ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: The work participation of young adults with chronic physical conditions lag behind compared to healthy age-mates. 'At Work' is a vocational rehabilitation intervention provided by occupational therapists, that supports them for entering the competitive labour market after graduating post-secondary education. AIM: To evaluate the effects of 'At Work' on self-efficacy, work-ability and employment status as compared to usual care. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In total, 88 young adults were included in a multicentre controlled trial; 49 entered 'At Work', 39 received usual care. GEE-analyses were applied. RESULTS: Scores on all outcome measures substantially improved over time in the intervention group, but no significant effects were found as compared to the control group. The effect on general self-efficacy showed a positive trend in favour of the intervention group. CONCLUSIONS AND SIGNIFICANCE: Unlike previous study results pointing to positive outcomes of At Work', the current study did not support the effectiveness of this program on work-related self-efficacy, work-ability and paid employment, as compared to usual care. Yet, we did find an indication for positive intervention effect on general self-efficacy, which is known to be an important capacity to achieve social participation.
Subject(s)
Rehabilitation, Vocational , Unemployment , Humans , Young Adult , Rehabilitation, Vocational/methods , Employment , Self Efficacy , Health Status , Chronic DiseaseABSTRACT
AIM: To identify meaningful outcomes of children and their caregivers attending a paediatric brain centre. METHOD: We compiled a long list of outcomes of health and functioning of children with brain-related disorders such as cerebral palsy, spina bifida, (genetic) neurodevelopmental disorders, and acquired brain injury. We incorporated three perspectives: patients, health care professionals, and published outcome sets. An aggregated list was categorized using the International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and Health: Children and Youth version in a patient validation survey for children and parent-caregivers to prioritize outcomes. Outcomes were considered meaningful when ranked 'very important' by 70% or more of the participants. RESULTS: We identified 104 outcomes from the three perspectives. After categorizing, 59 outcomes were included in the survey. Thirty-three surveys were completed by children (n = 4), caregivers (n = 24), and parent-caregivers together with their child (n = 5). Respondents prioritized 27 meaningful outcomes covering various aspects of health and functioning: emotional well-being, quality of life, mental and sensory functions, pain, physical health, and activities (communication, mobility, self-care, interpersonal relationships). Parent-caregiver concerns and environmental factors were newly identified outcomes. INTERPRETATION: Children and parent-caregivers identified meaningful outcomes covering various aspects of health and functioning, including caregiver concerns and environmental factors. We propose including those in future outcome sets for children with neurodisability. WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS: Outcomes that children with brain-related disorders and their parent-caregivers consider to be the most meaningful cover a wide range of aspects of functioning. Involving these children and their parent-caregivers resulted in the identification of important outcomes that were not covered by professionals and the literature. Parent-caregiver-related factors (coping, burden of care) and environmental factors (support, attitudes, and [health care] services) were identified as meaningful.
Subject(s)
Caregivers , Disabled Children , Adolescent , Child , Humans , Caregivers/psychology , Disabled Children/psychology , Quality of Life , Health Personnel , BrainABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: This international, multi-center cross-sectional study is one of the preparatory studies in the development of the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) Core Sets for adults with cerebral palsy (CP) to describe their functioning and health. OBJECTIVE: To identify the most common problems in functioning of adults with CP presenting in healthcare services, and facilitating and hindering environmental factors, using the ICF as a reference. METHODS: Participants were adults with CP who visited healthcare services in the Netherlands, Sweden, Thailand, and the United States. Structured interviews were performed using an adapted version of the generic ICF checklist 2.1a (106 categories) to rate the participant's functioning and the impact of environmental factors. Descriptive statistics were used for frequency analysis. RESULTS: In total, 101 participants were included, of whom 69 without intellectual disability (mean age ± SD of 38.4 ± 14.7 y; 85.5% with spastic type of CP; Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS) levels I-V) and 32 with intellectual disability (mean age ± SD of 25.0 ± 6.4 y; 71.9% with spastic type of CP; GMFCS levels I-V). A total of 104 ICF categories in the ICF checklist were frequently present in adults with CP: 27 body functions, 4 body structures, 53 activities and participation, and 20 environmental factors. CONCLUSIONS: The most common problems of adults with CP presenting in healthcare services are diverse and highly prevalent. The study results add the clinical perspective on relevant categories of functioning to the basis for developing the ICF Core Sets for adults with CP.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy , Disabled Persons , Intellectual Disability , Activities of Daily Living , Adult , Cross-Sectional Studies , Disability Evaluation , Humans , International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health , Muscle SpasticityABSTRACT
AIM: To: (1) investigate the importance of outcome measurement instruments (OMIs) within a core outcome set (COS) for multimorbidity (at least two chronic health conditions) risk in individuals with cerebral palsy (CP); (2) investigate the feasibility of OMIs within the COS in international clinical research settings in adolescents and adults with CP; and (3) describe the associations between the COS data and Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS) levels. METHOD: Eighty-three individuals with CP completed a survey on health outcomes: physical behaviour, nutrition, sleep, endurance, body composition, blood pressure, blood lipids, and glucose. A cross-sectional study assessed the feasibility of the COS in 67 adolescents and adults with CP (mean age 30y, SD 15y 1mo, min-max: 14-68y, 52.2% male) at four centres. Prevalence of multimorbidity risk and associations with GMFCS levels are described. RESULTS: Most participants rated physical behaviour, nutrition, sleep, and endurance as very important. Body composition, blood pressure, nutrition, and sleep were highly feasible since data were collected in 88% or more participants who consented to having the assessments. Physical behaviour, cardiorespiratory endurance, and blood draws were collected in less than 60% of participants. Total time sedentary (ρ=0.53, p<0.01) and endurance (ρ=-0.46, p<0.01) were significantly associated with GMFCS level. INTERPRETATION: The COS identified that most participants had poor sleep quality and endurance, did not have healthy diets, and showed increased sedentary behaviour. Individuals with CP valued these outcomes as most important, suggesting a need to assess these modifiable behaviours in this population. Objective measures of physical behaviour and cardiorespiratory endurance in the COS required additional personnel, time, and participant burden. We recommend that healthcare providers should perform a simpler first screen using questionnaire-based assessments and then focus the use of the remainder of the COS if required for the patient.
UM DESFECHO CENTRAL DEFINIDO PARA RISCO DE MULTIMORBIDADE EM INDIVÍDUOS COM PARALISIA CEREBRAL: OBJETIVO: (1) Investigar a importância dos instrumentos de medição de desfechos (IMD) dentro de um conjunto de desfechos principais (CDS) para risco de multimorbidade (pelo menos duas condições crônicas de saúde) em indivíduos com paralisia cerebral (PC); (2) Investigar a viabilidade de IMD dentro do CDS em cenários internacionais de pesquisa clínica em adolescentes e adultos com PC; e (3) Descrever as associações entre os dados do CDS e os níveis do Sistema de Classificação da Função Motora Grossa (GMFCS). MÉTODO: Oitenta e três indivíduos com PC completaram uma pesquisa sobre desfechos em saúde: comportamento físico, nutrição, sono, resistência, composição corporal, pressão arterial, lipídios no sangue e glicose. Um estudo transversal avaliou a viabilidade do COS em 67 adolescentes e adultos com PC (idade média de 30 anos, desvio padrão de 15 anos e 1 mês, min-max: 14-68 anos, 52,2% do sexo masculino) em quatro centros. São descritas a prevalência do risco de multimorbidade e as associações com os níveis de GMFCS. RESULTADOS: A maioria dos participantes classificou o comportamento físico, nutrição, sono e resistência como muito importantes. Composição corporal, pressão arterial, nutrição e sono foram altamente viáveis, uma vez que os dados foram coletados em 88% ou mais dos participantes que consentiram em realizar as avaliações. Comportamento físico, resistência cardiorrespiratória e coleta de sangue foram coletados em menos de 60% dos participantes. O tempo total de sedentarismo (ρ = 0,53, p < 0,01) e resistência (ρ = −0,46, p < 0,01) foram significativamente associados ao nível de GMFCS. INTERPRETAÇÃO: O CDS identificou que a maioria dos participantes tinha má qualidade e resistência do sono, não tinha dietas saudáveis e apresentava um comportamento sedentário aumentado. Indivíduos com PC valorizaram esses desfechos como mais importantes, sugerindo a necessidade de avaliar esses comportamentos modificáveis nessa população. Medidas objetivas de comportamento físico e resistência cardiorrespiratória no CDS exigiram pessoal adicional, tempo e sobrecarga do participante. Recomendamos que os profissionais de saúde realizem uma primeira triagem mais simples usando avaliações baseadas em questionários e, em seguida, concentrem o uso do restante do CDS, se necessário para o paciente.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy , Adolescent , Adult , Cerebral Palsy/epidemiology , Cross-Sectional Studies , Female , Humans , Male , Multimorbidity , Outcome Assessment, Health Care , Sedentary BehaviorABSTRACT
AIM: To report on the results of the online international consensus process to develop the comprehensive and brief International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) Core Sets for adults with cerebral palsy (CP). METHOD: An online iterative decision-making and consensus process involved 25 experts, including clinicians and researchers working with adults with CP, an adult with CP, and the parents of adults with CP from all six regions of the World Health Organization. The most relevant categories were selected from a list of 154 unique second-level candidate categories to develop the ICF Core Sets for adults with CP. This list resulted from evidence gathered during four preparatory studies, that is, a systematic literature review, a qualitative study, an expert survey, and an empirical study. RESULTS: The consensus process resulted in the comprehensive ICF Core Set containing 120 second-level ICF categories: 33 body functions; eight body structures; 50 activities and participation; and 29 environmental factors, from which the most essential categories, 33 in total, were selected for the brief ICF Core Set. For body functions, most of the categories were mental functions and neuromusculoskeletal and movement-related functions. Body structures were mostly related to movement. All the chapters of the activities and participation component were represented, with mobility and self-care as the most frequently covered chapters. For environmental factors, most of the categories addressed products and technology and services, systems, and policies. INTERPRETATION: The comprehensive and brief ICF Core Sets for adults with CP were created using a new online version of an established ICF Core Set consensus process. These Core Sets complement the age-specific ICF Core Sets for children and young people with CP and will promote standardized data collection worldwide.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy , Disabled Persons , Activities of Daily Living , Adolescent , Adult , Cerebral Palsy/diagnosis , Child , Consensus , Disability Evaluation , Humans , World Health OrganizationABSTRACT
PURPOSE: Chronic physical conditions often negatively affect work participation. The objective of this systematic review is to investigate the effectiveness and characteristics of vocational rehabilitation interventions for people with a chronic physical condition. METHODS: Searches in five databases up to April 2020 identified 30 studies meeting our inclusion criteria. Two reviewers independently assessed and extracted data. The Grading of Recommendation, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) framework was used to evaluate quality of evidence for three outcome measures related to work participation. RESULTS: All vocational rehabilitation interventions consisted of multiple components, but their characteristics varied widely. Analysis of 22 trials yielded a moderate positive effect with moderate certainty of interventions on work status; analysis of five trials with low risk of bias showed a large positive effect with moderate certainty (risk ratio 1.33 and 1.57, respectively). In addition, in eight studies we found a moderate to small positive effect with low certainty on work attitude (standardized mean difference = 0.59 or 0.38, respectively). We found no effect on work productivity in nine studies. CONCLUSION: The systematic review of the literature showed positive effects of vocational rehabilitation interventions on work status and on work attitude; we found no effect on work productivity.Implications for rehabilitationIn rehabilitation, addressing work participation of persons with a chronic physical condition using targeted interventions is beneficial to improve or sustain work participation, irrespective of the intervention characteristics and diagnosis.Interventions that include multiple components and offer individual support, whether or not combined with group sessions, are likely to be more effective in improving work participation in persons with a chronic physical condition.The overview of vocational interventions in this systematic review may assist healthcare professionals in making informed decisions as to which intervention to provide.Vocational rehabilitation, as well as studies on work participation in chronic disease, should include a long follow-up period to explore if work participation is sustainable and contributes to health and wellbeing.
Subject(s)
Outcome Assessment, Health Care , Rehabilitation, Vocational , Adult , Bias , Chronic Disease , Health Personnel , HumansABSTRACT
PURPOSE: Investigate pain, fatigue, depressive symptoms and sleep disturbance in young adults with cerebral palsy compared to references. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Young adults with cerebral palsy (n = 97, aged 21-34 years) and age-matched references from the general population (n = 190) rated pain using a numeric rating scale and fatigue, depressive symptoms, sleep disturbance and global health using Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System® short forms. Scores were compared between cerebral palsy subgroups and the reference population. Correlation coefficients and linear regression analyses assessed interrelationships of health issues and associations with global health. RESULTS: Individuals with Gross Motor Function Classification System level I had less pain, fatigue and depressive symptoms, while individuals with levels II and III-V had more pain (53% and 56%, p < 0.001) and those with levels III-V more fatigue (39%, p = 0.035) than references (pain: 26%, fatigue: 14%). Pain and fatigue were more interrelated (correlation coefficients: 0.71 vs. 0.41) and stronger associated with global mental health in individuals with cerebral palsy. CONCLUSIONS: Young adults with Gross Motor Function Classification System levels II-V report more pain and those with levels III-V report more fatigue than references. Pain and fatigue are highly interrelated and specifically relate to mental health in individuals with cerebral palsy.Implications for rehabilitationExcept for those in the highest level of motor function, young adults with cerebral palsy report higher levels of pain and fatigue compared to the general population of the same age.Pain and fatigue are strongly interrelated and associated with mental health in young adults with cerebral palsy.The present study recommends to monitor pain and fatigue in young adults with cerebral palsy with low levels of gross motor function.We advise rehabilitation professionals to consider combined treatment for both pain and fatigue.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy , Cerebral Palsy/complications , Depression/epidemiology , Depression/etiology , Fatigue/epidemiology , Fatigue/etiology , Humans , Pain/epidemiology , Pain/etiology , Sleep , Young AdultABSTRACT
AIM: To examine the most relevant aspects of functioning of adults with cerebral palsy (CP) from their perspective, in order to develop an International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) Core Set for adults with CP. METHOD: We conducted six focus group discussions with adults with CP without intellectual disability and seven interviews with adults with CP with intellectual disability and caregivers, addressing all ICF components. Meaningful concepts were identified from verbatim transcripts and linked to ICF categories by two independent researchers. RESULTS: In total, 31 adults with CP without intellectual disability (mean [SD] age 46y 1mo [14y 1mo]; 20 females, 11 males; Gross Motor Function Classification System [GMFCS] levels I-IV) and seven adults with CP and intellectual disability (mean [SD] age 25y 8mo [6y 8mo]; four females, three males; GMFCS levels III-V) participated. We identified 132 unique second-level categories: 47 body functions, seven body structures, 43 activities and participation, and 35 environmental factors. The most frequently mentioned categories were emotional function, pain, muscle tone function, support of family, products and technology, and health services. INTERPRETATION: Adults with CP experienced problems in a broad range of body functions and activities and indicated the importance of environmental factors for functioning. The identified categories will be added to the list of candidate items to reach consensus on an ICF Core Set for adults with CP. What this paper adds Including the lived experience is crucial for fully understanding functioning of adults with cerebral palsy (CP). Adults with CP perceive environmental factors as essential elements for everyday functioning. Adults with intellectual disability should be considered as a group with specific problems.
Subject(s)
Activities of Daily Living , Cerebral Palsy/physiopathology , Intellectual Disability/physiopathology , Adult , Aged , Cerebral Palsy/complications , Disability Evaluation , Disabled Persons , Female , Humans , Intellectual Disability/complications , International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health , Male , Middle Aged , Young AdultABSTRACT
PURPOSE: Employment of young adults with chronic physical conditions entering the labor market after finishing post-secondary education remains behind compared to typically developing peers. The aim of this study is to evaluate changes in their paid employment levels after following a vocational rehabilitation intervention ('At Work'). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Participants aged between 16 and 27 years (n = 90) were recruited via rehabilitation physicians and a jobcoach agency and participated in a vocational rehabilitation program. Cochran's Q and McNemar tests served to test the development of intervention participants' paid employment over time. Chi-square tests were used to compare intervention participants' paid employment level with national reference data selected on age and having a self-reported chronic physical condition. RESULTS: Paid employment level of the intervention cohort significantly increased from 10.0% at baseline to 42.4% at 2-years follow-up (p < 0.001). At 2-years follow-up, their employment rates approached the employment rates of national reference data (42.4% versus 52.9%, p = 0.17). CONCLUSION: Starting from a disadvantaged position, the paid employment rate of the intervention cohort substantially increased over time, approaching the employment rate of reference data. 'At Work' seems to be appropriate for supporting this specific group who face obstacles to enter the labor market, to find competitive employment.IMPLICATIONS FOR REHABILITATION'At Work' is a vocational rehabilitation intervention for young adults with chronic physical conditions who experience problems with finding and maintaining competitive employment after finishing post-secondary education.The 'At Work' intervention entails a combination of group sessions and individual coaching sessions based on the supported employment methodology.Paid employment rates of the intervention cohort substantially increased on the short- and long term, and approached employment rates of reference data of persons with chronic physical conditions.The 'At Work' intervention seems appropriate to support young adults with chronic physical conditions who experience barriers for work participation, to enter the labor market and find competitive and sustainable employment.
Subject(s)
Disabled Persons , Employment, Supported , Adolescent , Adult , Humans , Physical Examination , Rehabilitation, Vocational , Young AdultABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: There is little focus on adults with cerebral palsy (CP) in research and health care and insufficient knowledge on how to identify and manage pain in this population. OBJECTIVES: This systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to determine whether pain prevalence in adults with CP is high and to explore variations in pain prevalence of subgroups, pain locations, pain severity and pain interference. METHODS: Potential datasets were identified by experts in the field and literature searches in Embase, MEDLINE, and Cochrane, from January 2000 to October 2016. Included studies had a representative sample of ≥25 adults with CP and ≥1 pain outcomes. Methodological quality assessment, pain prevalence estimates and logistic regression models for subgroup effects on pain prevalence were conducted. RESULTS: In total, 17 eligible studies were identified from 4584 publications. A meta-analysis was performed with individual participant data from 15 studies totalling 1243 participants (mean [SD] age 34.3 [12.6] years). Overall mean pain prevalence was 70% (95% CI 62-78). Women were more likely to have pain than men (P<0.001). The odds of pain was increased in adults with gross motor function level II (odds ratio [OR] 1.92, 95% CI 1.22-3.12) and IV (OR 1.77, 95% CI 1.03-4.29). Participants with pain reported pain predominantly in the legs (76%, 95% CI 66-84), and mean pain severity was 3.7/10 (95% CI 2.7-4.7) and pain interference 3.5/10 (95% CI 2.5-4.5). CONCLUSIONS: This meta-analysis provides the first reliable pain prevalence estimate in a large international sample of adults with CP. The high prevalence of pain, 70%, suggests that adults with CP should be routinely screened for pain and treated accordingly. The range of measurement instruments used by the included studies emphasizes using common outcome measures specific to pain internationally.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy , Pain , Adult , Cerebral Palsy/complications , Female , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Pain/epidemiology , Pain/etiology , Prevalence , Young AdultABSTRACT
PURPOSE: Youth with disabilities face challenges regarding achieving autonomy. The 'Skills for Growing Up' tool was adapted for use in Dutch pediatric rehabilitation (SGU-D) to support development of autonomy. This study presents the experiences with the SGU-D tool. METHODS: The SGU-D was implemented in 18 settings, of which 4 participated in the evaluation. Rehabilitation professionals were trained in the use of the SGU-D. In a qualitative study, participants were interviewed for their opinions regarding the tool. RESULTS: Experience with the SGU-D was evaluated in 11 youth with disabilities, 11 parents and 8 rehabilitation professionals. They perceived the SGU-D as a helpful tool: i) to support development of autonomy, ii) to focus on future perspectives, and iii) to facilitate communication with family and rehabilitation professionals. Additional support from rehabilitation professionals on using the SGU-D was appreciated. CONCLUSION: Youth with disabilities, their parents and rehabilitation professionals value the SGU-D as a practical tool for working on autonomy, and to identify important areas of development.
Subject(s)
Adolescent Development , Child Development , Disabled Persons/rehabilitation , Patient Satisfaction/statistics & numerical data , Personal Autonomy , Rehabilitation/methods , Adolescent , Child , Disabled Persons/psychology , Female , Humans , Male , Parents , Qualitative Research , Self Care , Self Efficacy , Young AdultABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: To identify areas of functioning in adults with cerebral palsy that are considered relevant by experts, in order to develop an International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) Core Set for adults with cerebral palsy. PARTICIPANTS: Experts from various professional backgrounds worldwide who had experience working with adults with cerebral palsy for ≥2 years and were able to complete the survey in the English language. METHODS: A cross-sectional study using an international internet-based survey. The experts were asked to address relevant areas of functioning in adults with cerebral palsy. These areas of functioning were then linked to the ICF and the frequencies analysed. RESULTS: A total of 126 experts from 32 countries completed the survey. From the responses, 217 unique second-level ICF categories were identified. The three most frequently mentioned categories were "design, construction and building products and technology of buildings for public use (e150, 77%) and private use" (e155, 67%), followed by "sensation of pain" (b280, 62%). CONCLUSION: The broad diversity of ICF categories reported by the experts emphasize the known heterogeneity of cerebral palsy and the variety of func-tioning in adulthood. They also reported on many environmental factors, illustrating the importance of person-environment interactions. These findings provide information about relevant issues for use in developing an ICF Core Set for adults with cerebral palsy.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy/epidemiology , International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health/standards , Adult , Cross-Sectional Studies , Female , Humans , Male , Surveys and QuestionnairesABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: To describe the epidemiology of health status, impairments, activities and participation in adults with cerebral palsy (CP). DATA SOURCES: Embase, MEDLINE, Web of Science, PsycINFO, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health, Cochrane, and Google Scholar were searched for 3 themes ("cerebral palsy," "adult," and "outcome assessment") in literature published between January 2000 and December 2018. STUDY SELECTION: Full-article peer-reviewed English journal articles on descriptive, observational, or experimental studies describing the most studied outcomes in adults with CP (n≥25, age≥18y) were included. Studies were included in the analyses if frequently studied outcomes were described in at least 3 studies using similar methods of assessment. DATA EXTRACTION: Data were extracted independently by 2 authors from 65 articles (total N=28,429) using a standardized score sheet. DATA SYNTHESIS: Meta-analyses revealed that overall, on average 65.1% (95% confidence interval [CI], 55.1-74.5) of adults with CP experienced pain, 57.9% (95% CI, 51.1-64.6) were ambulant, 65.5% (95% CI, 61.2-69.7) had little or no limitation in manual ability, 18.2% (95% CI, 10.6-27.2) had tertiary education, 39.2% (95% CI, 31.5;47.1) were employed, and 29.3% (95% CI, 9.0-55.3) lived independently. In adults without intellectual disability, proportions of individuals who were ambulant (72.6% [95% CI, 58.8-84.5]) and lived independently (90.0% [95% CI, 83.8-94.9]) were higher (P=.014 and P<.01, respectively). The Fatigue Severity Scale score was 4.1 (95% CI, 3.8-4.4). Epilepsy (28.8% [95% CI, 20.1-38.4]) and asthma (28.3% [95% CI, 18.7-38.9]) were especially prevalent comorbidities. CONCLUSIONS: The present systematic review and meta-analysis on the epidemiology of adults with CP provided state-of-the-art knowledge on the most frequently studied outcomes. On average, adults with CP are fatigued, and a majority experience pain, are ambulant, and have little or no difficulty with manual ability. On average, 40% are employed and 30% live independently. More uniformity in assessment and reports is advised to improve knowledge on epidemiology and gain insight in more outcomes.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy/complications , Cerebral Palsy/epidemiology , Cerebral Palsy/physiopathology , Outcome Assessment, Health Care , Adult , HumansABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Adults with cerebral palsy (CP) may experience problems with participation in domestic life and interpersonal relationships. AIMS: To identify teenage predictors of adult participation in domestic life and interpersonal relationships. METHODS AND PROCEDURES: This 13-year follow-up of the PERRIN 16-24 cohort included 53 adults with CP without intellectual disability [current age 31.7 (SDâ¯=â¯1.4) years]. Participation performance was assessed as attendance (Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales), and difficulty/assistance with participation (Life Habits questionnaire). 56 teenage factors were categorized in ICF components. Stepwise multiple linear regression analyses explored predictors of participation. OUTCOMES AND RESULTS: Lower gross motor capacity, following special education, having protective parents and a rigid personality predicted less participation in domestic life. Having rejective parents, receiving little daily support, having a socially avoidant personality or coping style and the male gender predicted less participation in interpersonal relationships. Lower activity and participation levels as a teenager predicted less participation in both domestic life and interpersonal relationships of adults with CP. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: Environmental and personal factors, gross motor capacity and teenage participation were predictors of participation of adults with CP. These factors help identify subgroups at risk for suboptimal adult participation and provide targets for rehabilitation.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy/physiopathology , Interpersonal Relations , Parenting , Personality , Social Environment , Social Participation , Activities of Daily Living , Adaptation, Psychological , Adolescent , Adult , Cerebral Palsy/psychology , Education, Special , Female , Follow-Up Studies , Humans , Male , Sex FactorsABSTRACT
AIM: To determine development curves of communication and social interaction from childhood into adulthood for individuals with cerebral palsy (CP). METHOD: This Pediatric Rehabilitation Research in the Netherlands (PERRIN)-DECADE study longitudinally assessed 421 individuals with CP, aged from 1 to 20 years at baseline, after 13 years (n=121 at follow-up). Communication and social interactions were assessed using the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales. We estimated the average maximum performance limit (level) and age at which 90% of the limit was reached (age90 ) using nonlinear mixed-effects modeling. RESULTS: One-hundred individuals without intellectual disability were aged 21 to 34 years at follow-up (39 females, 61 males) (mean age [SD] 28y 5mo [3y 11mo]). Limits of individuals without intellectual disability, regardless of Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS) level, approached the maximum score and were significantly higher than those of individuals with intellectual disability. Ages90 ranged between 3 and 4 years for receptive communication, 6 and 7 years for expressive communication and interrelationships, 12 and 16 years for written communication, 13 and 16 years for play and leisure, and 14 and 16 years for coping. Twenty-one individuals with intellectual disability were between 21 and 27 years at follow-up (8 females, 13 males) (mean age [SD] 24y 7mo [1y 8mo]). Individuals with intellectual disability in GMFCS level V showed the least favourable development, but variation between individuals with intellectual disability was large. INTERPRETATION: Individuals with CP and without intellectual disability show developmental curves of communication and social interactions similar to typically developing individuals, regardless of their level of motor function. Those with intellectual disability reach lower performance levels and vary largely in individual development. WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS: Communication and social interactions in individuals with cerebral palsy without intellectual disability develop similarly to typically developing individuals. Communication and social interactions of individuals with intellectual disability develop less favourably and show large variation.
CURVAS DE DESARROLLO DE COMUNICACIÓN E INTERACCIÓN SOCIAL EN NIÑOS CON PARÁLISIS CEREBRAL: OBJETIVO: Determinar las curvas de desarrollo de la comunicación y la interacción social desde la infancia hasta la edad adulta para las personas con parálisis cerebral (PC). MÉTODO: Esta Investigación de Rehabilitación Pediátrica en el Estudio de los Países Bajos (PERRIN)-DECADE evaluó longitudinalmente 421 individuos con PC, de 1 a 20 años en el inicio, después de 13 años (n=121 en el seguimiento). La comunicación y las interacciones sociales se evaluaron utilizando la Escala de comportamiento adaptativo de Vineland. Estimamos el límite promedio de rendimiento máximo (nivel) y la edad a la que se alcanzó el 90% del límite (edad90 ) utilizando un modelo no lineal de efectos mixtos. RESULTADOS: Cien individuos sin discapacidad intelectual tenían entre 21 y 34 años en el seguimiento (39 mujeres, 61 varones; edad media [DS] 28 y 5 meses [3 años y 11meses]). Los límites de las personas sin discapacidad intelectual, independientemente del nivel del Sistema de Clasificación de la Función Motora Gruesa (GMFCS), se acercaron a la puntuación máxima y fueron significativamente superiores a los de personas con discapacidad intelectual. Edad 90s entre 3 y 4 años para la comunicación receptiva, 6 y 7 años para la comunicación expresiva y las interrelaciones, 12 y 16 años para la comunicación escrita, 13 y 16 años por juego y ocio, y 14 y 16 años por sobrellevarlo. Veintiún individuos con discapacidad intelectual tenían entre 21 y 27 años en seguimiento (8 mujeres, 13 hombres; edad media [DS] 24 años y 7 meses [1 año y 8 meses]). Las personas con discapacidad intelectual en el nivel V de GMFCS mostraron el desarrollo menos favorable, pero la variación entre las personas con discapacidad intelectual fue grande. INTERPRETACIÓN: Las personas con PC sin discapacidad intelectual muestran curvas de desarrollo de comunicación e interacciones sociales similares a las personas con desarrollo típico, no considerando su nivel de función motora. Las personas con PC y discapacidad intelectual alcanzan niveles de rendimiento más bajos y varían en gran medida en el desarrollo individual.
CURVAS DE DESENVOLVIMENTO DA COMUNICAÇÃO E INTERAÇÃO SOCIAL EM CRIANÇAS COM PARALISIA CEREBRAL: OBJETIVO: Determinar as curvas de desenvolvimento e interação social da infância para a adolescência para indivíduos com paralisia cerebral (PC). MÉTODO: Este estudo Europeu de Reabilitação Pediátrica na Holanda (PERRIN)-DECADE avaliou longitudinalmente 421 indivíduos com PC, com idades de 1 a 20 anos na linha de base, após 13 anos, (n=121 no acompanhamento). A comunicação e interação social foram avaliadas usando as Escalas Vineland de Compartamento Adaptativo. Estimamos o limite máximo de desempenho médio (nível) e idade em que 90% do limite foi atingido (idade90 ) usando modelos não-lineares de efeitos mistos. RESULTADOS: Cem indivíduos sem deficiência intelectual com idades entre 21 e 34 anos no acompanhamento (39 do sexo feminino, 61 do sexo masculino; média de idade [DP] 28a 5m [3a 11m]). Os limites de indivíuduos sem deficiência intelectual, independente do nível do Sistema de Classificação da Função Motora Grossa (GMFCS), se aproximou da pontuação maxima e foram significativamente maiores do que os valores de indivíduos com deficiência intelectual. A idade 90s variou entre 3 e 4 anos para comunicação receptiva, 6 e 7 anos para comunicação expressiva e intercomunicações, 12 e 16 anos para comunicação escrita, 12 e 16 years para brincadeiras e lazer, e 14 e 16 anos para adaptabilidade. Vinte e um indivíduos com deficiência intelectual estavam entre 21 e 27 anos no acompanhamento (8 do sexo feminino, 13 do sexo masculino; média de idade [DP] 24a 7m [1a 8m]). Indivíduos com deficiência intelectual no nível GMFCS V mostraram o desenvolvimento menos favorável, mas a variação entre indivíduos com deficiência intelectual foi grande. INTERPRETAÇÃO: Indivíduos com PC com e sem deficiência intelectual mostram curvas desenvolvimentais de comunicação e interação social similares a indivíduos com desempenho típico, independente do nível de função motora. Aqueles com deficiência intelectual tiveram menores níveis de performance e variaram amplamente no desenvolvimento individual.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy/physiopathology , Communication , Human Development/physiology , Intellectual Disability/physiopathology , Interpersonal Relations , Adolescent , Adult , Child , Child, Preschool , Female , Humans , Infant , Longitudinal Studies , Male , Young AdultABSTRACT
AIM: To determine the long-term development of autonomy in participation of individuals with cerebral palsy (CP) without intellectual disability. METHOD: Individuals with CP (n=189, 117 males, 72 females; mean age [SD] 21y 11mo [4y 11mo], range 12-34y); were assessed cross-sectionally (46%) or up to four times (54%), between the ages of 12 and 34 years. Autonomy in participation was classified using phase 3 of the Rotterdam Transition Profile. A logistic generalized estimating equation regression model was used to analyse autonomy in six domains (independent variables: age, Gross Motor Function Classification System [GMFCS] level, and interaction between age and GMFCS level). Proportions of autonomy were compared to references using binomial tests (p<0.05). RESULTS: In most domains, over 90% of participants (n=189, 400 observations, 80% in GMFCS levels I and II) reached autonomy in participation in their late twenties, except for intimate/sexual relationships. Those in GMFCS levels III to V compared to those in GMFCS levels I and II had less favourable development of autonomy in the transportation, intimate relationships, employment, and housing domains, and more favourable development in the finances domain. Compared to references, fewer individuals with CP were autonomous in participation. INTERPRETATION: This knowledge of autonomy may guide the expectations of young people with CP and their caregivers. Furthermore, rehabilitation professionals should address autonomy development in intimate relationships, employment, and housing, especially in individuals with lower gross motor function. WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS: Individuals with cerebral palsy without intellectual disability achieved autonomy in most participation domains. Regarding intimate relationships, they continued to have less experience compared to age-matched references. Development of autonomy was less favourable for individuals in Gross Motor Function Classification System levels III to V.
AUTONOMÍA EN LA PARTICIPACIÓN EN LA PARÁLISIS CEREBRAL DESDE LA INFANCIA A LA EDAD ADULTA: OBJETIVO: Determinar el desarrollo a largo plazo de la autonomía en la participación de individuos con parálisis cerebral (PC) sin discapacidad intelectual. MÉTODO: Individuos con PC (n=189, 117 varones, 72 mujeres; edad media [DE] 21 años y 11 meses [4 años y 11meses], rango 12-34 años); fueron evaluados de forma transversal (46%) o hasta cuatro veces (54%), entre las edades comprendidas entre los 12 y los 34 años. La autonomía en la participación fue clasificada usando la fase 3 del perfil de transición de Rotterdam (Rotterdam Transition Profile). Se utilizó un modelo de regresión logístico generalizado estimando la ecuación para analizar la autonomía en 6 dominios (variables independientes: edad, nivel del Sistema de Clasificación de la Función Motora Gruesa, [GMFCS], y la interacción entre la edad y el nivel GMFCS). Las proporciones de la autonomía se compararon con las referencias mediante pruebas binomiales (p<0,05). RESULTADOS: En la mayoría de los dominios, más del 90% de los participantes (n=189.400 observaciones, 80% en los niveles I y II de la GMFCS) alcanzaron la autonomía en la participación bien entrados los 20 años, excepto para las relaciones íntimas/sexuales. Aquellos en los niveles III y V de la GMFCS en comparación con los niveles I y II de la GMFCS tuvieron un desarrollo de la autonomía menos favorable en el transporte, relaciones íntimas, empleo y en el dominio de la vivienda, y un desarrollo más favorable en el dominio de las finanzas. En comparación con las referencias, menos individuos con PC fueron autónomos en la participación. INTERPRETACIÓN: Este conocimiento de la autonomía puede guiar las expectativas de los jóvenes con PC y de sus cuidadores. Además, los profesionales de la rehabilitación deberían abordar el desarrollo de la autonomía en las relaciones íntimas, el empleo y la vivienda, especialmente en aquellos individuos con una función motora gruesa más baja.
AUTONOMIA NA PARTICIPAÇÃO EM PARALISIA CEREBRAL DA INFÂNCIA À VIDA ADULTA: OBJETIVO: Determinar o desenvolvimento em longo prazo da autonomia na participação de indivíduos com paralisia cerebral (PC) sem deficiência intelectual. MÉTODO: Indivíduos com PC (n=189, 117 do sexo masculino, 72 do sexo feminino; média de idade [DP] 21a 11m [4a 11m], variação 12-34a); foram avaliados transversalmente (46%) ou até quatro vezes (54%), entre as idades de 12 e 34 anos. A autonomia na participação foi classificada usando a fase 3 do Perfil de Transição de Rotterdam. Um modelo de regressão logística com generalizada com equações estimadas foi usado para analisar a autonomia em seis domínios (variáveis independentes: idade, Nível segundo o Sistema de Classificação da Função Motora Grossa [GMFCS], e interação entre idade e nível GMFCS). As proporções de autonomia foram comparadas com as referências usando testes binomiais (p<0,05). RESULTADOS: Na maior parte dos domínios, cerca de 90% dos participantes (n=189.400 observações, 80% nos níveis GMFCS I e II) atingiram autonomia na participação no final da terceira década de vida, exceto para relações íntimas/sexuais. Aqueles nos níveis GMFCS III a V comparados com os níveis I e II tiveram desenvolvimento menos favorável nos domínios da autonomia no transporte, relações íntimas, emprego, e domicílio, e mais desenvolvimento mais favorável no domínio das finanças. Em comparação com as referências, menos indivíduos com PC foram autônomos na participação. INTERPRETAÇÃO: Este conhecimento sobre a autonomia pode guiar as expectativas de jovens com PC e seus cuidadores. Além disso, profissionais da reabilitação devem abordar o desenvolvimento da autonomia nas relações íntimas, emprego e domicílio, especialmente nos indivíduos com menor função motora grossa.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy/psychology , Interpersonal Relations , Personal Autonomy , Social Participation , Adolescent , Adult , Cerebral Palsy/diagnosis , Child , Disability Evaluation , Female , Humans , Male , Severity of Illness Index , Young AdultABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: To identify existing outcome measurement instruments (OMIs) assessing risk factors for cardiometabolic disease in adolescents and adults with cerebral palsy (CP) reported on in the literature or used in the field. DATA SOURCES: The COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement Instruments database of systematic reviews and 4 electronic databases (Embase, MEDLINE/Ovid, MEDLINE/Pubmed, PsychINFO) were searched up to June 19, 2017, that yielded 2594 articles. Experts in the field were consulted to identify any additional OMIs. STUDY SELECTION: Two reviewers independently applied inclusion criteria to select eligible studies using or evaluating measurement properties of OMIs assessing 1 of 8 outcomes: cardiorespiratory endurance, body size, body composition, physical behavior, sleep, nutrition, blood pressure, and blood lipids and glucose. Studies with an experimental or observational design including ≥10 adolescents or adults with CP were included. DATA EXTRACTION: One reviewer extracted data that were summarized for study and sample characteristics, outcomes, OMIs used, and if applicable data on measurement properties. Two reviewers rated the methodological quality and the quality of the OMIs. Feasibility for clinical practice and research was rated by experts in the field. DATA SYNTHESIS: Ninety OMIs were identified from 56 included articles and by the experts. Seventy OMIs pertained to cardiorespiratory endurance, body size, body composition, and physical behavior, whereas only 5 were identified for sleep and nutrition. Overall synthesis revealed that there is moderate to poor evidence for good quality of OMIs in this population. Based on feasibility for clinical practice, experts agreed on a single OMI per outcome (and 2 for cardiorespiratory endurance) to be included in a core set. CONCLUSION: Despite the range of available OMIs to assess risk factors for cardiometabolic disease in adolescents and adults with CP, evidence of good quality is often lacking. Nonetheless, a preliminary core set of 9 OMIs was systematically developed.
Subject(s)
Cardiovascular Diseases/epidemiology , Cerebral Palsy/epidemiology , Metabolic Diseases/epidemiology , Adolescent , Adult , Biomarkers , Blood Glucose , Blood Pressure , Body Weights and Measures , Cardiorespiratory Fitness , Diet , Exercise , Female , Humans , Life Style , Lipids/blood , Male , Middle Aged , Multimorbidity , Risk Factors , Sleep , Surveys and Questionnaires/standards , Young AdultABSTRACT
AIM: In the context of the development of an International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) Core Set for adults with cerebral palsy (CP), this systematic review sought to identify the outcome measures used in studies on adults with CP, to examine their content using the ICF as a reference, and to demonstrate the most studied areas in this population. METHOD: Embase, MEDLINE, Web of Science, PsycINFO, CINAHL, Cochrane, and Google Scholar were searched for studies on adults with CP published between 2000 and 2017. Meaningful concepts of commonly used outcome measures were linked to the ICF, and frequencies of resultant ICF categories were explored. RESULTS: In 274 included articles, 332 outcome measures were identified of which 155 were commonly used. In total, 4409 meaningful concepts were linked to the ICF. The component 'Activities and participation' included the most frequent categories, followed by 'Body functions'. The most frequent categories were b280 'Sensation of pain' (37.6%), d450 'Walking' (33.3%), and d850 'Remunerative employment' (27.5%). INTERPRETATION: The broad range of ICF categories identified in this systematic review emphasizes the heterogeneity of functioning and disability in adults with CP. The current results specifically reflect the researchers' perspective and will serve as candidate categories to consider in the development of an ICF Core Set for adults with CP. WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS: Outcomes studied in adults with cerebral palsy are captured in varying International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) categories. Activities and participation were studied more frequently than body functions and structures. Mobility, employment, and self-care were most frequent within ICF's 'Activities and participation' component. Pain and neuromusculoskeletal and movement-related functions were most frequent within 'Body functions'.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy/diagnosis , Activities of Daily Living , Cerebral Palsy/classification , Disability Evaluation , Humans , International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health , Outcome Assessment, Health CareABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Estimates of multimorbidity, defined as the presence of at least two chronic conditions, some of which attributable to modifiable behaviours, are high in adults with cerebral palsy (CP). An assessment protocol evaluating multimorbidity risk is needed in order to develop and evaluate effective interventions to optimize lifelong health in individuals with CP. The aim of this protocol paper is to describe the development of a core outcome set (COS) for assessing multimorbidity risk in adolescents and adults with CP, to be used in clinic and research. METHODS: The expert consortium will first define the target population and outcomes to be measured. Through a process of literature review and an international Delphi survey with expert clinicians and researchers, we will then determine which outcome measurement instruments (OMIs) can best measure those outcomes. The resulting OMIs will be used in a feasibility study with adolescents and adults with CP from an international clinical research network. Finally, a face-to-face stakeholder meeting with adolescents and adults with CP, their families/caregivers and researchers and clinicians who are experts in CP, will be organized to reach final agreement on the COS. DISCUSSION: This COS will guide clinicians and researchers in assessing multimorbidity risk in adolescents and adults with CP. The inclusion of experts and individuals with CP from international locations for establishing the COS lends strong support to its generalizability. Evidence of its feasibility and approval from all stakeholders will enable implementation in clinical practice, and guide future research using the COS in individuals with CP.
Subject(s)
Cerebral Palsy/therapy , Multimorbidity , Outcome Assessment, Health Care , Risk Assessment , Adolescent , Adult , Biomedical Research , Delphi Technique , Humans , Sample SizeABSTRACT
AIM: To determine the long-term course of difficulty in participation of individuals with cerebral palsy (CP) without intellectual disability between 16 years and 34 years of age. METHOD: One hundred and fifty-one individuals with CP aged 16 to 20 years were included (63% male, 37% female; Gross Motor Function Classification System [GMFCS] levels I-IV; without intellectual disability). The Assessment of Life Habits questionnaire 3.0 general short form was used up to three times biennially and at 13-year follow-up (13-year follow-up: n=98). Scores (range 0-10) reflect difficulty and assistance in participation in housing, education and employment, interpersonal relationships, recreation, community life, and responsibilities. Multilevel models were used to determine the course of difficulty in participation by GMFCS level. RESULTS: Despite high average participation levels, 41% to 95% of adolescents and young adults with CP experienced difficulty. Difficulty in participation in housing and interpersonal relationships increased from age 16 years onwards and in most other life areas in the mid- and late 20s. In adolescents in GMFCS levels III and IV, participation in recreation and community life improved up to age 23 years. INTERPRETATION: Individuals with CP experience increasing difficulties in participation in their mid- and late 20s. Clinicians should systematically check for participation difficulties in young adults with CP and offer timely personalized treatment. WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS: Many individuals with cerebral palsy (CP) aged 16 to 34 years experience difficulty in participation. Difficulty in participation increases in the mid- and late 20s for individuals with CP. Participation in recreation/community life improves before age 23 years for those in Gross Motor Function Classification System levels III and IV.