Comparing surgical experience with performance on a sinus surgery simulator.

BACKGROUND: This study evaluates whether surgical experience influences technical competence using the Flinders sinus surgery simulator, a virtual environment designed to teach nasal endoscopic surgical skills. METHODS: Ten experienced sinus surgeons (five consultants and five registrars) and 14 novices (seven resident medical officers and seven interns/medical students) completed three simulation tasks using haptic controllers. Task 1 required navigation of the sinuses and identification of six anatomical landmarks, Task 2 required removal of unhealthy tissue while preserving healthy tissue and Task 3 entailed backbiting within pre-set lines on the uncinate process and microdebriding tissue between the cuts. RESULTS: Novices were compared with experts on a range of measures, using Mann-Whitney U -tests. Novices took longer on all tasks (Task 1: 278%, P < 0.005; Task 2: 112%, P < 0.005; Task 3: 72%, P < 0.005). In Task 1, novices' instruments travelled further than experts' (379%, P < 0.005), and provided greater maximum force (12%, P < 0.05). In Tasks 2 and 3 novices performed more cutting movements to remove the tissue (Task 2: 1500%, P < 0.005; Task 3: 72%, P < 0.005). Experts also completed more of Task 3 (66%, P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: The study demonstrated the Flinders sinus simulator's construct validity, differentiating between experts and novices with respect to procedure time, instrument distance travelled and number of cutting motions to complete the task.

Real-time interactive isosurfacing: a new method for improving marching isosurfacing algorithm output and efficiency.

Efficient rendering of a changing volumetric data-set is central to the development of effective medical simulations that incorporate haptic feedback. A new method referred to as real-time interactive isosurfacing (RTII) is described in this paper. RTII is an algorithm that can be applied to output from Marching Cubes-like algorithms to improve performance for real-time applications. The approach minimises processing by re-evaluating the isosurface around changing sub-volumes resulting from user interactions. It includes innovations that significantly reduce mesh complexity and improve mesh quality as triangles are created from the Marching Tetrahedra isosurfacing algorithm. Rendering efficiency is further improved over other marching isosurfacing algorithm outputs by maintaining an indexed triangle representation of the mesh. The effectiveness of RTII is discussed within the context of an endoscopic sinus surgery simulation currently being developed by the authors.

Toward photorealism in endoscopic sinus surgery simulation.

BACKGROUND: Endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS) is the surgical standard treatment for chronic rhinitis/rhinosinusitis and nasal polyposis. There is a reported complication rate of 5-10% associated with this type of surgery. Simulation has been advocated as a means to improve surgical training and minimize the rates of complication and medical error. This study aimed to show how a virtual reality ESS simulator was developed, with particular emphasis on achieving satisfactory photorealism and surgical verisimilitude. METHODS: Sinus computed tomography scans were processed to create a triangle-based three-dimensional mesh model; this was incorporated into a spring-damper model of thousands of interconnected nodes, which is allowed to deform in response to user interactions. Dual haptic handpiece devices were programmed to simulate an endoscope and various surgical instruments. Textures and lighting effects were added to the mesh model to provide an accurate representation of the surgical field. Effects such as vasoconstriction in response to "virtual" decongestant were added. RESULTS: The final simulated endoscopic view of the sinuses accurately simulates the moist and glossy appearance of the sinuses. The interactive tissue simulation system enables the user to interactively cut and remove tissue while receiving accurate haptic feedback. A working prototype of the simulator has been developed that leverages recent advances in computer hardware to deliver a realistic user experience, both visually and haptically. CONCLUSION: This new computer-based training tool for practicing ESS provides a risk-free environment for surgical trainees to practice and develop core skills. The novel use of customized precision force feedback (haptic) devices enables trainees to use movements during training that closely mimic those used during the actual procedure, which we anticipate will improve learning, retention, and recall.