Collaborative study for the validation of cell line assays for in-process toxicity and antigenicity testing of Clostridium septicum vaccine antigens - Part 2: Optimisation of cell line assays.

During the production of clostridial vaccines large numbers of mice are used for various in-process control tests. Replacement in vitro assays had been developed for the testing of the toxins and toxoids of several clostridial species, but none of these assays had been assessed in an international collaborative study. Under the common aegis of the European Partnership for Alternative Approaches to Animal Testing (EPAA) and of the European Directorate for the Quality of Medicines & HealthCare (EDQM), a project on clostridial vaccines for veterinary use was started as part of the EDQM-co-ordinated Biological Standardisation Programme (BSP). Within the framework of this project (coded BSP130) a collaborative study was organised to evaluate Vero cell-based alternative methods to the current mouse tests used to measure: i) the toxicity of Clostridium septicum toxin, ii) the absence of toxicity of C. septicum toxoid and iii) the antigenicity of C. septicum toxoid. The principal aims of the study were to determine the repeatability and reproducibility of the in vitro assays and to demonstrate concordance of the in vitro and current in vivo tests. The study results demonstrated good concordance, but the information gathered through the study (later on called Part 1) and the participants' workshop prompted the extension of the project in order to further optimise the in vitro protocols and improve their repeatability and reproducibility, which were comparable to but not better than those of the in vivo assays in Part 1. The 3 in vitro assays to be optimised in the extension of the BSP130 project were : i) the in vitro toxin neutralisation equivalence plus (TNE+), as a replacement for the in vivo minimum lethal dose (MLD) test for quantification of the toxicity of toxin; ii) the in vitro MLD, as a replacement for the in vivo MLD test for detection of residual toxicity associated with toxoid; iii) the in vitro total combining power (TCP), as a replacement for the in vivo TCP test for quantification of the antigenicity of toxoid. At this point, the Analytical Method Transfer Laboratory of Ceva-Phylaxia (Hungary), supported by the project management team, developed suitable SOPs for the 3 in vitro assays. These optimised methods were further assessed in BSP130 through a second international collaborative study (Part 2) aimed at defining repeatability and reproducibility in different laboratories and determining the levels of improvement compared with the original in vivo tests and the initial in vitro assays used in Part 1 of the project. Fourteen laboratories, comprising 4 public sector and 10 manufacturers' medicines control laboratories, from 11 countries participated in the collaborative Part 2 study, each testing 6 different C. septicum toxins and 6 C. septicum toxoids. Improved repeatability and reproducibility were observed for the optimised assays. The results of this study confirm the suitability of these assays for in-process control of C. septicum vaccines, with better repeatability and reproducibility than their in vivo equivalents. It is expected that, with appropriate minor changes and the use of relevant reagents, these optimised in vitro assays could be used not only for the assessment of C. septicum toxins and toxoids but for all cytotoxin-based clostridial antigens. The development and implementation of such in vitro assays would offer a great opportunity to significantly reduce animal usage, shorten the duration of QC test procedures and increase the precision of toxicity and antigenicity assays in clostridial veterinary vaccine in-process control. This would also provide more accurate and reproducible dosing of antigens in the final vaccine products, help to promote compendial acceptance and to proffer a basis for improved international harmonisation across this area of product testing.

Collaborative study for the validation of cell line assays for in-process toxicity and antigenicity testing of Clostridium septicum vaccine antigens - Part 1.

Large numbers of mice are used in testing during the production of Clostridial vaccines. Previous work has indicated that cell line assays could replace mouse tests for certain aspects of this testing. Replacement assays have been developed for the testing of the toxins and toxoids of several clostridial species but none of these assays have been assessed in an international collaborative study. Under the common aegis of the European Partnership for Alternative Approaches to Animal Testing (EPAA) and of the European Directorate for the Quality of Medicines & HealthCare (EDQM), collaborative study BSP130 was initiated to evaluate Vero cell based alternative methods to the current mouse tests used to measure the toxicity of Clostridium septicum toxin (the minimum lethal dose (MLD) test), the freedom from toxicity of C. septicum toxoid (the MLD test) and the antigenicity of C. septicum toxoid (the total combining power (TCP) test). The principal aims of BSP130 were to determine the repeatability and reproducibility of the in vitro assays and to demonstrate concordance of the proposed in vitro and current in vivo TCP and MLD tests. 11 laboratories from 7 countries participated in the collaborative study and each tested 6 toxins and 6 toxoids. The participants' Vero cell lines were up to 1 000 times more sensitive than the mouse strains. The MLD assay in mice and on Vero cells generally ranked the toxins in a similar order in most of the laboratories. The TCP assay in mice and on Vero cells also generally ranked the toxoids in a similar order in most of the laboratories. The results demonstrate that the repeatability and reproducibility of the in vitro Vero cell based assays are no worse than that of the in vivo assays and that they are easily transferable to other laboratories. The concordance correlations between the in vivo and in vitro methods were for the MLD assays ρc=0.961 (log-transformed values) and ρc=0.921 (non-log-transformed values) and for the TCP assays ρc=0.968 (log-transformed values) and ρc=0.980 (non log-transformed values). These correlations are excellent showing that the Vero cell assays can be used as alternatives to the mouse tests for the assessment of C. septicum toxin MLD and toxoid TCP values. This study can be used by vaccine manufacturing companies as a guide for applying the same approach to other clostridial toxins and toxoids.

The vaccines consistency approach project: an EPAA initiative.

The consistency approach for release testing of established vaccines promotes the use of in vitro, analytical, non-animal based systems allowing the monitoring of quality parameters during the whole production process. By using highly sensitive non-animal methods, the consistency approach has the potential to improve the quality of testing and to foster the 3Rs (replacement, refinement and reduction of animal use) for quality control of established vaccines. This concept offers an alternative to the current quality control strategy which often requires large numbers of laboratory animals. In order to facilitate the introduction of the consistency approach for established human and veterinary vaccine quality control, the European Partnership for Alternatives to Animal Testing (EPAA) initiated a project, the "Vaccines Consistency Approach Project", aiming at developing and validating the consistency approach with stakeholders from academia, regulators, OMCLs, EDQM, European Commission and industry. This report summarises progress since the project's inception.

Testing of veterinary clostridial vaccines: from mouse to microtitre plate.

Vaccines to protect against clostridial diseases are among the most common veterinary biologicals. Each batch of these materials is subjected to a variety of toxicity and antigenicity tests. The potency of the final vaccine is then assessed by Toxin Neutralisation Test (TNT). All of these tests use mice and have lethal endpoints. Development of alternatives for potency testing was based on ELISAs able to measure antibody levels to the specific toxins relative to a standard serum with a defined unitage. These alternative assays were shown to correlate with the relevant TNTs and have been accepted by European Regulatory Authorities as batch release potency tests. Recently we have developed in vitro cell line alternatives for the toxicity and antigenicity tests for Cl. septicum using the VERO cell line. With this cell line it has been possible to develop in vitro assays which, when compared with the in vivo tests, gave correlations of 87% to 100%. Having shown proof of principle, similar cell line assays have been developed for Cl. novyi and Cl. perfringens types C and D.

An evaluation of the outcomes of psychosocial intervention training for qualified and unqualified nursing staff working in a low-secure mental health unit.

Psychosocial intervention (PSI) training results in enhanced knowledge, more positive attitudes, increased confidence and lower levels of clinical burnout for qualified mental health professionals and better outcomes for service users who they work with. This paper describes an evaluation of a PSI training course for qualified and unqualified nurses working in a low-secure unit. Forty-two staff (21 qualified) were randomly allocated to an experimental training group or a waiting list control group. Knowledge, attitudes and burnout were assessed before and after the training. In addition, a random sample of 44 care plans written by the qualified nurses were audited before and after to examine evidence of implementation of PSI in practice. Qualified and unqualified nurses in the experimental group showed significant improvements in knowledge and attitudes compared with the control group. Care plans showed a significant increase in the implementation of PSI. The only significant change in burnout was a reduction in depersonalization for qualified nurses in the experimental group. The PSI training may result in improvements in knowledge, attitude and practice in qualified and unqualified nurses working with severely mentally ill patients in low-secure settings, but in this study the training did not incur protection against burnout.

Veterinary vaccines: In-VITRO--International Veterinary Industry Test Replacement Organisation.

The International Veterinary Industry Test Replacement Organisation (In-VITRO) was established in 1995 with the aim of developing, validating and harmonising in vitro alternatives to replace in vivo methods for in-process and potency testing of veterinary clostridial vaccines. The emphasis has been on the reduction of animal usage in the Clostridium chauvoei potency assay and its eventual replacement by an in vitro assay. Replacement of the toxin neutralisation assay for Cl. tetani by an internationally validated indirect ELISA has already started. A validation programme involving a collaboration organised through EDQM which could ultimately lead to the standardisation of in vitro tests for all clostridial vaccines is in progress. In addition In-VITRO is now considering the setting up of a programme for Erysipelas vaccines. The collaboration between manufacturers of veterinary vaccines in the development and validation of in vitro tests is a major step towards the reduction and replacement of animal tests.

Necrotic enteritis challenge models with broiler chickens raised on litter: evaluation of preconditions, Clostridium perfringens strains and outcome variables.

The effect of Clostridium perfringens challenge, number of challenge days, and pre-challenge antibiotic treatment on the induction of necrotic enteritis in broiler chickens raised on litter was studied, and the relationship between bacterial counts and frequency of gut lesions was evaluated. Specific intestinal lesions in randomly selected birds were present despite a lack of disease-specific mortality. Challenge, number of challenge days and frequency of lesions were associated with median counts of C. perfringens. The effect of pre-challenge C. perfringens counts and antibiotics cannot be evaluated unless procedures for the control of pre-challenge infection and methods for the differentiation between wild-type and challenge strains are established.

Assessing the psychosocial consequences of epilepsy: a community-based study.

BACKGROUND: Few studies have measured, using validated scales, the psychosocial handicap of epilepsy in a general practice setting. AIM: To assess the prevalence of psychosocial problems associated with epilepsy. METHOD: A survey was undertaken of 309 subjects, with one or more non-febrile epileptic seizures, drawn from two general practices in the United Kingdom (UK). The outcome measures were the Subjective Handicap of Epilepsy Scale (SHE), the SF-36, and the Hospital Anxiety and Depression scale (HAD). RESULTS: One-third of persons with active epilepsy were significantly handicapped by their condition. The severity of subjective handicap was related to seizure frequency and to the duration of remission of seizures. Between one-third and one-half of subjects scored as 'cases' on the HAD scale and on the mental health subscale of the SF-36. Only one-third of the psychiatric morbidity revealed by the questionnaires had been recognized by the general practitioner (GP). Scores on the SF-36 indicated that people with active seizures perceived themselves as significantly less healthy than those in remission, and that, for persons in remission, drug treatment had a detrimental effect on certain aspects of well-being. CONCLUSIONS: The occurrence of seizures, even at low frequencies, is associated with psychosocial handicap, and this may remain covert in general practice.

Effect of schedule on reactogenicity and antibody persistence of acellular and whole-cell pertussis vaccines: value of laboratory tests as predictors of clinical performance.

The performance of four acellular pertussis vaccines containing between two and five pertussis antigens combined with diphtheria and tetanus toxoids was compared with that of British whole-cell diphtheria/tetanus/pertussis (DTP) vaccine both in laboratory assays for potency, toxicity and immunogenicity, and for reactogenicity and immunogenicity in infants. Clinical responses were evaluated in double blind randomized Phase II trials using 3/5/9 month and 2/3/4 month schedules. The acellular DTPs had much lower toxicity than whole-cell DTP in laboratory tests and were significantly less pyrogenic than whole-cell DTP under both schedules. Local reactions were not consistently lower in acellular than whole-cell vaccinees and varied with the source of the diphtheria and tetanus antigens used. Differences in endotoxin level and content of active pertussis toxin (PT) between acellular DTP vaccines were not clinically significant. The reactogenicity advantage of the acellular vaccines was substantially reduced under the 2/3/4 month schedule due to the reduced reactogenicity of the whole-cell DTP vaccine when given at a younger age. There was no relationship between antigen content measured in micrograms per dose and ELISA antibody responses to filamentous haemagglutinin (FHA) and PT in infants, nor was murine immunogenicity predictive of immunogenicity in humans. Antibody response to PT was attenuated in the whole-cell group under the 2/3/4 month schedule but was unaffected in the group receiving acellular vaccines with individually purified components; antibody response to pertactin (69 kDa antigen) was similar in recipients of the whole-cell and component acellular vaccines under the 2/3/4 month schedule. PT antibody persistence until 4-5 years of age was significantly better in recipients of the component acellular than either the whole-cell vaccine or the co-purified acellular vaccine under the 3/5/9 month schedule. However, diphtheria antitoxin levels were reduced in acellular vaccine recipients under both schedules. Despite significantly lower tetanus potencies of the acellular vaccines in laboratory tests, no differences were found in tetanus anti-toxin responses in children.

Audit of the care of patients with epilepsy in general practice.

BACKGROUND: Previous studies have shown that there is great potential for improving the management of patients with epilepsy. AIM: To identify all patients with epilepsy, to evaluate and audit their care in relation to an annual review, to document seizure frequency and appropriateness of daily therapy to aid compliance and to propose strategies to improve these and other aspects of epileptic care. METHOD: An audit of the care of patients with epilepsy was undertaken in two King's Lynn practices with a combined population of 22,500. Principles for the management of epilepsy were established. From these principles, the following standards were agreed: 75% of patients on treatment for epilepsy should be seen every year, 75% of patients should have their seizure frequency documented, and 75% of patients should take their anti-epileptic drugs no more than twice daily. As a result of the first audit cycle, changes were made in the documentation and advice regarding treatment relating to these standards. RESULTS: The first audit cycle showed that 83% of patients had been seen at least once in the previous year, that documentation of seizure frequency existed for 51% of patients in the past year, and that 63% of patients were taking their treatment no more than twice daily. The evaluation was repeated 22 months later and an overall improvement was demonstrated in the first two results: 95% of patients had been seen in the past year, 93% had had their seizure frequency documented; however, only 66% of patients were taking their treatment twice daily or less. CONCLUSION: Call and recall, and documentation of seizure frequency were improved by this clinical audit. However, alterations in daily therapy appeared difficult for a variety of reasons; for example, therapy might have been initiated by a hospital specialist, and patients in a stable condition might have been apprehensive about changes. In order to improve the care of patients with epilepsy, a primary care team approach is desirable within a structure of good specialist services.

Th1/Th2 cell dichotomy in acquired immunity to Bordetella pertussis: variables in the in vivo priming and in vitro cytokine detection techniques affect the classification of T-cell subsets as Th1, Th2 or Th0.

In studies of the mechanism of immunity to Bordetella pertussis in a murine respiratory infection model, we have previously demonstrated that natural infection of immunization with a whole cell vaccine induces a potent protective immune response, which is mediated by T-helper type-1 (Th1) cells. In contrast an acellular vaccine generates Th2 cells and is associated with delayed bacterial clearance following respiratory challenge. In the present study we have investigated the apparent Th1/Th2 cell dichotomy in acquired immunity and have examined the factors that affect their induction or detection. The cytokine profiles of B. pertussis-specific T cells in immune animals were determined using antigen-stimulated ex vivo spleen cells or CD4+ T-cell lines and clones established in the presence of interleukin-2 (IL-2) or IL-4. Antigen-specific T cells derived from mice immunized with the acellular vaccine were almost exclusively of the Th2 cell type. In contrast, T-cell lines and clones established following respiratory infection or immunization with the whole cell vaccine were predominantly of the Th1 type. However, a proportion of T cells from convalescent mice, especially when cultured in the presence of IL-4, secreted IL-4 and IL-5 with or without detectable IL-2 and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), suggesting that Th0 or Th2 cells were also primed during natural infection in vivo. Furthermore, when mice were assessed 6 months after infection, spleen cells produced significant levels of IL-4 and IL-5, which were not evident at 6 weeks. The route of immunization and the genetic background of the mice were also found to influence the preferential priming of Th1 cells, and this was directly related to the level of protection against respiratory or intracerebral (i.c.) challenge. Our findings underline the critical role of CD4+ Th1 cells in immunity to B. pertussis, but also demonstrate that a number of factors in the in vivo priming and in vitro restimulation can skew the apparent dominance of one Th cell type over another.

Developments in pertussis vaccines leading to reduction and replacement of in vivo testing.

The control of bacterial vaccines, in common with other biological products, requires that they conform to specified standards of purity, safety and efficacy. The specifications and the methods of assessment can vary between the different types of vaccines. Highly defined vaccines can be largely evaluated by physico-chemical methods. However, the control of whole-cell bacterial vaccines can be a very different proposition owing to the complex nature of the materials. Safety and efficacy testing of such products can involve number of in vivo assays. Our growing understanding of the pathogenesis of, and protective immune responses to, bacterial disease makes it possible to devise more effective and better-defined vaccines. In addition, it allows the the development of sensitive and precise in vitro assays. As a result, the requirement for in vivo control tests can be reduced and in some cases eliminated. This phenomenon is well illustrated by the recent advances in the development and control of pertussis vaccines. Certain in vitro tests, such as the LAL and CHO-cell assays, are proving valuable in checking for specific toxicities which can be associated with pertussis vaccines. Although some problems still exist in the development of a suitable potency assay for the acellular vaccines, as we gain more information on the contributions of the different aspects of the immune system towards protection from pertussis, the prospects for further improvements in both the vaccine and its control evaluation are promising.

Immunological characterization.

As part of the assessment of product consistency and putative potency, it is often necessary to check not only that a vaccine contains the desired antigens, but also that they are in the correct immunological form (see Note 1). In general, this immunological characterization of a vaccine is interpreted as the ability of the preparation to invoke an appropriate immune response to its major constitutent antigens. The immune response in question may be in the form of serum antibodies, secretory antibodies, cell-mediated immunity (CMI), or a combination of these. The best approach to characterization of the immune response may be qualitative, such as immunoblotting to check for the presence of antibodies to specific antigens (1), quantitative, such as immunosorbent assays to measure the level of the antibody response to a particular antigen (2), or functional, such as toxin neutralization (3) to assess the magnitude of the functional activity of the response. The nature of the vaccine to be characterized and how its protective efficacy is mediated must be considered when deciding which aspects of the immune response should be examined and how they will be assessed.

Immune responses and protection against Bordetella pertussis infection after intranasal immunization of mice with filamentous haemagglutinin in solution or incorporated in biodegradable microparticles.

The intranasal (i.n.) immunization of mice with Bordetella pertussis filamentous haemagglutinin (FHA) either as a solution or incorporated in biodegradable microparticles induced very similar immune responses. Both resulted in strong systemic IgG responses to FHA and good levels of anti-FHA IgG and IgA in the lungs of immunized mice. In comparison, the intraperitoneal (i.p.) immunization of mice with FHA, as a solution, engendered anti-FHA antibody responses which were stronger for serum IgG, similar for lung IgG and lower for lung IgA. The anti-FHA antibody levels, as measured by immunosorbent assay, were shown to correlate with their functional activity in the blocking of B. pertussis adhesion to HeLa tissue-culture cells. All three forms of immunization appeared to stimulate T-cell responses as assessed by in vitro antigen-specific spleen cell proliferation and IL-2 secretion indicative of a Th1 type response, however, cells from i.p. immunized mice only secreted low levels of IL-5. All three methods of FHA immunization provided mice with significant protection against subsequent aerosol challenge with virulent B. pertussis. Mice which had been immunized intra-nasally eliminated the bacteria from their lungs slightly more rapidly than i.p. immunized mice, demonstrating the efficacy of intranasal administration of FHA in solution and in the more practical biodegradable microparticle form.

Combination of DTP and Haemophilus influenzae type b conjugate vaccines can affect laboratory evaluation of potency and immunogenicity.

A commonly used Diphtheria-Tetanus-Pertussis (whole-cell) vaccine was combined with each of three different Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) capsular polysaccharide vaccines. Each Hib vaccine incorporated one of three different protein conjugates: tetanus toxoid, diphtheria CRM197 toxoid or group B Neisseria meningitidis outer membrane vesicles. The effects of these combinations on the subsequent laboratory control testing were examined. The addition of the Hib vaccines had no significant effect on the reactogenicity or the potency of the whole-cell pertussis component. The potency of, and antibody responses to, the diphtheria component were also unaffected in all three combinations. However, combination with the Hib vaccine comprising polysaccharide conjugated to tetanus toxoid had dramatic effects on tetanus potency and immunogenicity when assayed in mice. This combination resulted in a five-fold potentiation of the tetanus potency and a similarly large increase in the antibody responses to tetanus toxin and toxoid. The level of the antibody response to the Hib polysaccharide in this vaccine was also elevated, more than 20-fold, as a result of the combination. Such phenomena were not evident with combinations involving the other two Hib vaccines. These results have implications for the control testing of combined vaccines containing a whole-cell pertussis component and Hib polysaccharide-tetanus protein conjugate vaccine.

Interaction of Haemophilus influenzae type b conjugate vaccines with diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis vaccine in control tests.

The effects of combining three Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) capsular polysaccharide vaccines, conjugated to different proteins, with DTP vaccine on the subsequent control testing were examined. The addition of the Hib vaccines had little effect on the reactogenicity or the potency of the whole-cell pertussis component. The potency of, and antibody responses to, the diphtheria component were also unaffected in all three combinations. However, combination with the Hib vaccine comprising polysaccharide conjugated to tetanus toxoid resulted in a fivefold potentiation of the tetanus potency and large increases in the antibody responses to tetanus toxin and toxoid and Hib polysaccharide. These results have implications for the control testing of combined vaccines containing a whole-cell pertussis component and Hib polysaccharide-tetanus protein conjugate vaccine.