quantify cocaine in biological fluids is crucial for both the diagnosis of intoxication and overdose in the clinic as well as investigation of the drug's pharmacological and toxicological effects in the laboratory. To this end, we have performed high-stringency in vitro selection to generate DNA aptamers that bind cocaine with nanomolar affinity and clinically relevant specificity, thus representing a dramatic improvement over the current-generation, micromolar-affinity, low-specificity cocaine aptamers. Using these novel aptamers, we then developed two sensors for cocaine detection. The first, an in vitro fluorescent sensor, successfully detects cocaine at clinically relevant levels in 50% human serum without responding significantly to other drugs of abuse, endogenous substances, or a diverse range of therapeutic agents. The second, an electrochemical aptamer-based sensor, supports the real-time, seconds-resolved measurement of cocaine concentrations in vivo in the circulation of live animals. We believe the aptamers and sensors developed here could prove valuable for both point-of-care and on-site clinical cocaine detection as well as fundamental studies of cocaine neuropharmacology.

Implantable Hydrogel-Protective DNA Aptamer-Based Sensor Supports Accurate, Continuous Electrochemical Analysis of Drugs at Multiple Sites in Living Rats.

The ability to track the levels of specific molecules, such as drugs, metabolites, and biomarkers, in the living body, in real time and for long durations, would improve our understanding of health and our ability to diagnose, treat, and monitor disease. To this end, we are developing electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) biosensors, a general platform supporting high-frequency, real-time molecular measurements in the living body. Here we report that the use of an agarose hydrogel protective layer for EAB sensors significantly improves their signaling stability when deployed in the complex, highly time-varying environments found in vivo. The improved stability is sufficient that these hydrogel-protected sensors achieved good baseline stability and precision when deployed in situ in the veins, muscles, bladder, or tumors of living rats without the use of the drift correction approaches traditionally required in such placements. Finally, our implantable gel-protective EAB sensors achieved good biocompatibility when deployed in vivo in the living rats without causing any severe inflammation.

Precise Electrochemical Sizing of Individual Electro-Inactive Particles.

Nanoimpact electrochemistry enables the time-resolved in situ characterization (e.g., size, catalytic activity) of single nanomaterial units, providing a means of elucidating heterogeneities that would be masked in ensemble studies. To implement this technique with redox inactive particles, a solution-phase redox reaction is used to produce a steady-state background current on a disk ultramicroelectrode. When a particle adsorbs onto the electrode, it produces a stepwise reduction in the exposed electrode area, which produces, in turn, a stepwise decrease in the current commensurate with the size of the adsorbing species. Historically, however, nanoimpact electrochemistry has suffered from "edge effects," in which the radial diffusion layer formed at the circumference of the ultramicroelectrodes renders the step size dependent not only on the size of the particle but also on where it lands on the electrode. The introduction of electrocatalytic current generation, however, mitigates the heterogeneity caused by edge effects, thus improving the measurement precision. In this approach, termed "electrocatalytic interruption," a substrate that regenerates the redox probe at the diffusion layer is introduced. This shifts the rate-limiting step of the current generation from diffusion to the homogeneous reaction rate constant, thus reducing flux heterogeneity and increasing the precision of particle sizing by an order of magnitude. The protocol described here explains the set-up and data collection employed in nanoimpact experiments implementing this effect for improved precision in the sizing of redox in-active materials.

Calibration-Free, Seconds-Resolved In Vivo Molecular Measurements using Fourier-Transform Impedance Spectroscopy Interrogation of Electrochemical Aptamer Sensors.

Electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors are capable of measuring the concentrations of specific molecules in vivo, in real time, and with a few-second time resolution. For their signal transduction mechanism, these sensors utilize a binding-induced conformational change in their target-recognizing, redox-reporter-modified aptamer to alter the rate of electron transfer between the reporter and the supporting electrode. While a variety of voltammetric techniques have been used to monitor this change in kinetics, they suffer from various drawbacks, including time resolution limited to several seconds and sensor-to-sensor variation that requires calibration to remove. Here, however, we show that the use of fast Fourier transform electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (FFT-EIS) to interrogate EAB sensors leads to improved (here better than 2 s) time resolution and calibration-free operation, even when such sensors are deployed in vivo. To showcase these benefits, we demonstrate the approach's ability to perform real-time molecular measurements in the veins of living rats.

Continuous molecular monitoring of human dermal interstitial fluid with microneedle-enabled electrochemical aptamer sensors.

The ability to continually collect diagnostic information from the body during daily activity has revolutionized the monitoring of health and disease. Much of this monitoring, however, has been of physical "vital signs", with the monitoring of molecular markers having been limited to glucose, primarily due to the lack of other medically relevant molecules for which continuous measurements are possible in bodily fluids. Electrochemical aptamer sensors, however, have a recent history of successful in vivo demonstrations in rat animal models. Herein, we present the first report of real-time human molecular data collected using such sensors, successfully demonstrating their ability to measure the concentration of phenylalanine in dermal interstitial fluid after an oral bolus. To achieve this, we used a device that employs three hollow microneedles to couple the interstitial fluid to an ex vivo, phenylalanine-detecting sensor. The resulting architecture achieves good precision over the physiological concentration range and clinically relevant, 20 min lag times. By also demonstrating 90 days dry room-temperature shelf storage, the reported work also reaches another important milestone in moving such sensors to the clinic. While the devices demonstrated are not without remaining challenges, the results at minimum provide a simple method by which aptamer sensors can be quickly moved into human subjects for testing.

High-precision monitoring of and feedback control over drug concentrations in the brains of freely moving rats.

Knowledge of drug concentrations in the brains of behaving subjects remains constrained on a number of dimensions, including poor temporal resolution and lack of real-time data. Here, however, we demonstrate the ability of electrochemical aptamer-based sensors to support seconds-resolved, real-time measurements of drug concentrations in the brains of freely moving rats. Specifically, using such sensors, we achieve <4 µM limits of detection and 10-s resolution in the measurement of procaine in the brains of freely moving rats, permitting the determination of the pharmacokinetics and concentration-behavior relations of the drug with high precision for individual subjects. In parallel, we have used closed-loop feedback-controlled drug delivery to hold intracranial procaine levels constant (±10%) for >1.5 hours. These results demonstrate the utility of such sensors in (i) the determination of the site-specific, seconds-resolved neuropharmacokinetics, (ii) enabling the study of individual subject neuropharmacokinetics and concentration-response relations, and (iii) performing high-precision control over intracranial drug levels.

Survey of oligoethylene glycol-based self-assembled monolayers on electrochemical aptamer-based sensor in biological fluids.

The ability to monitor levels of endogenous markers and clearance profiles of drugs and their metabolites can improve the quality of biomedical research and precision with which therapies are individualized. Towards this end, electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors have been developed that support the real-time monitoring of specific analytes in vivo with clinically relevant specificity and sensitivity. A challenge associated with the in vivo deployment of EAB sensors, however, is how to manage the signal drift which, although correctable, ultimately leads to unacceptably low signal-to-noise ratios, limiting the measurement duration. Motivated by the correction of signal drift, in this paper, we have explored the use of oligoethylene glycol (OEG), a widely employed antifouling coating, to reduce the signal drift in EAB sensors. Counter to expectations, however, when challenged in 37 °C whole blood in vitro, EAB sensors employing OEG-modified self-assembled monolayers exhibit both greater drift and reduced signal gain, compared with those employ a simple, hydroxyl-terminated monolayer. On the other hand, when EAB sensor was prepared with a mix monolayer using MCH and lipoamido OEG 2 alcohol, reduced signal noise was observed compared to the same sensor prepared with MCH presumably due to improved SAM construction. These results suggest broader exploration of antifouling materials will be required to improve the signal drift of EAB sensors.

Using seconds-resolved pharmacokinetic datasets to assess pharmacokinetic models encompassing time-varying physiology.

AIM: Pharmacokinetics have historically been assessed using drug concentration data obtained via blood draws and bench-top analysis. The cumbersome nature of these typically constrains studies to at most a dozen concentration measurements per dosing event. This, in turn, limits our statistical power in the detection of hours-scale, time-varying physiological processes. Given the recent advent of in vivo electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors, however, we can now obtain hundreds of concentration measurements per administration. Our aim in this paper was to assess the ability of these time-dense datasets to describe time-varying pharmacokinetic models with good statistical significance. METHODS: We used seconds-resolved measurements of plasma tobramycin concentrations in rats to statistically compare traditional one- and two-compartmental pharmacokinetic models to new models in which the proportional relationship between a drug's plasma concentration and its elimination rate varies in response to changing kidney function. RESULTS: We found that a modified one-compartment model in which the proportionality between the plasma concentration of tobramycin and its elimination rate falls reciprocally with time either meets or is preferred over the standard two-compartment pharmacokinetic model for half of the datasets characterized. When we reduced the impact of the drug's rapid distribution phase on the model, this one-compartment, time-varying model was statistically preferred over the standard one-compartment model for 80% of our datasets. CONCLUSIONS: Our results highlight both the impact that simple physiological changes (such as varying kidney function) can have on drug pharmacokinetics and the ability of high-time resolution EAB sensor measurements to identify such impacts.

A tight squeeze: geometric effects on the performance of three-electrode electrochemical-aptamer based sensors in constrained, in vivo placements.

Electrochemical, aptamer-based (EAB) sensors are the first molecular monitoring technology that is (1) based on receptor binding and not the reactivity of the target, rendering it fairly general, and (2) able to support high-frequency, real-time measurements in situ in the living body. To date, EAB-derived in vivo measurements have largely been performed using three electrodes (working, reference, counter) bundled together within a catheter for insertion into the rat jugular. Exploring this architecture, here we show that the placement of these electrodes inside or outside of the lumen of the catheter significantly impacts sensor performance. Specifically, we find that retaining the counter electrode within the catheter increases the resistance between it and the working electrode, increasing the capacitive background. In contrast, extending the counter electrode outside the lumen of the catheter reduces this effect, significantly enhancing the signal-to-noise of intravenous molecular measurements. Exploring counter electrode geometries further, we find that they need not be larger than the working electrode. Putting these observations together, we have developed a new intravenous EAB architecture that achieves improved performance while remaining short enough to safely emplace in the rat jugular. These findings, though explored here with EAB sensors may prove important for the design of many electrochemical biosensors.

On the Rational Design of Cooperative Receptors.

Cooperativity (homotropic allostery) is the primary mechanism by which evolution steepens the binding curves of biomolecular receptors to produce more responsive input-output behavior in biomolecular systems. Motivated by the ubiquity with which nature employs this effect, over the past 15 years we, together with other groups, have engineered this mechanism into several otherwise noncooperative receptors. These efforts largely aimed to improve the utility of such receptors in artificial biotechnologies, such as synthetic biology and biosensors, but they have also provided the first quantitative, experimental tests of longstanding ideas about the mechanisms underlying cooperativity. In this article, we review the literature on the design of this effect, paying particular attention to the design strategies involved, the extent to which each can be rationally applied to (and optimized for) new receptors, and what each teaches us about the origins and optimization of this important phenomenon.

Efforts toward the continuous monitoring of molecular markers of performance.

OBJECTIVES: Technologies supporting the continuous, real-time measurement of blood oxygen saturation and plasma glucose levels have improved our ability to monitor performance status. Our ability to monitor other molecular markers of performance, however, including the hormones known to indicate overtraining and general health, has lagged. That is, although a number of other molecular markers of performance status have been identified, we have struggled to develop viable technologies supporting their real-time monitoring in the body. Here we review biosensor approaches that may support such measurements, as well as the molecules potentially of greatest interest to monitor. DESIGN: Narrative literature review. METHOD: Literature review. RESULTS: Significant effort has been made to harness the specificity, affinity, and generalizability of biomolecular recognition in a platform technology supporting continuous in vivo molecular measurements. Most biosensor approaches, however, are either not generalizable to most targets, or fail when challenged in the complex environments found in vivo. Electrochemical aptamer-based sensors, in contrast, are the first technology to simultaneously achieve both of these critical attributes. In an effort to illustrate the potential of this platform technology, we both critically review the literature describing it and briefly survey some of the molecular performance markers we believe will prove advantageous to monitor using it. CONCLUSIONS: Electrochemical aptamer-based sensors may be the first truly generalizable technology for monitoring specific molecules in situ in the body and how adaptation of the platform to subcutaneous microneedles will enable the real-time monitoring of performance markers via a wearable, minimally invasive device.

Conformational-switch biosensors as novel tools to support continuous, real-time molecular monitoring in lab-on-a-chip devices.

Recent years have seen continued expansion of the functionality of lab on a chip (LOC) devices. Indeed LOCs now provide scientists and developers with useful and versatile platforms across a myriad of chemical and biological applications. The field still fails, however, to integrate an often important element of bench-top analytics: real-time molecular measurements that can be used to "guide" a chemical response. Here we describe the analytical techniques that could provide LOCs with such real-time molecular monitoring capabilities. It appears to us that, among the approaches that are general (i.e., that are independent of the reactive or optical properties of their targets), sensing strategies relying on binding-induced conformational change of bioreceptors are most likely to succeed in such applications.

Real-Time, Seconds-Resolved Measurements of Plasma Methotrexate In Situ in the Living Body.

Dose-limiting toxicity and significant patient-to-patient pharmacokinetic variability often render it difficult to achieve the safe and effective dosing of drugs. This is further compounded by the slow, cumbersome nature of the analytical methods used to monitor patient-specific pharmacokinetics, which inevitably rely on blood draws followed by post-facto laboratory analysis. Motivated by the pressing need for improved "therapeutic drug monitoring", we are developing electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors, a minimally invasive biosensor architecture that can provide real-time, seconds-resolved measurements of drug levels in situ in the living body. A key advantage of EAB sensors is that they are generalizable to the detection of a wide range of therapeutic agents because they are independent of the chemical or enzymatic reactivity of their targets. Three of the four therapeutic drug classes that have, to date, been shown measurable using in vivo EAB sensors, however, bind to nucleic acids as part of their mode of action, leaving open questions regarding the extent to which the approach can be generalized to therapeutics that do not. Here, we demonstrate real-time, in vivo measurements of plasma methotrexate, an antimetabolite (a mode of action not reliant on DNA binding) chemotherapeutic, following human-relevant dosing in a live rat animal model. By providing hundreds of drug concentration values, the resulting seconds-resolved measurements succeed in defining key pharmacokinetic parameters, including the drug's elimination rate, peak plasma concentration, and exposure (area under the curve), with unprecedented 5 to 10% precision. With this level of precision, we easily identify significant (>2-fold) differences in drug exposure occurring between even healthy rats given the same mass-adjusted methotrexate dose. By providing a real-time, seconds-resolved window into methotrexate pharmacokinetics, such measurements can be used to precisely "individualize" the dosing of this significantly toxic yet vitally important chemotherapeutic.

Using Spectroscopy to Guide the Adaptation of Aptamers into Electrochemical Aptamer-Based Sensors.

Electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors utilize the binding-induced conformational change of an electrode-attached, redox-reporter-modified aptamer to transduce target recognition into an easily measurable electrochemical output. Because this signal transduction mechanism is single-step and rapidly reversible, EAB sensors support high-frequency, real-time molecular measurements, and because it recapitulates the reagentless, conformation-linked signaling seen in vivo among naturally occurring receptors, EAB sensors are selective enough to work in the complex, time-varying environments found in the living body. The fabrication of EAB sensors, however, requires that their target-recognizing aptamer be modified such that (1) it undergoes the necessary binding-induced conformational change and (2) that the thermodynamics of this "conformational switch" are tuned to ensure that they reflect an acceptable trade-off between affinity and signal gain. That is, even if an "as-selected" aptamer achieves useful affinity and specificity, it may fail when adapted to the EAB platform because it lacks the binding-induced conformational change required to support EAB signaling. In this paper we reveal the spectroscopy-guided approaches we use to modify aptamers such that they support the necessary binding-induced conformational change. Specifically, using newly reported aptamers, we demonstrate the systematic design of EAB sensors achieving clinically and physiologically relevant specificity, limits of detection, and dynamic range against the targets methotrexate and tryptophan.

On the Disinfection of Electrochemical Aptamer-Based Sensors.

Electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors encompass the only biosensor approach yet reported that is simultaneously: (1) independent of the chemical or enzymatic reactivity of its target, rendering it general; (2) continuous and real-time; and (3) selective enough to deploy in situ in the living body. Consistent with this, in vivo EAB sensors supporting the seconds-resolved, real-time measurement of multiple drugs and metabolites have been reported, suggesting the approach may prove of value in biomedical research and the diagnosis, treatment, and monitoring of disease. However, to apply these devices in long-duration animal models, much less in human patients, requires that they be free of any significant pathogen load. Thus motivated, here we have characterized the compatibility of EAB sensors with standard sterilization and high-level disinfection techniques. Doing so, we find that, while many lead to significant sensor degradation, treatment with CIDEX OPA (0.55% ortho-phthalaldehyde) leads to effective disinfection without causing any detectable loss in sensor performance.

Pulsed transistor operation enables miniaturization of electrochemical aptamer-based sensors.

By simultaneously transducing and amplifying, transistors offer advantages over simpler, electrode-based transducers in electrochemical biosensors. However, transistor-based biosensors typically use static (i.e., DC) operation modes that are poorly suited for sensor architectures relying on the modulation of charge transfer kinetics to signal analyte binding. Thus motivated, here, we translate the AC "pulsed potential" approach typically used with electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors to an organic electrochemical transistor (OECT). Specifically, by applying a linearly sweeping square-wave potential to an aptamer-functionalized gate electrode, we produce current modulation across the transistor channel two orders of magnitude larger than seen for the equivalent, electrode-based biosensor. Unlike traditional EAB sensors, our aptamer-based OECT (AB-OECT) sensors critically maintain output current even with miniaturization. The pulsed transistor operation demonstrated here could be applied generally to sensors relying on kinetics-based signaling, expanding opportunities for noninvasive and high spatial resolution biosensing.

The sequestration mechanism as a generalizable approach to improve the sensitivity of biosensors and bioassays.

Biosensors and bioassays, both of which employ proteins and nucleic acids to detect specific molecular targets, have seen significant applications in both biomedical research and clinical practice. This success is largely due to the extraordinary versatility, affinity, and specificity of biomolecular recognition. Nevertheless, these receptors suffer from an inherent limitation: single, saturable binding sites exhibit a hyperbolic relationship (the "Langmuir isotherm") between target concentration and receptor occupancy, which in turn limits the sensitivity of these technologies to small variations in target concentration. To overcome this and generate more responsive biosensors and bioassays, here we have used the sequestration mechanism to improve the steepness of the input/output curves of several bioanalytical methods. As our test bed for this we employed sensors and assays against neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin (NGAL), a kidney biomarker for which enhanced sensitivity will improve the monitoring of kidney injury. Specifically, by introducing sequestration we have improved the responsiveness of an electrochemical aptamer based (EAB) biosensor, and two bioassays, a paper-based "dipstick" assay and an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Doing so we have narrowed the dynamic range of these sensors and assays several-fold, thus enhancing their ability to measure small changes in target concentration. Given that introducing sequestration requires only the addition of the appropriate concentration of a high-affinity "depletant," the mechanism appears simple and easily adaptable to tuning the binding properties of the receptors employed in a wide range of biosensors and bioassays.